The features of bone articular lesions in dialysis-related amyloidosis (DRA) and criteria for the clinical diagnosis of DRA
- 87 Downloads
We introduced criteria for the clinical diagnosis of dialysis-related amyloidosis (DRA) from the Amyloidosis Research Group study supported by a Grant-in-Aid from the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare of Japan. DRA exhibits various kinds of bone articular lesions, such as carpal tunnel syndrome, trigger finger, destructive spondyloarthropathy, spinal canal stenosis, and joint pains. These bone articular lesions, excluding destructive spondyloarthropathy, are observed in non-dialysis patients or dialysis patients without DRA. We carefully compared these lesions between DRA and non-DRA patients and summarized the differences between them. The incidence age, male to female ratio, and coincidence rate were distinct between these groups of patients. Biopsies from bone articular lesions are invasive and burdensome for dialysis patients; therefore, a precise clinical diagnosis is required for DRA. We discussed the validity and availability of our proposed criteria.
KeywordsAmyloidosis Carpal tunnel syndrome Trigger finger Destructive spondyloarthropathy Joint pains
Carpal tunnel syndrome
Spinal canal stenosis
Dialysis-related amyloidosis (DRA) is a type of systemic amyloidosis. Compared to the clinical features of other types of systemic amyloidosis, such as immunoglobulin light chain amyloidosis (AL) and inflammatory amyloidosis (AA) types, the clinical features of DRA are distinct in terms of preferential amyloid deposition at multiple bone articular lesions. Initially, carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) was reported as a common bone articular lesion of DRA [1, 2]. Consequently, trigger finger (TF) , destructive spondyloarthropathy (DSA) [4, 5], spinal canal stenosis (SCS) , and joint pains [7, 8] have been identified as bone articular lesions associated with DRA.
Fundamentally, the diagnosis of amyloidosis should be determined via precise pathological examinations, including Congo red staining, green color polarization, and immunohistostaining with specific antibodies to the precursor proteins. Tissue specimens obtained from the gastrointestinal mucosa, kidney, liver, and heart are typically available for histological examination in AA and AL amyloidosis. Although the biopsy specimens from bone articular lesions are indeed necessary for the exact examination of DRA, compared with organ tissue biopsies, biopsies from bone articular lesions are invasive and technically difficult due to enclosed and narrow environments. Additionally, a biopsy from bone articular lesions becomes burdensome for DRA patients. Surgical tissues from bone articular lesions have been used limitedly for histological diagnosis in DRA.
In this review, we summarized the issues concerning the diagnosis of DRA and introduced criteria for the clinical diagnosis of DRA.
Criteria for the clinical diagnosis of DRA
In Japan, we have already proposed criteria for the clinical diagnosis of dialysis-related amyloidosis (DRA) in 2010 from the Amyloidosis Research Group study supported by a Grant-in-Aid from the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare of Japan .
We surveyed the prevalence of bone articular lesions from dialysis patients with various vintage groups, ranging from short to long. We asked three dialysis institutes to randomly select each 5 patients from 4 vintage groups, 0 to 5 years, 5 to 10 years, 10 to 15 years, and greater than 15 years. All 60 cases were subject to medial interviews for signs and symptoms concerning bone articular lesions associated with DRA, and patients were subject to X-rays of the spine and joints, including wrist, shoulder, hip, and knee. The diagnosis of bone articular lesions associated with DRA was clinically performed by doctors based on patients’ complaints and bone X-rays.
Criteria for the clinical diagnosis of dialysis-related amyloidosis
1. Multiple joints pain
2. Carpal tunnel syndrome
3. Trigger finger
4. Dialysis spinal lesions (destructive spondyloarthropathy or spinal canal stenosis)
5. Bone cyst
1. Bone fracture
2. Ischemic colitis
3. Other lesions: subcutaneous skin tumor, urolithiasis
Definitive case: patient with two or more major findings
Doubtful case: patient with one major finding plus one or more accessory findings
Osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, infectious arthritis, gout, pseudogout
Lumbar or cervical spondylosis, pyogenic spondylitis
The following diseases were established as exclusion criteria: rheumatoid arthritis, osteoarthritis joint, pyogenic arthritis, gout, pseudogout cervical or lumbar spondylosis, and suppurative spondylitis.
How to diagnose bone articular lesions observed in dialysis patients
Comparison of bone articular lesions between non-dialysis and dialysis patients
Female and male ratio, even
Unilateral lesion, common
Bilateral lesions, common
CTS and TF coincidence, less
CTS and TF coincidence, more
No relationship between CTS and TF
Appearance after CTS and TF
Incident age, young
Incident age, old
A medical interview is a basic procedure for the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). American Academy of Neurology (AAN) clinical diagnostic criteria  noted that the following symptoms represent typical findings: paraesthesia, pain, swelling, weakness or clumsiness of the hand provoked or worsened by sleep, sustained hand or arm position, repetitive action of the hand or wrist that is mitigated by changing posture or by shaking the hand; sensory deficit or hypotrophy of the median innervated thenar muscle.
El Miedany et al.  reported that provocative tests, such as Tinel’s, Phalen’s, reverse Phalen’s, and carpal tunnel compression tests, were not highly sensitive or specific tests for the diagnosis of CTS. The highest sensitivity was 47% in Phalen’s test and the highest specificity was 65% in Tinel’s test in patients diagnosed by AAN criteria. Although the nerve conduction test assists in the diagnosis of CTS, 31.5% of positive Phalen’s cases and 23.6% of positive Tinel’s tests exhibited normal findings in nerve conduction tests.
Ultrasonographic diagnosis is helpful for the diagnosis of CTS; however, this technique cannot perfectly diagnose CTS. Kolovos et al.  measured the anteroposterior to transverse diameter of the median nerve inside the canal and at its entrance by sonography. They concluded that a gray zone existed in between patients with CTS and healthy persons. Based on these comments, sensitive and objective diagnosis methods are lacking; thus, clinical diagnosis is the best method for the diagnosis of CTS.
Compared with CTS in non-dialysis patients, the clinical features of CTS associated with DRA are distinctive based on the following points. The female ratio is dominant in non-dialysis CTS. In contrast, the male to female ratio is approximately even in CTS-associated DRA. Guan et al.  reported that the female ratio was 91.8% in 1360 cases with non-dialysis CTS. In contrast, Hoshino et al.  reported that female ratios were 43.6% and 50.4% in a large Japanese dialysis cohort who received carpal tunnel release operation for CTS in 1998 (n = 647) and 2010 (n = 2157), respectively. Another distinct point is the bilateral progression in dialysis CTS as well as AL or AA amyloidosis . Unilateral development is common in non-dialysis CTS.
In terms of the gender difference and bilateral lesions, CTS associated with DRA exhibits distinctive clinical features compared with CTS without DRA (Table 1).
Although the diagnostic criteria of trigger finger (TF) have not been reported in previous articles and textbooks, only the criteria of clinical classification have been reported. The severity of the trigger finger was graded by Newport et al. . They defined three clinical grades of symptoms as follows. Grade I was considered a simple tenosynovitis with tenderness and pain but without a palpable nodule or triggering. Grade II is characterized by fingers with demonstrated tenderness, a swelling or nodularity of the tendon, and occasional catching or triggering. Grade III is the category with the most severe symptoms, including all manifestations of grade II as well as frequent catching, triggering, or locking. McKee et al.  reported that greater than half of non-dialysis patients (52%) exhibited spontaneous resolution without any surgical intervention. Spontaneous resolution is rare in TF in dialysis patients. The coincidence rates might not be negligible between CTS and TF in dialysis patients (Table 1). Lin et al.  reported that TF developed in 8.5% non-dialysis patients after a carpal tunnel release operation. In our analysis of long-term dialysis patients with DRA, 27.0% cases (n = 20 in total of 74 cases) exhibited a coincidence of CTS and TF .
Kuntz et al.  first reported destructive spondyloarthropathy (DSA) as a new syndrome in dialysis patients in 1984. They described the specific features as microbial spondylitis, degenerative disc disease, and destructive spondyloarthropathy of calcium pyrophosphate dihydrate deposition disease. They insisted radiologic signs were essential for the diagnosis of DSA. The following findings served as base findings: severe narrowing of the intervertebral disc, erosions, and geodes of the adjacent vertebral plates, and absence of significant osteophytosis. The main lesions of DSA were highly mobile spine areas, such as C5–7 and L3–5 , and DSA was reported in approximately 20% of long-term dialysis patients [24, 25]. Chin et al.  divided the progression of DSA into four grades based on the radiological findings of the spines. Based on these results, the radiological examination can lead to a diagnosis of DSA and determine the progression.
Spinal canal stenosis (SCS) develops from spinal cord compression due to the narrowing of the canal space. Thickening of ligamentum flavum, protruded intervertebral discs, and bone spurs lead to a narrow canal. Rheumatoid arthritis, trauma, and compression fracture of vertebral bones occasionally induce SCS.
NASS guidelines  describe the definition of clinical SCS as follows: patients with history and physical examination findings consistent with a degenerative spinal cord. MRI is suggested as the most appropriate, non-invasive test to confirm the presence of anatomic narrowing of the spinal canal or the presence of nerve root impingement.
DSA and SCS associated with DRA exhibit a delayed appearance after CTS and TF in long-term hemodialysis patients  (Table 1). In our analysis, dialysis vintage values of patients with DSA and/or SCS versus that of patients without DSA and/or SCS were 362.5 ± 133.4 months and 298.0 ± 127.8 months (p = 0.039), respectively . Among 30 cases with DSA and/or SCS, 23 cases (76.7%) had CTS and/or TF.
Bone cysts are typically divided into three groups: unicameral bone cyst, aneurysmal bone cyst, and traumatic bone cyst. Unicameral bone cyst or simple bone cyst is a benign, fluid-containing lesion. A simple cyst is frequently observed on the metaphysis of long bones, such as the proximal humerus or femur in children and adolescents . The etiology is unknown, but occasionally unicameral bone cysts spontaneously disappear. An aneurysmal bone cyst is an expansive hemorrhagic lesion and exhibits walled multicystic lesions . Seventy-five to 90% of cases of traumatic bone cyst develop before the age of 20. A traumatic bone cyst is a rare non-epithelial-lined cyst found in the mandibular bone. The true etiology is unclear, but the lesion is called a traumatic cyst .
Multiple joints pain
Bardin et al.  reported that multiple joints pain derived from DRA dramatically disappeared after kidney transplantation. After kidney transplantation, the number of painful joint sites was significantly reduced from 15 to 72. Among multiple sites of joint pain, shoulder pain was most common. Hoshino et al.  compared the rates of multiple joints pain between DRA and non-DRA patients. The rate was 63.6% in DRA patients, whereas that in non-DRA patients was only 2.1%. Multiple joints pain is considered a specific feature of DRA.
MRI and ultrasound sonography indicated the thickening of intra-articular tendons and the increase in bursal fluid in painful shoulder joints of dialysis patients [38, 39, 40]. Amyloid deposition in synovial tissues may induce intra-articular inflammation related to joint pain.
Other lesions of DRA
Pathological bone fractures have been documented as a clinical finding of DRA [41, 42]. Major target lesions included hip joints and femoral necks. Bone cyst formation and inflammation around the joints were suspected as the cause of pathological bone fracture due to DRA [43, 44]. Walking disturbances are frequently noted in patients with DRA because they suffered from knee and shoulder joint pain . The walking disturbance derived from joint pain occasionally causes falls, and traumatic bone fractures may easily appear in dialysis patients.
Ischemic colitis has been reported as a complication of long-term dialysis patients. To date, a few reports described that intestinal beta 2-microglobulin amyloid deposition developed into ischemic colitis [45, 46]. A part of ischemic colitis has been suspected an extra-articular lesion associated with DRA. The subcutaneous amyloid deposition has also been reported as an extra-articular lesion associated with DRA [47, 48, 49]. Preferred deposition sites include the gluteal and back regions. Subcutaneous amyloid depositions occasionally grow to a large-sized mass; therefore, it is called an amyloid ball. It has been rarely documented that beta 2-microglobulin amyloidosis was involved in the formation of renal stones in dialysis patients. Lysine-specific cleavage of beta 2-microglobulin was extracted from amyloid stones in dialysis patients [50, 51, 52].
Bone fracture, ischemic colitis, subcutaneous tumor, and renal stone in dialysis patients are potential lesions associated with DRA.
The necessity of criteria for a clinical diagnosis of DRA
We have discussed the difference in bone articular lesions between patients with or without DRA. DSA is a specific lesion of DRA, and other bone articular lesions have distinctive characteristics between the two groups with and without DRA (Table 2). Of course, we cannot perfectly differentiate both groups without pathological evidence. Chikawa et al.  compared the rates of amyloid deposition in operative specimens obtained from the decompression surgery of the spinal canal in DSA and SCS cases. The amyloid deposition rate was 100% in the DSA group, whereas the rate was decreased to 66.7% in SCS cases without DSA. Based on these facts, we believe that the criteria for the clinical diagnosis of DRA must be established based on a combination method for multiple DRA lesions.
Validation of criteria for the clinical diagnosis of DRA
Validation with pathological examination should be performed to ensure the adequacy of the criteria. As previously mentioned above, unfortunately, bone articular lesion biopsy is invasive and harmful. A few reports described the pathological diagnostic rate based on the surgical specimens. Chary-Valckenaere  and Kessler  reported that 68.3% and 62.0% of dialysis cases exhibited amyloid deposits in the surgical specimens from CTS. Jadoul et al.  studied the pathological rate of amyloid detection from postmortem evaluation concerning joint lesions. The amyloid deposition rates were 97% in sternoclavicular joints, 91% in knee joints, and 57% in shoulder joints. Based on these results, the clinical diagnosis exclusively based on one bone articular lesion seems less precise; however, clinical diagnosis based on two or more bone articular lesions promises increased accuracy.
The availability of criteria for the clinical diagnosis of DRA
In the clinical setting, missing a DRA diagnosis represents a risk for dialysis patients. Severe cervical DSA may lead to spinal damage upon intratracheal intubation. Large bone cysts may cause bone fractures if falls occur. Proposed criteria are useful for the safety control of dialysis patients.
Dialysis-related amyloidosis clinical scoring system
Carpal tunnel syndrome
The treatments for DRA
Unfortunately, we have no curative medicine for DRA. Prevention and early detection are important for DRA treatments. The accumulation of beta 2-microglobulin and inflammatory reaction in dialysis patients accelerate the amyloid deposition , therefore highly biocompatible and high-flux membranes have been recommended for a decrease in the incidence of DRA . The use of ultrapure dialysate is also necessary as a preventive intervention . Compared to conventional hemodialysis, hemodiafiltration and hemofiltration with higher removal efficacy of beta 2-microglobulin can effectively inhibit the progression of DRA . In Japan, beta 2-microglobulin absorption column has been approved by the insurance system. This absorption treatment is effective in particular for the joint pain relief derived from DRA and leads to the improvement of activity of daily life and sleeplessness . Early kidney transplantation can prevent the incidence of DRA or ameliorate symptoms and sings associated with DRA, while it cannot perfectly cure the once developed DRA . We would like everyone to use our clinical criteria for the early detection and the early start of prevention.
We compared the characteristics of bone articular lesions between the two groups: patients with and without DRA. Significant differences were confirmed between them. Thus, bone articular lesions in dialysis patients may suggest lesions associated with DRA. Unfortunately, biopsies of bone articular lesions are not easy; thus, we introduced criteria for the clinical diagnosis of DRA.
This work was supported in part by a Grant-in-Aid from the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare of Japan. We are grateful for clinical data provided from the dialysis hospital by Kentaro Oomori, Isei Ei, Yutaka Oosawa, Yoshifumi Ubara, and Shigeko Hara.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets used and analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
SN, SY, JH, KT, and HN contributed to the construction of clinical diagnostic criteria for DRA. SN was a major contributor in writing the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors are members of Amyloidosis Research Group supported by the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare of Japan.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
- 9.Nishi S. Clinical criteria of dialysis related amyloidosis and its evaluation. The reports for Amyloidosis Research Group study supported by a Grant-in-Aid from the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare of Japan, 2009; 13–15, Published in 2010 (in Japanese).Google Scholar
- 12.No authors. Practice parameter for carpal tunnel syndrome (summary statement). Report of the quality standards subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. Neurology. 1993;43:2406–2409.Google Scholar
- 29.NASS Clinical Guidelines. Diagnosis and Treatment of Degenerative Lumbar Spinal Stenosis. https://www.spine.org/Portals/0/Documents/ResearchClinicalCare/Guidelines/LumbarStenosis.pdf. Revised in 2011.
- 39.Turk AC, Fidan N, Ozcan O, Ozdemir F, Tomak L, Ozkurt S, et al. Painful and painless shoulder magnetic resonance imaging comparisons in hemodialysis patients and correlation with clinical findings. J Back Musculoskelet Rehabil. 2016. https://doi.org/10.3233/BMR-160715.
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.