Zinc in Preventing the Progression of pre-Diabetes (ZIPPeD Study) – study protocol for a randomised placebo-controlled trial in Australia
- 292 Downloads
Diabetes is increasing in incidence, morbidity and treatment costs globally, hence prevention strategies need to be explored. Animal studies and some human data have shown that zinc can improve glycaemic control, but the impact of this effect in a pre-diabetic population remains uncertain. This study is designed to investigate whether zinc gluconate and lifestyle coaching can improve glucose handling and ultimately reduce diabetes incidence in an at-risk pre-diabetic population in Australia.
The study will be a randomised, placebo-controlled, double-blind clinical trial. The study will be conducted at the Hunter New England Local Health District New South Wales (NSW), Australia. Pre-diabetic (haemoglobin A1c [HbA1c] 5.7–6.4) male and female participants (n = 410) aged 40–70 years will be recruited through the Diabetes Alliance Network, a collaboration of diabetes specialists and general practitioner practices. All participants will be given routine care to encourage healthy lifestyle changes using a telephone coaching service (Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service, NSW Health) and then randomised to receive a supplement, either zinc gluconate (equivalent to 30 mg of elemental zinc) or placebo of identical appearance for 12 months. The identity of the supplements will be blinded to both research personnel and the participants. Participants will be asked to complete medical, lifestyle and dietary surveys and will have baseline and final visits at their general practitioner practice. Primary outcomes will be HbA1c and insulin sensitivity collected at baseline and at 1, 6 and 12 months; secondary outcomes will include fasting blood glucose, fasting cholesterol, blood pressure and body mass index. The primary efficacy endpoint will be judged at 6 months.
This study will generate new evidence about the potential for health coaching, with or without zinc supplementation, to improve glucose handling and ultimately to reduce progression from pre-diabetes to diabetes.
Australian and New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry, ACTRN12618001120268. Registered on 6 July 2018.
KeywordsZinc supplementation Healthy lifestyle Pre-diabetes Australia Adults
Australian and New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry
Body mass index
Fasting blood glucose
Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service
Human islet amyloid polypeptide
Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio
Linear mixed model
Research Electronic Data Capture
Type 2 diabetes mellitus
The global burden of diabetes (among adults aged 20–79 years) in 2015 was estimated at US 415 million and is expected to rise up to 642 million by 2040 [1, 2, 3]. The global health cost in 2015 was approximately US $673 billion with an expected 25.4% increased cost to US $802 billion in 2040 . The number of deaths attributed to diabetes worldwide in 2015 was 5 million . It is known that 90–95% of diabetes cases are type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM), which is a preventable and modifiable disease . Pre-diabetes mellitus (PreDM) is a potentially reversible condition of impaired glucose handling. It is increasingly being diagnosed on the basis of a haemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) measurement, given the low coefficient of variation of this test . The natural history of PreDM is variable; progression to T2DM occurs in ~ 25%; the abnormal glycaemic state remains in 50%; and reversion to normal glycaemic state occurs in 25% over 3–5 years . People with PreDM are 5–15 times more likely to develop T2DM and are at increased risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) . The progression of disease through the pre-diabetic phase provides an opportunity to intervene to reduce or delay the onset of frank diabetes.
Interventions for PreDM are limited. Improving lifestyle factors, such as nutrition and physical activity, and maintenance of healthy weight have been found to reduce the progression from PreDM to T2DM by ~ 50%, although these changes take time to institute and are often difficult to maintain for the long term . Despite the effectiveness of interventions to reduce such risk factors, the prevalence/incidence of obesity and PreDM continues to increase globally and in Australia [2, 8]. Given this trend, additional and complementary treatment options that will prevent, or at least delay, progression of PreDM are needed. Our intervention will involve the referral of all participants to an existing health promotion programme provided by the NSW State Health Department: the Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service . The free telephone coaching service contacts participants on up to 13 occasions over the first 6 months of the study to encourage lifestyle improvements. In addition, participants will be randomised to receive either a zinc or placebo daily supplement.
Zinc is essential in insulin action and carbohydrate metabolism .
Human islet amyloid polypeptide (HIAPP) is a hormone that is stored with insulin in the secretory granule and is released from the pancreatic beta-cells when blood glucose levels are elevated. Under normal conditions, zinc concentration in the beta-cells is the highest in the human body, and zinc plays a role in keeping glucose levels and HIAPP stabilised. When zinc status is low, HIAPP aggregates into amyloid fibres that in turn become cytotoxic to beta-cells .
Zinc stimulates two different classes of zinc transporter which enhance glucose-stimulated insulin secretion .
Two separate meta-analyses of 25 different small-scale zinc supplementation trials have found a significant reduction in fasting blood glucose and HbA1c, as well as cholesterol, in people with PreDM and metabolic syndrome [15, 16].
A randomised controlled trial of zinc supplementation among people with PreDM reduced progression to diabetes from 25% to 11% over 1 year . However, this study was completed in Sri Lanka, where the dietary intake may be different and the diabetes incidence is high [1, 3].
Given such findings, zinc supplementation may be a useful additional strategy to complement existing effective risk reduction interventions. Our study will add to the limited scientific literature and will be the first randomised placebo-controlled trial of its kind in Australia.
Our study is designed to help patients better manage their own health and prevent T2DM, using an existing and effective lifestyle intervention with and without a low-cost zinc supplement, in an Australian population of men and women with PreDM aged between 40 and 70 years.
To determine if the Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service with zinc supplementation over 12 months improves glucose-handling parameters (HbA1c and insulin sensitivity [IS]) (Cohen’s d = 0.4) compared with the Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service with placebo supplementation.
To determine if the Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service with zinc supplementation delays or prevents progression to diabetes mellitus compared with the Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service with placebo supplementation.
To determine if the Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service with zinc supplementation improves CVD risk factors compared with the Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service with placebo supplementation.
To determine if the Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service alone will improve glucose handling and CVD risk factors compared with each individual’s own baseline (within control group only).
To determine if the Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service can be incorporated into a new model of care of patients with PreDM through general practitioner (GP) practices.
To determine the cost-effectiveness of the new model of care (Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service and zinc supplementation) with early intervention.
To determine the acceptability of daily zinc supplementation for patients with PreDM.
Participants will be selected by the Diabetes Alliance team through GP practices in the Hunter New England Local Health District, NSW, Australia.
To be eligible, men and women aged 40–70 years and with a body mass index (BMI) ≥ 28 kg/m2 will be screened for PreDM on the basis of one HbA1c measurement (5.7–6.4 mmol/L) as per the American Diabetes Association guidelines . Potential participants must be willing to enrol in the Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service and not meet any of the exclusion criteria.
Potential participants must not have any of the following: a diagnosis of diabetes; taking zinc, calcium or iron supplements; receiving a weight loss medicine or programme; alcohol intake > 20 g/day; impaired hepatic or renal function; lactating, pregnant or planning a family; or a history of any condition that the investigator may consider a contraindication to participation .
All participants will be enrolled in the Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service. This is a registered service run by the New South Wales state health department that provides up to 13 telephone calls over 6 months from allied health professionals who provide health information and support participants to achieve a better lifestyle; it focuses on diet, physical activity, smoking cessation and alcohol reduction .
The intervention group will receive a daily oral zinc gluconate capsule (30 mg of elemental zinc, provided by Blackmores, Sydney, Australia) to be consumed before breakfast for a period of 12 months. The placebo group will receive a cellulose capsule (appearance identical to the zinc capsule) to be taken similarly.
The primary outcomes are fasting blood glucose (FBG) and HbA1c.
Progression to diabetes mellitus (based on FBG or HbA1c)
CVD risk factors, including, for example, FBG, plasma cholesterol, body weight, BMI, smoking, alcohol consumption, dietary intake, physical activity and blood pressure
Acceptability of the supplements, as shown by pill counts and adverse effects.
The sample size is based on an estimated mean difference in IS of 0.3 (with SD of 0.7, equal to Cohen’s d of 0.4) between the intervention and control groups. We will need 164 participants per group to reject the null hypothesis that the intervention and control group means are equal with probability (power) 0.9 and type I error probability (α) of 0.01. Allowing up to 20% loss to follow-up over 1 year, we will need to recruit a total of 410 participants.
Screening and recruitment
Participants will be screened and selected through the Diabetes Alliance network. Men and women aged 40–70 years with a diagnosis of PreDM will be invited to participate in the study. Informed consent, baseline measures and questionnaire responses will be obtained.
Randomisation and blinding
Research staff will randomise participants into the study using permuted blocks of sizes 4 and 6, stratified by GP practice and biological sex (male or female), programmed into a computerised research electronic data capture (REDCap) database . The allocation will be concealed and study personnel, the participants and the statistician will be blinded. The study coordinator will send out the capsules (labelled as A or B) to participants according to the allocation at baseline and every 3 months until 1 year. The adjudicators for adverse events will also be blinded to the allocation. Unblinding will occur at the close of the study unless a participant wishes to withdraw from the study or the GP requests unblinding of a participant for medical reasons, in particular for the diagnosis of T2DM.
Data collection methods
An online REDCap database will store all data collected. This database will be managed by an independent statistician.
Analyses will be undertaken in accordance with the Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT) guidelines by an independent statistician blinded to treatment group allocation .
Effectiveness of zinc
IS and HbA1c at baseline and at 1, 6 and 12 months will be plotted to assess response trajectories. We will fit a linear mixed model (LMM) with IS or HbA1c measured at 1, 6 and 12 months as the dependent variable and fixed effects for time (categorical predictor), group and time-by-group interaction terms. This will allow us to identify the time points at which maximal group differences are observed, although the primary outcomes will be judged at 6 months. A random intercept will be included to account for repeated measures on participants, and the model will be adjusted for baseline HbA1c or IS, age, sex, physical activity and diet. The LMM uses all available values for each participant and provides robust effect estimates assuming data are missing at random. All statistical analyses will observe the intention-to-treat principle. A significant difference on either of the primary outcomes will be sufficient to declare an effect, although we will also look at consistency in the direction of the secondary outcomes.
A similar LMM approach will be used to jointly analyse the data at baseline and 1, 6 and 12 months for insulin resistance, beta-cell function, lipids and other secondary outcomes across the zinc and control groups.
Effectiveness of Get Healthy T2DM Prevention Program
HbA1c values at baseline and at 1, 6 and 12 months will be plotted for the placebo group alone to allow us to describe the effect of the Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service without zinc supplementation. We will fit an LMM with fixed effects for time as a categorical predictor and HbA1c as the dependent variable. This will allow us to estimate the mean within-person pre-post differences due to lifestyle changes. A random intercept will be included to account for repeated measures on participants, and the model will be adjusted for baseline age, sex, physical activity and diet quality.
A similar LMM approach will be used to analyse IS and FBG and to jointly analyse the baseline and 12-month data for BMI, waist/hip ratio and blood pressure. In addition, completion rates for the Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service for those referred as part of the study will be benchmarked to current rates for those referred through other sources.
Cost-effectiveness of zinc and Get Healthy T2DM Prevention Program
The cost-effectiveness of zinc supplementation will be assessed in a trial-based analysis. The analysis will adopt a modified societal perspective to account for health care system costs as well as patient costs which would be incurred if the zinc supplement were an out-of-pocket expense. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) will be calculated as the difference in average cost between the zinc supplementation group and the placebo group, divided by the difference in average FPG level. Uncertainty intervals for the incremental costs and ICER will be calculated using a non-parametric bootstrap procedure to reflect sampling uncertainty. Sensitivity analysis will examine imputation uncertainty, comparing the reference case results with the analysis of participants with complete data. Additional sensitivity analysis will involve variation in the market price of zinc capsules.
The results of the trial-based analysis will be extrapolated in a cost-consequence analysis comparing the health care resource use profiles for two cohorts over a 5-year period: those people with delayed progression to diabetes as a result of zinc supplementation in conjunction with effective lifestyle modification and those people who follow the natural history of diabetes progression.
A second modelled analysis will extrapolate the results from the trial-based analysis and transform the intermediate, primary trial outcome into a final, patient-relevant outcome: quality-adjusted life-years saved. The cost-utility analysis will model costs, expected cost savings and patient outcomes over the lifetime of a hypothetical cohort of patients with PreDM. Similar direct and modelled analyses will be performed for the evaluation of the Get Healthy Information and Coaching T2DM Prevention Program, looking at pre- and post-glycaemic markers.
Acceptability of zinc supplementation
Acceptability will be determined using compliance, assessed by quarterly pill counts. Average number of capsules taken divided by the theoretical maximum taken, over the four quarters, will be used to calculate percentage of apparent compliance .
An independent statistician will monitor the data collected and will review any adverse events which may require reporting.
Participants will complete an “adverse events questionnaire” every 3 months to ascertain tolerance to the zinc or placebo. Any unexpected serious adverse events will be reported to the ethics committee and regulatory bodies.
Periodic audits will be attended by an independent statistician. The online database will have in-built structures to ensure data are entered appropriately and in a quality fashion.
This trial sets out to explore whether a new model of care for preventing diabetes in an at-risk Australian population can delay or prevent the onset of diabetes. The scientific literature has supporting evidence, but the sample sizes are small and follow-up duration is short in some instances. Also, the previous studies have been in Asian populations (Bangladesh and Sri Lanka) [1, 24] with differing physical and metabolic characteristics. Their dietary intakes are different, and they are more likely to have an underlying zinc deficiency compared with the overall Australian population. We do not expect a conversion rate from PreDM to diabetes to be as high as 25% over a 12-month period in the control group as observed in the Asian population group . In the Australian population, progression from PreDM to diabetes can take from 7.5 years (females) to 9.5 years (males) or more in a similar age group . However, any differences between treatment groups in the Australian population are important to note. Our study aims to support the current literature by recruiting 410 men and women with PreDM aged between 40 and 70 years who are residing in Australia who would benefit from lifestyle changes with or without zinc supplementation over a 12-month period. If the study proves successful, it will pave the way for a much larger, multi-centre clinical trial with frank diabetes as the endpoint.
This is protocol version 4, dated 25th September 2018 (ANZCTR registration number ACTRN 12618001120268). Recruitment commenced in November 2018 and is expected to be completed by July 2019.
This work is supported by the NSW Ministry of Health Translational Research Grant Scheme (TRGS) for the overall funding of the study (H18/31636) and Blackmores Limited for the provision of study supplements and associated costs for mailing the supplements to participants.
The overall funding for the trial is through the New South Wales Ministry of Health Translational Research Grants Scheme (H18/31636). Blackmores Limited is providing the zinc gluconate and placebo with funding support for the postage and delivery of the supplements. The funding bodies are not involved in the design of the study; collection, analysis or interpretation of data; or the writing of manuscripts.
Availability of data and materials
All protocol amendments will be discussed and confirmed by the investigators prior to seeking approval by the ethics committee to be endorsed. Any changes will be reported to the ANZCTR and any relevant journals that have published data. Any significant changes that impact participants will be communicated to the regulatory bodies and the participants.
All participants must be able to read and understand the information statement and consent form prior to enrolment in the study. Study personnel will provide written information for participants to read, consider and agree/not agree to participate in the study.
All electronic information will be stored in locked, password-protected databases. All paper-based information will be stored in locked research facilities at the University of Newcastle. All data shared or published will be group data in a de-identified format.
Access to data
All investigators will have access to the final de-identified study dataset for the purpose of scientific publications.
The investigators will report the results of the study in scientific journals, at conferences or at seminars. The scientific publications will be made available through the Diabetes Alliance, which will facilitate the distribution of information to the participating general practitioner practices.
RP is the study coordinator and has prepared the draft materials. AH is the protocol dietitian. JW is the protocol expert in population health, translational research and implementation, MM is the protocol epidemiologist. EH is the protocol statistician. AS and PR are the protocol economists. SA and JL are diabetes experts and recruitment facilitators. PR, SS and RJ are members of the research steering committee. CR is the project lead for the “Get Healthy Information and Coaching Service” and facilitator for this service to be used within general practitioner practices. JA is the chief investigator and sponsor for the study. All authors read, contributed to and approved the final manuscript.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The study has been approved by the Hunter New England Human Research Ethics Committee, NSW, Australia (reference 18/07/18/3.03). The approval is registered with the University of Newcastle Human Research Ethics Committee (reference H-2018-0302-959).
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
- 3.International Diabetes Federation. IDF diabetes atlas. Brussels: International Diabetes Federation; 2018.Google Scholar
- 14.Chimienti F, Devergnas S, Pattou F, Schuit F, Garcia-Cuenca R, Vandewalle B, Kerr-Conte J, Van Lommel L, Grunwald D, Favier A, Seveet M. In vivo expression and functional characterization of the zinc transporter ZnT8 in glucose-induced insulin secretion. J Cell Sci. 2006;119:4199–206.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 19.American Diabetes Association. Diagnosing diabetes and learning about prediabetes 2019. http://www.diabetes.org/diabetes-basics/diagnosis/. Accessed 25 Jan 2019.
- 22.CONSORT Group. Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials, CONSORT Statement 2018 [19/07/2018]. http://www.consort-statement.org/. Accessed 25 Jan 2019.
- 24.Islam MR, Attia J, Ali L, McEvoy M, Selim S, Sibbritt D, Akhter A, Akter S, Peel R, Faruque O, Mona T, Lona H, Milton AH. Zinc supplementation for improving glucose handling in pre-diabetes: a double blind randomized placebo controlled pilot study. Diabetes Res Clin Pract. 2016;115:39–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 26.Chan AW, Tetzlaff JM, Altman DG, Laupacis A, Gotzsche PC, Krleza-Jeric K, Hrobjartsson A, Mann H, Dickersin K, Berlin JA, Dore CJ, Parulekar WR, Summerskill WS, Groves T, Schulz KF, Sox HC, Rockhold FW, Rennie D, Moher D. SPIRIT 2013 statement: defining standard protocol items for clinical trials. Ann Intern Med. 2013;158(3):200–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.