Medical vectors: Surgical HIV transmission and the location of culpability

  • Catherine Waldby
  • Annette Houlihan
  • June Crawford
  • Susan Kippax

Abstract

This paper investigates the first documented case of non-transfusion-related surgical HIV transmission in a developed country, Australia. In 1989, four women were infected with HIV as a result of surgical procedures in a private clinic. A subsequent medical tribunal failed to establish medical negligence or a failure of infection control procedures on the part of the surgeon. We use this case to interrogate some of the assumptions about human culpability that feature in both HIV epidemiology and criminal law approaches to HIV transmission. We argue that these models for explaining viral spread overestimate the role of human agency and underestimate the importance of anonymous, contingent, material relations between viruses, bodies, and technologies. We suggest that the medical tribunal model, with its implicit recognition of viral agency and the impossibility of eliminating risk, offers an alternative model of justice to the criminal justice system, with its exclusive focus on human agency.

Keywords

HIV transmission medical technology epidemiology criminal law human intention 

References

  1. Buchanan, D. (1994). Patient-patient transmission in NSW stirs debate around universal precautions and testing. National HIV/AIDS Legal Link Newsletter, 5(1), 16–18.Google Scholar
  2. Chant, K., Lowe, D., Rubin, G., & Manning, W. (1994). Authors’ reply. The Lancet, 343, 416.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Chant, K., Lowe, D., Rubin, G., Manning, W., O’Donoughue, R., Lyle, D., et al. (1993). Patient-to-patient transmission of HIV in private surgical consulting rooms. The Lancet, 342, 1548–1549.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Collignon, P. (1994). Patient-to-patient transmission of HIV [Letter to the editor]. The Lancet, 343, 415.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Curtin, J. (1994, December 10). Reprimand for multiple AIDS doctor. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 3.Google Scholar
  6. Dwyer, J. (1993, December 23). AIDS scare is no cause for alarm [Letter to the editor]. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 8.Google Scholar
  7. Finucane, M., Slovic, P., & Mertz, C. (2000). Public perception of the risk of blood transfusion. Transfusion, 40, 1017–1022.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  8. Franceschi, S., Dal Maso, L., & La Vecchia, C. (1995). Trends in incidence of AIDS associated with transfusion of blood and blood products in Europe and the United States, 1985–93. British Medical Journal, 311(7019), 1534–1536.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  9. Ghent, C. (Executive producer). (1996, August 19). Four Corners: Minor surgery, major risk [Television broadcast]. Sydney: Australian Broadcasting Commission.Google Scholar
  10. Grosz, E. (1994). Volatile bodies: Toward a corporeal feminism. Sydney, Australia: Allen and Unwin.Google Scholar
  11. Larriera, A. (1993a, December 16). Surgery spreads AIDS: Four women infected after treatment by doctor. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 1.Google Scholar
  12. Larriera, A. (1993b, December 18). Doubts cast on the way AIDS virus was spread. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 1.Google Scholar
  13. Larriera, A. (1994, February 19). Doctor continues work after spreading AIDS. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 1.Google Scholar
  14. Larriera, A. (1995, April 20). Hospital staff mostly ignore infection safety rules. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 1.Google Scholar
  15. Leder, D. (1990). The absent body. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  16. Medical Tribunal of New South Wales. (December, 1994). Re: Dr. T. P. Davis. Reasons for determination.Google Scholar
  17. Shields, J. (1994). Patient-to-patient transmission of HIV [Letter to the editor]. The Lancet, 343, 415.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Shilts, R. (1987). And the band played on: Politics, people and the AIDS epidemic. London: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
  19. Waldby, C. (1996). AIDS and the body politic: Biomedicine and sexual difference. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  20. Waldby, C. (2000). The visible humanproject: Informatic bodies andposthuman medicine. London: Routledge.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer New York 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  • Catherine Waldby
    • 1
  • Annette Houlihan
    • 2
  • June Crawford
    • 3
  • Susan Kippax
    • 3
  1. 1.School of Sociology and AnthropologyUniversity of New South WalesSydneyAustralia
  2. 2.Griffith Law School, Nathan CampusGriffith UniversityNathanAustralia
  3. 3.National Centre in HIV Social ResearchUniversity of New South WalesSydneyAustralia

Personalised recommendations