A randomized controlled trial of mindfulness meditation versus relaxation training: Effects on distress, positive states of mind, rumination, and distraction
Background: Although mindfulness meditation interventions have recently shown benefits for reducing stress in various populations, little is known about their relative efficacy compared with relaxation interventions.Purpose: This randomized controlled trial examines the effects of a 1-month mindfulness meditation versus somatic relaxation training as compared to a control group in 83 students (M age=25; 16 men and 67 women) reporting distress.Method: Psychological distress, positive states of mind, distractive and ruminative thoughts and behaviors, and spiritual experience were measured, while controlling for social desirability.Results: Hierarchical linear modeling reveals that both meditation and relaxation groups experienced significant decreases in distress as well as increases in positive mood states over time, compared with the control group (p<.05 in all cases). There were no significant differences between meditation and relaxation on distress and positive mood states over time. Effect sizes for distress were large for both meditation and relaxation (Cohen’s d=1.36 and .91, respectively), whereas the meditation group showed a larger effect size for positive states of mind than relaxation (Cohen’s d=.71 and .25, respectively). The meditation group also demonstrated significant pre-post decreases in both distractive and ruminative thoughts/behaviors compared with the control group (p<.04 in all cases; Cohen’s d=.57 for rumination and .25 for distraction for the meditation group), with mediation models suggesting that mindfulness meditation’s effects on reducing distress were partially mediated by reducing rumination. No significant effects were found for spiritual experience.Conclusions: The data suggest that compared with a no-treatment control, brief training in mindfulness meditation or somatic relaxation reduces distress and improves positive mood states. However, mindfulness meditation may be specific in its ability to reduce distractive and ruminative thoughts and behaviors, and this ability may provide a unique mechanism by which mindfulness meditation reduces distress.
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- (2).Kabat-Zinn J, Lipworth L, Burney R, Sellers W: Four-year follow-up of a meditation-based program for the self-regulation of chronic pain: Treatment outcomes and compliance.Clinical Journal of Pain. 1986,2:159–173.Google Scholar
- (6).Kabat-Zinn J:Full Catastrophe Living. New York: Delta Books, 1990.Google Scholar
- (7).Nhat Hanh T:The Path of Emancipation. Berkeley, CA: Parallax Press, 2001.Google Scholar
- (11).Benson H:The Relaxation Response. New York: Avon Books, 1975.Google Scholar
- (15).Davidson RJ, Schwartz GE: Psychobiology of relaxation and related states. In Monstofsky D (ed),Behavior Modification and Control of Physiological Activity. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1976.Google Scholar
- (23).Schwarzer R: Thought control of action: Interfering self-doubts. In Saronson I, Pierce G, Saronson B (eds),Cognitive Interference. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc., 1996.Google Scholar
- (26).Linden W: The autogenic training method of J.H. Schultz. In Lehrer P, Woolfolk R (eds),Principles and Practice of Stress Management. New York: Guilford, 1993.Google Scholar
- (27).Derogatis LR:BSI: Administration, Scoring, and Procedures Manual I. Minneapolis, MN: National Computer Systems, 1993.Google Scholar
- (28).Derogatis LR, Savitz KL: The SCL-90-R, Brief Symptom Inventory, and Matching Clinical Rating Scales. In Maruish M (ed),The Use of Psychological Testing for Treatment Planning and Outcomes Assessment. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc., 1999.Google Scholar
- (36).Byrk AS, Raudenbush SW:Hierarchical Linear Models: Application and Data Analysis Methods. Newbury Park, CA: Sage, 1992.Google Scholar
- (39).Cohen J:Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences (2nd Ed.), Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc., 1998.Google Scholar
- (43).Carlson LE, Speca M, Patel KD, Goodey E: Mindfulness-based stress reduction in relation to quality of life, mood, symptoms of stress and levels of cortisol, dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate (DHEAS) and melatonin in breast and prostate cancer outpatients.Psychoneuroendocrinology. 2004,29:448–474.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- (46).Oikawa M: Distraction as an intervention for depression: The distraction process.Japanese Journal of Educational Psychology. 2002,50:185–192.Google Scholar