Advertisement

The Police Surgeon, Medico-Legal Networks and Criminal Investigation in Victorian Scotland

  • Kelly-Ann Couzens
Chapter
Part of the Palgrave Histories of Policing, Punishment and Justice book series (PHPPJ)

Abstract

As a medical practitioner affiliated to the city police and responsive to the demands of legal officials, the police surgeon daily worked at the intersection between differing professional collectives and communities in the nineteenth century. Conducting physical examinations of assaulted parties, undertaking post-mortem dissections and certifying cases of mental insanity formed the cornerstone of the police surgeon’s daily diet of forensic work in Victorian Edinburgh. In addition, the police surgeon was frequently on call day or night (and in any weather) to the local force. Accordingly, this practitioner often became the vital first point of medical contact with victims (and suspects) in cases of homicide or assault in the nineteenth century. Yet despite the pivotal role this practitioner occupied as a forensic expert in the Victorian city, relatively little scholarship has been dedicated to analysing the contribution and nature of the police surgeon’s medico-legal work. However, analysis of the career and life of one Scottish police surgeon—Henry Duncan Littlejohn—indicates that the experience gained from the regular practice of medical jurisprudence was vital in developing and maintaining an authoritative medico-legal presence both within and outside the courtroom. In particular, historical records suggest that the surgeon of police collaborated with constables, detectives and prosecutors to facilitate the investigation and prosecution of violent crime. Sometimes this collaboration would be procedural and routine, such as directing officers to remove bodies to the mortuary of the police chambers. At other times, these practitioners worked closely with the local force and legal officials in more complex and influential ways that blurred the professional and practical boundaries between medicine, policing and criminal investigation. Moreover, the nature of Scottish procedure in suspicious deaths also forced the police surgeon to co-operate with a diverse range of medical practitioners in the examination and certification of death, injury and lunacy in the Scottish city. Sometimes, resolving inconsistencies in medical evidence could be a core part of the police surgeon’s role when consulted by the Crown. On other occasions, working in partnership with other doctors to establish an informed, robust and objective medical opinion of a case was vital to the consolidation of the police surgeon’s medico-legal authority.

Archives

  1. Anon., Duties and Emoluments of Police Surgeon, Edinburgh: Pamphlet Collection of the Royal College of Physicians, c. 1847, 1–4.Google Scholar
  2. Forensic Medicine: Volume of Notes on Forensic Medicine from Lectures Delivered, C. 1906 by Sir Henry Duncan Littlejohn, Physician, While Professor of Forensic Medicine at Edinburgh University, 1897–1906, Edinburgh: National Library of Scotland, 1906, GB 233/MS.19321.Google Scholar
  3. Precognition Against Ann McQue for the Crime of Child Murder at York Place, Edinburgh, Edinburgh: National Records of Scotland, 1860, GB234/AD14/60/260.Google Scholar
  4. Precognition Against Edward Pratt Evatt for the Crime of Rape and Assault with Intent to Ravish, Edinburgh: National Records of Scotland, 1882, GB234/AD14/82/41.Google Scholar
  5. Precognition Against Jessie Peattie for the Crime of Child Murder, Edinburgh, National Records of Scotland, 1882, GB234/AD14/82/47.Google Scholar
  6. Precognition Against John Adamson for the Crime of Murder at 39 Potterrow, Edinburgh, Edinburgh: National Records of Scotland, 1902, GB234/AD15/02/22.Google Scholar
  7. Precognition Against John Walker for the Crime of Rape and Assault with Intent to Ravish at Torphichen Village, Linlithgow, Edinburgh: National Records of Scotland, 1874, GB234/AD14/74/307.Google Scholar
  8. Precognition Against John Webster, John Webster for the Crime of Murder at Newtown Hotel, Southmuir of Kirriemuir, Forfarshire, Edinburgh: National Records of Scotland, 1891, GB234/AD14/91/154.Google Scholar
  9. Print of Declarations and Reports of Experts in the Trial of Eugene Marie Chantrelle for Murder in Trial Papers Relating to Eugene Marie Chantrelle for the Crime of Murder at 81a George Street, Edinburgh. Tried at High Court, Edinburgh, Edinburgh: National Records of Scotland, 1878, GB234/JC26/1878/296/15.Google Scholar
  10. Trial Papers Relating to Edward Pratt Evatt for the Crime of Rape and Assault with Intent to Ravish. Tried at High Court, Edinburgh, Edinburgh: National Records of Scotland, 1882, GB234/JC26/1882/316.Google Scholar
  11. Trial Papers Relating to John Walker for the Crime of Rape and Assault with Intent to Ravish at Torphichen Village, Linlithgow. Tried at High Court, Edinburgh, Edinburgh: National Records of Scotland, 1874, GB234/JC26/1874/400.Google Scholar
  12. Trial Papers Relating to William King for the Crime of Rape and Assault with Intent to Ravish. Tried at High Court, Edinburgh, Edinburgh: National Records of Scotland, 1876, GB234/JC26/1876/313.Google Scholar

Bibliography

  1. Bates, V., ‘“So far as I can define without a microscopical examination”: Venereal disease diagnosis in English courts, 1850–1914’, Social History of Medicine, 2012, 26(1): 38–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Bourke, J., ‘Police surgeons and sexual violence: A history’, The Lancet, 2017, 390(10094): 548–549.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bourke, J., ‘Police surgeons and victims of rape: Cultures of harm and care’, Social History of Medicine, 2018, 31(4): 711–731.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bradshaw, Y., Savage, S.P., Moon, G. and Kelly, K., ‘A different sort of doctor: The police surgeon in England and Wales’, Social Policy & Administration, 1995, 29(2):122–134.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Brown-May, A. and Cooke, S., ‘Death, decency and the dead-house: The city morgue in colonial Melbourne’, Provenance: The Journal of Public Record Office Victoria, 2004, 3: 25–36.Google Scholar
  6. Couzens, K.A., Medicine on Trial: Medical Testimony & Forensic Expertise in the Scottish High Court of Justiciary, C. 1822–1906, Unpublished Doctoral dissertation, University of Western Australia, Perth, 2019.Google Scholar
  7. Couzens, K.-A., ‘“Upon my word, I do not see the use of medical evidence here”: Persuasion, authority and medical expertise in the Edinburgh High Court of Justiciary’, History, 2019, 104(359): 42–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Crowther, M.A., ‘Criminal precognitions and their value for historians’, Scottish Archives, 1995, 1: 75–84.Google Scholar
  9. Crowther, M.A., ‘Crime, prosecution and mercy: English influence and Scottish practice in the early nineteenth century’, in S.J. Connolly (ed.), Kingdoms United? Great Britain and Ireland since 1500: Integration and Diversity, Dublin & Portland: Four Courts Press, 1999, 225–238.Google Scholar
  10. Crowther, M.A., ‘Forensic medicine and medical ethics in nineteenth-century Britain’, in R. Baker (ed.), The Codification of Medical Morality, Dordrecht, Boston and London: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1995, 173–190.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Crozier, I. and G. Rees, ‘Making a space for medical expertise: Medical knowledge of sexual assault and the construction of boundaries between forensic medicine and the law in late nineteenth-century England’, Law, Culture and the Humanities, 2012, 8(2): 285–304.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Digby, A., Making a Medical Living: Doctors and Patients in the English Market for Medicine, 1720–1911, Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press, 1994.Google Scholar
  13. ‘High Court of Justiciary’, The Scotsman, Edinburgh, 5 December 1876, 3.Google Scholar
  14. ‘High Court of Justiciary—The Queen’s Park Murder Case’, The Scotsman, Edinburgh, 3 June 1872, 6–7.Google Scholar
  15. ‘High Court of Justiciary: Charge of Child Murder’, The Scotsman, Edinburgh, 11 May 1860, 4.Google Scholar
  16. ‘High Court of Justiciary: Concealment of Pregnancy’, The Scotsman, Edinburgh, 25 July 1882, 3.Google Scholar
  17. ‘High Court of Justiciary: The Potterow Case’, The Scotsman, Edinburgh, 20 September 1902, 11.Google Scholar
  18. ‘High Court of Justiciary: The York Place Child-Murder’, The Scotsman, Edinburgh, 13 March 1860, 4.Google Scholar
  19. Jackson, L.A., Child Sexual Abuse in Victorian England, London and New York: Routledge, 2000.Google Scholar
  20. Kalifa, D., ‘Crime scenes: Criminal topography and social imaginary in nineteenth-century Paris’, French Historical Studies, 2004, 27(1): 175–194.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Lacqueur, T.W., ‘Bodies, details, and the humanitarian narrative’, in L. Hunt (ed.), The New Cultural History, Berkeley: University of California Press, 1989, 176–204.Google Scholar
  22. ‘The Late Sir Henry D. Littlejohn, M.D.: A Distinguished Public Official and Medical Jurist’, The Scotsman, Edinburgh, 2 October 1914, 5.Google Scholar
  23. Laxton, P. and Rodger, R. Insanitary City: Henry Littlejohn and the Condition of Edinburgh, Lancaster: Carnegie Publishing Limited, 2013.Google Scholar
  24. Levitt, I., ‘Henry Littlejohn and Scottish health policy, 1859–1908’, Scottish Archives, 1996, 2: 63–77.Google Scholar
  25. Littlejohn, H.D., ‘A case of poisoning with nitrate of potash, with hints as to the conduct of medical practitioners in cases of suspected poisoning’, Transactions of the Medico-Chirurgical Society of Edinburgh, 1885, 4: 23–32.Google Scholar
  26. Littlejohn, H.D., ‘On the practice of medical jurisprudence: No IV post-mortem examination. B. Internal examination’, Edinburgh Medical Journal, 1876, XXI(VIII): 1112–1124.Google Scholar
  27. ‘Littlejohn, Thomas’, Post Office Annual Directory, Edinburgh: Postmaster General, 1828–1829, 103.Google Scholar
  28. Miller, W.I., The Anatomy of Disgust, Cambridge, MA and London: Harvard University Press, 1997.Google Scholar
  29. ‘Police Commission’, The Scotsman, Edinburgh, 16 August 1854, 3.Google Scholar
  30. ‘Professor Sir Henry Littlejohn’s opening lecture’, The Scotsman, Edinburgh, 5 May 1897, 12.Google Scholar
  31. ‘Resignation of Sir Henry D Littlejohn’, The Scotsman, Edinburgh, 16 March 1908, 7.Google Scholar
  32. Riggs, P.T., ‘Prosecutors, juries, judges and punishment in early nineteenth-century Scotland’, Journal of Scottish Historical Studies, 2012, 32(2): 166–189.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Robins, J., The Magnificent Spilsbury and the Case of the Brides in the Bath, London: John Murray, 2010.Google Scholar
  34. Savage, S.P., Moon, G., Kelly, K. and Bradshaw, Y., ‘Divided loyalties? The police surgeon and criminal justice’, Policing and Society, 1997, 7(2): 79–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. The Scotsman, 1817–1955: Scotland’s National Newspaper, Edinburgh: The Scotsman Publications Limited, 1955.Google Scholar
  36. Shpayer-Makov, H., ‘Journalists and police detectives in Victorian and Edwardian England: An uneasy reciprocal relationship’, Journal of Social History, 2009, 42(4): 963–987.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Shpayer-Makov, H., The Ascent of the Detective: Police Sleuths in Victorian and Edwardian England, Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press, 2011.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Smith, A.D. (ed.), Trial of Eugene Marie Chantrelle, Glasgow and Edinburgh: William Hodge & Company, 1906.Google Scholar
  39. Summers, R.D., History of the Police Surgeon, London: Association of Police Surgeons of Great Britain, 1988.Google Scholar
  40. ‘The Suspected Murder in the Queen’s Park’, The Scotsman, Edinburgh, 26 March 1872, 3.Google Scholar
  41. Sutherland, H., A Time to Keep, London: Geoffrey Bles, 1934.Google Scholar
  42. Tait, H.P., ‘Sir Henry Duncan Littlejohn: Great Scottish sanitarian and medical jurist’, The Medical Officer, 21 September 1962, 108: 183–190.Google Scholar
  43. ‘United Kingdom Police Surgeons’ Association’, British Medical Journal, London, 20 August 1897, 492–493.Google Scholar
  44. White, B.M., ‘The police surgeon as Medical Officer of Health in Scotland 1862–1897’, The Police Surgeon, 1989, 35: 29–37.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2020

Authors and Affiliations

  • Kelly-Ann Couzens
    • 1
  1. 1.University of Western AustraliaPerthAustralia

Personalised recommendations