Advertisement

Labour Safeguards of International Financial Institutions: Can They Help to Avoid Violations of ILO Core Labour Standards?

  • Franz Christian EbertEmail author
Chapter
Part of the European Yearbook of International Economic Law book series (EUROYEAR, volume 10)

Abstract

A number of International Financial Institutions (IFIs) at the global and regional level have adopted labour-related safeguard policies to avoid that projects financed by them contribute to labour standards violations. This chapter analyses the potential of these safeguards to contribute to the protection of the Core Labour Standard, as defined by the ILO. To this end, the chapter looks, first, at the safeguards’ legal design. It reviews the normative content of selected IFI labour safeguards and assesses their relation with relevant ILO instruments, highlighting a number of inconsistencies in this regard. Furthermore, the chapter scrutinizes the scope of relevant labour safeguards, revealing several loopholes that may provide borrowers with avenues to avoid many of the safeguards’ requirements by adjusting the project structure. Secondly, the chapter assesses the safeguards’ practical implications. To this end, it examines the mechanisms established by several IFIs to prevent and remedy violations of the safeguards’ requirements. In addition, the chapter reviews evidence on the safeguards’ application, highlighting positive outcomes in several cases despite an overall mixed picture. The concluding section points to some general caveats that may hamper the safeguards overall effectiveness and emphasises the need for more comprehensive mechanisms to protect workers with regard to IFI activities.

References

  1. Abouharb R, Cingranelli D (2007) Human rights and structural adjustment. CUP, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  2. Agustí-Panareda J, Ebert FC, LeClercq D (2015) ILO labor standards and trade agreements: a case for consistency. Comp Labor Law Policy J 36:347–380Google Scholar
  3. Anner M, Caraway T (2010) International institutions and workers’ rights: between labor standards and market flexibility. Stud Comp Int Dev 45:151–169CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Arp B (2012) La integración de los derechos humanos en la labor del Banco Mundial: El caso del Ombudsman y Asesor en Materia de Observancia. Revista Española de Derecho Internacional 64:11–14Google Scholar
  5. Asrani S, Dann P (2012) International Finance Corporation (IFC). In: Wolfrum R (ed) Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law, vol V. OUP, Oxford, pp 793–896Google Scholar
  6. Bakvis P (2009) The World Bank’s doing business report: a last fling for the Washington Consensus? Transfer: Eur Rev Labour Res 15:419–438CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bakvis P, McCoy M (2008) Core labour standards and international organizations: what inroads has labour made? Friedrich Ebert Stiftung, BonnGoogle Scholar
  8. Berg J, Cazes S (2008) Policymaking gone awry: the labor market regulations of the doing business indicators. Comp Labor Law Policy J 29:349–381Google Scholar
  9. Blanton RG, Blanton SL, Peksen D (2015) The impact of IMF and World Bank programs on labor rights. Polit Res Q 68:324–336CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bohoslavsky JP, Ebert FC (2018) Debt crises, economic adjustment, and labour standards. In: Bantekas I, Lumina C (eds) Sovereign debt and human rights, vol 2018. OUP, Oxford, pp 284–302Google Scholar
  11. Bradlow D (2005) Private complainants and international organizations: a comparative study of the independent inspection mechanisms in International Financial Institutions. Georgetown J Int Law 36:403–494Google Scholar
  12. Bradlow D, Naudé Fourie A (2013) The operational policies of the World Bank and the international finance corporation. Int Organ Law Rev 10:3–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Bugalski N (2016) The demise of accountability at the World Bank? Am Univ Int Law Rev 31:1–56Google Scholar
  14. Carrasco ER, Guernsey AK (2008) The World Bank’s Inspection Panel: promoting true accountability through arbitration. Cornell Int Law J 41:577–629Google Scholar
  15. Cradden C, Graz J-C, Pamingle L (2017) Governance by contract? The impact of the International Finance Corporation’s social conditionality on worker organization and social dialogue. Working Paper Université de Lausanne/Swiss Network for International Studies. https://snis.ch/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/3296_final_wp_governancebycontract_final_working_paper_1.pdf
  16. Dann P, Riegner M (2017) Safeguard-Review der Weltbankgruppe. Ein neuer Goldstandard für das globale Umwelt- und Sozialrecht? Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ), BonnGoogle Scholar
  17. Darrow M (2003) Between light and shadow: the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund and International Human Rights Law. Hart, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  18. Davis KE, Dadush S (2010) The privatization of development assistance: symposium overview. N Y Univ J Int Law Polit 42:1079–1089Google Scholar
  19. Ebert FC (2014) The integration of labour standards concerns into the environmental and social policy of the International Finance Corporation. Verfassung und Recht in Übersee 47:229–249CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Ebert FC (2015) International Financial Institutions’ approaches to labour law: the case of the International Monetary Fund. In: Blackett A, Trebilcock A (eds) Research handbook on transnational labour law. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, pp 124–137CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Ebert FC (2018) Labour standards and the World Bank. Analysing the potential of safeguard policies for protecting workers. In: Gött H (ed) Labour standards in international economic law. Springer, Cham, pp 273–304CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Fischer S (1999) A role for labor standards in the new international economy? Opening and overview: International Architecture Reform, 29 October 1999 (Washington)Google Scholar
  23. ITUC (2011) Labour standards in World Bank group lending. Lessons Learned and Next Steps, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  24. La Hovary C (2009) Les droits fondamentaux au travail. Origines, statut et impact en droit international. Presses Universitaire de France, ParisGoogle Scholar
  25. McBeth A (2010) International economic actors and human rights. Routledge, LondonGoogle Scholar
  26. Murphy H (2014) The World Bank and core labour standards: between flexibility and regulation. Rev Int Polit Econ 21:399–431CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Naudé Fourie A (2009) The World Bank Inspection Panel and quasi-judicial oversight. In search of the ‘Judicial Spirit’ in public international law. Eleven International Publishing, UtrechtGoogle Scholar
  28. O’Brien R (2014) Antagonism and accommodation: the labor-IMF/World Bank relationship. In: Kaasch A, Stubbs P (eds) Transformations in global and regional social policies. Springer, Heidelberg, pp 153–174CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Passoni C, Rosenbaum A, Vermunt E (2016) Empowering the inspection panel: the impact of the World Bank’s new environmental and social safeguards. N Y Univ J Int Law Polit 49:921–958Google Scholar
  30. Ragazzi M (2012a) Financial institutions, international. In: Wolfrum R (ed) Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law, vol IV. OUP, Oxford, pp 21–29Google Scholar
  31. Ragazzi M (2012b) World Bank group. In: Wolfrum R (ed) Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law, vol X. OUP, Oxford, pp 909–912Google Scholar
  32. Saper B (2012) The International Financial Corporation’s Compliance Advisor/Ombudsman (CAO): an examination of accountability and effectiveness from a global administrative law perspective. Int Law Polit 44:1279–1329Google Scholar
  33. Sarfaty GA (2012) Values in translation. Human rights and the culture of the World Bank. Stanford University Press, StanfordGoogle Scholar
  34. Schill SW (2012) Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA). In: Wolfrum R (ed) Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law, vol VII. OUP, Oxford, pp 410–416Google Scholar
  35. Schlemmer-Schulte S (2012) International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD). In: Wolfrum R (ed) Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law, vol V. OUP, Oxford, pp 363–393Google Scholar
  36. Suzuki E (2012) Regional development banks. In: Wolfrum R (ed) Max Planck Encyclopaedia of Public International Law, vol VIII. OUP, Oxford, pp 824–838Google Scholar
  37. Tiroch K (2012) Black Sea. In: Wolfrum R (ed) Max Planck Encyclopaedia of Public International Law, vol I. OUP, Oxford, pp 949–956Google Scholar
  38. Van Den Meersche D (2017) Accountability in international organisations: reviewing the World Bank’s environmental and social framework. In: Sciso E (ed) Accountability, transparency and democracy in the functioning of Bretton Woods Institutions, pp 157–187Google Scholar
  39. Wang H (2017) New multilateral development banks: opportunities and challenges for global governance. Global Policy 8:113–118CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Wong Y, Mayer B (2015) The World Bank’s Inspection Panel. A tool for accountability? World Bank Leg Rev 6:495–530Google Scholar
  41. Yifeng C (2018) The making of global public authorities: the role of IFIs in setting International Labor Standards, AIIB Yearbook of International Law, pp 109–128Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International LawHeidelbergGermany

Personalised recommendations