A comparison of methods for investigating the perceptual center of musical sounds
- 127 Downloads
In speech and music, the acoustic and perceptual onset(s) of a sound are usually not congruent with its perceived temporal location. Rather, these "P-centers" are heard some milliseconds after the acoustic onset, and a variety of techniques have been used in speech and music research to find them. Here we report on a comparative study that uses various forms of the method of adjustment (aligning a click or filtered noise in-phase or anti-phase to a repeated target sound), as well as tapping in synchrony with a repeated target sound. The advantages and disadvantages of each method and probe type are discussed, and then all methods are tested using a set of musical instrument sounds that systematically vary in terms of onset/rise time (fast vs. slow), duration (short vs. long), and center frequency (high vs. low). For each method, the dependent variables were (a) the mean P-center location found for each stimulus type, and (b) the variability of the mean P-center location found for each stimulus type. Interactions between methods and stimulus categories were also assessed. We show that (a) in-phase and anti-phase methods of adjustment produce nearly identical results, (b) tapping vs. click alignment can provide different yet useful information regarding P-center locations, (c) the method of adjustment is sensitive to different sounds in terms of variability while tapping is not, and (d) using filtered noise as an alignment probe yields consistently earlier probe-onset locations in comparison to using a click as a probe.
KeywordsRhythm P-center Tapping task Alignment task Negative mean asynchrony Microtiming
APP KeywordsMusic cognition Sound recognition Psychoacoustics Temporal processing
We want to thank Elise Måsvær for assistance with data collection to Experiment 2. This work was partially supported by the Research Council of Norway through its Centres of Excellence scheme, project number 262762, and the TIME project, grant number 249817.
Open practices statement
None of the data or materials for the experiments reported here are available, and none of the experiments was preregistered.
- Boring, E. G. (1942). Sensation and perception in the history of experimental psychology. New York: D. Appleton-Century Co.Google Scholar
- Danielsen, A. (2010). Here, there, and everywhere. Three accounts of pulse in D'Angelo's 'Left and Right'. In A. Danielsen (Ed.), Musical rhythm in the age of digital reproduction (pp. 19-36). Farnham: Ashgate/Routledge, UK.Google Scholar
- Danielsen, A., Nymoen, K., Anderson, E., Câmara, G. S., Langerød, M. T., Thompson, M. R., & London, J. (2019). Where is the beat in that note? Effects of attack, duration, and frequency on the perceived timing of musical and quasi-musical sounds. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, in press.Google Scholar
- Nymoen, K., Danielsen, A., & London, J. (2017). Validating attack phase descriptors obtained by the Timbre Toolbox and MIRtoolbox. In Proceedings of the SMC conferences (pp. 214–219). Aalto University, Finland.Google Scholar
- Pompino-Marschall, B. (1989). On the psychoacoustic nature of the P-center phenomenon. Journal of Phonetics 17(3): 175–192.Google Scholar
- Scott, S. K. (1993). P-Centres in speech: an acoustic analysis, PhD diss., University College London, London, UK.Google Scholar
- Thompson, M.R., Diapoulis, G., Johnson, S., Kwan, P.Y., & Himberg, T. (2015). Effect of tempo and vision on interpersonal coordination of timing in dyadic performance. In Proceedings of the 11th International Symposium on Computer Music Multidisciplinary Research, M. Aramaki, R. Kronland-Martinet, and S. Ystad (Eds.). University of Plymouth, Plymouth.Google Scholar
- Villing, R. (2010). Hearing the Moment: Measures and Models of the Perceptual Centre. PhD diss., National University of Ireland, Maynooth, Ireland.Google Scholar
- Vorberg, D., & Wing, A. M. (1996). Modeling variability and dependence in timing. In Handbook of perception and action, volume 2: Motor skills, H. Heuer, & S. W. Keele, (eds.) New York, Academic Press: 181-262.Google Scholar
- Wright, M. J. (2008). The shape of an instant: Measuring and modeling perceputal attack time with probability density functions. PhD diss., Stanford University, Stanford, CA.Google Scholar