Advertisement

The Priority of Compatriots as a Challenge to Global Justice: The Case of Open Borders

  • Federico ArcosEmail author
Chapter
Part of the Studies in Global Justice book series (JUST, volume 18)

Abstract

One of the main arguments used to advocate in favor of the current model of closed borders is known as priority of compatriots. According to this argument, a state would be entitled to control and limit the entry of foreigners into its territory because otherwise it could not maintain the socioeconomic system that allows to devote special attention to the needs of its less advantaged members. If it were not true that opening would undermine rich countries’ redistributive efforts and their schemes of social and economic justice, such an argument would no longer make sense. Yet, criticism to the priority of compatriots as justification for the closure of borders does not have to rest on the empirical level. Without denying the practical conflict between patriotic loyalties and global distributive responsibilities, I develop a critique to this argument analyzing whether these are strong enough to withstand the weight of the intrinsic value of all human beings and their most basic and urgent needs.

Notes

Acknowledgments

This work has been supported by the R&D grant “Human rights and global justice in the context of international migrations” (FFI2013-42521-P) funded by the Spanish Program for the Promotion of Scientific and Technical Research for Excellence.

References

  1. Abizadeh, Arash. 2016. The Special-Obligations Challenge to More Open Borders. In Migration in Political Theory, ed. Lea Ypi and Sara Fine, 105–124. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Abizadeh, Arash, and Pablo Gilabert. 2008. Is There a Genuine Tension Between Cosmopolitan Egalitarianism and Special Responsibilities? Philosophical Studies 138: 349–365.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Abizadeh, Arash, Manish Pandey, and Sohrab Abizadeh. 2015. Wage Competition and the Special-Obligations Challenge to More Open Borders. Politics, Philosophy & Economics 14 (3): 255–269.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Arneson, Richard. 2016. Extreme Cosmopolitanism Defended. Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 5: 1–19.Google Scholar
  5. Azan, Muhamed, Muhamed, Hasseb and Shamzaeffa, Samsudin. 2016. The Impact of Foreign Remittances on Poverty Alleviation: Global Evidence. Economics & Sociology 9 (1): 264–281.Google Scholar
  6. Barry, Brian. 1992. The Quest for Consistency: A Skeptical View. In Free Movement, ed. Brian Barry and Robert Goodin, 279–287. University Park: The Pennsylvania State University Press.Google Scholar
  7. Barry, Christian, and David Wiens. 2015. What Second Best Scenarios Reveal About Ideals of Global Justice. In Oxford Handbook to Global Justice, ed. Tom Brooks. Oxford: Oxford University Press (forthcoming), https://bfi.uchicago.edu/sites/default/files/research/Barry_Wiens.pdf. Accessed 5 Oct 2017.Google Scholar
  8. Blake, Michael. 2002. Distributive justice, State Coercion and Autonomy. Philosophy and Public Affairs 30 (3): 257–296.Google Scholar
  9. Blau, Francine, and Christopher Mackie. 2016. The Economic and Fiscal Consequences of Immigration. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.Google Scholar
  10. Borjas, George, and Lawrence Katz. 2007. The Evolution of the Mexican-Born Workforce in the United State. In Mexican Immigration in the United States, ed. Georges Borjas, 15–36. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Brochmann, Grete. 1999. Controlling Immigration in Europe. In Mechanism of Immigration: A Comparative Analysis of European Regulation Policies, ed. Grete Brochmann and Tomas Hammar, 297–334. Oxford: Berg.Google Scholar
  12. Brock, Gillian. 2009. Global Justice: A Cosmopolitan Account. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Campbell, Tom. 1976. Humanity Before Justice. British Journal of Political Science 4 (1): 1–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Caney, Simon. 2011. Humanity, Associations and Global Justice. The Monist 94 (4): 506–534.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Carens, Joseph. 1987. Aliens and Citizens: The Case for Open Borders. The Review of Politics 49 (2): 251–273.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. ———. 2013. The Ethics of Immigration. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  17. Casal, Paula. 2011. Global Taxes on Natural Resources. Journal of Moral Philosophy 8: 307–327.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Cohen, Gerard. 2011. In Mind the Gap, ed. Michael Otsuka, 203–210. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  19. Dagger, Richard. 2000. Membership, Fair Play and Political Obligation. Political Studies 48: 104–117.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Dworkin, Ronald. 2002. Sovereign Virtue. The Theory and Practice of Equality. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  21. Entzinger, Han. 2007. Open Borders and the Welfare State. In Migration Without Borders, ed. Antonine Pécoud and Paul De Guchteneire, 119–134. New York: Bergham Books.Google Scholar
  22. Fetzer, Joel S. 2016. Open Borders and International Migration Policy. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
  23. Gaisbauer, Helmut P., Gottfried Schweiger, and Clemens Sedmak, eds. 2016. Ethical Issues in Poverty Alleviation. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
  24. Garcia Gibson, Francisco. 2016. Conflicts Between Domestic Inequality and Global Poverty: Lexicality vs. proportionality. Ethics & Global Politics 9. Available at: http://www.ethicsandglobalpolitics.net/index.php/egp/article/view/29803/50467
  25. Gilabert, Pablo. 2012. From Global Poverty to Global Equality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Goodin, Robert. 1992. If People Were Money…. In Free Movement, ed. Brian Barry Brian and Robert Goodin, 6–22. University Park: The Pennsylvania State University Press.Google Scholar
  27. ———. 1988. What Is So Special About Our Fellow Countrymen? Ethics 98: 633–686.Google Scholar
  28. Higgins, Peter W. 2013. Immigration Justice. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Howard, Michael. 2006. Basic Income and Migration Policy: A Moral Dilemma. Basic Income Studies. An International Journal of Basic Income Research 1 (1): 1–22.Google Scholar
  30. Huemer, Michael. 2010. Is There a Right to Immigrate? Social Theory and Practice 36 (3): 429–461.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Hulme, David. 2015. Global Poverty. Abingdon: Routldge.Google Scholar
  32. Ibister, John. 2000. A Liberal Argument for Border Controls: Reply to Carens. International Migration Review 34 (2): 629–635.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Iglesias, Marisa. 2007. Poverty and humanity. In Ethics and Social Justice, ed. Jordi Ferrer and Susana Pozzolo, 155–190. Berlin: Duncker & Humblot.Google Scholar
  34. Kagan, Shelley. 1991. The Limits of Morality. Oxford: Clarendon Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Kukathas, Chandran. 2014. The Case for Open Immigration. In Contemporary Debates in Applied Ethics, ed. Andrew Cohen and Christopher Wellman, 376–388. Chichester: Willey-Blackwell.Google Scholar
  36. Ladin, Keren. 2014. Absolute Deprivation. In The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia of Health, Illness, Behavior, and Society, ed. William Cockerham, Robert Dingwall, and Stella Quah. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell.Google Scholar
  37. Lenard, Patti Tamara, and Margaret Moore. 2009. Ineliminable Tension: A Reply to Abizadeh and Gilabert’s. Philosophical Studies 138: 349–365.Google Scholar
  38. Lomasky, Loren, and Fernando Teson. 2015. Justice at Distance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Loriaux, Sylvie. 2006. Beneficence and Distributive Justice in a Globalized World. Global Society 20 (3): 251–266.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Macedo, Stephen. 2011. When and Why Should Liberal Democracies Restrict Immigration? In Citizenship, Borders and Human Needs, ed. Rogers Smith, 301–323. Pennsylvania: The University of Pennsylvania Press.Google Scholar
  41. Mason, Andrew. 2006. Levelling the Playing Field. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Milanovic, Branko. 2016. Global Inequality. Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Miller, Richard. 1998. Cosmopolitan Respect and the Patriotic Concern. Philosophy and Public Affairs 27 (3): 202–224.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. ———. 2007. National Responsibility and Global Justice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. ———. 2008. A Response. Critical Review of Social and Political Philosophy 11 (4): 553–567.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Miller, Richard. 2010. Globalizing Justice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Nagel, Thomas. 1991. Equality and Partiality. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  48. ———. 2005. The Problem of Global Justice. Philosophy & Public Affairs 33 (2): 113–147.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Oberman, Kieran. 2015. Poverty and Immigration Policy. American Political Science Review 109 (2): 239–251.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. ———. 2016. Immigration as a Human Right. In Migration in Political Theory, ed. Lea Ypi and Sara Fine, 35–56. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  51. Øyen, Else. 2008. The Paradox of Poverty Research. Forum for Development Studies 2: 331–345.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Pevnick, Ryan. 2011. Immigration and the Constrains of Justice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Pogge, Thomas. 1997. Migration and Poverty. In Citizenship and Exclusion, ed. Veit Bader, 12–27. Basingstoke: Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. ———. 2002. World Poverty and Human Rights. Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar
  55. ———. 2011. Are We Violating the Human Rights of the World’s Poor? Yale Human Rights & Development Law Journal 14 (2): 1–33.Google Scholar
  56. Rawls, John. 1999a. A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  57. ———. 1999b. The Law of Peoples with “The idea of Public Reason Revisited”. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  58. Reiff, Mark. 2009. Proportionality, Winner-Take-all and Distributive Justice. Politics, philosophy & economics 8 (1): 5–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Risse, Mathias. 2005. Do We Owe the Global Poor Assistance or Rectification? Ethics & International Affairs 19 (1): 9–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Sangiovanni, Andrea. 2007. Global Justice, Reciprocity and the State. Philosophy & Public Affairs 35 (1): 3–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Scheffler, Samuel. 2001. Boundaries and Allegiances. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  62. Schemmel, Christian. 2007. On the Usefulness of Luck Egalitarian Arguments for Global Justice. Global Justice: Theory Practice Rhetoric 1: 54–67.Google Scholar
  63. Shachan, Ayelet. 2009. The Birthright Lottery. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  64. Singer, Peter. 2016. Famine, Affluence and Morality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  65. Tan, Kok-Chor. 2004. Justice Without Borders. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. ———. 2012. Cosmopolitanism and Patriotism. In Rooted Cosmopolitanism. Canada and the Word, ed. Will Kymlicka and Kathryn Walker, 31–46. Vancouver: UBC Press.Google Scholar
  67. ———. 2014. Sufficiency, Equality and the Consequences of Global Coercion. Law, Ethics and Philosophy 8: 190–209.Google Scholar
  68. Valentini, Laura. 2011. Justice in a Globalized World. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Van der Ven, Robert. 2008. Reasonable Partiality for Compatriots and the Global Responsibility Gap. Critical Review of Social and Political Philosophy 11 (4): 413–432.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Van Parijs, Philippe, Yanick Vanderborght. 2010. Basic income, globalization and migration. In Sustainable Utopia and basic income in a Global Era pages. Seoul: Seoul National University. Available at: https://www.uclouvain.be/cps/ucl/doc/etes/documents/2010.BIGlobalizationMigrationdraft4.pdf.
  71. Velasco, Juan Carlos. 2016. El azar de las fronteras. México: FCE.Google Scholar
  72. Wellman, Carl. 2008. Immigration and Freedom of Association. Ethics 119: 109–141.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. ———. 2009. Immigration and Membership. In A Liberal Theory of International Justice, ed. Andrew Altman and Christopher Wellman, 158–188. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  74. Wilcox, Shelley. 2014. Do Duties to Outsiders Entail Open Borders. A Reply to Wellman. Philosophical Studies 169: 123–132.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. ———. 2015. Immigration and Borders. In The Bloomsbury Companion to Political Philosophy, ed. Andrew Fiala, 183–198. London: Bloomsbury.Google Scholar
  76. Woodward, James. 1992. Commentary: Liberalism and Immigration. In Free Movement: Ethical Issues in Transnational Migration of People and of Money, ed. Brian Barry Brian and Robert Goodin, 58–84. University Park: The Pennsylvania State University Press.Google Scholar
  77. Ypi, Lea. 2013. Cosmopolitanism Without If and Without But. In Cosmopolitanism versus Non-Cosmopolitanism, ed. Gillian Brock, 75–91. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Philosophy of LawUniversity of AlmeríaAlmeríaSpain

Personalised recommendations