Abstract
According to common practice and oral tradition, learning verbal materials through song should facilitate word recall. In the present study, we provide evidence against this belief. In Experiment 1, 36 university students, half of them musicians, learned an unfamiliar song in three conditions. In the sung—sung condition, the song to be learned was sung, and the response was sung too. In the sung—spoken condition, the response was spoken. In the divided—spoken condition, the presented lyrics (accompanied by music) and the response were both spoken. Superior word recall in the sung—sung condition was predicted. However, fewer words were recalled when singing than when speaking. Furthermore, the mode of presentation, whether sung or spoken, had no influence on lyric recall, in either short- or long-term recall. In Experiment 2, singing was assessed with and without words. Altogether, the results indicate that the text and the melody of a song have separate representations in memory, making singing a dual task to perform, at least in the first steps of learning. Interestingly, musical training had little impact on performance, suggesting that vocal learning is a basic and widespread skill.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Besson, M., Faïta, F., Peretz, I., Bonnel, A.-M., &Requin, J. (1998). Singing in the brain: Independence of lyrics and tunes.Psychological Science,9, 494–498.
Bigand, E., &Poulin-Charronnat, B. (2006). Are we experienced listeners? A review of the musical capacities that do not depend on formal musical training.Cognition,100, 100–130.
Bonnel, A.-M., Faïta, F., Peretz, I., &Besson, M. (2001). Divided attention between lyrics and tunes of operatic songs: Evidence for independent processing.Perception & Psychophysics,63, 1201–1213.
Booth, M. W. (1981).The experience of songs. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Bowra, C. M. (1962). Primitive song. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson.
Calvert, S. L., &Billingsley, R. L. (1998). Young children’s recitation and comprehension of information presented by songs.Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology,19, 97–108.
Calvert, S. L., &Tart, M. (1993). Song versus verbal forms for verylong-term, long-term, and short-term verbatim recall.Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology,14, 245–260.
Chan, A. S., Ho, Y.-C., &Cheung, M.-C. (1998). Music training improves verbal memory.Nature,396, 128.
Chazin, S., &Neuschatz, J. S. (1990). Using a mnemonic to aid in the recall of unfamiliar information.Perceptual & Motor Skills,71, 1067–1071.
Crowder, R. G., Serafine, M. L., &Repp, B. (1990). Physical interaction and association by contiguity in memory for the words and melodies of songs.Memory & Cognition,18, 469–476.
Dell, F. (1989). Concordances rythmiques entre la musique et les paroles dans le chant: L’accent de l’e muet dans la chanson française. In M. Dominicy (Ed.),Le souci des apparences (pp. 121–136). Bruxelles: Université de Bruxelles.
Dickson, D., &Grant, L. (2003). Physics karaoke: Why not?Physics Education,4, 320–323.
Drake, C., &Palmer, C. (2000). Skill acquisition in music performance: Relations between planning and temporal control.Cognition,74, 1–32.
Gingold, H., &Abravanel, E. (1987). Music as a mnemonic: The effects of good- and bad-music settings on verbatim recall of short passages by young children.Psychomusicology,7, 25–39.
Ginsborg, J. (2002). Classical singers learning and memorising a new song: An observational study.Psychology of Music,30, 58–101.
Hayes, N., &Kaun, A. (1996). The role of phonological phrasing in sung and chanted verse.Linguistic Review,13, 243–303.
Hébert, S., &Peretz, I. (2001). Are text and tune of familiar songs separable by brain damage?Brain & Cognition,46, 169–175.
Hébert, S., Racette, A., Gagnon, L., &Peretz, I. (2003). Revisiting the dissociation between singing and speaking in expressive aphasia.Brain,126, 1838–1850.
Ho, Y.-C., Cheung, M.-C., &Chan, A. S. (2003). Music training improves verbal but not visual memory: Cross-sectional and longitudinal explorations in children.Neuropsychology,17, 439–450.
Jakobson, L. S., Cuddy, L. L., &Kilgour, A. R. (2003). Time tagging: A key to musicians’ superior memory.Music Perception,20, 307–313.
Janik, V. M., &Slater, P. J. B. (1997). Vocal learning in mammals.Advances in the Study of Behavior,26, 56–99.
Jellison, J. A., &Miller, N. L. (1982). Recall of digit and word sequences by musicians and nonmusicians as a function of spoken or sung input and task.Journal of Music Therapy,19, 194–209.
Kilgour, A. R., Jakobson, L. S., &Cuddy, L. L. (2000). Music training and rate of presentation as mediators of text and song recall.Memory & Cognition,28, 700–710.
Lerdahl, F., &Jackendoff, R. (1983).A generative theory of tonal music. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
McElhinney, M., &Annett, J. M. (1996). Pattern of efficacy of a musical mnemonic on recall of familiar words over several presentations.Perceptual & Motor Skills,82, 395–400.
Medina, S. L. (1993). The effect of music on second language vocabulary acquisition.National Network for Early Language Learning,6, 1–8.
Merker, B. (2004).Vocal learning for song: Key constraint on the path to language. Unpublished manuscript.
Morrongiello, B. A., &Roes, C. L. (1990). Children’s memory for new songs: Integration or independent storage of words and tunes?Journal of Experimental Child Psychology,50, 25–38.
New, B., Pallier, C., Ferrand, L., &Matos, R. (2001). Une base de données lexicales du français contemporain sur Internet: Lexique.L’Année Psychologique,101, 447–462.
Palmer, C., &Kelly, M. H. (1992). Linguistic prosody and musical meter in song.Journal of Memory & Language,31, 525–542.
Peretz, I. (1996). Can we lose memories for music? The case of music agnosia in a nonmusician.Journal of Cognitive Neurosciences,8, 481–496.
Peretz, I., Gagnon, L., Hébert, S., &Macoir, J. (2004). Singing in the brain: Insights from cognitive neuropsychology.Music Perception,21, 373–390.
Peretz, I., &Hyde, K. L. (2003). What is specific to music processing? Insights from congenital amusia.Trends in Cognitive Sciences,7, 362–367.
Peretz, I., Radeau, M., &Arguin, M. (2004). Two-way interactions between music and language: Evidence from priming recognition of tune and lyrics in familiar songs.Memory & Cognition,32, 142–152.
Racette, A., Bard, C., &Peretz, I. (2006). Making non-fluent aphasics speak: Sing along!Brain,129, 2571–2584.
Rainey, D. W., &Larsen, J. D. (2002). The effects of familiar melodies on initial learning and long-term memory for unconnected text.Music Perception,20, 173–186.
Rey, A. (1964).L’examen clinique en psychologie. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
Rubin, D. C. (1995).Memory in oral traditions: The cognitive psychology of counting-out rhymes, ballads, and epics. New York: Oxford University Press.
Samson, S., &Zatorre, R. J. (1991). Recognition memory for text and melody of songs after unilateral temporal lobe lesion: Evidence for dual encoding.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, & Cognition,17, 793–804.
Scotto Di Carlo, N., &Germain, A. (1985). A perceptual study of the influence of pitch on the intelligibility of sung vowels.Phonetica,42, 188–197.
Serafine, M. L., Crowder, R. G., &Repp, B. H. (1984). Integration of melody and text in memory for songs.Cognition,16, 285–303.
Serafine, M. L., Davidson, J., Crowder, R. G., &Repp, B. H. (1986). On the nature of melody—text integration in memory for songs.Journal of Memory & Language,25, 123–135.
Sloboda, J. A., &Parker, D. H. H. (1985). Immediate recall of melodies. In P. Howell, I. Cross, & R. West (Eds.),Musical structure and cognition (pp. 143–168). London: Academic Press.
Thompson, W. F., &Russo, F. A. (2004). The attribution of emotion and meaning to song lyrics.Polskie Forum Psychologiczne,9, 51–62.
Wallace, W. T. (1994). Memory for music: Effect of melody on recall of text.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, & Cognition,20, 1471–1485.
Wolfe, D. E., &Hom, C. (1993). Use of melodies as structural prompts for learning and retention of sequential verbal information by preschool students.Journal of Music Therapy,30, 100–118.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
This research was supported by a doctoral fellowship from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research to A.R. and grants from the International Human Frontier Science Program and the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada to I.P.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Racette, A., Peretz, I. Learning lyrics: To sing or not to sing?. Memory & Cognition 35, 242–253 (2007). https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03193445
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03193445