Abstract
Beck, Prazdny, and Ivry’s (1984) interpretation of Metelli’s theory of phenomenal transparency is reexamined here. There are no constraints, because the theory considers only balanced transparency and nothing is asserted against the existence of forms of unbalanced transparency. Experiment 4 of the present study proves that conditions of intensity are primary for complete balanced transparency and cannot be overcome if figural conditions strongly suggest transparency. The equation α = (p−q)/(a−b) does not require further restrictions because the cases cited by Beck et al. concern nonbalanced transparency. Experiment i proves that figural conditions cannot be considered primary and thus be the cause of the perception of transparency. The present paper reports that, contrary to the results Beck et al. obtained in their Experiment 4, a series of experiments in which experienced subjects were used and in which estimation of transparency was compared with predictions calculated with the α formula gave satisfactory results. Beck et al.’s thesis, according to which α ∈ α′ hinders transparency whereas t ∈ t′ allows it, is confirmed. Experienced subjects and simple instructions appear to yield clearer results.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Beck.J, Prazdny, K, &Ivry, R (1984). The perception of transparency with achromatic colorsPerception& Psychophysics,35, 407–422
Da Pos, O, Cavedon, A, & Izzinoso, F. (1985). La stima soggettiva der parametri della trasparenzaAtti e Memorie dell’Accademia Patavina di Scienze, Lettere ed Artt.97
Heider, G M. (1933) New studies in transparency, form and color.Psychologische Forschung,17, 13–56.
Koffka, K. (1935)Principles of Gestalt psychology. New York. Harcourt Brace.
Metelli.F (1970) An algebraic development of the theory of perceptual transparencyErgonomics,13, 59–66.
Metelli, F. (1974a) Achromatic color conditions in the perception of transparency In R. B Macleod & H. L. Pick (Eds),Perception (pp 95–116). Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Metelli, F (1974b) The perception of transparency.Scientific American,230(4), 90–98
Metelli, F. (1975) On the visual perception of transparency. In G. B. Flores D’Arcais (Ed),Studies in perception (pp. 445–487). Milan Martello.
Metelli F (1982).Stimulation and perception of transparency (Report No. 73). Padua, Italy: University of Padua, Institute of Psychology
Metelli, F. (1985). Su alcune condizioni spazio-figurali della trasparenza. In W. Gerbino (Ed),Conoscenza e struttura (pp. 303–331). Bologna: Il Mulino.
Metzoer, W. (1955). Über Durchsichtigkeits-Erscheinungen (Vorlaufige Mitteilung).Rivista di Psicologia,49, 187–189
Morinaga, S., Noguchi, K., &Osihi, A. (1962) Dominance of mum direction in the apparent transparency.Japanese Psychological Research,4, 113–128.
Petter, G. (1960). Osservazioni sulla trasparenza fenomenicaRivista di Psicologia,54, 183–186.
Remondino, C. (1975). Achromatic color conditions in the perception of transparency. The development of an analytical model. In G. B Flores D’Arcais. (Ed.),Studies in perception (pp. 111–138). Milan: Martello.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Metelli, F., Da Pos, O. & Cavedon, A. Balanced and unbalanced, complete and partial transparency. Perception & Psychophysics 38, 354–366 (1985). https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03207164
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03207164