Crimes Against Animals

  • Heidi M. HurdEmail author


Criminal provisions governing the treatment of animals collectively embody inconsistencies that reflect deep-seated ambivalence about who counts as the victim of animal cruelty, what constitutes the wrong of such cruelty, and what role punishment ought to play in response to it. In the first part, I shall sketch how animal cruelty laws embody tensions and contradictions that make manifest the criminal law’s need for philosophical clarity. In the second part, I shall argue that one way to bring a modicum of order to animal cruelty provisions is to recognize that their cross-cutting prohibitions and permissions respond to, and perhaps exploit, competing understandings of whether one, some, or all of the five principles of legislation appropriately inform the reach of the criminal law. I shall, accordingly, unpack the significant doctrinal disagreements about when and why we should punish animal abusers by working through the ways in which animal cruelty provisions appear to be responsive to inconsistent views about the very point of the criminal law.


  1. 11 R.I. Gen. Laws Ann. § 11-10-1 (West 2018).Google Scholar
  2. 18 U.S.C. § 48 (2012).Google Scholar
  3. 142 Cong. Rec. S4630-05 (statement of Sen. Cohen).Google Scholar
  4. 510 Ill. Comp. Stat. Ann. 70/2.01a (West 2018).Google Scholar
  5. 510 Ill. Comp. Stat. Ann. 70/3.02 (West 2018).Google Scholar
  6. 510 Ill. Comp. Stat. Ann. 70/3.03 (West 2018).Google Scholar
  7. 510 Ill. Comp. Stat. Ann. 70/3.03(c) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  8. 1846 Vt. Acts & Resolves 34.Google Scholar
  9. Alaska Stat. Ann. § 11.61.140(c)(3) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  10. Animal Welfare Act, 7 U.S.C. §§ 2131–2159 (2012).Google Scholar
  11. Baltimore County Code § 3-3-2401.Google Scholar
  12. Cal. Penal Code § 597(f) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  13. Cal. Senate Bill 313 (2019-20 Regular Session) (California Legislative Information,
  14. Colo. Rev. Stat. Ann. §§ 18-9-201.5, 18-9-202 (2)(a.5)(VII), (2)(b)(III)(d)(I) (West 2018) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  15. Conn. Gen. Stat. Ann. § 53-247(b) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  16. Del. Code Ann. Tit. 11, § 1325 (West 2018).Google Scholar
  17. Fish and Wildlife Act, 16 U.S.C. §§ 741-754a (2012).Google Scholar
  18. Ga. Code Ann. § 4-11-9.3(b) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  19. Ga. Code Ann. § 16-12-4(d) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  20. H.B. 5817 at 4-23-23(d), 2003 Gen. Assembly (R.I. 2003).Google Scholar
  21. H.B. 7789 at 4-1-46(d), 2004 Gen. Assembly (R.I. 2004).Google Scholar
  22. Idaho Code Ann. § 25-3514(3) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  23. Iowa Code Ann. § 717B.1 (West 2018).Google Scholar
  24. Iowa Code Ann. § 717B.2 (West 2018).Google Scholar
  25. La. Stat. Ann. § 14:102.2(c) (2018).Google Scholar
  26. Mass. Gen. Laws Ann. ch. 272, § 34 (2018).Google Scholar
  27. Md. Code Ann., Crim. Law § 3-322 (West 2018).Google Scholar
  28. Me. Rev. Stat. Ann. tit. 17, § 1034 (2018).Google Scholar
  29. Me. Rev. Stat. Ann. tit. 7, § 3906-C (2017).Google Scholar
  30. Me. Rev. Stat. Ann. tit. 7, § 4011 I-A (2018).Google Scholar
  31. Me. Rev. Stat. Ann. tit. 7, § 4018 (2018).Google Scholar
  32. Mich. Comp. Laws Ann. § 333.18827 (West 2018).Google Scholar
  33. Mich. Comp. Laws Ann. § 750.50(11)(d) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  34. Mich. Comp. Laws Ann. § 750.158 (West 2018).Google Scholar
  35. Mont. Code Ann. § 45-8-211(4)(b) (West 2017).Google Scholar
  36. Mont. Code Ann § 45-8-211(4)(c) (West 2017).Google Scholar
  37. Neb. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 28-1013(8) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  38. N.Y. Agric. & Mkts. Law § 353-a (McKinney 2018).Google Scholar
  39. Ohio Rev. Code Ann. § 959.13 (West 2018).Google Scholar
  40. Ohio Rev. Code Ann. § 959.13(A)(2) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  41. Ohio Rev. Code Ann. § 959.13(A)(4) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  42. Or. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 167.335(2) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  43. Or. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 686.445 (West 2018).Google Scholar
  44. S.B. 1232, 85th Leg. (Tx. 2017).Google Scholar
  45. S.C. Code Ann. § 16-15-120 (2018).Google Scholar
  46. S.C. Code Ann. § 47-1-40 (2018).Google Scholar
  47. Tex. Code Crim. Proc. Ann. art. 62.001(5) (West 2017).Google Scholar
  48. Tex. Penal Code Ann. § 42.09(e) (West 2017).Google Scholar
  49. Tex. Penal Code Ann. § 42.092(a)(2) (West 2017).Google Scholar
  50. Utah Code Ann. § 76-9-301(1)(b)(ii) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  51. Utah Code Ann. § 76-9-301(11)(b)(ii) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  52. Wis. Stat. Ann. § 951.06 (West 2018).Google Scholar
  53. Wyo. Stat. Ann. § 6-3-203(f) (West 2018).Google Scholar
  54. State v. Cleve, 980 P.2d 23, 36 (N.M. 1999).Google Scholar
  55. People v. Garcia, 777 N.Y.S.2d 846 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 2004).Google Scholar
  56. People v. Garcia, 812 N.Y.S.2d 66 (N.Y. App. Div. 2006).Google Scholar
  57. The T.J. Hooper, 60 F.2d 737, 737 (2d Cir. 1932).Google Scholar
  58. State v. Tweedie, 444 A.2d 855 (R.I. 1982).Google Scholar
  59. 2018. Animal hoarding: An in-depth look at the phenomenon. Accessed 23 Aug 2018.
  60. Arluke, Arnold, and Celeste Killeen. 2009. Inside animal hoarding: The story of Barbara Erickson and her 522 dogs. West Lafayette: Purdue University Press.Google Scholar
  61. Ascione, Frank, and Phil Arkow. 1999. Child abuse, domestic violence, and animal abuse: Linking the circles of compassion for prevention and intervention. West Lafayette: Purdue University Press.Google Scholar
  62. Bershadker, Matt, and Rep. Katherine Clark. 2015. Protecting all the victims of domestic violence. ASPCA. Accessed 22 Aug 2018.
  63. Bork, Robert. 1971. Neutral principles and some First Amendment problems. Indiana Law Journal 47: 1–35.Google Scholar
  64. Bryant, Tammie L. 2006. Trauma, law and advocacy for animals. Journal of Animal Law and Ethics 1: 63–183.Google Scholar
  65. Campbell, Danielle K. 2013. Animal abusers beware: Registry law in the works to curb your abuse. Valparaiso University Law Review 48: 271–328.Google Scholar
  66. Chiesa, Luis E. 2008. Why is it a crime to stomp on a goldfish?—Harm, victimhood and the structure of anti-cruelty offenses. Mississippi Law Journal 78: 1–68.Google Scholar
  67. Cohn-Sherbok, Dan. 2006. Hope for the animal kingdom: A Jewish vision. In A communion of subjects: Animals in religion, science, and ethics, ed. Paul Waldau and Kimberley Patton, 81–90. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
  68. DaSilva, Jessica. 2016. Bestiality laws matter in preventing, prosecuting sex crimes. Bloomberg Law. Accessed 23 Aug 2018.
  69. Dworkin, Gerald. 2005. Moral paternalism. Law and Philosophy 24: 305–319.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Ely, John Hart. 1980. Democracy and distrust. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  71. Favre, David S. 1993. The development of anti-cruelty laws during the 1800s. Detroit College of Law Review 1993: 1–35.Google Scholar
  72. Feinberg, Joel. 1985. Offensive nuisances. In Offense to others. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  73. Francione, Gary L. 1996. Rain without thunder: The ideology of the animal rights movement. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.Google Scholar
  74. Frasch, Pamela D., Stephan K. Otto, Kristen M. Olsen, and Paul A. Ernest. 1999. State animal anti-cruelty statutes: An overview. Animal Law 5: 69–80.Google Scholar
  75. Friend, Ted H., and Gisela R. Dellmeier. 1988. Common practices and problems related to artificially rearing calves: An ethological analysis. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 20: 47–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Gerry, Elbridge T. 1875. Address before the bar of Delaware county. August 16.Google Scholar
  77. Hurd, Heidi M. 1988. Relativistic jurisprudence: Skepticism founded on confusion. Southern California Law Review 61: 1417–1510.Google Scholar
  78. ———. 2002. Liberty in law. Law and Philosophy 21: 385–465.Google Scholar
  79. ———. 2004. When can we do what we want? Australian Journal of Legal Philosophy 29: 37–69.Google Scholar
  80. Ibrahim, Darian M. 2006. The anticruelty statute: A study in animal welfare. Journal of Animal Law and Ethics 1: 175–204.Google Scholar
  81. JAVMA. 2014. South Dakota is last state to make animal cruelty a felony. JAVMA News. Accessed 6 Sept 2018.
  82. Kruse, Corwin R. 2002. Baby steps: Minnesota raises certain forms of animal cruelty to felony status. William Mitchell Law Review 28: 1649–1680.Google Scholar
  83. Lacroix, Charlotte A. 1998. Another weapon for combating family violence: Prevention of animal abuse. Animal Law 4: 1–32.Google Scholar
  84. Linzey, Andrew, ed. 2009. The link between animal abuse and human violence. Eastbourne: Sussex Academic Press.Google Scholar
  85. Livingston, Margit. 2001. Desecrating the ark: Animal abuse and the law’s role in prevention. Iowa Law Review 87: 1–74.Google Scholar
  86. Lockwood, Randall, and Frank R. Ascione, eds. 1998. Cruelty to animals and interpersonal violence: Readings in research and application. West Lafayette: Purdue University Press.Google Scholar
  87. Madeline, Beth Ann. 2000. Cruelty to animals: Recognizing violence against nonhuman victims. University of Hawai‘i Law Review 23: 307–340.Google Scholar
  88. Matheny, Gaverick, and Cheryl Leahy. 2007. Farm-animal welfare, legislation, and trade. Law and Contemporary Problems 70: 325–358.Google Scholar
  89. Mill, John Stuart. 1892. Book 5, Chap. 11, § 9. In Principles of political economy. London: Longmans, Green, and Co.Google Scholar
  90. ———. 1963–91. On liberty. In Vol. 18 of The collected works of John Stuart Mill, ed. John M. Robson. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
  91. Moore, Michael S. 1997. Placing blame: A general theory of the criminal law. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
  92. ———. 2014. Liberty’s constraints on what should be made criminal. In Criminalization: The political morality of the criminal law, ed. Antony Duff, Farmer Lindsay, S.E. Marshall, Massimo Renzo, and Victor Tadros, 182–212. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  93. ———. 2017. Legal moralism revisited. San Diego Law Review 54: 441–464.Google Scholar
  94. Otto, Stephan K. 2005. State animal protection laws—The next generation. Animal Law 11: 131–166.Google Scholar
  95. Raz, Joseph. 1986. The morality of freedom. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
  96. ———. 1989. Liberalism, skepticism, and democracy. Iowa Law Review 74: 761–786.Google Scholar
  97. Ritter, William, Jr. 1996. The cycle of violence often begins with violence toward animals. Prosecutor 30: 31–33.Google Scholar
  98. Rowland, Michael Pellman. 2017. State laws are creating anxiety for food producers. Forbes. Accessed 6 Sept 2018.
  99. Satz, Ani B. 2009. Animals as vulnerable subjects: Beyond interest-convergence, hierarchy, and property. Animal Law 16: 1–50.Google Scholar
  100. Sauder, Joseph G. 2000. Enacting and enforcing felony animal cruelty laws to prevent violence against humans. Animal Law 6: 1–22.Google Scholar
  101. Serafino, Laurie. 2011. No walk in the park: Drafting animal cruelty statutes to resolve double jeopardy concerns and eliminate unfettered prosecutorial discretion. Tennessee Law Review 78: 1119–1172.Google Scholar
  102. Shapiro, Allison. 2017. County adds animal welfare committee. Daily Journal. Accessed 6 Sept 2018.
  103. Soehnel, Sonja A. 1992. What constitutes offense of cruelty to animals—Modern cases. American Law Reports 6: 733.Google Scholar
  104. Tannenbaum, Jerold. 1995. Animals and the law: Property, cruelty, rights. Social Research 62: 539–607.Google Scholar
  105. The Human Society of the United States Special Report 6. 1973. Special report on rodeos. The human society of the United States special report 6. Accessed 6 Sept 2018.
  106. Wall, Steven. 1998. Liberalism, perfectionism, and restraint. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  107. White, Rob. 2013. Environmental harm: An eco-justice perspective. Bristol: Policy Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  108. Wisch, Rebecca F. 2017. Table of state animal sexual assault laws. Animal Legal & Historical Center. Accessed 6 Sept 2018.
  109. ———. 2018. Table of state laws that protect animals left in parked vehicles. Animal Legal & Historical Center. Accessed 6 Sept 2018.

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.University of IllinoisUrbanaUSA

Personalised recommendations