Patterns of molar variation in great apes and their implications for hominin taxonomy

Part of the Vertebrate Paleobiology and Paleoanthropology book series (VERT)


In studying the nature of variation and determining the taxonomic composition of a hominin fossil assemblage the phylogenetically closest and thus the most relevant modern comparators are Homo and Pan and following these, Gorilla and Pongo. Except for Pan, however, modern hominids lack taxonomic diversity, since by most accounts each one is represented by a single living species. Pan is the sister taxon to modern humans and it is represented by two living species. As such the species of Pan have greater relevance for studying interspecific variation in fossil hominin taxonomy. Despite their relatively impoverished species representations Pan troglodytes, Gorilla gorilla and Pongo pygmaeus are, nevertheless, represented by subspecies. This makes them relevant for studying the nature of intraspecific variation, in particular for addressing the question of subspecies in hominin taxonomy. The aim of this study is to examine the degree and pattern of molar variation in species and subspecies of P. pygmaeus, G. gorilla, P. troglodytes and P. paniscus. I test the hypothesis that measurements taken on the occlusal surface of molars are capable of discriminating between species and subspecies in commingled samples of great apes. The results of this study are used to draw inferences about our ability to differentiate between species and subspecies of fossil hominins. The study samples include P. t. troglodytes (n = 152), P. t. verus (n = 64), P. t. schweinfurthii (n = 79), G. g. gorilla (n = 208), G. g. graueri (n = 61), G. g. beringei (n = 30), P. p. pygmaeus (n = 140), and P. p. abelii (n = 25) . Measurements taken from digital images were used to calculate squared Mahalanobis distances between subspecies pairs. Results indicate that molar metrics are successful in differentiating between the genera, species and subspecies of great apes. There was a hierarchical level of differentiation, with the greatest separation between genera, followed by that between species within the genus Pan and finally between subspecies within species. The patterns of molar differentiation showed excellent concordance with the patterns of molecular differentiation, which suggests that molar metrics have a reasonably strong phylogenetic signal. Pan troglodytes troglodytes and P. troglodytes schweinfurthii were separated by the least dental distance. P. troglodytes verus was separated by a greater distance from these two, but on the whole the distances among subspecies of P. troglodytes were less than among subspecies of G. gorilla and P. pygmaeus. The dental distance between G. g. gorilla and G. g. graueri was greater than that observed between P. troglodytes and P. paniscus. With size adjustment intergroup distances between gorilla subspecies were reduced, resulting in distances comparable to subspecies of P. troglodytes. A contrast between size-preserved and size-adjusted analyses reveal that size, sexual dimorphism and shape are significant factors in the patterning of molar variation in great apes. The results of this study have several implications for hominin taxonomy, including identifying subspecies among hominins. These implications are discussed.


Pan Pongo Gorilla models molar metrics 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Ackermann, R.R., 2002. Patterns of covariation in the hominoid craniofacial skeleton: implications for paleoanthropological models. Journal of Human Evolution 42, 167–187.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Albrecht, G.H., Gelvin, B.R., Miller, J.M.A., 2003. The hierarchy of intraspecific craniometric variation in gorillas: a population-thinking approach with implications for fossil species recognition studies. In: Taylor, A.B., Goldsmith, M.L. (Eds.), Gorilla Biology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 62–103.Google Scholar
  3. Bailey, S.E., Pilbrow, V.C., Wood, B.A., 2004. Interobserver error involved in independent attempts to measure cusp base areas of Pan M1s . Journal of Anatomy 205, 323–331.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Begun, D.R., 1992. Miocene fossil hominids and the chimp-human clade. Science 257, 1929–1933.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Braga, J.C., 1995. Définition de certains caractères discrets crâniens chez Pongo, Gorilla, et Pan. Perspectives taxonomiques et phylogénétiques. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Bordeaux.Google Scholar
  6. Caccone, A., Powell, J.R., 1989. DNA divergence among hominoids. Evolution 43, 925–942.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Collard, M., Wood, B., 2000. How reliable are human phylogenetic hypothesis? Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 97, 5003–5006.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Collard, M., Wood, B., 2001. Homoplasy and the early hominid masticatory system: inferences from analyses of extant hominoids and papionins. Journal of Human Evolution 41, 167–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Coolidge, H.J., 1929. A revision of the genus Gorilla. Memoirs of the Museum of Comparative Zoology Harvard 50, 293–381.Google Scholar
  10. Coolidge, H.J., 1933. Pan paniscus: Pygmy chimpanzee from south of the Congo River. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 18, 1–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Courtenay, J., Groves, C.P., Andrews, P., 1988. Inter– or intra-island variation? An assessment of the differences between Bornean and Sumatran orang-utans. In: Schwartz, J.H. (Ed.), Orangutan Biology. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 19–29.Google Scholar
  12. Darroch, J.N., Mosimann, J.E., 1985. Canonical and principal components of shape. Biometrika 72, 241–252.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Falsetti, A.B., Jungers, W.L., Cole III, T.M., 1993. Morphometrics of the callitrichid forelimb: a case study in size and shape. International Journal of Primatology 14, 551–572.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Futuyma, D.J., 1986. Evolutionary Biology. Sinauer Associates, Inc., Sunderland, MAGoogle Scholar
  15. Gagneux, P., Wills, C., Gerloff, U., Tautz, D., Morin, P.A., Boesch, C., Fruth, B., Hohmann, G., Ryder, O., Woodruff, D.S., 1999. Mitochondrial sequences show diverse evolutionary histories of African hominoids. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 96, 5077–5082.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Garner, K.J., Ryder, O.A., 1996. Mitochondrial DNA diversity in gorillas. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 6, 39–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Gibbs, S., Collard, M., Wood, B., 2000. Soft-tissue characters in higher primate phylogenetics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 97, 11130–11132.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Goldberg, T.L., 1998. Biogeographic predictors of genetic diversity in populations of eastern African chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes schweinfurthii). International Journal of Primatology 19, 237–254.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Gonder, M.K., Oates, J.E., Disotell, T.R., Forstner, M.R.J., Morales, J.C., Melnick, D.J., 1997. A new west African chimpanzee subspecies? Nature 388, 337.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Goodman, M., 1962. Evolution of the immunologic species specificity of human serum proteins. Human Biology 34, 104–150.Google Scholar
  21. Goodman, M., Romero-Herrera, A.E., Dene, H., Czelusniak, J., Tashian, R.E., 1982. Macromolecular sequences in systematic and evolutionary biology. In: Goodman, M. (Ed.), Macromolecular Sequences in Systematic and Evolutionary Biology. Plenum Press, New York, pp. 115–191.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Goodman, M., Porter, C.A., Czelusniak, J., Page, S.L., Schneider, H., Shoshani, J., Gunnell, G., Groves, C.P., 1998. Toward a phylogenetic classification of primates based on DNA evidence complemented by fossil evidence. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, 585–598.Google Scholar
  23. Groves, C.P., 1967. Ecology and taxonomy of the Gorilla. Nature 213, 890–893.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Groves, C.P., 1970. Population systematics of the Gorilla. Journal of Zoology. London. 161, 287–300.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Groves, C.P., 1986. Primate systematics. In: Swindler, D.R., Erwin, J. (Eds.), Comparative Primate Biology, Volume 1. Systematics, Evolution, and Anatomy. Alan R. Liss, New York, pp. 187–218.Google Scholar
  26. Groves, C.P., 2001. Primate Taxonomy. Smithsonian University Press, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
  27. Grubb, P., 1982. Refuges and dispersals in the speciation of African forest mammals. In: Prance, G.T. (Ed.), Biological Diversification in the Tropics. Columbia University Press, New York, pp. 537–553.Google Scholar
  28. Grubb, P., 1999. Evolutionary processes implicit in distribution patterns of modern African mammals. In: Bromage, T.J., Schrenk, F. (Eds.), African Biogeography, Climate Change, and Human Evolution. Oxford University Press, New York, pp. 150–164.Google Scholar
  29. Guy, F., Brunet, M., Schmittbuhl, M., Viriot, L., 2003. New approaches in hominoid taxonomy: morphometrics. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 121, 198–218.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Harvati, K., Frost, S.R., McNulty, K.P., 2004. Neanderthal taxonomy reconsidered: implications of 3D primate models of intra- and interspecific differences. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 101,1147–1152.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Hill, W.C.O., 1967. The taxonomy of the genus Pan. In: Starck, D. Schneider, R., Kuhn, H.-J. (Eds.), Neue Ergebnisse der Primatologie. Fischer, Stuttgart, pp. 47–54.Google Scholar
  32. Hill, W.C.O., 1969. The nomenclature, taxonomy and distribution of Chimpanzees. In: Bourne, G.H. (Ed.). The Chimpanzee. Vol. 1. Karger, Basel, pp. 22–49.Google Scholar
  33. Horn, A.D., 1979. The taxonomic status of the bonobo chimpanzee. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 51, 273–282.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. James, F.C., McCullough, C.E., 1990. Multivariate statistical methods in ecology and systematics: Panacea or Pandora’s Box. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 211, 129–166.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Jenkins, P., 1990. Catalogue of Primates in the British Museum (Natural History). Part V. Natural History Museum Publications, London.Google Scholar
  36. Jensen-Seaman, M.I., Kidd, K.K., 2001. Mitochondrial DNA variability and biogeography of eastern gorillas. Molecular Ecology 10, 2241–2247.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Jensen-Seaman, M.I., Deinard, A.S., Kidd, K.K., 2003. Mitochondrial and nuclear DNA estimates of divergence between western and eastern gorillas. In: Taylor, A.B., Goldsmith, M.L. (Eds.), Gorilla Biology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 247–268.Google Scholar
  38. Johanson, D.C., 1974. An odontological study of the chimpanzee with some implications for hominoid evolution. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Chicago.Google Scholar
  39. Jolly, C.J., 1993. Species, subspecies, and baboon systematics. In: Kimbel, W.H., Martin, L.B. (Eds.) Species, Species Concepts, and Primate Evolution. Plenum Press, New York, pp. 67–107.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Jolly, C.J., 2001. A proper study for mankind: analogies from the papionin monkeys and their implications for human evolution. Yearbook of Physical Anthropology 44, 177–204.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Jolly, C.J., Oates, J.F., Disotell, T.R., 1995. Chimpanzee kinship. Science 268, 185–187.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Jungers, W.L. Susman, R.S., 1984. Body size and skeletal allometry in African apes. In: Susman, R.L. (Ed.), Evolutionary Morphology and Behavior of the Pygmy Chimpanzee. Plenum Press, New York. pp. 131–178.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Kano, T., 1992. The Last Ape: Pygmy Chimpanzee Behavior and Ecology. Stanford University Press, Stanford.Google Scholar
  44. Kimbel, W.H., 1991. Species, species concepts and hominid evolution. Journal of Human Evolution 20, 355–372.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Kimbel, W.H., Martin, L.B., 1993. (Eds). Species, Species Concepts and Primate Evolution. Plenum Press, New York.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Kingdon, J., 1989. Island Africa. Princeton University Press, Princeton.Google Scholar
  47. Kinzey, W.G., 1984. The dentition of the pygmy chimpanzee, Pan paniscus. In: Susman, R.L. (Ed.), The Pygmy Chimpanzee: Evolutionary Biology and Behavior. Plenum Press, New York, pp. 65–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Leigh, S.R., Shea, B.T., 1995. Ontogeny and the evolution of adult body size dimorphism in apes. American Journal of Primatology 36, 37–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Leigh, S.R., Relethford, J.H., Park, P.B., Konigsberg, L.W., 2003. Morphological differentiation of Gorilla subspecies. In: Taylor, A.B., Goldsmith, M.L. (Eds.), Gorilla Biology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 104–131.Google Scholar
  50. Lindstedt, S.L., Calder, W.A.III., 1981. Body size, physiological time, and longevity of homeothermic animals. Quaterly Review of Biology 56, 1–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Lockwood, C.A., Kimbel, W.H., Lynch, J.M., 2004. Morphometrics and hominoid phylogeny: Support for a chimpanzee-human clade and differentiation among great ape subspecies. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 101, 4356–4360.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Mahler, P.E., 1973. Metric variation in the pongid dentition. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Michigan.Google Scholar
  53. Mayr, E., 1942. Systematics and the Origin of Species. Columbia University Press, New York.Google Scholar
  54. Mayr, E., 1982. Of what use are subspecies? The Auk 99, 593–595.Google Scholar
  55. Miller, J.M.A., Albrecht, G.H., Gelvin, B.R., 2004. Craniometric variation in early Homo compared to modern gorillas: a population-thinking approach. In: Anapol, F., German, R.Z., Jablonski, N.G. (Eds.), Shaping Primate Evolution. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 66–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Morbeck, M.E., Zihlman, A.L., 1989. Body size and proportions in chimpanzees, with special reference to Pan troglodytes schweinfurthii from Gombe National Park, Tanzania. Primates 30, 369–382.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Morin, P.A., Moore, J.J., Chakraborthy, R., Jin, L., Goodall, J., Woodruff, D.S., 1994. Kin selection, social structure, gene flow, and the evolution of chimpanzees. Science 265, 1193–1201.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Mosimann, J.E., James, F. C., 1979. New statistical methods for allometry with application to Florida red-winged blackbirds. Evolution 33, 444–459.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Muir C.C., Galdikas B.M., Beckenbach A.T., 2000. MtDNA sequence diversity of orangutans from the islands of Borneo and Sumatra. Journal of Molecular Evolution 51, 471–80.Google Scholar
  60. Pilbeam, D., 1996. Genetic and morphological records of the Hominoidea and hominid origins: a synthesis. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 5, 155–168.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Pilbeam, D., 2000. Hominoid systematics: the soft evidence. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 97, 10684–10686.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Pilbrow, V.C., 2003. Dental variation in African apes with implications for understanding patterns of variation in species of fossil apes. Ph.D. Dissertation, New York University.Google Scholar
  63. Pilbrow, V.C., 2006a. Lingual incisor waits in the modern hominoids and their utility for fossil hominoid taxonomy. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 129, 323-338.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Pilbrow, V.C., 2006b. Population systematics of chimpanzees using molar morphometrics. Journal of Human Evolution 51, 646-662.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Pilbrow, V.C. Bailey, S.E., 2005. Patterns of intraspecific variation in dental metrics of Gorilla gorilla, Pan troglodytes and Homo sapiens: a comparison using Wright’s (1969) Fst statistic. PaleoAnthropology 3, 13. Google Scholar
  66. Röhrer-Ertl, O., 1984. Research history, nomenclature and taxonomy of the orang-utan. In: Schwartz, J.H., (Ed.), Orang-utan Biology. Oxford University Press, Oxford,pp. 7–18.Google Scholar
  67. Ruvolo, M., 1994. Molecular evolutionary processes and conflicting gene trees: the hominoid case. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 94, 89–113.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Ruvolo, M., 1997. Molecular phylogeny of the hominoids: inferences from multiple independent DNA sequence data sets. Molecular Biology and Evolution 14, 248–265.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Ruvolo, M., Pan, D., Zehr, S., Goldberg, T., Disotell, T.R., 1994. Gene trees and hominoid phylogeny. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 91, 8900–8904.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Saltonstall, K., Amato, G., Powell, J., 1998. Mitochondrial DNA variability in Grauer’s gorillas of Kahuzi-Biega National Park. Journal of Heredity 89, 129–135.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Sarmiento, E.E., Butynski, T., 1996. Present problems in gorilla taxonomy. Gorilla Journal 19, 5–7.Google Scholar
  72. Sarmiento, E.E., Oates, J.F., 2000. The Cross River gorillas: a distinct subspecies, Gorilla gorilla diehli Matschie 1904. Am. Mus. Novitates 3250, 56 pp.Google Scholar
  73. Schaefer, K., Mitteroecker, P., Gunz, P., Bernhard, M., Bookstein, F.L., 2004. Craniofacial sexual dimorphism patterns and allometry among extant hominids. Annals of Anatomy 186, 471–478.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Schwartz, J.H., 1984. The evolutionary relationships of man and orang-utans. Nature 308, 501–505.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Scott, J.E., Lockwood C.A., 2004. Patterns of tooth crown size and shape variation in great apes and humans and species recognition in the hominid fossil record. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 125, 303–319.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Shea, B.T., 1981. Relative growth of the limbs and trunk in the African apes. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 56, 179–201.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Shea, B.T., 1983a. Size and diet in the evolution of African ape craniodental form. Folia Primatologica 40, 32–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Shea, B.T., 1983b. Allometry and heterochrony in the African apes. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 62, 275–289.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Shea, B.T., 1983c. Paedomorphy and neoteny in the pygmy chimpanzee. Science 222, 521–522.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Shea, B.T., 1984. An allometric perspective on the morphological and evolutionary relationships between pygmy (Pan paniscus) and common (Pan troglodytes) chimpanzees. In: Susman, R.L. (Ed.), The Pygmy Chimpanzee: Evolutionary Biology and Behavior. Plenum Press, New York, pp. 89–130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Shea, B.T., Coolidge, H.J. Jr., 1988. Craniometric differences and systematics in the genus Pan. Journal of Human Evolution 17, 671–685.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Shea, B.T., Leigh, S.R., Groves, C.P., 1993. Multivariate craniometric variation in chimpanzees: implications for species identification in paleoanthropology. In: Kimbel, W.H., Martin, L.B. (Eds.), Species, Species Concepts, and Primate Evolution. Plenum Press, New York, pp. 265–296.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Sibley, C., Ahlquist, J., 1984. The phylogeny of the hominoid primates, as indicated by DNA-DNA hybridization. Journal of Molecular Evolution 20, 1–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Smith, H., Chiszar, M.D., Montanucci, R.R., 1997. Subspecies and classification. Herpetological Review 28, 13–16.Google Scholar
  85. Stumpf, R.M., Polk, J.D., Oates, J.F., Jungers, W.L., Heesy, C.P., Groves, C.P., Fleagle, J. G., 2003. Patterns of diversity in gorilla cranial morphology. In: Taylor, A.B., Goldsmith, M.L. (Eds.), Gorilla Biology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 35–61.Google Scholar
  86. Swindler, D.R., 1976. Dentition of Living Primates. Academic Press, London.Google Scholar
  87. Swindler, D.R., 2002. Primate Dentition: An Introduction to the Teeth of Non-Human Primates. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. Taylor, A.B., 2006. Size and shape dimorphism in great ape mandibles and implications for fossil species recognition. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 129, 82–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Taylor, A.B., Groves, C.P., 2003. Patterns of mandibular variation in Pan and Gorilla and implications for African ape taxonomy. Journal of Human Evolution 44, 529–561.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  90. Tattersall, I., 1986. Species recognition in human paleontology. Journal of Human Evolution 15, 165–175.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. Tattersall. I., 1991. What was the human revolution? Journal of Human Evolution 20, 77–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  92. Tattersall, I., 1993. Speciation and morphological differentiation in the genus Lemur. In: Kimbel, W.H., Martin, L.B. (Eds.), Species, Species Concepts, and Primate Evolution. Plenum Press, New York, pp. 163–176.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  93. Templeton, A.R., 1999. Human Races: A genetic and evolutionary perspective. American Anthropologist 100, 632–650.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  94. Uchida, A., 1992. Intra-species variation among the great apes: Implications for taxonomy of fossil hominoids. Ph.D. Dissertation, Harvard University.Google Scholar
  95. Uchida, A., 1996. Craniodental variation among the great apes. Peabody Museum Bulletin, 4. Harvard University.Google Scholar
  96. Wolpoff, M.H., Hawks, J., Frayer, D.W., Hunley, K. 2001. Modern human ancestry at the peripheries: a test of the replacement theory. Science. 291, 293–297.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  97. Wood, B., Richmond, B.G., 2000. Human evolution: taxonomy and paleobiology. Journal of Anatomy 197, 19–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  98. Wrangham, R.W., de Waal, F.B.M., McGrew, W.C., 1994. The challenge of behavioral diversity. In: Wrangham, R.W., McGrew, W.C., de Waal, F.B.M., Heltne, P.G. (Eds.), Chimpanzee Cultures. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass., pp. 1–18.Google Scholar
  99. Xu, X., Arnason, U., 1996. The mitochondrial DNA molecule of Sumatran orangutan and a molecular proposal for two (Bornean and Sumatran) species of orangutan. Journal of Molecular Evolution 43, 431–437.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  100. Zhi, L., Karesh, W.B., Janczewski, D.N., Frazier-Taylor, H., Sajuthi, D., Gombek, F., Andau, M., Martenson, J.S., O’Brien, S.J., 1996. Genomic differentiation among natural populations of orang-utan (Pongo pygmaeus). Current Biology 6, 1326–1336.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2007

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Zoology DepartmentUniversity of MelbourneVictoriaAustralia

Personalised recommendations