Abstract
A number of points and criticisms were raised in the commentaries on our review paper (Farmer & Klein, 1995), and in this reply we address the most pertinent and major of those points. First, we clarify and expand upon what we mean by a temporal processing deficit. We then address Studdert-Kennedy and Mody’s (1995) major claims, which are confined to the auditory modality, that (1) a discriminative deficit underlies what they see as a rate of processing deficit, and (2) discriminative/rate deficits for speech and nonspeech materials are independent. We explain why we believe the first proposal is unlikely to provide an explanation of the temporal processing deficits that we reviewed, and we present a simple framework within which speech and nonspeech perceptual codes are viewed as higher level isolable subsystems that depend on a common, lower level, auditory input system. The speech and nonspeech systems may be influenced similarly by damage to, or impairments of, their common input system, but they can be selectively influenced by insults after the pathways diverge. Then we address some of the issues raised by Rayner, Pollatsek, and Bilsky (1995), relating to visual deficits and oculomotor behavior, and we point to the rapidly growing evidence to diminish skepticism about the occurrence of a transient system deficit in dyslexia. Next, while agreeing that case studies are valuable, we dispute Martin’s (1995) endorsement of the case study as the preferred methodology for studying a heterogeneous deficit such as developmental dyslexia. Finally, we affirm our original conclusion that more research aimed at revealing the nature and generality of the visual and auditory temporal processing deficits is warranted, and we reiterate some of our suggestions for the types of study that might help elucidate if and how these deficits might be causally related to the dyslexia with which they are frequently associated.
Article PDF
References
Aram, D. M., &Ekelman, B. L. (1988). Auditory temporal perception of children with left or right brain lesions.Neuropsychologia,26, 931–935.
Arnett, J. L., &DiLollo, V. (1979). Visual information processing in relation to age and to reading ability.Journal of Experimental Child Psychology,27, 143–152.
Breitmeyer, B. G. (1980). Unmasking visual masking: A look at the “why” behind the veil of the “how.”Psychological Review,87, 52–69.
Castles, A., &Coltheart, M. (1993). Varieties of developmental dyslexia.Cognition,47, 149–180.
Cornelissen, P., Richardson, A., Mason, A., Fowler, S., &Stein, J. (1995). Contrast sensitivity and coherent motion detection measured at photopic luminance in dyslexics and controls.Vision Research,35, 1483–1494.
DiLollo, V., Hanson, D., &McIntyre, J. S. (1983). Initial stages of visual information processing in dyslexia.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception & Performance,9, 923–935.
Edwards, V. T.,Hogben, J. H.,Clark, C. D., &Pratt, C. (in press). Effects of a red background on magnocellular functioning in average and specifically reading disabled readers.Vision Research.
Farmer, M. E. (1993).A comparison of the sequential processing abilities of dyslexic and normal readers, using visual and auditory tasks. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Dalhousie University.
Farmer, M. E., &Klein, R. (1993). Auditory and visual temporal processing in dyslexic and normal readers. In P. Tallal, A. M. Galabarda, R. R. Llinas, & C. von Euler (Eds.),Temporal information processing in the nervous system: Special reference to dyslexia and dysphasia (Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, Vol. 682, pp. 339–341). New York: New York Academy of Sciences.
Farmer, M. E., &Klein, R. M. (1995). The evidence for a temporal processing deficit linked to dyslexia: A review.Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,2, 460–493.
Geiger, G., &Lettvin, J. Y. (1987). Peripheral vision in persons with dyslexia.New England Journal of Medicine,316, 1238–1243.
Godfrey, J. J., Syrdal-Lasky, A. K., Millay, K. K., &Knox, C. M. (1981). Performance of dyslexic children on speech perception tests.Journal of Experimental Psychology,32, 401–424.
Goolkasian, P., &King, J. (1990). Letter identification and lateral masking in dyslexic and average readers.American Journal of Psychology,103, 519–538.
Hirsh, I. J., &Sherrick, C. E., Jr. (1961). Perceived order in different sense modalities.Journal of Experimental Psychology,62, 423–432.
Hyönä, J., &Olson, R. K. (1994). Dyslexic and normal readers’ eye movement patterns in reading, visual search, and tracking. In J. Ygge & G. Lennerstrand (Eds.), Eye movements in reading (pp. 233–244). Oxford: Pergamon Press.
Hyönä, J., &Olson, R. K. (in press). Eye fixation patterns among dyslexic and normal readers: Effects of word length and word frequency.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, & Cognition.
Jusczyk, P. W., Rosner, B. S., Reed, M. A., &Kennedy, L. J. (1989). Could temporal order differences underlie 2-month-olds’ discrimination of English voicing contrasts?Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,85, 1741–1749.
Kinsbourne, M., Rufo, D. T., Gamzu, E., Palmer, R. L., &Berliner, A. K. (1991). Neuropsychological deficits in adults with dyslexia.Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology,33, 763–775.
Klein, R. M., Berry, G., Briand, K., D’Entremont, B., &Farmer, M. [E.] (1990). Letter identification declines with increasing retinal eccentricity at the same rate for normal and dyslexic readers.Perception & Psychophysics,47, 601–606.
Klein, R. M., &McMullen, P. (in press).Converging methods for understanding reading and dyslexia. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Kuhl, P. K. (1992, September).The perception of speech by infants: What is given by nature, what is gained by experience. Paper presented at the New York Academy of Sciences/Rodin Remediation Academy Conference, New York.
Lehmkuhle, S., Garzia, R. P., Turner, L., Hash, T., &Baro, J. A. (1993). A defective visual pathway in children with reading disability.New England Journal of Medicine,382, 989–996.
Livingstone, M. S., &Hubel, D. H. (1987). Psychophysical evidence for separate channels for the perception of form, color, movement, and depth.Journal of Neuroscience,7, 3416–3468.
Livingstone, M. S., Rosen, G. D., Drislane, F. W., &Galaburda, A. M. (1991). Physiological and anatomical evidence for a magnocellular defect in developmental dyslexia.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,88, 7943–7947.
Lovegrove, W. J., Martin, F., &Slaghuis, W. (1986). A theoretical and experimental case for a visual deficit in specific reading disability.Cognitive Neuropsychology,3, 225–267.
Martin, R. C. (1995). Heterogeneity of deficits in developmental dyslexia and implications for methodology.Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,2, 494–500.
McConkie, G. W., &Rayner, K. (1975). The span of the effective stimulus during a fixation in reading.Perception & Psychophysics,17, 578–586.
Mody, M. (1993).Bases of reading impairment in speech perception: A deficit in rate of auditory processing or in phonological coding? Unpublished doctoral dissertation, City University of New York.
Mody, M.,Studdert-Kennedy, M., &Brady, S. (1995).Speech perception deficits in poor readers: Auditory processing of phonological coding? Manuscript submitted for publication.
Molfese, D. L., &Molfese, V. J. (1985). Electrophysical indices of auditory discrimination in newborn infants: The bases for predicting later language development?Infant Behavior & Development,8, 197–211.
Pavlidis, G. T. (1981). Do eye movements hold the key to dyslexia?Neuropsychologia,19, 57–64.
Pavlidis, G. T. (1985). Eye movement differences between dyslexic, normal, and retarded readers while sequentially fixating digits.American Journal of Optometry & Physiological Optics,62, 820–832.
Perry, A. R., Dember, W. N., Warm, J. S., &Sacks, J. G. (1989). Letter identification in normal and dyslexic readers: A verification.Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society,27, 445–448.
Posner, M. I. (1978).Chronometric explorations of mind. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Rayner, K., Murphy, L. A., Henderson, J. M., &Pollatsek, A. (1989). Selective attentional dyslexia.Cognitive Neuropsychology,6, 357–378.
Rayner, K., Pollatsek, A., &Bilsky, A. B. (1995). Can a temporal processing deficit account for dyslexia?Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,2, 501–507.
Reed, M. A. (1989). Speech perception and the discrimination of brief auditory cues in reading disabled children.Journal of Experimental Child Psychology,48, 270–292.
Shapiro, K. L., Ogden, N., &Lind-Blad, F. (1990). Temporal processing in dyslexia.Journal of Learning Disabilities,23, 99–107.
Stefanatos, G. A., Green, G. G. R., &Ratcliff, G. G. (1989). Neurophysiological evidence of auditory channel anomalies in developmental dysphasia.Archives of Neurology,46, 871–875.
Steffens, M. L., Eilers, R., Gross-Glenn, K., &Jallad, B. (1992). Speech perception in adult subjects with familial dyslexia.Journal of Speech & Hearing Research,35, 192–200.
Steinschneider, M., Schroeder, C. E., Arezzo, J. C., &Vaughan, H. G. (1995). Physiologic correlates of the voice onset time boundary in primary auditory cortex (A1) of the awake monkey: Temporal response patterns.Brain & Language,48, 326–340.
Stuart, A. (1994).A visual transient system deficit in developmental dyslexia: Psychophysical, visuospatial, electrophysiological, and anatomical evidence. Unpublished manuscript.
Studdert-Kennedy, M., &Mody, M. (1995). Auditory temporal perception deficits in the reading impaired: A critical review of the evidence.Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,2, 508–514.
Tallal, P. (1980). Auditory temporal perception, phonics, and reading disabilities in children.Brain & Language,9, 182–198.
Tallal, P., &Newcombe, F. (1978). Impairment of auditory perception and language comprehension in dysphasia.Brain & Language,5, 13–24.
Tallal, P., &Piercy, M. (1973). Developmental aphasia: Impaired rate of non-verbal processing as a function of sensory modality.Neuropsychologia,11, 389–398.
Tallal, P., Sainburg, R. L., &Jernigan, T. (1991). The neuropathology of developmental dysphasia: Behavioral, morphological, and physiological evidence for a pervasive temporal processing disorder.Reading & Writing,3, 363–377.
Treisman, A., &Gelade, G. (1980). A feature integration theory of attention.Cognitive Psychology,12, 97–136.
Underwood, N. R., &Zola, D. (1986). The span of letter recognition of good and poor readers.Reading Research Quarterly,21, 6–19.
Watson, B. U., &Miller, T. K. (1993). Auditory perception, phonological processing, and reading ability/disability.Journal of Speech & Hearing Research,36, 850–863.
Werker, J. (1989). Becoming a native listener.American Scientist,77, 54–59.
Williams, M., &LeCluyse, K. (1990). Perceptual consequences of a temporal processing deficit in reading disabled children.Journal of the American Optometric Association,61, 111–121.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
The authors would like to thank Dennis Phillips for his feedback on the ideas in this commentary.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Klein, R.M., Farmer, M.E. Dyslexia and a temporal processing deficit: A reply to the commentaries. Psychon Bull Rev 2, 515–526 (1995). https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03210987
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03210987