Planning and chemical plant operating procedure synthesis: A case study
Operating Procedure Synthesis (OPS) has been used to produce operating procedures for chemical plants. However, the application of AI planning to this domain has rarely been considered, and when it has the scope of the system used has limited it to solving ‘toy’ problems.
This paper describes a case study for the INTergrating OPerability (INT-OP) project at Salford and Loughborough that used a state-of-the-art least commitment planner with ‘goals of prevention’, called CEP (Chemical Engineering Planner), to produce procedures for a real-world chemical plant. A double effect evaporator test rig is the domain for the case study.
The development of the domain is discussed. Particular attention is paid to the domain modelling, which involved the description of the domain, development of operators/ safety restrictions, and the definition of the problem. There is then a presentation of the results, the lessons learned and the problems that remain.
KeywordsHeat Exchanger Plan Graph Chemical Plant Safety Restriction Feed Tank
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Aelion, V & Powers, G.J. (1991) A Unified Strategy for the Retrofit Synthesis of Flowsheet Structures for Attaining or Improving Operating Procedures. In: Computers and Chemical Engineering, vol. 15 no 5, pp349–360, Pergamon 1991Google Scholar
- Aylett, R.S. & Jones, S.D. (1996) Planner and Domain: Domain Configuration for a Task Planner. International Journal of Expert Systems v9 no2 pp279–318, JAI Press 1996.Google Scholar
- Chien, S.A. (1996) Static and Completion Analysis for Planning Knowledge Base Development and Verification. Proceedings, 3rd International Conference on AI Planning Systems, pp53–61, AAAI Press, 1996.Google Scholar
- Chien, S.A; Hill, R.W; Wang, X; Estlin, T; Fayyad, K.V. & Mortenson, H.B. (1996) Why Realworld Planning is Difficult: a Tale of Two Applications. In: New Directions in AI Planning, M.Ghallab & A.Milani, eds, IOS Press, Washington DC 1996 pp 287–298.Google Scholar
- Chung, P.W.H. (1993) Qualitative Analysis of Process Plant Behaviour. Proceedings, Industrial and Engineering Applications of AI and Expert Systems,ed. PWH.Chung, G.Lovegrove & M.Ali, pp277-283 Gordon & Breach 1993.Google Scholar
- Crooks, C.A. & Macchietto, S. (1992) A Combined MILP and Logic-Based Approach to the Synthesis of Operating Procedures for Batch Plants. Chem. Eng. Comm. 114, pp 117–144.Google Scholar
- Currie, K, & Tate, A. (1991) O-plan: the Open Planning Architecture. AI, 52:49–86, 1991.Google Scholar
- Drabble, B. (1993) Excalibur: a program for planning and reasoning with processes. Artificial Intelligence, v62 no 1, pp 1–40, Elsevier 1993Google Scholar
- Foulkes, N.R.; Walton, M.J.; Andow, P.K. & Galluzo, M. (1988) Computer Aided Synthesis of Complex Pump and Valve Operations. Computers and Chem. Eng., 12 pp1035–1044.Google Scholar
- Fusillo, R.H. & Powers, G.J. (1987) A Synthesis Method for Chemical Plant Operating Procedures. In: Computers in Chemical Engineering, vol 11 no 4, pp 369–382, Pergamon, 1987Google Scholar
- Ivanov, V.A.; Kafarov, VV; Perov, V.L. & Reznichenko, A.A. (1980) On Algorithmization of the Start-up of Chemical Productions. Engineering Cybernetics, 18, pp104–110.Google Scholar
- Kinoshita, A.; Umeda, T & O'Shima, E. (1981) An Algorithm for Synthesis of Operational Sequences of Chemical Plants. 14th Symposium on Computerized Control and Operation of Chemical Plants, Vienna, Austria, 1981.Google Scholar
- Lakshmanan, R. & Stephanopolous, G. (1988a) Synthesis of Operating Procedures for Complete Chemical Plants-1. Hierarchical Structured Modelling for Nonlinear Planning In: Computers in Chemical Engineering, vol 12 no 9/10, pp985–1002, Pergamon 1988Google Scholar
- Lakshmanan, R. & Stephanopolous, G. (1988b) Synthesis of Operating Procedures for Complete Chemical Plants-2. A Nonlinear Planning Methodology In: Computers in Chemical Engineering, vol 12 no 9/10, pp1003–1021, Pergamon 1988Google Scholar
- Lakshmanan, R. & Stephanopolous, G. (1990) Synthesis of Operating Procedures for Complete Chemical Plants-3. Planning in the Presence of Qualitative Mixing Constraints In: Computers in Chemical Engineering, vol 14 no 3, pp301–317, Pergamon 1990Google Scholar
- Penberthy, J.S. & Weld, D.S. (1992) UCPOP: A Sound, Complete, Partial Order Planner for ADL. 3rd Int. Conf. on Knowledge Representation and Reasoning. Oct. 1992.Google Scholar
- Rivas, J.R. & Rudd, D.F. (1974) Synthesis of Failure-Safe Operations. In: AIChE Journal, vol 20 no 2, pp 320–325, March 1974Google Scholar
- Soutter, J. (1996) An Integrated Architecture for Operating Procedure Synthesis. PhD thesis, Loughborough University, Loughborough LEI 1 3TU, UK.Google Scholar
- Soutter, J. & Chung, P.W.H. (1996) Partial Order Planning with Goals of Prevention. proceedings, 15th Workshop of the UK Planning and Scheduling SIG, vol 2 pp 300–311, John Moores University, Liverpool, UK.Google Scholar
- Soutter, J. & Chung, P.W.H. (1997) Utilising Hybrid Problem Solving to Solve Operating Procedure Synthesis Problems, IChemE Research Event 97, vol2 pp793–796, Nottingham.Google Scholar
- Tate, A. (1994) O-Plan2 Task Formalism Manual Ver 2.2. Internal Report of the AI Applications Institute, 1994, University of Edinburgh.Google Scholar
- Valente, A. (1995) Knowledge-level Analysis of Planning Systems. ACM SIGART Bulletin Special Issue, 6(1), Jan 1995.Google Scholar