Abstract
This paper provides an introduction to optimal investment rules in electricity generation. It attempts to bring together methods commonly used in practice to assess electricity generation investments as well as the sophisticated tools developed by mathematical economists in the last 30 years. It begins with a description of the fundamentals of the problem (economic context of the energy and electricity sectors, the technical constraints and cost structures of generation technologies). In a second part it recalls the investment rule based on the positivity of the net present value (NPV) together with the standard tools of corporate finance needed to perform this evaluation (CAPM, WACC). This list is completed with the more specific tool of levelised cost of electricity (LCOE) used by electrical utilities and policymakers. The third part of the paper shows how the advances made in the last quarter century by economic theory mainly under the real options trademark challenged the standard investment rule. Using intensively stochastic control theory and its connection with partial differential equations, real options theory was able to assess the effects of key drivers of investment decision: uncertainty, time to build, competitive pressure and strategic interactions. The paper presents models that provided a breakthrough in the analysis of the impact of each of these drivers on investment decision rules. Despite this interest, the conclusion points out remaining obstacles for the adoption of these methods by financial divisions, mainly but not only their high level of technicity. Research guidelines that could help fill this gap are suggested.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
New Policies Scenario is defined as the expected energy demand and capacity growth when current environmental policies and announced regulations are taken into account. See [82, p. 46].
- 2.
European Union: Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovak Republic, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden and United Kingdom.
- 3.
Or even has already passed it. According to World Energy Outlook 2010 (p. 48), world oil production is to stay at 68 mb/d for the next 25 years.
- 4.
Not to be mistaken for capacity factor.
- 5.
1 MT of coal contains broadly 8.2 MWh of heat.
- 6.
- 7.
The short-term revenue is \(\pi (K,L) = p_{t}{L}^{\alpha }{K}^{1-\alpha }- wL_{t}\), we have \(\max _{L}\pi (K,L) = hp_{t}^{1/(1-\alpha )}K_{t}\) hence \(hp_{t}^{1/(1-\alpha )}\) is the short-term marginal revenue of capital which expected value can be shown to be equal to q.
References
A. B. Abel. Optimal investment under uncertainty. American Economic Review, 73, 228–233 (1983).
A. B. Abel. The effects of uncertainty on investment and the expected long-run capital stock. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 7, 39–54 (1984).
A. B. Abel, A. K. Dixit, J. C. Eberly, and R. C. Pindyck. Options, the value of capital and investment. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 111(3), 753–777 (1996).
R. Aid. Long-term risk for utility companies: The next challenges. Int. Jour. of Theoretical and Applied Finance, 13(4), 517–535 (2010).
F. L. Aguerrevere. Equilibrium investment strategies and output price behavior: A real-options approach. Review of Financial Studies, 16(4), 1239–1272, (2003).
J. M. Allen and K. P. Norris. Project estimates and outcomes in electricity generation research. Journal of Management Studies, (October), 271–287, (1970).
E. Alos, A. Eydeland, and P. Laurence. A Kirk’s and a Bachelier’s formula for three asset spread options. Energy Risk, (September), (2011).
S. Altug. Time-to-build and aggregate fluctuations: Some new evidence. International Economic Review, 30, 889–920 (1989).
K. Arrow and A. Fisher. Environmental preservation, uncertainty and irreversibility. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 88(2), 312–319 (1974).
K. Asea and P. J. Zak. Time-to-build and cycles. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 23(8), 1155–1175 (1999).
K. Back and D. Paulsen. Open-loop equilibria and perfect competition in option exercise games. Review of Financial Studies, 22(11), 4531–4532, (2009).
H. K. Baker, S. Dutta, and S. Saadi. Management views on real options in capital budgeting. Journal of Applied Finance, 21(1), 18–29 (2011).
F. M. Baldursson. Irreversible investment under uncertainty in oligopoly. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 22, 627–647 (1998).
A. Bar-Ilan and W. C. Strange. Investment lags. American Economic Review, 86(3), 610–623, June (1996).
A. Bar-Ilan, A. Sulem, and A. Zanello. Time-to-build and capacity choice. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 26, 69–98 (2002).
A. Bensoussan, G. Da Prato, M. C. Delfour, and S. K. Mitter. Representation and control of infinite dimensional systems. Birkhauser, (2007). 2nd edition.
F. E. Benth, J. S. Benth, and S. Koekebakker. Stochastic Modeling of Electricity and Related Markets. World Scientific Publishing Company, (2008).
H. J. Bierman. Capital budgeting in 1992: A survey. Financial Management, 22(24-xx) (1993).
S. Block. Are ‘Real Options’ actually used in the real world? Engineering Economist, 52(3), 255–267 (2007).
G. Bodnar, G. Hayt, and R. Marston. Wharton survey of financial risk management by US non-financial firms. Financial Management, 27(70–91), (1998).
O. Bokanowski, S. Maroso, and H. Zidani. Some convergence result for Howard’s algorithm. SIAM J. Num. Analysis, 47(4), 3001–3026 (2009).
A. Borison. Real Options analysis: Where are the Emperor’s clothes. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 17(2), 17–31 (2005).
B. Bouchard, R. Elie, and C. Imbert. Optimal control under stochastic target constraints. SIAM Journal on Control and Optimization, 48(5), 3501–3531 (2010).
B. Bouchard, R. Elie, and N. Touzi. Stochastic target problems with controlled loss. SIAM Journal on Control and Optimization, 48(5), 3123–3150 (2010).
G. Boyle and G. Guthrie. Payback without apology. Accounting and Finance, 46, 1–10 (2006).
R. Brealy and S. Myers. Principles of Corporate Finance. McGraw Hill Higher Education, (2007). 9th edition.
M. J. Brennan and E. S. Schwartz. Evaluating natural resource investments. Journal of Business, 58(2), 135–157, April (1985).
D. Brounen, A. de Jong, and K. Koedijk. Corporate finance in Europe: Confronting theory with practice. Financial Management, 33(4), 71–101, (2004).
K. C. Brown. The rate of return of selected investment projects. Journal of Finance, 33(4), 1250–1253, (1978).
D. Bunn. Evaluating the effects of privatisation of electricity. Journal of the Operational Research Society, 45, 367–375, (1994).
J. S. Busby and C. G. C. Pitts. Real options in practice: An exploratory survey of how finance officers deal with flexibility in capital appraisal. Management Accounting Research, 8, 169–186, (1997).
B. Bykşahin, M. S. Haigh, J. H. Harris, J. A. Overdahl, and M. A. Robe. Fundamentals, trader activity and derivative pricing. EFA 2009 Bergen Meetings Paper. Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=966692.
R. J. Caballero. On the sign of the investment - uncertainty relation. American Economic Review, 81, 279–288, (1991).
A. Carruth, A. Dickerson, and A. Henley. What do we know about investment under uncertainty? Journal of Economic Surveys, 14(2), 119–153, (2000).
L. Clewlow and C. Strickland. Energy Derivatives. Lacima Group, (2000).
G. M. Constantinides and S. F. Richard. Existence of optimal simple policies for discounted cost inventory and cash management in continuous time. Operations Research, 26(4), 620–636, (1978).
A. Damodaran. The promise of Real Options. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 13(2), 29–44, (2000).
Danish Energy Agency. Technology data for energy plants. Technical report, Danish Energy Agency, (2010). ISBNwww: 978-87-7844-857-6.
M. A. G. Dias. The timing of investment in E&P: Uncertainty, irreversibility, learning, and strategic consideration. In Proceedings of 1997 SPE Hydrocarbon Economics and Evaluation Symposium, (1997).
M. A. G. Dias and J. P. Teixeira. Continuous-time option games: A review of models and extensions. Multinational Finance Journal, 14(3–4), 219–254, (2010).
A. Dixit. Entry and exit decisions under uncertainty. Journal of Political Economy, 97(3), 620–638, (1989).
A. Dixit. Investment and hysteresis. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 6(1), 107–132, (1992).
A. Dixit and R. S. Pindyck. Investment Under Uncertainty. Princeton University Press, (1994).
T. Driouchi and D. Bennett. Real options in multinational decision-making: Managerial awareness and risk implications. Journal of World Business, 46, 205–219, (2011).
Y. Du and J. Parsons. Update on the cost of nuclear power. Technical Report WP-09-004, Center for Energy and Environmental Policy, (2009).
D. Duffie. Dynamic Asset Pricing Theory. Princeton University Press, (2001).
A. Ehrenmann and Y. Smeers. Stochastic equilibrium models for generation capacity expansion. Discussion paper 2010/28, CORE, (2010).
R. Epps and C. Mitchem. A comparison of capital budgeting techniques with those used in Japan and Korea. Advances in International Accounting, 7, 205–214, (1994).
A. Eydeland and K. Wolyniec. Energy and Power Risk Management: New Developments in Modeling, Pricing and Hedging. Wiley, (2002).
E. F. Fama and K. R. French. The cross-section of expected stock returns. Journal of Finance, 47,(2), 427–465, (1992).
E. F. Fama and K. R. French. The capital asset pricing model: Theory and evidence. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 18(3), 25–46, (2004).
E. O. Fisher, R. Heinkel, and J. Zechner. Dynamic capital structure choice: Theory and tests. Journal of Finance, 44, 19–40, (1989).
I. Fisher. The Theory of Interest: As Determined by Impatience to Spend Income and Opportunity to Invest. Macmillan, New York, (1930).
S. E. Fleten, K. M. Maribu, and I. Wangensteen. Optimal investment strategies in decentralized renewable power generation under uncertainty. Energy, 32, 803–815, (2007).
A. M. Foley, B. P. Ó Gallachóir, J. Hur, R. Baldick, and E. J. McKeogh. A strategic review of electricity systems models. Energy, 35, 4522–4530, (2010).
A. Ford. System dynamics and the electric power industry. System Dynamics Review, 13(1), 57–85, (1997).
D. Fudenberg and J. Tirole. Understanding rent dissipation: On the use of Game Theory in Industrial Organization. American Economic Review, 77(2), 176–183, (1985).
D. Fudenberg and J. Tirole. Preemption and rent equalization in the adoption of new technology. Review of Economic Studies, 52, 383–401, (1985).
L. Gitman and J. Forrester Jr. A survey of capital budgeting techniques used by major U.S. firms. Financial Management, 6, 66–71, (1977).
L. Gitman and V. Mercurio. Cost of capital techniques used by major U.S. firms: Survey and analysis of Fortune’s 1000. Financial Management, 14, 21–29, (1982).
H. Gman. Commodities and Commodity Derivatives: Modelling and Pricing for Agriculturals, Metals and Energy. Wiley, (2007).
H. Gman and A. Roncoroni. Understanding the fine structure of electricity prices. Journal of Business, 79(3), 1225–1262, (2006).
J. R. Graham and C. R. Harvey. The theory and practice of corporate finance: Evidence from the field. Journal of Financial Economics, 60, 187–243, (2001).
M. R. Grasselli. Getting real with real options: A utility-based approach for finite-time investment in incomplete markets. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 38(5), 740–764, (2011).
S. R. Grenadier. Equilibrium with time-to-build: A real options approach. Project Flexibility, Agency and Competition. M. Brennan and L. Trigeorgis (eds), Oxford University Press edition, (2000).
S. R. Grenadier. Option exercise games: An application to the equilibrium investment strategies of firms. Review of Financial Studies, 15(3), 691–721, (2002).
M. Grinblatt and S. Titman. Financial Markets and Corporate Strategy. McGraw Hill Higher Education, (2002). 2nd edition.
H. He and R. S. Pindyck. Investment in flexible production capacity. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 16, 575–599, (1992).
V. Henderson. Valuing the option to invest in incomplete market. Mathematics and Financial Economics, 1(2), 103–128, (2007).
C. Henry. Option values in the economics of irreplaceable assets. Review of Economic Studies, 41, 89–104, (1974).
C. Henry. Investment decisions under uncertainty: The “irreversibility effect”. American Economic Review, 646), 1006–1012, (1974).
J. Houghton. Global Warming: The Complete Briefing. Cambridge University Press, (2009). 4th edition.
R. A. Howard. Dynamic Programming and Markov Processes. MIT Press, (1960).
J. Hugonnier and E. Morellec. Corporate control and real investment in incomplete markets. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 31(5), 1781–1800, (2007).
K. J. M. Huisman. Technology Investment: A Game Theoretic Real Options Approach. Kluwer Academic Publishers, (2001).
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Climate change 2007: Synthesis report. Technical report, (2007).
International Atomic Energy Agency. Expansion planning for electrical generating systems: A guidebook. Technical Reports Series 241, Vienna, (1984).
International Energy Agency. Projected Costs of Generating Electricity. (1998).
International Energy Agency. Projected Costs of Generating Electricity. (2005).
International Energy Agency. Energy Technology Perspectives. (2008).
International Energy Agency. World Energy Outlook. (2009).
International Energy Agency. World Energy Outlook. (2010).
International Energy Agency. Projected Costs of Generating Electricity. (2010).
M. Jeanblanc, M. Yor, and M. Chesney. Mathematical Methods for Financial Markets. Springer, (2009).
P. Joskow and J. Tirole. Reliability and competitive electricity markets. RAND Journal of Economics, 38(1), 60–84, (2007).
P. J. Joskow. Vertical integration and long-term contracts: The case of coal-burning electric generating plants. Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization, 1(1), 33–80, (1985).
S. Kaplan. Power plants: Characteristics and costs. Congressional Research Services Report for Congress RL34746, US Congress, (2008).
H. Khatib. Economic Evaluation of Projects in the Electricity Supply Industry. Power and Energy Series. The Institution of Electrical Engineer, (2003).
P. Koeva. The facts about time-to-build. IMF Working Paper WP/00/138, IMF, August (2000).
P. Krueger, A. Landier, and D. Thesmar. The WACC fallacy: The real effects of using unique discount rate. 2011. AFA 2012 Chicago Meetings Paper. Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1764024.
N. Kulatilaka and E. C. Perotti. Strategic growth options. Management Science, 44(8), 1021–1031, (1998).
F. Kydland and E. Prescott. Time-to-build and aggregate fluctuations. Econometrica, 50(6), 1345–1369, (1982).
B. M. Lambrecht and W. Perraudin. Real options and preemption under incomplete information. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 27, 619–643, (2003).
E. Lannoye, M. Milligan, J. Adams, A. Tuohy, H. Chandler, D. Flynn, and M. O’Malley. Integration of variable generation: Capacity value and evaluation of flexibility. IEEE Power and Energy Society General Meeting, (2010).
J. Leahy. Investment in competitive equilibrium: The optimality of myopic behavior. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 108, 1105–1133, (1993).
S. Madj and R. Pindyck. Time-to-build, option value and investment decisions. Journal of Financial Economics, 18, 7–27, (1986).
S. Marglin. Approaches to Dynamic Investment Planning. Amsterdam North-Holland, (1967).
S. A. Marglin. Investment and interest: A reformulation and extension of Keynesian theory. The Economic Journal, 80(320), 910–931, (1970).
J. Martin and S. Titman. Single vs. multiple discount rates: How to limit “influence costs” in the capital allocation process? Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 20(2), 79–83, (2008).
R. McDonald. Real options and rules of thumb in capital budgeting. Innovation, Infrastructure, and Strategic Options. Brennan, M.J. and Trigeorgis, L., Oxford University Press edition, (1998).
R. McDonald and D. Siegel. The value of waiting to invest. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 101, 707–727, (1986).
R. C. Merton. Continuous-time finance. Wiley-Blackwell, (1992).
E. M. Miller. Uncertainty induced bias in capital budgeting. Financial Management, Autumn: 12–18, (1978).
A. Moel and P. Tufano. When are real options exercised? An empirical study of mine closings. Review of Financial Studies, 15(1), 35–64, (2002).
J. S. Moore and A. K. Reichert. An analysis of the financial management techniques currently employed by large U.S corporations. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 10(4), 623–645, (1983).
F. S. Murphy and Y. Smeers. Generation capacity expansion in imperfectly competitive restructured electricity markets. Operations Research, 53(4), 646–661, (2005).
S. C. Myers. Determinants of corporate borrowing. Journal of Financial Economics, 5, 147–175, (1977).
North American Electric Reliability Corporation. Flexibility requirements and metrics for variable generation: Implications of system planning studies. Technical report, NERC, (2010).
R. Novy-Marx. An equilibrium model of investment under uncertainty. Review of Financial Studies,20(7), 1461–1502, (2007).
Nuclear Energy Agency. Reduction of Capital Costs of Nuclear Power Plants. Nuclear Energy Agency, (2000).
H. Pham. Continuous-time Stochastic Control and Optimization with Financial Applications. Springer, (2011).
D. Pilipovic. Energy Risk: Valuing and Managing Energy Derivatives. McGraw-Hill, (1997).
D. Pilipovic. Energy Risk: Valuing and Managing Energy Derivatives. McGraw Hill, (2007). 2nd edition.
R. S. Pindyck. Adjustment costs, uncertainty, and the behavior of the firm. American Economic Review, 72(3), 415–427, (1982).
R. S. Pindyck. Irreversible investment, capacity choice, and the value of the firm. American Economic Review,78(5), 969–985, (1988).
R. S. Pindyck. Irreversibility, uncertainty, and investment. Journal of Economic Literature, 29, 1110–1148, (1991).
R. S. Pindyck. A note on competitive investment under uncertainty. American Economic Review, 83(1), 273–277, (1993).
J. Pinegar and L. Wilbricht. What managers think of capital structure theory: A survey. Financial Management, 18, 82–91, (1989).
G. Pohl and D. Mihaljek. Project evaluation and uncertainty in practice: A statistical analysis of rate-of-return divergences of 1,015 World Bank projects. World Bank Economic Review, 6(2), 255–277, (1992).
A. Porchet, N. Touzi, and X. Warin. Valuation of power plants by utility indifference and numerical computation. Mathematical Methods for Operations Research, 70(1), 47–75, (2007).
J. Quirk and K. Terasawa. Sample selection and cost underestimation bias in pioneer projects. Land Economics, 62(2), 192–200, (1986).
J.-C. Rochet and S. Villeneuve. Corporate portofolio management. Annals of Finance, 1, 225–243, (2005).
F. A. Roques, D. M. Newbery, and W. J. Nuttall. Fuel mix diversification incentives in liberalized electricity markets: A mean-variance portfolio theory approach. Energy Economics, 30, 1831–1849, (2008).
P. A. Ryan and G. P. Ryan. Capital budgeting tools for Fortune 1000: How have things changed? Journal of Business and Management, 8(4), 355–364, (2002).
P. A. Samuelson. Rational theory of warrant pricing. Industrial Management Review, 6(2), 13–32, (1965).
A. Sangster. Capital investment appraisal techniques: A survey of current usage. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 20, 307–332, (1993).
H. Scarf. The optimality of (S, s) policies in the dynamic inventory problem. In K. J. Arrow, S. Karlin, and S. Suppes, editors, Mathematical Methods in Social Sciences, pages 196–202. Stanford University Press, (1959).
E. Schwartz. Valuing long-term commodity assets. Journal of Energy Finance and Development, 3(2), 85–99, (1998).
L. Shao and A. Shao. Risk analysis and capital budgeting techniques of U. S. multinational enterprises. Managerial Finance, 22, 41–47, (1996).
W. Sharpe. Capital asset prices: A theory of market equilibrium under conditions of risk. Journal of Finance, 19, 425–42, (1964).
F. P. Sioshansi. Electricity market reform: What has the experience taught us thus far? Utilities Policy, 14(2), 63–75, (2006).
F. P. Sioshansi and W. Pfaffenberger. Electricity Market Reform: An International Perspective. Elsevier, (2006).
F. Smets. Essays on foreign direct investment. PhD thesis, Yale University, (1993).
H. T. J. Smit and L. Trigeorgis. Strategic Investment Real Options and Games. Princeton University Press, (2004).
S. C. Spatt and F. P. Sterbenz. Learning, preemption and the degree of rivalry. RAND Journal of Economics, 16(1), 84–92, (1985).
M. Stanley and S. Block. A survey of multinational capital budgeting. The Financial Review, 19, 36–54, (1984).
M. Statman and T. T. Tyebjee. Optimistic capital budgeting forecasts: An experiment. Financial Management, (Autumn), 27–33, (1985).
N. Stern. The Economics of Climate Change: The Stern’s Review. Cambridge University Press, (2010).
A. Sulem. A solvable one-dimensional model of a diffusion inventory system. Mathematics of Operations Research, 11, 125–133, (1986).
J. Thijssen. Investment under Uncertainty, Market Evolution and Coalition Spillovers in a Game Theoretic Framework. Kluwer Academic Publishers, (2004).
E. Trahan and L. Gitman. Bridging the theory-practice gap in corporate finance: A survey of chief financial officers. Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 35, 73–87, (1988).
A. Triantis and A. Borison. Real options: State of the practice. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 14, 8–14, (2001).
N.-H. M. von der Fehr and P. V. Hansen. Electricity retailing in Norway. The Energy Journal, 13(1), 25–45, (2010).
A. Vuorinen. Planning of Optimal Power Systems. Ekoenergo Oy, (2009).
J. T. Williams.: Equilibrium and options on real assets. Review of Financial Studies, 6(4), 825–850 (1993).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2014 Springer Science+Business Media New York
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Aïd, R. (2014). A Review of Optimal Investment Rules in Electricity Generation. In: Benth, F., Kholodnyi, V., Laurence, P. (eds) Quantitative Energy Finance. Springer, New York, NY. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4614-7248-3_1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4614-7248-3_1
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, New York, NY
Print ISBN: 978-1-4614-7247-6
Online ISBN: 978-1-4614-7248-3
eBook Packages: Business and EconomicsEconomics and Finance (R0)