Using an individual simple questionnaire, we identified a number of various topics designated by patients to be discussed with health care team. Even if some topics of this questionnaire such as cough or fatigue are frequently assessed in CF, many topics appeared different from the topics addressed during regular visits usually focusing on life threatening complications like chronic respiratory failure and malnutrition.
More than half of the patients indicated at least one topic with 10% selecting more than 10 topics, highlighting frequent uncovered needs during regular follow-up visits. A few previous studies investigated CF specific needs and association with clinical characteristics [6,7,8, 13, 14]. Those studies used questionnaires filled during a follow-up visit or sent by mail and mainly focused on medical topics [6, 7]. Despite differences in methods, our study confirmed some previously identified unmet needs: Sawicki et al. [6] described the most frequent unmet needs as “decreased energy” (32%), “new CF therapies” (31%), “unpredictability of the future” (28%), “CF worsening” (27%) and “medication side effects” (27%). Fatigue is a very frequent symptom in CF, considered as moderate to severe in 56% of cases [8]. Its associations with clinical and functional patients’ characteristics is controversial but its impact on health status has been showed [15, 16]. In our study, we identified a clear association between fatigue as an unmet need and quality of life impairment, highlighting the importance fatigue screening.
Information about procreation was frequently selected, especially by female and youngest patients. Previous survey identified information about procreation as a need for CF patients [6, 7]. Patients’ need for discussion about procreation should be periodically assessed during visits and not restricted to urgent need expressed by patients facing this issue. Another major unmet topic to discuss raised by this study is the difficulties encountered in studies or professional activities. Patients’ employment status in our study was similar to the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation Patient Registry with 70% of student or working patients [3]. In our study, professional or scholar worries were not associated with employment status. CF can have important impact on professional life. Previous studies reported that 40% of CF patients quit their job because of the disease, 47% declared that CF affected their career choice, 24% changed duties and 23% suffered from workplace discrimination [17]. Surprisingly, in a cohort of 73 patients diagnosed with CF after 18 years, the item of employment/insurance was considered as of moderate interest [13]. In our study, more than half of the patients who were concerned about study or job suffered from diabetes. Quality of life has been shown to be significantly impaired in CF-related diabetes, especially when requiring insulin [18]. Our results suggest that CF-related diabetes may also be associated with more concerns regarding study or job. To our knowledge, the impact of CF-related diabetes on professional activity or studies has not been previously evaluated, justifying additional studies in this field.
Our study highlighted very different needs among CF adult population. Half of patients expressed no specific needs. Those patients were not different regarding demographical, clinical and functional characteristics. Lack of responses may reflect either a lack of interest (however, no patient declined the study) or absence of unmet management needs. It should also be pointed out that identified unmet needs are very disparate. Indeed, sixty items among the 62 proposed have been selected at least once. In the study of Obregon et al. [14], none of the main unmet supportive care needs (anxiety, sadness, pain and worries about the future) were associated with pulmonary impairment, BMI and pulmonary exacerbation in prior year but with age, income and or religion. Given the absence of associations between CF phenotype and patient needs, a systematic use of an educational questionnaire during follow-up visits could help to identify unmet needs.
Some topics were rarely selected in our study. Patients considered themselves as well-informed regarding treatment (interruption, limitation, logistical supports/supply, efficacy) and daily life organization. CF patients usually report a high level of confidence in their abilities in nutritional care and role of enzymes in CF therapy [7]. Sawicki et al. [6] reported that the needs in information regarding advance care planning, lung transplant, genetics, and nutrition were low. We can speculate that needs may have changed over time. Thirty years ago, most of patients reported that problems related to daily life with CF were not discussed [19]. Patients may be reluctant to approach concerns related to sexual life. None of the previous studies about expectations of CF patients analyzed this topic [4, 6,7,8, 13]. In a recent study, only one-third of interprofessional CF providers (physicians, nurses, social workers and other disciplines) reported being comfortable with sexual and reproductive health for adolescent and young adult women [20]. A majority of women confirmed never receiving or discussing sexual and reproductive health care with their CF team [21].
There are limitations to our study. First, our sample size is relatively small which could limit the generalizability of our results. However, clinical and functional characteristics of our cohort were similar to other studies regarding BMI [22], prevalence of exocrine pancreatic insufficiency [23], diabetes [24], Pseudomonas aeruginosa infections [12] and FEV1 [25]. Second, the questionnaire developed by a therapeutic education group has not been evaluated yet, and our study has to be considered as a pilot exploratory study. Of note previous studies have also used or modified some questionnaires not validated in CF and developed in other diseases such as cancer [4, 8, 14]. Finally, we have not assessed if the specific needs identified by this questionnaire led to a specific management. It would be interesting to analyse the impact of this custom questionnaire on therapeutic management of CF patients in a larger cohort.