Abstract
When an interaction has been detected among the chemicals in a mixture, it may be of interest to predict the interaction threshold. A method is presented for estimation of an interaction threshold along a mixture ray which allows differences in the shapes of the dose-response curves of the individual components (e.g., mixtures of full and partial agonists with differing response maxima). A point estimate and confidence interval for the interaction threshold may be estimated. The methods are illustrated with data from a study of a mixture of 18 polyhalogenated aromatic hydrocarbons (PHAHs) in rats exposed by oral gavage for four consecutive days. Serum total thyroxine (T4) was the response variable. Previous analysis of these data demonstrated a dose-dependent interaction among the 18 chemicals in the mixture, with additivity suggested in the lower portion of the dose-response curve and synergy (greater than additive response) in the higher portion of the dose-response curve. The present work builds on this analysis by construction of an interaction threshold model along the mixture ray. This interaction threshold model has two components: an implicit additivity region and an explicit region that describes the departure from additivity; the interaction threshold is the boundary between the two regions. Estimation of the interaction threshold within the observed experimental region suggested evidence of additivity in the low dose region. Total doses of the mixture that exceed the upper limit of the confidence interval on the interaction threshold were associated with a greater-than-additive interaction.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Berenbaum, M. C. (1981), “Criteria for Analyzing Interactions Between Biologically Active Agents,” Advances in Cancer Research, 35, 269–335.
— (1985), “The Expected Effect of a Combination of Agents: The General Solution,” Journal Theoretical Biology, 114, 413–431.
Carpy, S. A., Kobel, W., and Doe, J. (2000), “Health Risk of Low-Dose Pesticides Mixtures: A Review of the 1985–1998 Literature on Combination Toxicology and Health Risk Assessment,” Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health, Part B, Critical Reviews 3, 1–25.
Casey, M., Gennings, C., Carter, Jr., W. H., Moser, V. C., and Simmons, J. E. (2004) “Detecting Interaction(s) and Assessing the Impact of Component Subsets in a Chemical Mixture Using Fixed-Ratio Mixture Ray Designs,” Journal of Agricultural, Biological, and Environmental Statistics, 9, 339–361.
Crofton, K. M., Gennings, C., Simmons, J. E., Fisher, K. C., DeVito, M. J. (2005), “Short-Term Exposure to an Environmental Mixture of PHAHs: Dose-Additive Effects on Serum Thyroxine,” Environmental Health Perspectives, 113, 1549–1554.
Dobrev, I. D., Andersen, M. E., and Yang, R. S. H. (2001), “Assessing Interaction Thresholds for Trichloroethylene in Combination with Tetrachloroethylene and 1,1,1-trichloroethane Using Gas Uptake Studies and PBPK Modeling,” Archives of Toxicology, 75, 134–144.
El-Masri, H. A., Constan, A. A., Ramsdell, H. S., and Yang, R. S. H. (1996a), “Physiologically Based Pharmacokinetic Modeling of an Interaction Threshold Between Trichloroethylene and 1,1-Dichloroethylene in Fischer 344 Rats,” Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology, 141, 124–132.
El-Masri, H. A., Tessari, J. D., and Yang, R. S. H. (1996b), “Exploration of an Interaction Threshold for the Joint Toxicity of Trichloroethylene and 1,1-Deichloroethylene: Utilization of a PBPK Model,” Archives of Toxicology, 70, 527–539.
El-Masri, M.A., Yushak, M.L., and Mumtaz, M.M. (2002), “Development of a Response Surface for the Toxicological Interaction Between Chlorpyrifos and Parathion using Physiologically Based Pharmacokinetic Modeling,” Toxicologist, 66, 36; Poster Presentation, 2002 Society of Toxicology Annual Meeting.
Gennings, C., Carter, W. H., Jr., Campain, J. A., Bae, D., and Yang, R. S. H. (2002), “Statistical Analysis of Interactive Cytotoxicity in Human Epidermal Keratinocytes Following Exposure to a Mixture of Four Metals,” Journal of Agricultural, Biological, and Environmental Statistics, 7, 58–73.
Gennings, C., Carter, W. H., Jr., Carney, E. W., Charles, G. D., Gollapudi, B. B., and Carchman, R. A. (2004), “A Novel Flexible Approach for Evaluating Fixed Ratio Mixtures of Full and Partial Agonists,” Toxicological Sciences, 80, 134–150.
Gennings, C., Carter, Jr., W. H., Carchman, R. A., Teuschler, L. K., Simmons, J. E., and Carney, E. W. (2005), “A Unifying Concept for Assessing Toxicological Interactions: Changes in Slope,” Toxicological Sciences, 88, 287–297.
Hamm, A. K. (2004), “Analysis of an Interaction Threshold in Drug/Chemical Mixtures,” Unpublished doctoral dissertation from the Department of Biostatistics, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, VA.
Hamm, A. K., Carter, Jr., W. H., and Gennings, C. (2005), “Analysis of an Interaction Threshold in a Mixture of Drugs and/or Chemicals,” Statistics in Medicine, 24, 2493–2507.
Konemann, W. H., and Pieters, M. N. (1996), “Confusion of Concepts in Mixture Toxicology,” Food and Chemical Toxicology, 34, 1025–1031.
Loewe, S. (1953), “The Problem of Synergism and Antagonism of Combined Drugs,” Arzneimittle forshung, 3, 285–290.
Loewe, S., and Muischnek, H. (1926), “Uber kombinationswirkunger. I. Mitteilung: Hiltsmittel der fragstellung Naunyn-Schmiedebergs,” Arch. Pharmacol, 114, 313–326.
McCullagh, P. (1983), “Quasi-Likelihood Functions,” The Annals of Statistics, 11, 59–67.
McCullagh, P., and Nelder, J. A. (1989), Generalized Linear Models (2nd ed.), London: Chapman & Hall.
Monosson, E. (2005), “Chemical Mixtures: Considering the Evolution of Toxicology and Chemical Assessment,” Environ Health Perspect, 113, 383–390.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (1986), Guidelines for the Health Risk Assessment of Chemical Mixtures. EPA/630/R-98/002, National Center for Environmental Assessment, Office of Research and Development, Washington, D.C. 51 FR 34014-34025. Available online at http://www.epa.gov/ncea/raf/pdfs/chem_mix/chemmix_1986.pdf.
— (1989), Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund, Vol 1, Human Health Evaluation Manual. EPA 540/1-89/002. Washington, D.C. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (2000). Supplementary Guidance for Conducting Health Risk Assessment of Chemical Mixtures. USEPA EPA/630/R-00/002. National Center for Environmental Assessment, Office of Research and Development, Washington, D.C. 51 FR 34014. Available online at http://www.epa.gov/NCEA/raf/chem_mix.htm.
— (2002), Guidance on Cumulative Risk Assessment of Pesticide Chemicals that have a Common Mechanism of Toxicity. USEPA EPA/630/R-00/002. Office of Pesticide Programs, Washington, D.C. 51 FR 34014. Available online at http://www.epa.gov/pesticides/trac/science/cumulative_guidance.pdf.
Yang, R.S.H., El-Masri, H.A., Thomas, R.S., Constan, A.A., and Tessari, J.D. (1995), “The Application of Physiologically Based Pharmacokinetic/Pharmacodynamic (PBPK/PD) Modeling for Exploring Risk Assessment Approaches of Chemical Mixtures,” Toxicology Letters, 79, 193–200.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Disclaimer: The research described in this article has been reviewed by the National Health and Environmental Effects Research Laboratory, Office of Research and Development, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and approved for publication. Approval does not signify that the contents necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Agency nor does mention of trade names or commercial products constitute endorsement or recommendation for use.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gennings, C., Carter, W.H., Carchman, R.A. et al. The impact of exposure to a mixture of eighteen polyhalogenated aromatic hydrocarbons on thyroid function: Estimation of an interaction threshold. JABES 12, 96–111 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1198/108571107X176727
Received:
Revised:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1198/108571107X176727