Summary
Patient-controlled analgesia (PCA) is the use of a portable infusion pump activated by the patient to inject an analgesic drug intravenously, subcutaneously or epidurally. PCA permits a patient to deliver a small bolus of opioid to achieve prompt relief without over sedation. Use of PCA for pain management is increasing in hospitals and home settings, largely because it can provide equivalent or better analgesia than conventional methods, and patients are more satisfied with its use. This article reports on studies published between January 1984 and December 1995 which considered cost aspects of PCA. Most studies compared the direct costs of administering PCA with the cost of other forms of drug delivery, usually intramuscular injections. A few studies have included indirect costs such as length of stay and adverse effects associated with the use of PCA. The research on cost considerations of PCA is dominated by case reports, descriptive studies and poorly designed quasi-experimental studies. The most complete and well conducted studies usually have included only drug, equipment and labour costs. Only 6 randomised controlled trials were reported, all of which were conducted on postoperative patients.
The cost effectiveness of PCA for pain management is an unresolved question because of the variability in methods used to determine costs and expenses, the different settings and patient populations in which PCA is applied, the different means to organise its management and the fact that it is a rapidly evolving technology during an era of changing reimbursement practices. There is substantial variation in the cost of drugs used in PCA and in the devices themselves, which influences the comparison of costs across studies. Also, researchers do not include the full scope of costs associated with the use of PCA in comparison with conventional drug delivery methods and some do not measure the level of pain relief achieved. Of the few complete and well designed published studies found, PCA was reported to produce superior analgesia at a higher cost than conventional intramuscular therapy in 3 studies, but to be more costly and produce less pain relief than intramuscular therapy in 1 study. There is a pressing need for cost-effectiveness, cost-utility and cost-benefit analyses to determine the appropriate clinical and cost circumstances for the use of PCA.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Carr DB, Jacox A, Chapman R, et al. Acute pain management: operative or medical procedures and trauma. Clinical practice guideline. Rockville (MD): Agency for Health Care Policy and Research; 1992 Mar. AHCPR Pub. No.: 92-0032
Sechzer PH. Create objective measurement of pain. Anesthesiology 1968; 29: 209–10
Florest WH, Methurst PWR, Kienitz ME. Self-administration of intravenous analgesics. Anesthesiology 1970; 3: 363–5
White PF. Use of parenteral narcotics in the postoperative period: the concept of ‘on-demand’ analgesia. Curr Rev Pain 1985; 16: 120–2
Marks RM, Sachar EJ. Undertreatment of medical inpatients with narcotic analgesics. Intern Med 1973; 78: 173–8
Citron ML, Kalra JM. Patient-controlled analgesia for the treatment of oncologic pain. In: Ferrante FM, Ostheimer GW, Covino BG, editors. Patient-controlled analgesia. Boston: Blackwell, 1990: 107–13
Jacox A, Carr DB, Payne R, Cancer Pain Guideline Panel. Management of cancer pain: clinical practice guideline. Rockville (MD): Agency for Health Care Policy and Research, 1994 Mar. AHCPR Pub. no.: 94-0592
Camann WR. Patient-controlled analgesia for the treatment of obstetric pain: labor. In: Ferrante FM, Ostheimer GW, Covino BG, editors. Patient-controlled analgesia. Boston: Blackwell, 1990: 114–28
Eisenach JC. Patient-controlled analgesia for the treatment of obstetric pain: post-cesarean delivery. In: Ferrante FM, Ostheimer GW, Covino BG, editors. Patient-controlled analgesia. Boston: Blackwell, 1990: 122–8
Rosaeg OP, Lindsay MP. Epidural opioid analgesia after caesarean section: a comparison of patient-controlled analgesia with meperidine and single bolus injection of morphine. Can J Anaesth 1989; 41: 1063–8
Broadman LM. Patient-controlled analgesia in children and adolescents. In: Ferrante FM, Ostheimer GW, Covino BG, editors. Patient-controlled analgesia. Boston: Blackwell, 1990: 129–38
Ballantyne JC, Carr DB, Chalmers TC, et al. Postoperative patient-controlled analgesia: meta-analyses of initial randomized control trials. J Clin Anesth 1993; 5: 182–93
Smythe M. Patient-controlled analgesia: a review. Pharmacotherapy 1992; 12(2): 132–43
Egan KJ. What does it mean to a patient to be in control? In: Ferrante FM, Ostheimer GW, Covino BG, editors. Patient-controlled analgesia. Boston: Blackwell, 1990: 17–26
White P. Patient-controlled analgesia: do the advantages outweigh the costs? Pharm Pract News 1989 May: 33
Ferrell BR, Rhiner M. Use of technology in the management of cancer pain. J Pharm Care Pain Symptom Control 1994; 2(1): 17–35
Fischberg BL, Mead DS, Ritter HTM. Evaluation and selection of patient-controlled analgesia infusion pumps. Hosp Pharm 1991; 26: 412–23, 51
Callan CM. An analysis of complaints and complications with patient-controlled analgesia. In: Ferrante FM, Ostheimer GW, Covino BG, editors. Patient-controlled analgesia. Boston: Blackwell, 1990: 139–50
Ferrell BR, Griffith H. Cost issues related to pain management: report from the Cancer Pain Panel of the Agency for Health Care Policy and Research. J Pain Symptom Manage 1994; 9: 221–34
Barbarash RA, Wellman GS. Considerations in the cost analysis of patient-controlled analgesia. Postgrad Med 1986; Special Report: 47-50
Hecker BR, Albert L. Patient-controlled analgesia: a randomized, prospective comparison between two commercially available PCA pumps and conventional analgesic therapy for postoperative pain. Pain 1988; 35: 115–20
Jones L, Neiswender JA, Perkins M. PCA: patient satisfaction, nursing satisfaction and cost-effectiveness. Nurs Manage 1989; 20: 16–7
Ferris FD, Wodinsky HB, Kerr IG, et al. A cost-minimization study of cancer patients requiring a narcotic infusion in hospital and at home. J Clin Epidemiol 1991; 44: 313–32
Moulin DE, Johnson NG, Murray-Parsons N, et al. Subcutaneous narcotic infusions for cancer pain: treatment outcome and guidelines for use. Can Med Assoc J 1992; 146(6): 891–7
Scalley RD, Berquist KD, Cochran RS. Patient-controlled analgesia in orthopedic procedures. Orthoped Rev 1988; 17(11): 1106–13
Jackson DA. Study of pain management: patient-controlled analgesia versus intramuscular analgesia. J Intraven Nurs 1989; 12(1): 42–51
McCallister JC. A painless path to PCA. An approach for success: development of a pain management program. Durham (NC): Duke University Medical Center, 1987: 1–11
Pierce JE. From all perspectives, patient-controlled analgesia seen as beneficial and profitable. Pharm Prac News 1988
Brown LD, Creswell S. Patient-controlled analgesia: an evaluation. Hosp Pharm 1988; 23: 144–52
Rose PG, Piber MS, Batista E, et al. Patient-controlled analgesia in gynecologic oncology: a comparative analysis. J Reprod Med 1989; 34(9): 651–4
Smith CV, Rayburn WF, Karaiskakis PT, et al. Comparison of patient-controlled analgesia and epidural morphine for postcesarean pain and recovery. J Reprod Med 1991; 36: 430–4
Smythe KL, Schad RF, Lucaroti RL. Patient-controlled analgesia versus intramuscular analgesic therapy. Am J Hosp Pharm 1994; 51: 1433–40
Colwell CW, Morris BA. Patient-controlled analgesia compared with intramuscular injection of analgesics for the management of pain after an orthopaedic procedure. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1995; 77A(5): 726–34
Chan WS, Chung F, McQuestion M, et al. Impact of patient-controlled analgesia on required nursing time and duration of postoperative recovery. Reg Anesth 1995; 20(6): 506–14
Bruera E, Velasco-Leiva A, Spechynski K, et al. Use of the Edmonton injector for parenteral opioid management of cancer pain: a study of 100 consecutive patients. J Pain Symptom Manage 1995; 8(8): 525–8
Jones L, Brooks J. The ABCs of PCA. RN 1990: 54–60
Weigelt JA, Dyke C, Martin RL. Alternative delivery system for controlled drugs in the surgical intensive care unit. J Trauma 1990; 30(9): 1141–7
Ross EL, Perumbeti MD. PCA: is it cost effective when used for postoperative pain management [abstract]? Anaesthesia 1988; 69,Suppl. 3A: A710
Rawal M, Berggren L. Organization of acute pain services: a low-cost model. Pain 1994; 57: 117–23
Ready LB. The economics of patient-controlled analgesia. In: Ferrante FM, Ostheimer GW, Covino BG, editors. Patient-controlled analgesia. Boston: Blackwell; 1990: 191–7
Schug SA, Large G. Economic considerations in pain management. Pharmacoeconomics 1993; 3(4): 260–5
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Jacox, A., Carr, D.B., Mahrenholz, D.M. et al. Cost Considerations in Patient-Controlled Analgesia. Pharmacoeconomics 12, 109–120 (1997). https://doi.org/10.2165/00019053-199712020-00002
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2165/00019053-199712020-00002