Demography

, Volume 46, Issue 2, pp 281–301 | Cite as

Nature’s experiment? Handedness and early childhood development

  • David W. Johnston
  • Michael E. R. Nicholls
  • Manisha Shah
  • Michael A. Shields
Article

Abstract

In recent years, a large body of research has investigated the various factors affecting child development and the consequent impact of child development on future educational and labor market outcomes. In this article, we contribute to this literature by investigating the effect of handedness on child development. This is an important issue given that around 10% of the world’s population is left-handed and given recent research demonstrating that child development strongly affects adult outcomes. Using a large, nationally representative sample of young children, we find that the probability of a child being left-handed is not significantly related to child health at birth, family composition, parental employment, or household income. We also find robust evidence that left-handed (and mixed-handed) children perform significantly worse in nearly all measures of development than right-handed children, with the relative disadvantage being larger for boys than girls. Importantly, these differentials cannot be explained by different socioeconomic characteristics of the household, parental attitudes, or investments in learning resources.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Aggleton, J.P., R.W. Kentridge, and J.M.M. Good. 1994. “Handedness and Musical Ability: A Study of Professional Orchestral Players, Composers, and Choir Members.” Psychology of Music 22:148–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Annett, M. 1985. Left, Right, Hand and Brain: The Right Shift Theory. London: Lawrence Earlbaum.Google Scholar
  3. — 1992. “Spatial Ability in Subgroups of Left- and Right-Handers.” British Journal of Psychology 83:492–515.Google Scholar
  4. Annett, M. and D. Kilshaw. 1982. “Mathematical Ability and Lateral Asymmetry.” Cortex 18:547–68.Google Scholar
  5. Annett, M. and M. Manning. 1989. “The Disadvantage of Dextrality for Intelligence.“ British Journal of Psychology 80:213–26.Google Scholar
  6. Bailey, L.M. and W.F. McKeever. 2004. “A Large-Scale Study of Handedness and Pregnancy/Birth Risk Events: Implications for Genetic Theories of Handedness.” Laterality 9:175–88.Google Scholar
  7. Bakan, P., G. Dibb, and P. Reed. 1973. “Handedness and Birth Stress.” Neuropsychologia 11:363–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Baxter, J. 2007. “Children’s Time Use in the Longitudinal Study of Australian Children: Data Quality and Analytical Issues in the 4-year Cohort.” Technical Paper No. 4. Australian Institute of Family Studies, Melbourne.Google Scholar
  9. Benbow, C.P. 1986. “Physiological Correlates of Extreme Intellectual Precocity.” Neuropsychologia 24:719–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. — 1988. “Sex Differences in Mathematical Reasoning Ability in Intellectually Talented Preadolescents: Their Nature, Effects and Possible Causes.” Behavioural and Brain Sciences 11:169–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Bianki, V.L., E.B. Filippova, V.A. Shramm, K.B. Magnitskaya, and E.V. Kharitonov. 1996. “Audio-Verbal and Visuo-Spatial Memory of Elementary School Children With Varying Lateral Profiles.” Human Physiology 22:296–301.Google Scholar
  12. Bishop, D.V.M. 1990. Handedness and Developmental Disorder. London: Lawrence Erlbaum.Google Scholar
  13. Blau, D.M. 1999. “The Effect of Income on Child Development.” Review of Economics and Statistics 81:261–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Bryden, M.P., E.A. Roy, I.C. McManus, and M.B. Bulman-Fleming. 1997. “On the Genetics and Measurement of Human Handedness.” Laterality 2:317–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Bryden, P.J., J. Bruyn, and P. Fletcher. 2005. “Handedness and Health: An Examination of the Association Between Different Handedness Classification and Health Disorders.” Laterality 10:429–40.Google Scholar
  16. Cerone, L.J. and W.J. McKeever. 1999. “Failure to Support the Right-Shift Theory’s Hypothesis of a ‘Heterozygote Advantage’ for Cognitive Abilities.” British Journal of Psychology 90:109–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Chapman, L.J. and J.P. Chapman. 1987. “The Measurement of Handedness.” Brain and Cognition 6:175–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Corballis, M.C. 1991. The Lopsided Ape. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  19. Corballis, M.C., J. Hattie, and R. Fletcher. 2008. “Handedness and Intellectual Achievement: An Even-Handed Look.” Neuropsychologia 26:374–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Coren, S. 1992. The Left-Hander Syndrome: The Causes and Consequences of Left-Handedness. New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
  21. — 1995. “Differences in Divergent Thinking as a Function of Handedness and Sex.” American Journal of Psychology 108:311–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Crow, T.J., L.R. Crow, D.J. Done, and S. Leask. 1998. “Relative Hand Skill Predicts Academic Ability: Global Deficits at the Point of Hemispheric Indecision.” Neuropsychologia 36:1275–282.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Cunha, F., J.J. Heckman, L.J. Lochner, and D.V. Masterov. 2006. “Interpreting the Evidence on Life Cycle Skill Formation.” Pp. 697–812 in Handbook of the Economics of Education, edited by E.A. Hanushek and F. Welch. Amsterdam: North-Holland.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Dancey, C.P., A.E. Attree, G. Bàrdos, and A. Kovacs. 2005. “Is There a Link Between Irritable Bowel Syndrome and Left-Handedness?: An Exploratory Study.” Integrative Physiological & Behavioral Science 40:55–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Dane, S. and K. Gumustekin. 2002. “Handedness in Deaf and Normal Children.” International Journal of Neuroscience 112:995–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Denny, K. and V. O’Sullivan. 2007. “The Economic Consequences of Being Left-Handed: Some Sinister Results.” Journal of Human Resources 42:353–74.Google Scholar
  27. Faurie, C., N. Vianey-Liaud, and M. Raymond. 2006. “Do Left-Handed Children Have Advantages Regarding School Performance and Leadership Skills?” Laterality 11:57–70.Google Scholar
  28. Fox, N.A. 1985. “The Relationship of Perinatal Birth Status to Handedness: A Prospective Study.” Infant Mental Health Journal 6:175–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Fry, C. 1990. “Left-Handedness: Association With College Major Familial Sinistrality, Allergies, and Asthma.” Psychological Reports 67:419–33.Google Scholar
  30. Geschwind, N. and P. Behan. 1982. “Left-Handedness: Association With Immune Disease, Migraine, and Developmental Learning Disorder.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 79:5097–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Giagazoglou, P., E. Fotiadou, N. Angelopoulou, J. Tsikoulas, and V. Tsimaras. 1997. “Gross and Fine Motor Skills of Left-Handed Preschool Children.” Perceptual and Motor Skills 92:1122–28.Google Scholar
  32. Good, J.M.M., J.P. Aggleton, R.W. Kentridge, J.G.M. Barker, and N.J. Neave. 1997. “Measuring Musical Aptitude in Children: On the Role of Age, Handedness, Scholastic Achievement, and Socioeconomic Status.” Psychology of Music 25:57–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Gray, M. and A. Sanson. 2005. “Growing Up in Australia: the Longitudinal Study of Australian Children.” Family Matters 72:4–9.Google Scholar
  34. Guo, G. 2000. “The Mechanisms Mediating the Effects of Poverty on Children’s Intellectual Development.” Demography 37:431–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Gurd, J.M., J. Schulz, L. Cherkas, and G.C. Ebers. 2006. “Hand Preference and Performance in 20 Pairs of Monozygotic Twins With Discordant Handedness.” Cortex 42:934–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Halpern, D.F., M.G. Haviland, and C.D. Killian. 1998. “Handedness and Sex Differences in Intelligence: Evidence From the Medical College Admission Test.” Brain & Cognition 38:87–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Haveman, R. and B. Wolfe. 1995. “The Determinants of Children’s Attainments: A Review of Methods and Findings.” Journal of Economics Literature 33:1829–78.Google Scholar
  38. Heckman, J.J. 2006. “The Economics of Investing in Early Childhood.” Presentation given at The Niftey Conference, University of New South Wales, Sydney, February 8.Google Scholar
  39. Heilman, K.M. 2005. Creativity and the Brain. New York: Psychology Press.Google Scholar
  40. Heinz, M. and W. Heinz. 2002. “No Deficits at the Point of Hemispheric Indecision.” Neuropsychologia 40:701–704.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Hermelin, B. and N. O’Connor. 1986. “Spatial Representations in Mathematically and in Artistically Gifted Children.” British Journal of Educational Psychology 56:150–57.Google Scholar
  42. Inskip, P.D., R.E. Tarone, A.V. Brenner, H.A. Fine, P.M. Black, W.R. Shaprio, R.G. Selker, and M.S. Linet. 2003. “Handedness and Risk of Brain Tumours in Adults.” Cancer Epidemiology Biomarkers & Prevention 12:223–25.Google Scholar
  43. Johnston, D.W., M. Shah, and M.A. Shields. 2007. “Handedness, Time Use and Early Childhood Development.” IZA Discussion Paper No. 2752. Institute for the Study of Labor, Bonn, Germany.Google Scholar
  44. Ku, I. and R. Plotnick. 2003. “Do Children From Welfare Families Obtain Less Education?” Demography 40:151–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. McKeever, W.F. 1986. “The Influences of Handedness, Sex, Familial Sinistrality and Androgyny on Language Laterality, Verbal Ability, and Spatial Ability.” Cortex 22:521–37.Google Scholar
  46. McManus, I.C. 2002. Right Hand, Left Hand: The Origins of Asymmetry in Brains, Bodies, Atoms and Cultures. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson.Google Scholar
  47. McManus, I.C. and C.G.N. Mascie-Taylor. 1983. “Biosocial Correlates of Cognitive Abilities.“ Journal of Biosocial Science 15:289–306.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. McManus, I.C., S. Shergill, and M.P. Bryden. 1993. “Annett’s Theory That Individuals Heterozygous for the Right-Shift Gene Are Intellectually Advantaged: Theoretical and Empirical Problems.” British Journal of Psychology 84:517–37.Google Scholar
  49. Meng, L. 2007. “The Rate of Handedness Conversion and Related Factors in Left-Handed Children.” Laterality 12:131–38.Google Scholar
  50. Michel, G.F., A.N. Tyler, C. Ferre, and C. Sheu. 2006. “The Manifestation of Infant Hand-Use Preferences When Reaching for Objects During the Seven- to Thirteen-Month Age Period.” Developmental Psychobiology 48:436–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Miller, J.W., S. Jayadev, C.B. Dodrill, and G.A. Ojemann. 2005. “Gender Differences in Handedness and Speech Lateralization Related to Early Neurologic Insults.” Neurology 65:1974–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Nettle, D. 2003. “Hand Laterality and Cognitive Ability: A Multiple Regression Approach.” Brain and Cognition 52:390–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Oldfield, R.C. 1971. “The Assessment of Handedness: The Edinburgh Inventory.” Neuropsychologia 9:97–133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Orton, S.J. 1937. Reading, Writing and Speech Problems in Children. New York: Norton.Google Scholar
  55. Paxson, C. and N. Schady. 2007. “Cognitive Development Among Young Children in Ecuador: The Roles of Wealth, Health, and Parenting.” Journal of Human Resources 42:49–84.Google Scholar
  56. Peters, M. 1991. “Sex, Handedness, Mathematical Ability, and Biological Causation.” Canadian Journal of Psychology 45:415–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Peters, M., S. Reimers, and J.T. Manning. 2006. “Hand Preference for Writing and Associations With Selected Demographic and Behavioural Variables in 255,100 Subjects: The BBC Internet Study.” Brain & Cognition 62:177–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Peterson, J.M. and L.M. Lansky. 1977. “Left-Handedness Among Architects: Partial Replication and Some New Data.” Perceptual and Motor Skills 45:1216–18.Google Scholar
  59. Pipe, M.E. 1987. “Pathological Left-Handedness: Is It Familial?” Neuropsychologia 25:571–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Piro, J.M. 1998. “Handedness and Intelligence: Patterns of Hand Preference in Gifted and Nongifted Children.” Developmental Neuropsychology 14:619–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Porac, C. and S. Coren. 1977. Lateral Preferences and Human Behavior. New York: Springer-Verlag.Google Scholar
  62. Preti, A. and M. Vellante. 2007. “Creativity and Psychopathology: Higher Rates of Psychosis Proneness and Nonright-Handedness Among Creative Artists Compared to Same Age and Gender Peers.” Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 195:837–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Ramadhani, M., I. Koomen, D. Grobbee, C. van Donselaar, A.M. van Furth, and C. Uiterwaal. 2006. “Increased Occurrence of Left-Handedness After Severe Childhood Bacterial Meningitis: Support for the Pathological Left-Handedness Hypothesis.” Neuropsychologia 44:2526–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Resch, F., J. Haffner, P. Parzer, U. Pfueller, U. Strehlow, and C. Zerahn-Hartung. 1997. “Testing the Hypothesis of the Relationships Between Laterality and Ability According to Annett’s Right-Shift Theory: Findings in an Epidemiological Sample of Young Adults.” British Journal of Psychology 88:621–35.Google Scholar
  65. Ruebeck, C.S., J.E. Harrington Jr., and R. Moffitt. 2007. “Handedness and Earnings.” Laterality 12:101–20.Google Scholar
  66. Ruhm, C.J. 2004. “Parental Employment and Child Cognitive Development.” Journal of Human Resources 39:155–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Satz, P., D.L. Orsini, E. Saslow, and R. Henry. 1985. “The Pathological Left-Handedness Syndrome.” Brain and Cognition 4:27–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Snyder, P.J. and L.J. Harris. 1993. “Handedness, Sex, and Familial Sinistrality Effects on Spatial Tasks.” Cortex 29:115–34.Google Scholar
  69. Taylor, B.A., E. Dearing, and K. McCartney. 2004. “Incomes and Outcomes in Early Childhood.” Journal of Human Resources 39:980–1007.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Waldfogel, J., W. Han, and J. Brooks-Gunn. 2002. “The Effects of Early Maternal Employment on Child Cognitive Development.” Demography 30:369–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Williams, S.M. 1987. “Differences in Academic Performance at School Depending on Handedness: Matter for Neuropathology?” Journal of Genetic Psychology 148:469–78.Google Scholar
  72. Wood, C.J. and J.P. Aggleton. 1991. “Occupation and Handedness: An Examination of Architects and Mail Survey Biases.” Canadian Journal of Psychology 45:395–404.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Population Association of America 2009

Authors and Affiliations

  • David W. Johnston
    • 1
  • Michael E. R. Nicholls
    • 2
  • Manisha Shah
    • 3
  • Michael A. Shields
    • 3
  1. 1.School of Economics and FinanceQueensland University of TechnologyAustralia
  2. 2.Department of PsychologyUniversity of MelbourneAustralia
  3. 3.Department of EconomicsUniversity of MelbourneAustralia

Personalised recommendations