Advertisement

The Charlie Hebdo Affair and the Right to Take Offense: Religious Sensibilities Versus Freedom of Expression in India

  • Lyombe EkoEmail author
Chapter

Abstract

India’s journalistic field is ensconced in a complex, politico-cultural, religious, and communitarian environment that has given rise to a geography of freedom of expression that recognizes the right to take offense at perceived objectionable media content and seek legal redress against that content. This chapter describes and explains the tensions between the journalistic and religious fields of India using, as a case study, disputes and controversies spawned by the 2006 Jyllands-Posten Mohammed cartoons controversy and the 2015 Charlie Hebdo terrorist attack. Specifically, it looks at the tension between the human right/rite of freedom of expression and the human right/rite of freedom of religion. This tension is complicated because, in India, the human right/rite of freedom of religion comes with a collateral religious rite of freedom from blasphemy. After tracing the legal contours of freedom of expression and the legally recognized entitlement of respect for religion, as well as the right to take offense, we explore the censorious religious and legal actions taken against the Urdu-language daily Avadhnama and its editor, Shireen Dalvi, for republishing the “Weeping Mohamed” Charlie Hebdo Mohamed cartoon to illustrate an editorial critique of Charlie Hebdo’s Mohammed cartoons.

Keywords

Charlie Hebdo Je Suis Charlie Religious field of India Freedom of expression Freedom of religion Journalistic field of India Mohammed cartoons 

References

  1. Arora, A. (2018). Farmer in Rural India Worships Donald Trump Like a Hindu God. Special Broadcasting Service (SBS, Australia). Retrieved from https://www.sbs.com.au/language/english/farmer-in-rural-india-worships-donald-trump-like-a-hindu-god
  2. Arpitaccg. (2017). Streaming Platforms and Self-censorship: An Indian Perspective. The CCG Blog. Retrieved from https://ccgnludelhi.wordpress.com/2017/07/05/streaming-platforms-and-self-censorship-an-indian-perspective/
  3. Arvind, A. (2016, December 6). Avadhnama Case: Bombay High Court Restrains Police from Booking Urdu Newspaper Editor. Hindustan Times. Retrieved from https://www.hindustantimes.com/mumbai-news/avadhnama-case-bombay-high-court-restrains-police-from-booking-urdu-newspaper-editor/story-B67JakGXPNrCb0SP9J93UL.html
  4. Barry, E. (2014, February 13). Indian Publisher Withdraws Book, Stoking Fears of Nationalist Pressure. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/15/world/asia/indian-publisher-withdraws-book-stoking-fears-of-nationalist-
  5. Beriss, D. (2004). Culture-as Race or Culture-as-Culture. In H. Chapman & L. Frader (Eds.), Race in France (pp. 111–140). New York: Berghahn Books.Google Scholar
  6. Bourdieu P. (1971). Genèse et structure du champ religieux (Origin and Structure of the Religious Field). Revue française de sociologie, 12(3), 295–334. Retrieved from http://www.persee.fr/doc/rfsoc_0035-2969_1971_num_12_3_1994
  7. Bourdieu, P. (1994). L’emprise du journalisme. Actes de la recherche en sciences sociales, 101(1), 3–9.Google Scholar
  8. Christensen, M., & Christensen, C. (2013). The Arab Spring as Meta- Event and Communicative Spaces. Television and New Media, 14(4), 351–364.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Cinematograph (Certification) Rules. (1983). Retrieved from https://www.cbfcindia.gov.in/main/CBFC_English/Attachments/cine_rule1983.pdf
  10. Cinematograph Act (No. XXXVII). (1952). Retrieved from http://www.theindianlawyer.in/statutesnbareacts/acts/c54.html
  11. Clothey, F. (2007). Religion in India: A Historical Introduction. New York: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Code of Criminal Procedure. (1973). Act No. 2 of 1974. Retrieved from http://devgan.in/all_sections_crpc.php
  13. Cole, B. (2018, June 27). Trump is Worshipped as a God by this Man—And He is Not Even a Republican. Newsweek. Retrieved from https://www.newsweek.com/trump-worshipped-god-man-and-he-not-even-republican-996854
  14. Dayashankar, K. (2014). Now, a Temple for Sonia Gandhi in Karimnagar, The Hindu. Retrieved from http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/telangana/now-a-temple-for-sonia-gandhi-in-karimnagar/article6079483.ece
  15. Deleuze, G. & Guattari, F., (1980). Mille plateaux (One Thousand Plateaux) (pp. 381–433). Paris: Éditions de Minuit.Google Scholar
  16. Delhi Editor Held for Publishing Prophet Cartoons. (2006, November 5). Hindustan Times. Retrieved from https://www.hindustantimes.com/india/delhi-editor-held-for-publishing-prophet-cartoons/story-aegxTS3Ydz9Wy0rQy4tFhL.html
  17. Dutta, S., & Balachandran, M. (2015, January 11). Indian Newspaper Deletes Charlie Hebdo Cartoons. Mint, New Delhi. Retrieved from https://qz.com/324581/indian-second-largest-business-newspaper-deletes-charlie-hebdos-cartoons/
  18. Eko, L. (2012). New Media, Old regimes: Case Studies in Comparative Communication Law and Policy. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
  19. Eko, L. (2018). The Legal Interpretation of Freedom of Expression and Blasphemy. The Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Communication. Oxford University Press.  https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228613.013.193
  20. Eko, L., & Berkowitz, D. (2009). Le Monde, French Secular Republicanism and the Mohammad Cartoons Affair: Journalistic “Re-presentation” of the Sacred Right to Offend. The International Communication Gazette, 47(3), 181–202.Google Scholar
  21. Eko, L., Kumar, A., & Yao, Q. (2011). Google This: The Great Firewall of China, The IT Wheel of India, Google, Inc., and Internet Regulation. Journal of Internet Law, 15(3), 3–14.Google Scholar
  22. Esser, F. (2013). The Emerging Paradigm of Comparative Communication Enquiry. International Journal of Communication.  https://doi.org/10.5167/uzh-91247.
  23. Foucault, M. (1994). Dits et Ecrits (Tome III), Sayings and Writings (Vol. III). Paris: Editions Gallimard.Google Scholar
  24. Galhotra, S. (2015). In India, Editor Arrested Over Charlie Hebdo Cartoons Goes Into Hiding. Committee to Protect Journalists. Retrieved from https://www.huffingtonpost.com/committee-to-protect-journalists/in-india-editor-arrested_b_6699436.html
  25. Gupta, D. (2016, April 4). India’s Godman Syndrome. The Hindu. Retrieved from http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/indias-godman-syndrome/article6633497.ece
  26. Hallin, D., & Mancini, P. (2004). Comparative Media Systems: Three Models of Media and Politics. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Jerreat, J. (2015, January 27). After Charlie Hebdo Attack, Vigils, Protests and Publishing Bans. CPJ. Retrieved from https://cpj.org/blog/2015/01/after-charlie-hebdo-attack-vigils-protests-and-pub.php
  28. Joseph, M. (2013, January 30). A Paradise for Those Who Take Offense. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/31/world/asia/31iht-letter31.html?_r=0
  29. Magazine Editor Held in Delhi Over Prophet Cartoons. (2006, February 22). Indian Express News Service. Retrieved from https://web.archive.org/web/20060825142556/http://cities.expressindia.com/fullstory.php?newsid=171054
  30. Maharashtra CID to Investigate All Cases Against Awadhnama Editor and Publisher. (2015, March 18). Hindustan Times. Retrieved from https://www.hindustantimes.com/mumbai/maharashtra-cid-to-investigate-all-cases-against-awadhnama-editor-and-publisher/story-6WgbJW8oOyvk1jBnHQVPiP.html
  31. Mahendra Singh Dhoni vs Yerraguntla Shyamsundar, Transfer Petition, Supreme Court of India (Criminal). No. 23 of 2016 (April 2017).Google Scholar
  32. Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India. (1978). 1 SCC 248; AIR 1978 SC 597.Google Scholar
  33. Matal v. Tam, 582 U.S. ___ (2017).Google Scholar
  34. Mittal, M. (2012). Reading Satanic Verses Legal. The Times of India. Retrieved from https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Reading-Satanic-Verses-legal/articleshow/11622048.cms
  35. Morgan, W., & MacPherson, A. (1861). The Indian Penal Code [Act XLV of 1860]. Calcutta, India: G. C. Hay & Co.Google Scholar
  36. Morin, E. (1990). Le trou noir de la laicité (The Black Hole of Secularism). Le Débat, no. 58, p. 38.Google Scholar
  37. Mumbai High Court Relief for Avadhnama Editor Shirin Dalvi. (2015, February 9). Hindustan Times. Retrieved from https://www.hindustantimes.com/mumbai/mumbai-hc-relief-for-avadhnama-editor-shirin-dalvi/story-Exzlo4gmnByq5eLmZRaBZN.html
  38. No Legal Action Against Yaqoob: UP Govt. (2006, February 19). Times of India. Retrieved from http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/1420231.cms
  39. Nussbaum, M. (2014, February 21). Law for Bad Behavior. Section 295A of the IPC Opens the Door for Bullies to Walk in. The Indian Express. Retrieved from http://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/law-for-bad-behaviour/
  40. Ohiheiser, A. (2015, January 25). Pope Francis on Charlie Hebdo: ‘You cannot Insult the Faith of Others.’ The Washington Post.Google Scholar
  41. Prabhala, A. (2015). When India Became the First Country to Ban ‘The Satanic Verses’ Much Before the Iranian Fatwa. Scroll.in. Retrieved from https://scroll.in/article/758288/when-india-became-the-first-country-to-ban-the-satanic-verses-much-before-the-iranian-fatwa
  42. Punwani, J. (2015, February 4). Behind Hounding of Female Editor Who Published Hebdo Cover, Pettiness of Urdu Journalism Lies Exposed. Scroll.in. Retrieved from https://scroll.in/article/704074/behind-hounding-of-female-editor-who-published-hebdo-cover-pettiness-of-urdu-journalism-lies-exposed
  43. Saigal, S. (2019, March 28). HC Grants Relief to Former Urdu Daily Editor Shirin Dalvi. The Hindu. Retrieved from https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/mumbai/hc-grants-relief-to-former-urdu-daily-editor-shirin-dalvi/article26657195.ece
  44. Sarkar, P. (2017). Section 295A of Indian Penal Code, 1860—Explained! Share Your Essays. Retrieved from http://www.shareyouressays.com/knowledge/section-295a-of-indian-penal-code-1860-explained/118782
  45. Sen, S. (2015). Newspaper Vendor Arrested for Selling Urdu Daily Avadhnama with Charlie Hebdo Cartoon. CNN News18.com (India). Retrieved from https://www.news18.com/news/india/urdu-daily-avadhnama-965616.html
  46. Sharma, S. (2015). My Success is Not Palatable to Many: Avadhnama Editor Shirin Dalvi. Hindustan Times. Retrieved from https://www.hindustantimes.com/mumbai/my-success-is-not-palatable-to-many-avadhnama-editor-shirin-dalvi/story-gZqstamZDX5OOnn1DQbpAL.html
  47. Singh, S. (2006, February 15). Cartoon Controversy. Outlook (India). Retrieved from https://www.outlookindia.com/website/story/the-cartoon-controversy/230218
  48. Sreeraman, V. R. (2006, November 5). Journalist Alok Tomar Arrested. MD India. Retrieved from https://www.medindia.net/news/view_news_main.asp?x=15651
  49. Stewart, N. (1951). Divide and Rule: British Policy in Indian History. Science & Society, 15(1, Winter), 49–57.Google Scholar
  50. Supreme Court Dismisses PIL Against UP Minister. (2006, March 20). ANI-Asian News International. Retrieved from http://in.news.yahoo.com/060320/139/632my.html
  51. The Indian Penal Code. (1860, October 6). Chapter XV, Act No. 45 of 1860.Google Scholar
  52. TNN. (2015, May 31). Cheraman Juma Masjid: A 1,000-Year-Old Lamp Burns in this Mosque. The Times of India. Retrieved from https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Cheraman-Juma-Masjid-A-1000-year-old-lamp-burns-in-this-mosque/articleshow/47486911.cms
  53. Vinocur, N., & Paone, A. (2018, January 8). Terrorist Attack on Paris Magazine ‘Charlie Hebdo’ Kills 12; France on Alert. Mint (New Delhi). Retrieved from https://www.livemint.com/Politics/x5N8Ykf27hG1IkqKA0G6YM/At-least-10-dead-in-Paris-shooting-French-media.html

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Journalism and Creative MediaTexas Tech UniversityLubbockUSA

Personalised recommendations