Abstract
Martin and Cheng (2006) report the results of an experiment aimed at disentangling the effects of association strength from those of competition on performance on a verb generation task. Their experiment is situated at the center of a putative debate regarding the function of the left inferior frontal gyrus in language processing (see, e.g., Wagner, Paré-Blagoev, Clark, & Poldrack, 2001). Following in this tradition, Martin and Cheng purport to contrast two processes—selection between competing representations and controlled retrieval of weak associates—that we argue can be reduced to the same mechanism. We contend that the distinction between competition and association strength is a false dichotomy, and we attempt to recast this discussion within a Bayesian framework in an attempt to guide research in this area in a more fruitful direction.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Badre, D., Poldrack, R. A., Paré-Blagoev, E. J., Insler, R. Z., &Wagner, A. D. (2005). Dissociable controlled retrieval and generalized selection mechanisms in ventrolateral prefrontal cortex.Neuron,47, 907–918.
Botvinick, M. M., Braver, T. S., Barch, D. M., Carter, C. S., &Cohen, J. D. (2001). Conflict monitoring and cognitive control.Psychological Review,108, 624–652.
Desimone, R., &Duncan, J. (1995). Neural mechanisms of selective visual attention.Annual Review of Neuroscience,18, 193–222.
Gold, J. I., &Shadlen, M. N. (2001). Neural computations that underlie decisions about sensory stimuli.Trends in Cognitive Sciences,5, 10–16.
Hamilton, A. C., &Martin, R. C. (2005). Dissociations among tasks involving inhibition: A single-case study.Cognitive, Affective, & Behavioral Neuroscience,5, 1–13.
Kan, I. P., &Thompson-Schill, S. L. (2004). Selection from perceptual and conceptual representations.Cognitive, Affective, & Behavioral Neuroscience,4, 466–482.
Martin, R. C., &Cheng, Y. (2006). Selection demands versus association strength in the verb generation task.Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,13, 396–401.
Murdock, B. B., Jr. (1985). An analysis of the strength-latency relationship.Memory & Cognition,13, 511–521.
Nelson, D. L., Dyrdal, G. M., &Goodmon, L. B. (2005). What is preexisting strength? Predicting free association probabilities, similarity ratings, and cued recall probabilities.Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,12, 711–719.
Nelson, D. L., McEvoy, C. L., & Schreiber, T. A. (1998).The University of South Florida word association, rhyme, and word fragment norms. Available at w3.usf.edu/FreeAssociation/.
Pouget, A., Dayan, P., &Zemel, R. S. (2003). Inference and computation with population codes.Annual Review of Neuroscience,26, 381–410.
Ratcliff, R., &Rouder, J. N. (1998). Modeling response times for two-choice decisions.Psychological Science,9, 347–356.
Robinson, G., Blair, J., &Cipolotti, L. (1998). Dynamic aphasia: An inability to select between competing verbal responses?Brain,121, 77–89.
Shadlen, M. N., &Newsome, W. T. (2001). Neural basis of a perceptual decision in the parietal cortex (Area LIP) of the rhesus monkey.Journal of Neurophysiology,86, 1916–1936.
Thompson-Schill, S. L. (2005). Dissecting the language organ: A new look at the role of Broca’s area in language processing. In A. Cutler (Ed.),Twenty-first century psycholinguistics: Four cornerstones (pp. 173–189). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
Thompson-Schill, S. L., Bedny, M., &Goldberg, R. F. (2005). The frontal lobes and the regulation of mental activity.Current Opinion in Neurobiology,15, 219–224.
Thompson-Schill, S. L., D’Esposito, M., Aguirre, G. K., &Farah, M. J. (1997). Role of left inferior prefrontal cortex in retrieval of semantic knowledge: A reevaluation.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,94, 14792–14797.
Thompson-Schill, S. L., D’Esposito, M., &Kan, I. P. (1999). Effects of repetition and competition on activity in left prefrontal cortex during word generation.Neuron,23, 513–522.
Thompson-Schill, S. L., Swick, D., Farah, M. J., D’Esposito, M., Kan, I. P., &Knight, R. T. (1998). Verb generation in patients with focal frontal lesions: A neuropsychological test of neuroimaging findings.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,95, 15855–15860.
Usher, M., Cohen, J. D., Servan-Schreiber, D., Rajkowski, J., &Aston-Jones, G. (1999). The role of locus coeruleus in the regulation of cognitive performance.Science,283, 549–554.
Usher, M., &McClelland, J. L. (2001). The time course of perceptual choice: The leaky, competing accumulator model.Psychological Review,108, 550–592.
Vigliocco, G., Vinson, D. P., Damian, M. F., &Levelt, W. (2002). Semantic distance effects on object and action naming.Cognition,85, B61-B69.
Wagner, A. D., Paré-Blagoev, E. J., Clark, J., &Poldrack, R. A. (2001). Recovering meaning: Left prefrontal cortex guides controlled semantic retrieval.Neuron, 31, 329–338.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
The preparation of this article was supported by the following grants from the National Institutes of Health: MH60414, MH67008, MH70850 (to S.L.T.-S.), and MH062196 (to M.M.B.).
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Thompson-Schill, S.L., Botvinick, M.M. Resolving conflict: A response to Martin and Cheng (2006). Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 13, 402–408 (2006). https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03193860
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03193860