The Economics of Parallel Trade
- 243 Downloads
The potential for parallel trade in the European Union (EU) has grown with the accession of low price countries and the harmonisation of registration requirements. Parallel trade implies a conflict between the principle of autonomy of member states to set their own pharmaceutical prices, the principle of free trade and the industrial policy goal of promoting innovative research and development (R&D).
Parallel trade in pharmaceuticals does not yield the normal efficiency gains from trade because countries achieve low pharmaceutical prices by aggressive regulation, not through superior efficiency. In fact, parallel trade reduces economic welfare by undermining price differentials between markets. Pharmaceutical R&D is a global joint cost of serving all consumers worldwide; it accounts for roughly 30% of total costs. Optimal (welfare maximising) pricing to cover joint costs (Ramsey pricing) requires setting different prices in different markets, based on inverse demand elasticities. By contrast, parallel trade and regulation based on international price comparisons tend to force price convergence across markets. In response, manufacturers attempt to set a uniform ‘euro’ price. The primary losers from ‘euro’ pricing will be consumers in low income countries who will face higher prices or loss of access to new drugs. In the long run, even higher income countries are likely to be worse off with uniform prices, because fewer drugs will be developed.
One policy option to preserve price differentials is to exempt on—patent products from parallel trade. An alternative is confidential contracting between individual manufacturers and governments to provide country—specific ex post discounts from the single ‘euro’ wholesale price, similar to rebates used by managed care in the US. This would preserve differentials in transactions prices even if parallel trade forces convergence of wholesale prices.
KeywordsAdis International Limited Consumer Welfare Price Differential Uniform Price Patent Holder
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- 1.Remit Consultants. Single market review 1996: impact on manufacturing pharmaceutical products. London: Remit Consultants, 1996Google Scholar
- 2.Mac Arthur D. Bangemann round table: no break in EU pricing impasse. Pharma Pricing Rev 1997; 2 (1): 1–6Google Scholar
- 3.Danzon PM. Trade and price differentials for pharmaceuticals: policy options. London: Office of Health Economics (OHE), 1997Google Scholar
- 4.Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America (PhRMA). Industry profile. Washington, DC: PhRMA, 1997Google Scholar
- 6.US Government Office of Technology Assessment (OTA). Pharmaceutical R&D: costs, risks and rewards. Washington, DC: OTA, 1993Google Scholar
- 7.Danzon PM. The effects of price regulation for pharmaceuticals: national vs. global interests. Washington, DC: The American Enterprise Institute Press, 1997Google Scholar
- 9.Clarkson KW. The effects of research and promotion on rates of return. In: Helms R, editor. Competitive strategies in the pharmaceutical industry. Washington, DC: The American Enterprise Institute Press, 1996Google Scholar
- 11.Baumol WJ, Bradford DF. Optimal departures from marginal cost pricing. Am Econ Rev 1970; 60: 265–83Google Scholar
- 12.Laffont J—J, Tirole J. 1993. A theory of incentives in procurement and regulation. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1993Google Scholar
- 13.Brittan L. Brittan speech on pharmaceutical pricing [press release]. Brussels: European Commission, 1992 Dec 2Google Scholar
- 14.Danzon PM, Percy A. The effects of price regulation on productivity in pharmaceuticals: studies on income and wealth. Proceedings of a Conference on Income and Wealth; 1996 Mar: Washington, DC. New York: National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER). In pressGoogle Scholar
- 15.Thomas LG. Industrial policy and international competitiveness in the pharmaceutical industry. In: Helms RB, editor. Competitive strategies in the pharmaceutical industry. Washington, DC: The American Enterprise Institute Press, 1996Google Scholar
- 16.Varian H. 1989. Price discrimination. In: Schmalensee R, Willig R, editors. Handbook of industrial organization. Amsterdam: North Holland, 1989Google Scholar