Table 9 Qualitative ratings of data quality and model performance, from this study of post-fire tree mortality models from the USA, from fires occurring from 1981 to 2016. R-A = Ryan and Amman model, which can be applied to many species; Pre-fire models predict mortality after fire based on predictors available before fire; Post-fire models predict mortality after fire based on predictors available after fire. Model formulas are in Tables 5 and 6, and model variables are defined in Table 3. See Table 7 for rating criteria. Species not evaluated due to poor data quality are listed in Additional file 3
Data quality | Model performance | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Poor | Acceptable | Excellent | Outstanding | |||||
Species | Model | Species | Model | Species | Model | Species | Model | |
Fair | Abies amabilis | R-A | Abies lasiocarpa | Pre-fire | Populus deltoides ssp. wislizeni | R-A | Pinus albicaulis | Pre-fire |
Acer rubrum | R-A | Abies lasiocarpa | Post-fire | Pinus ponderosa | Post-fire scorch | |||
Chamaecyparis lawsoniana | R-A | Abies magnifica | Pre-fire | Pinus ponderosa | Post-fire kill | |||
Oxydendrum arboreum | R-A | Juniperus occidentalis | R-A | Pseudotsuga menziesii | Post-fire | |||
Pinus coulteri | R-A | Juniperus osteosperma | R-A | |||||
Pinus elliottii | R-A | Juniperus scopulorum | R-A | |||||
Pinus virginiana | R-A | Notholithocarpus densiflorus | R-A | |||||
Quercus alba | R-A | Pinus flexilis | R-A | |||||
Quercus garryana | R-A | Pinus strobiformis | R-A | |||||
Quercus montana | Populus tremuloides | Pre-fire low | ||||||
Populus tremuloides | Pre-fire moderate | |||||||
Tsuga mertensiana | R-A | |||||||
Acceptable | Pinus attenuata | R-A | Cornus nuttallii | R-A | Larix occidentalis | Post-fire | ||
Pinus echinata | R-A | Juniperus deppeana | R-A | Pinus lambertiana | Post-fire | |||
Pinus palustris | R-A | Picea engelmannii | Pre-fire | |||||
Pre-fire | Post-fire | |||||||
Pinus taeda | R-A | Pinus albicaulis | R-A | |||||
Pinus edulis | R-A | |||||||
Pinus monticola | R-A | |||||||
Quercus gambelii | R-A | |||||||
Quercus kelloggii | R-A | |||||||
Thuja plicata | R-A | |||||||
Excellent | Picea engelmannii | R-A | Abies concolor | Post-fire | Abies concolor | R-A | Pinus contorta | Post-fire |
Abies grandis | R-A | Abies concolor | Pre-fire | Pseudotsuga menziesii | Pre-fire | |||
Abies lasiocarpa | R-A | Larix occidentalis | Pre-fire | |||||
Abies magnifica | R-A | Pinus ponderosa | Pre-fire | |||||
Pinus contorta | R-A | Pre-fire Black Hills | ||||||
Pinus contorta | Pre-fire | |||||||
Pinus ponderosa | R-A | |||||||
Populus tremuloides | R-A | |||||||
Pseudotsuga menziesii | R-A | |||||||
Tsuga heterophylla | R-A | |||||||
Outstanding | Larix occidentalis | R-A | Calocedrus decurrens | R-A | ||||
Calocedrus decurrens | Pre-fire | |||||||
Pinus jeffreyi | R-A | |||||||
Pinus lambertiana | R-A | |||||||
Pre-fire | ||||||||