Advertisement

The Collaborative Economy Within the Framework of the European Union’s Digital Single Market

  • Marco Inglese
Chapter

Abstract

This chapter encapsulates the collaborative economy within the current development of the Digital Single Market (DSM). To do so, the collaborative economy is assessed against the bulk of European Union (EU) law, primarily through the lenses of classical free movement rules. In addition, the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (the Charter) has a salient role to play in what concerns the freedom to choose an occupation and to conduct a business. Once the impact of primary law has been tested, secondary law is used to evaluate whether the collaborative economy fits within a well-designed framework comprising the Services Directive, the Information Society Services Directive, the Database Directive, the Recognition of Qualification Directive and the General Data Protection Regulation. Case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in the Uber saga is further discussed in this specific respect. Chapter  2 hence concludes that, when a collaborative economy transaction is at stake, its legal qualification, as well as the consequences stemming from it, depends on the very nature of the underlying service.

Keywords

Online platforms European Union digital single market Economic freedoms Charter of fundamental rights Harmonization 

References

  1. Adamski D (2018) Lost on the digital platforms: Europe’s legal travails with the digital single market. Common Mark Law Rev 55(3):719–751Google Scholar
  2. Aloni E (2016) Pluralizing the sharing economy. Wash Law Rev 91(4):1397–1459Google Scholar
  3. Ashiagbor D (2014) Article 15. Freedom to choose an occupation and right to engage in work. In: Peers S, Hervey T, Kenner J, Ward A (eds) The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. A commentary. CH Bec, Hart, Nomos, Portland, pp 423–435CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Barnard C (2008) Unravelling the Services Directive. Common Mark Law Rev 45(3):323–394Google Scholar
  5. Bartl M (2015) Internal market rationality, private law and the direction of the Union: resuscitating the market as the object of the political. Eur Law J 21(5):572–598CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bell M (2012) Between flexicurity and fundamental social rights: the EU directives on atypical work. Eur Law Rev 37(1):31–48Google Scholar
  7. Bently L, Burrell R (1997) Copyright and the information society in Europe: a matter of timing as well as content. Common Mark Law Rev 34(6):1197–1227CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Berke D (2016) Products liability in the sharing economy. Yale J Regul 33(2):603–653Google Scholar
  9. Brownsword R (2017) The e-Commerce Directive, consumer transactions, and the digital single market – questions of regulatory fitness, regulatory disconnection and rule redirection. In: Grundmann S (ed) European contract law in the digital age. Intersentia, Cambridge, pp 165–204Google Scholar
  10. Busch C, Schulte-Nölke H, Wiewiórowska-Domagalska A, Zoll F (2016) The rise of the platform economy: a new challenge for EU consumer law? J Eur Common Mark Law 5(1):3–10Google Scholar
  11. Catchpole J (2001) The regulation of electronic commerce: a comparative analysis surrounding the principles of establishment. Int J Law Inform Technol 9(1):1–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Cauffman C (2016) The Commission’s European agenda for the collaborative economy – (too) platform and service provider friendly? Eur Common Mark Law 5(6):235–243Google Scholar
  13. Codagnone C, Abadie F, Biagi F (2016) The future of work in the sharing economy: market efficiency and equitable opportunities or unfair precarisation? EU Commission JRCGoogle Scholar
  14. Colangelo G, Maggiolino M (2018) ISPs’ copyright liability in the EU digital single market strategy. Int J Law Inform Technol 26(1):142–159CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Davies G (2007) The services directive: extending the country of origin principle, and reforming public administration. Eur Law Rev 32(2):232–245Google Scholar
  16. De Baere G (2004) Is this a conflict of rule which I see before me? Looking for a hidden conflict rule in the principle of origin as implemented in primary European Community law and in the “Directive on Electronic Commerce”. Maastricht J Eur Comp Law 11(3):287–319CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. De Franceschi A (2018) Uber Spain and the “identity crisis” of online platforms. Eur Common Mark Law 7(1):1–4Google Scholar
  18. Delimatsis P (2010) “Thou shall not… (dis)trust”: codes of conduct and harmonization of professional standards in the EU. Common Mark Law Rev 47(4):1049–1087Google Scholar
  19. Dermine E (2018) Liberté professionnelle et droit de travailler. In: Picod F, Van Drooghenbroeck S (eds) Charte des droit fondamentaux de l’Union européenne. Commentaire article par article. Bruylant, Brussels, pp 325–348Google Scholar
  20. Enchelmaier S (2011) Always at your service (within limits): the ECJ’s case law on Article 56 TFEU (2006–2011). Eur Law Rev 36(5):615–650Google Scholar
  21. Everson M, Gonçalves RC (2014) Article 16. Freedom to conduct a business. In: Peers S, Hervey T, Kenner J, Ward A (eds) The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. A commentary. CH Bec, Hart, Nomos, Portland, pp 437–463Google Scholar
  22. Farah Y (2009) Electronic contracts and information society services under the e-Commerce Directive. J Internet Law 12(12):3–14Google Scholar
  23. Finck M (2018) Digital co-regulation: designing a supranational legal framework for the platform economy. Eur Law Rev 43(1):47–68Google Scholar
  24. Geradin G (2015) Online intermediation platforms and free trade principles – some reflections on the Uber preliminary ruling case. CPI 11(1):1–10Google Scholar
  25. Giubboni S (2018) Freedom to conduct a business and labour law. Eur Const Law Rev 14(1):172–190Google Scholar
  26. Grosheide E, Barenberg M (2016) Minimum fees for the self-employed: a European response to the “uber-ized” economy? Columbia J Eur Law 22(2):193–236Google Scholar
  27. Hatzopoulos V (2008) Assessing the Services Directive (2006/123/EC). Cambridge Yearb Eur Legal Stud 10(1):215–261CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Hatzopoulos V (2012) Regulating services in the European Union. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Hatzopoulos V (2013) The Court’s approach to services (2006–2012): from case law to case load? Common Mark Law Rev 50(2):459–501Google Scholar
  30. Hatzopoulos V (2018a) The collaborative economy and EU law. Hart, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  31. Hatzopoulos V (2018b) La première prise de position de la Cour en matière d’économie collaborative. Rev trim droit eur 13(1):273–285Google Scholar
  32. Hatzopoulos V, Roma S (2017) Caring for sharing? The collaborative economy under EU law. Common Mark Law Rev 54(1):81–128Google Scholar
  33. Havu K (2017) The EU digital single market from a consumer standpoint: how do promises meet means? Contemp Read Law Soc Justice 9(2):146–183CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Hultmark Ramberg C (2001) The e-Commerce Directive and formation of contract in a comparative perspective. Eur Law Rev 26(5):429–450Google Scholar
  35. Jackobsen SS (2010) Mobile commerce and ISP liability in the EU. Int J Law Inform Technol 19(1):29–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Janczuk-Gorywoda A (2016) Online platforms as providers of transnational payments law. Eur Rev Priv Law 24(2):223–251Google Scholar
  37. Leonard T (2018) Article 16. Liberté d’entreprise. In: Picod F, Van Drooghenbroeck S (eds) Charte des droit fondamentaux de l’Union européenne. Commentaire article par article. Bruylant, Brussels, pp 349–368Google Scholar
  38. Lopez-Tarruella A (2001) A European Community regulatory framework for electronic commerce. Common Mark Law Rev 38(6):1337–1384CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Lynksey O (2017) The Europeanisation of data protection law. Cambridge Yearb Eur Legal Stud 19(1):252–286Google Scholar
  40. Mak V (2017) Regulating online platforms – the case of Airbnb. In: Grundmann S (ed) European contract law in the digital age. Intersentia, Cambridge, pp 87–102Google Scholar
  41. Mortelmans K (1998) The common market, the internal market and the single market: what’s in a market? Common Mark Law Rev 35(1):101–136CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Mostacci E, Somma A (eds) (2016) Il caso Uber. La sharing economy nel confronto tra common law e civil law Egea, MilanGoogle Scholar
  43. Pearce G, Platten N (2000) Promoting the information society: the EU directive on electronic commerce. Eur Law J 6(4):363–378CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Peers S (2013) Equal treatment of atypical workers: a new frontier of EU law? Yearb Eur Law 32(1):30–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Prassl J (2015) Business freedoms and employment rights in the European Union. Cambridge Yearb Eur Legal Stud 17(1):189–209CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Rogers B (2015–2016) The social costs of Uber. Univ Chicago Law Rev Dialogue 82:85–102Google Scholar
  47. Roth WH (2017) Mutual recognition. In: Koutrakos P, Snell J (eds) Research handbook on the law of the EU’s internal market. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, pp 427–459CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Schammo P (2013) Home country control with consent: a new paradigm for ensuring trust and cooperation in the internal market? Cambridge Yearb Eur Legal Stud 15(1):467–501CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Schepisi C (2017) Piattaforme digitali e caso Uber dinanzi alla Corte di giustizia: servizio di trasporto urbano o servizio della società dell’informazione? Osservatorio europeo Dir Un Eur, 1–17Google Scholar
  50. Simon P (2017) Uber saisi par le droit du marché intérieur. Rev aff eur 28(3):521–532Google Scholar
  51. Smorto G (2017) Critical assessment of European agenda for the collaborative economy. In-depth analysis for the IMCO Committee IP/A/IMCO/2016-10, PE 595.361Google Scholar
  52. Snell J (2010) The notion of market access: a concept or a slogan? Common Mark Law Rev 47(2):437–472Google Scholar
  53. Sorensen MJ (2016) Private law perspectives on platform services. J Eur Common Mark Law 5(1):15–19Google Scholar
  54. Twigg-Flesner C (2016) Disrupting technology-disrupted law? How the digital revolution affects (contract) law. In: De Franceschi A (ed) European contract law and the digital single market. The implications of the digital revolution. Intersentia, Cambridge, pp 19–48Google Scholar
  55. Van Cleynenbreugel P (2017) Le droit de l’Union européenne face à l’économie collaborative. Rev trim droit eur 12(4):697–722Google Scholar
  56. Walden I (2001) Regulating electronic commerce: Europe in the global economy. Eur Law Rev 26(6):529–547Google Scholar
  57. Weatherill S (2017a) The several internal markets. YEL 36(1):125–178Google Scholar
  58. Weatherill S (2017b) The internal market as legal concept. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Weatherill S (2018) The principle of mutual recognition: it doesn’t work because it doesn’t exist. Eur Law Rev 43(2):224–233Google Scholar
  60. Wyman KM (2017) Taxi regulation in the age of Uber. N Y Univ J Legis Public Policy 20(1):1–100Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  • Marco Inglese
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Law, Politics and International StudiesUniversity of ParmaParmaItaly

Personalised recommendations