The Biggar Murder: ‘A Triumph for Forensic Odontology’
This chapter focuses on the murder of a fifteen-year-old girl in a small Scottish town, Biggar, in 1967. The main evidence was a bite-mark on her body. Dental impressions from staff and youths at the nearby ‘approved school’ were made, and Gordon Hay, a youth with highly unusual dental features, became the chief suspect. Professor Keith Simpson, the UK’s foremost forensic pathologist, argued that it was possible to identify the person who was responsible for making a bite-mark on a body. The case was the first in Scotland where results from forensic odontology formed the main evidence in the trial. It was a ‘triumph for forensic odontology’ in that the evidentiary links, some of which were quite fragile, held together without breaking.
- National Records of Scotland, NRS AD99/7/5 Extracts from trial of Gordon Hay, Volume IIGoogle Scholar
- National Records of Scotland, NRS ED15/347/1 Loaningdale School, BiggarGoogle Scholar
- Aitken, C.G.G. and Taroni, F., Statistics and the Evaluation of Evidence for Forensic Scientists, 2nd ed., Chichester: Wiley, 2004, 101–102.Google Scholar
- Asquith, S. (ed.), The Kilbrandon Report. Children and Young Persons in Scotland, Edinburgh: HMSO, 1995.Google Scholar
- Bell, A.H., ‘Bodies in the bed: English crime scene photographs as documentary images’, in A. Adam (ed.), Crime and the Construction of Forensic Objectivity from 1850, Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan, 2020, 17–41.Google Scholar
- Collins, H., Tacit and Explicit Knowledge, Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 2010.Google Scholar
- Crowther, M.A. and White, B., On Soul and Conscience. The Medical Expert and Crime. 150 Years of Forensic Medicine in Glasgow, Aberdeen: Aberdeen University Press, 1988.Google Scholar
- Evett, I.W. and Williams, R.L., ‘Review of the sixteen points fingerprint standard in England and Wales’, Journal of Forensic Identification, 1996, 46(1): 49–73.Google Scholar
- Gaw, A., ‘The Biggar murder & Warren Harvey’, Forensic Dentistry Online, 2015, http://www.forensicdentistryonline.org/the-biggar-murder-warren-harvey/, Accessed 7 May 2019.
- Harvey, W., Butler, O., Furness, J. and Laird, R., ‘The Biggar murder. Dental, medical, police and legal aspects of a case “in some ways unique, difficult and puzzling”’, (with a note on the law by A.R. Brownlie and a foreword by K. Simpson, Journal of the Forensic Science Society, 1968, 8(4): 157–219.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Laird, R. ‘The Biggar murder—Some personal recollections’, Dental History Magazine, 2010, 4(1): 8–14.Google Scholar
- Mnookin, J.L., ‘The image of truth: Photographic evidence and the power of analogy’, Yale Journal of Law & the Humanities, 1998, 10(1), Article 1: 1–74, https://digitalcommons.law.yale.edu/yjlh/vol10/iss1/1, Accessed 8 May 2019.
- Muncie, W., The Crime Pond. Memoirs of William Muncie, Edinburgh: Chambers, 1979.Google Scholar
- Murphy, J. and McMillan, G., British Social Services: The Scottish Dimension, Edinburgh: Scottish Academic Press, 1992.Google Scholar
- Ross, M. and Chalmers, J., Walker and Walker. The Law of Evidence in Scotland, 3rd ed., Haywards Heath and Sussex: Tottel, 2009.Google Scholar
- Saunders, G., Casebook of the Bizarre: A Review of Famous Scottish Trials, Edinburgh: John Donald, 1991.Google Scholar
- Simpson, K., ‘Dental evidence in the reconstruction of crime’, British Dental Journal, 1951, 91(9): 229–237.Google Scholar
- Simpson, K., Forty Years of Murder. An Autobiography, London: Harrap, 1978.Google Scholar
- Smith, M., ‘Something lost along the way: Changing patterns of leadership in Scottish residential schools’, Scottish Journal of Residential Child Care, 2015, 14(2): 1–16.Google Scholar