Demography

, Volume 47, Issue 2, pp 269–298 | Cite as

Retirement and death in office of U.S. Supreme Court justices

Article

Abstract

We construct demographic models of retirement and death in office of U.S. Supreme Court justices, a group that has gained demographic notice, evaded demographic analysis, and is said to diverge from expected retirement patterns. Models build on prior multistate labor force status studies, and data permit an unusually clear distinction between voluntary and “induced” retirement. Using data on every justice from 1789 through 2006, with robust, cluster-corrected, discrete-time, censored, event-history methods, we (1) estimate retirement effects of pension eligibility, age, health, and tenure on the timing of justices’ retirements and deaths in office, (2) resolve decades of debate over the politicized departure hypothesis that justices tend to alter the timing of their retirements for the political benefit or detriment of the incumbent president, (3) reconsider the nature of rationality in retirement decisions, and (4) consider the relevance of organizational conditions as well as personal circumstances to retirement decisions. Methodological issues are addressed.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Abel, E. and M. Kruger. 2005. “The Longevity of Baseball Hall of Famers Compared to Other Players.” Death Studies 29: 959–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Abraham, H.J. 1999. Justices and Presidents and Senators: A History of the U.S. Supreme Court Appointments From Washington to Clinton. Revised ed. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  3. Allison, P.D. 1995. Survival Analysis Using the SAS System: A Practical Guide. Cary, NC: SAS Institute, Inc.Google Scholar
  4. Atkinson, D.N. 1999. Leaving the Bench: Supreme Court Justices at the End. Lawrence, KS: Kansas University Press.Google Scholar
  5. Baker, M., M. Stabile, and C. Deri. 2004. “What Do Self-Reported, Objective, Measures of Health Measure?” Journal of Human Resources 39: 1067–93.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Baron, J.N. and J. Pfeffer. 1994. “The Social Psychology of Organizations and Inequality.” Social Psychology Quarterly 57: 190–209.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Barrow, D.J., G.S. Gryski, and G. Zuk. 1996. The Federal Judiciary and Institutional Change. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
  8. Barrow, D.J. and G. Zuk. 1990. “An Institutional Analysis of Turnover in the Lower Federal Courts, 1900–1987.” Journal of Politics 52: 457–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Bibb, R. and W. Form. 1977. “The Effects of Industrial, Occupational, and Gender Stratification on Wages in Blue Collar Labor Markets.” Social Forces 55: 974–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Biskupic, J. 2004. “The Next President Could Tip High Court.” USA Today, September 29.Google Scholar
  11. Blau, P. 1986. Exchange and Power in Social Life. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books.Google Scholar
  12. Blau, P. and O.D. Duncan. 1967. The American Occupational Structure. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
  13. Bound, J. 1991. “Self-reported Versus Objective Measures of Health in Retirement Models.” Journal of Human Resources 26: 106–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Box-Steffensmeier, J. and B. Jones. 1997. “Time Is of the Essence: Event History Models in Political Science.” American Journal of Political Science 41: 1414–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Box-Steffensmeier, J.M. and C.J.W. Zorn. 1998. “Duration Models and Proportional Hazards in Political Science.” Paper presented at the Midwest Political Science Association annual meeting, April 23–25.Google Scholar
  16. Brenner, S. 1999. “The Myth that Justices Strategically Retire.” Social Science Journal 36: 431–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Calabresi, S.G. and J. Lindgren. 2006a. “The President: Lightning Rod or King?” Yale Law Journal 115: 2611–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. —. 2006b. “Term Limits for the Supreme Court: Life Tenure Reconsidered.” Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 29: 770–877.Google Scholar
  19. Caldeira, G.A., J.R. Wright, and C.J.W. Zorn. 1999. “Strategic Voting and Gatekeeping in the Supreme Court.” Journal of Law, Economics and Organization 15: 549–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Callen, E. and H. Leidecker, Jr. 1971. “A Mean Life on the Supreme Court.” American Bar Association Journal 57: 1188–92.Google Scholar
  21. Cannell, C., P. Miller, and L. Oksenberg. 1981. “Research on Interviewing Techniques.” Pp. 389–437 in Sociological Methodology, edited by S. Leinhardt. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.Google Scholar
  22. Cleveland, W.S. and S.J. Devlin. 1988. “Locally Weighted Regression: An Approach to Regression Analysis by Local Fitting.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 83: 596–610.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Cobb, G.W. and Y.-P. Chen. 2003. “An Application of Markov Chain Monte Carlo to Community Ecology.” American Mathematical Monthly 110: 265–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Cotterman, R. and F. Peracchi. 1992. “Classification and Aggregation: An Application to Industrial Classification in CPS Data.” Journal of Applied Econometrics 7: 31–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Davies, A. and J. Ware. 1981. “Measuring Health Perceptions in the Health Insurance Experiment.” Document R-2711-HHS. Rand Corporation, Santa Monica, CA.Google Scholar
  26. Dwyer, D.S. and O.S. Mitchell. 1999. “Health Problems as Determinants of Retirement: Are Self-rated Measures Endogenous?” Journal of Health Economics 18: 173–93.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Eisenhower, D., N. Mathiowetz, and D. Morganstein. 1991. “Recall Error: Sources and Bias Reduction Techniques.” Pp. 127–44 in Measurement Errors in Surveys, edited by P.P. Biemer, R.M. Groves, L.E. Lyberg, N.A. Mathiowetz, and S. Sudman. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
  28. Epstein, L., J.A. Segal, H.J. Spaeth, and T.G. Walker, eds. 2006. Supreme Court Compendium: Data, Decisions, and Developments. 4th ed. Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly.Google Scholar
  29. Fairman, C. 1938. “The Retirement of Federal Judges.” Harvard Law Review 51: 397–443.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Farnsworth, W. 2005. “The Regulation of Turnover on the Supreme Court.” University of Illinois Law Review 2005: 407–53.Google Scholar
  31. Fazio, R.H. 1986. “How Do Attitudes Guide Human Behavior?” Pp. 204–43 in Handbook of Motivation and Cognition, Vol. 19, edited by R.M. Sorrentino and E.T. Higgins. New York: Guilford.Google Scholar
  32. Federal Judicial Center. n.d. Biographical Directory of Federal Judges. Available online at http:// www.fjc.gov/public/home.nsf/hisj.Google Scholar
  33. Fishbein, M. and I. Ajzen. 1975. Belief, Attitude, Intention and Behavior: An Introduction to Theory and Research. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.Google Scholar
  34. Fletcher, B.C. 1983. “Marital Relationships as a Cause of Death: An Analysis of Occupational Mortality and the Hidden Consequences of Marriage-Some U.K. Data.” Human Relations 36: 123–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. —. 1988. “Occupation, Marriage and Disease-Specific Mortality Concordance.” Social Science and Medicine 27: 615–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. French, E. 2005. “The Effects of Health, Wealth, and Wages on Labour Supply and Retirement Behaviour.” Review of Economic Studies 72: 395–427.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Fujiwara-Greve, T. and H.R. Greve. 2000. “Organizational Ecology and Job Mobility.” Social Forces 79: 547–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Garrow, D.J. 1998. Liberty and Sexuality: The Right to Privacy and the Making of Roe v. Wade (Updated). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  39. —. 2000. “Mental Decrepitude on the U.S. Supreme Court: The Historical Case for a 28th Amendment.” University of Chicago Law Review 67: 995–1087.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Gavrilov, L.A. and N.S. Gavrilova. 2001. “Biodemographic Study of Familial Determinants of Human Longevity.” Population: An English Selection 13: 197–222.Google Scholar
  41. Gilmour, S.G. and L.A. Trinca. 2005. “Fractional Polynomial Response Surface Models.” Journal of Agricultural, Biological and Environmental Statistics 10: 50–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Goff, J.S. 1960. “Old Age and the Supreme Court.” Journal of American History 4: 95–106.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Green, G.M. and F. Baker, eds. 1991. Work, Health, and Productivity. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  44. Greenhouse, L. 1984. “Taking the Supreme Court’s Pulse.” New York Times, Jan. 28, sec. 1, p. 8, col. 3.Google Scholar
  45. -. 2007. “As to the Direction of the Roberts Court: The Jury Is Still Out.” New York Times, March 7, sec. A, p. 15.Google Scholar
  46. Guralnik, L. 1962. “Mortality by Occupation and Industry Among Men 20 to 64 Years of Age: United States 1950.” Vital Statistics: Special Reports 53(2). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
  47. Gustman, A., O.S. Mitchell, and T.L. Steinmeier. 1995. “Retirement Measures in the Health and Retirement Study.” Journal of Human Resources 30: S57-S83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Hagle, T.M. 1993. “Strategic Retirements: A Political Model of Turnover on the United States Supreme Court.” Political Behavior 15: 25–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Han, B., C. Phillips, L. Ferrucci, K. Bandeen-Roche, M. Jylha, J. Kasper, and J.M. Guralnik. 2005. “Change in Self-rated Health and Mortality Among Community-Dwelling Disabled Older Women.” Gerontologist 45: 216–21.Google Scholar
  50. Haveman, H. 2000. “The Future of Organizational Sociology: Forging Ties Among Paradigms.” Contemporary Sociology 29: 476–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Hayward, M.D. and M.A. Hardy. 1985. “Early Retirement Processes Among Older Men: Occupational Differences.” Research on Aging 7: 491–515.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Hayward, M., W. Grady, M. Hardy, and D. Sommers. 1989. “Occupational Influences on Retirement, Disability, and Death.” Demography 26: 393–409.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Hodson, R. and R.L. Kaufman. 1982. “Economic Dualism: A Critical Review.” American Sociological Review 47: 727–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Hollander, I. 1972. “Health of Leaders and Policy-Makers.” Industrial Medicine and Surgery 41(5): 17–21.Google Scholar
  55. Hutchinson, D. 1998. The Man Who Once Was Whizzer White. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
  56. Idler, E. and S. Kasl. 1991. “Health Perceptions and Survival: Do Global Evaluations of Health Status Really Predict Mortality?” Journal of Gerontology 46: 55–65.Google Scholar
  57. Johnson, N., P. Sorlie, and E. Backlund. 1999. “The Impact of Specific Occupation on Mortality in the U.S. National Longitudinal Mortality Study.” Demography 36: 355–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Kalberg, S. 1980. “Max Weber’s Types of Rationality: Cornerstones for the Analysis of Rationalization Processes in History.” American Journal of Sociology 85: 1145–79.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Kalton, G. and H. Schuman. 1982. “The Effect of the Question on Survey Responses: A Review.” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society 145: 42–57.Google Scholar
  60. Kaplan, S. 1987. “Patient Reports of Health Status as Predictors of Physiologic Health Measures in Chronic Disease.” Journal of Chronic Disease 40(Suppl.): 27–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Kemeny, J.G. and J.L. Snell. 1960. Finite Markov Chains. Princeton, NJ: Van Nostrand.Google Scholar
  62. King, G. 1987. “Presidential Appointments to the Supreme Court, Adding Systematic Explanation to Probabilistic Description.” American Politics Quarterly 15: 373–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. —. 1997. A Solution to the Ecological Inference Problem: Reconstructing Individual Behavior From Aggregate Data. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  64. Kitagawa, E. and P. Hauser. 1973. Differential Mortality in the United States: A Study in Socioeconomic Epidemiology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  65. Land, K.C., J.M. Guralnik, and D.G. Blazer. 1994. “Estimating Increment-Decrement Life Tables With Multiple Covariates From Panel Data: The Case of Active Life Expectancy.” Demography 31: 297–319.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Lawrence, B.S. 1997. “The Black Box of Organizational Demography.” Organization Science 8: 1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Ledoux, J., G. Rubino, and B. Sericola. 1994. “Exact Aggregation of Absorbing Markov Processes Using the Quasi-Stationary Distribution.” Journal of Applied Probability 31: 626–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Lumsdaine, R. 1995. “Factors Affecting Labor Supply Decisions and Retirement Income.” NBER Working Paper No. 5223. National Bureau for Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
  69. Lumsdaine, R., J. Stock, and D.A. Wise. 1994. “Pension Plan Provisions and Retirement: Men and Women, Medicare, and Models.” Pp. 183–220 in Studies in the Economics of Aging, edited by D.A. Wise. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  70. Mace, M.L. 1986. Directors: Myth and Reality. Revised ed. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.Google Scholar
  71. McCann, J.C. 1972. “Differential Mortality and the Formation of Political Elites: The Case of the House of Representatives.” American Sociological Review 37: 689–700.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Moen, P., J.E. Kim, and H. Hofmeister. 2001. “Couples’ Work/Retirement Transitions, Gender, and Marital Quality.” Social Psychology Quarterly 64: 55–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Mossey, J. and E. Shapiro. 1982. “Self-rated Health: A Predictor of Mortality Among the Elderly.” American Journal of Public Health 72: 800–808.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Neumann, R.K., Jr. 2003. “Conflicts of Interest in Bush v. Gore: Did Some Justices Vote Illegally?” Georgetown Journal of Legal Ethics 16: 375–443.Google Scholar
  75. Nixon, D.C. and J.D. Haskin. 2000. “Judicial Retirement Strategies: The Judge’s Role in Influencing Party Control of the Appellate Courts.” American Politics Quarterly 28: 458–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. O’Hara, E. 1993. “Social Constraint or Implicit Collusion?: Toward a Game Theoretic Analysis of Stare Decisis.” Seton Hall Law Review 24: 736–78.Google Scholar
  77. Oliver, P.D. 1986. “Systematic Justice: A Proposed Constitutional Amendment to Establish Fixed, Staggered Terms for Members of the United States Supreme Court.” Ohio State Law Journal 47: 799–834.Google Scholar
  78. Parsons, D.O. 1982. “The Male Labour Force Participation Decision: Health, Reported Health, and Economic Incentives.” Economica, New Series, 49(193): 81–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Posner, R. 1993. “What Do Judges and Justices Maximize? (The Same Thing Everybody Else Does).” Supreme Court Economic Review 3: 1–41.Google Scholar
  80. Preston, S. 1977. “Mortality Trends.” Annual Review of Sociology 3: 163–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Quint, J.V. and B.R. Cody. 1970. “Preeminence and Mortality: Longevity of Prominent Men.” American Journal of Public Health 60: 1118–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Redelmeier, D.A. and S.M. Singh. 2001a. “Longevity of Screenwriters Who Win an Academy Award: A Longitudinal Study.” British Medical Journal 323: 1491–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. —. 2001b. “Survival in Academy Award-Winning Actors and Actresses.” Annals of Internal Medicine 134: 955–62.Google Scholar
  84. Robinson, W.S. 1950. “Ecological Correlations and the Behavior of Individuals.” American Sociological Review 15: 351–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Ross, C. and C.L. Wu. 1995. “The Links Between Education and Health.” American Sociological Review 60: 719–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Royston, P. and D.G. Altman. 1994. “Regression Using Fractional Polynomials of Continuous Covariates.” Applied Statistics 3: 429–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  87. Schmidhauser, J.R. 1962. “When and Why Justices Leave the Supreme Court.” Pp. 117–34 in Politics of Age, edited by W. Donahue and C. Tibbitts. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
  88. Schoen, R. and K. Woodrow. 1980. “Labor Force Status Life Tables for the United States, 1972.” Demography 17: 297–322.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Schwartz, B. 1983. Super Chief: Earl Warren and His Supreme Court. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
  90. Sørensen, J.B. and O. Sørensen. 2007. “Corporate Demography and Income Inequality.” American Sociological Review 72: 766–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. Spriggs, J.F., II and P.J. Wahlbeck. 1995. “Calling It Quits: Strategic Retirement on the Federal Courts of Appeals, 1893–1991.” Political Research Quarterly 48: 573–97.Google Scholar
  92. Squire, P. 1988. “Politics and Personal Factors in Retirement From the United States Supreme Court.” Political Behavior 10: 180–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  93. Stewman, S. 1986. “Demographic Models of Internal Labor Markets.” Administrative Science Quarterly 31: 212–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  94. Stolzenberg, R.M. 1975. “Occupations, Labor Markets and the Process of Wage Attainment.” American Sociological Review 40: 645–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  95. —. 1978. “Bringing the Boss Back in: Employer Size, Employee Schooling, and Socioeconomic Achievement.” American Sociological Review 43: 813–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  96. —. 1989. “Job Quits in Empirical and Theoretical Perspective.” Pp. 99–130 in Research in Social Stratification and Mobility, edited by A.L. Kalleberg. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.Google Scholar
  97. Stolzenberg, R.M. and D. Relles. 1990. “Theory Testing in a World of Constrained Research Design: The Significance of Heckman’s Censored Sampling Bias Correction for Nonexperimental Research.” Sociological Methods and Research 18: 395–415.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  98. —. 1997. “Tools for Intuition About Sample Selection Bias and Its Correction.” American Sociological Review 62: 494–507.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  99. Sudman, S. and N.M. Bradburn. 1982. Asking Questions: A Practical Guide to Questionnaire Design. London: Jossey-Bass.Google Scholar
  100. Swidler, A. 1973. “The Concept of Rationality in the Work of Max Weber.” Sociological Inquiry 43: 35–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  101. Toobin, J. 2007. The Nine. New York: Doubleday.Google Scholar
  102. Treas, J. 1977. “ALife Table for Postwar Senate Careers: A Research Note.” Social Forces 56: 202–207.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  103. Ulmer, S.S. 1982. “Supreme Court Appointments as a Poisson Distribution.” American Journal of Political Science 26: 113–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  104. USA Today. 2007. “Justices Judge if Health Keeps Them From Work.” USA Today, July 31. Available online at http://www.usatoday.com/news/washington/2007-07-3 1-justices-health_N.htm.Google Scholar
  105. U.S. Supreme Court. 2006. Members of the Supreme Court (1789 to Present). http://www.supremecourtus.gov/about/members.pdf.Google Scholar
  106. Van Tassel, F. 1993. “Resignations and Removals: A History of Federal Judicial Service—and Disservice—1789–1992.” University of Pennsylvania Law Review 142: 333–430.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  107. Vriend, N. 1996. “Rational Behavior and Economic Theory.” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 29: 263–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  108. Walker, T.G., J.A. Segal, H.J. Spaeth, and L. Epstein, eds. 1996. Supreme Court Compendium: Data, Decisions, and Developments. 2nd ed. Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly, Inc.Google Scholar
  109. Wallis, W.A. 1936. “The Poisson Distribution and the Supreme Court.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 31: 376–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  110. Ward, A. 2003. Deciding to Leave: The Politics of Retirement From the United States Supreme Court. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.Google Scholar
  111. —. 2004. “How One Mistake Leads to Another: On the Importance of Verification/Replication.” Political Analysis 12: 199–200.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  112. Waterbor, J., P. Cole, E. Delzell, and D. Jelkovich. 1988. “The Mortality Experience of Major-League Baseball Players.” New England Journal of Medicine 318: 1278–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  113. White, G.E. 1982. Earl Warren: A Public Life. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  114. Winship, C. and R.D. Mare. 1992. “Models for Sample Selection Bias.” Annual Review of Sociology 18: 327–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  115. Woodward, B. and S. Armstrong. 1979. The Brethren: Inside the Supreme Court. New York: Simon and Schuster.Google Scholar
  116. Wooldridge, J.M. 2001. Economic Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
  117. Yalof, D.A. 1999. Pursuit of Justices: Presidential Politics and the Selection of Supreme Court Nominees. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  118. Yamaguchi, K. 1991. Event History Analysis. Newbury Park: Sage.Google Scholar
  119. Yoon, A. 2006. “Pensions, Politics, and Judicial Tenure, An Empirical Study of Federal Judges, 1869–2002.” American Law and Economics Review 8: 143–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  120. Zorn, C.J.W. and S.R. Van Winkle. 2000. “A Competing Risks Model of Supreme Court Vacancies.” Political Behavior 22: 145–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Population Association of America 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of SociologyUniversity of ChicagoChicago
  2. 2.School of LawNorthwestern UniversityUSA

Personalised recommendations