Multianalytical approach for the analysis of the Codices Millenarius Maior and Millenarius Minor in Kremsmuenster Abbey, Upper Austria
Two precious Carolingian manuscripts kept in the library of Kremsmuenster Abbey in Upper Austria were subject of investigation. The well-known Codices Millenarius Maior (Inv. No. CC Cim 1, Fig. 1a) and Millenarius Minor (Inv. No. CC Cim 2, Fig. 1b) were studied within the framework of the Centre of Image and Material Analysis in Cultural Heritage (CIMA) in Vienna. The manuscripts are especially famous for their precious and colorful miniatures of a very early medieval period. The aim of the work was the material identification (colors and inks) used for the make-up of the two codices in order to gain a better understanding of their evolution and their provenance. The instrumentation available in the CIMA laboratories allowed performing in situ measurements using non-destructive and non-invasive analytical methods. The investigations comprised a combination of three complementary methods: X-ray fluorescence analysis (XRF), Fourier transform infrared spectrometry in the reflection mode (rFTIR) and Raman spectrometry. In addition to the identification of the pigments and inks also a detailed characterization of the parchment concerning its manufacturing process was achieved by that combination. The identification of calcium carbonates on the surface of the parchment is an indicator for the liming or whitening of the animal skin, whereas the polishing process of the parchment surface with pumice stone, left traces of silicates, detected by rFTIR. The combination of XRF and Raman spectrometry enabled the characterization of black/brown inks in the text revealing the usage of iron gall inks. For the red inks applied for text and initials vermilion and red lead were applied in both codices. Furthermore, the pigment palette used for the illumination included: lead white, orpiment/realgar, red lead, vermilion and red iron oxides as well as azurite and indigo, together with the rather rare copper chloride hydroxide. Furthermore, in both gospels the application of metal leaves as well as powders made of silver–copper and gold–copper alloys could be determined by XRF on several folios.
KeywordsMedieval manuscripts Pigments Inks XRF rFTIR Raman
Centre of Image and Material Analysis in Cultural Heritage
Infrared and Raman Users Group
Institute of Science and Technology in Art
Fourier transform infrared spectrometry in the reflection mode
fiber optic reflectance spectroscopy
Codex Millenarius Maior
Codex Millenarius Minor
During the last decades a particular collaboration between representatives of various humanities such as philology, art history and conservation–restoration on the one side and natural scientists on the other has been established, completed by a co-operation with computer vision specialists. Simultaneously the booming development of analytical methods has offered the possibility to use a great number of new instrumental micro-analytical techniques with non-sampling and in situ applicability for the analysis of written heritage objects. In order to give this collaboration a solid structure, the Centre of Image and Material Analysis in Cultural Heritage (CIMA) in Vienna  was established in 2014 with the HRSM-project  running from 2014 until 2017 with the aid of the Structural Fund for Austrian Higher Education.
Within this framework a series of historical manuscripts of various libraries selected by philologists were examined. The selection comprises badly preserved or rewritten manuscripts (palimpsests) on the one hand, and manuscripts with a remarkable design on the other, deriving from the 8th to the 14th centuries. The material investigation aims to determine the composition of inks and pigments used for writing and illuminating, as well as the characterization of the support material. Besides chemical analyses, multispectral imaging was carried out to improve the legibility of historical texts. With all this information philologists and art historians are studying these objects. The data of material analysis will help to classify the manuscripts and their making. The final objective of the research is to compare the data gained to reveal correlations within data stemming from multiple modalities and, in general, to make new scholarly and scientific findings.
In this paper the results of investigations for two codices from the Carolingian period are presented. The examination of such early manuscripts has been rarely attempted, possibly due to extreme care in their administration which gives preferences to the preservation over the knowledge of the material aspects used for the manufacturing. Conferring to scientific literature, only a small number of analytical studies are known on manuscripts dating in this period [3, 4, 5, 6].
According to historical tradition, in 1777 the papal nuncio Giuseppe Garampi attended the 1000th anniversary celebration of the Abbey. When he got aware of the older of the two codices, he proclaimed: “Vere hicce millenarius codex est!”.1 Although his dating later proved to be somewhat too early, its proclamation lead to the name of codex CC Cim 1. Codex Millenarius Maior (henceforth: MMA) is a Gospel plenary, containing the complete text of the four Canonical Gospels . They are preceded by the usual canon tables and introductory texts. Usually, it is assumed that it originates from the scriptorium of Mondsee Abbey not far from Kremsmuenster . MMA happens to be the oldest of altogether three manuscripts deriving from this monastery (from where Kremsmuenster Abbey may have been founded) and dates from the early ninth century. The Gospels are written in two columns with black ink in the solemn Carolingian Majuscule (Uncial), the additions in the denser Capitalis Rustica. The beginning and the end of each part are composed in Capitalis Quadrata and held in red and green. The regularity of the writing suggests a single scribe. The text is a variant of the northern Italian Vulgata, influenced by the tradition of the Vetus Latina.
As is known, MMA is especially famous for its four double-sided evangelist miniatures before their respective Gospel . On the writing desk of the evangelists, the incipit of the corresponding Gospel is cast in fine minuscule, which is significant for the dating. Apart from that, the decoration of the book is limited to the initials at the beginning of each gospel.
Due to the first Ottoman siege of 1529, the metal applications of the last known medieval binding had to be fused in order to enable the monastery to pay the tax levied by the emperor to finance the war. After this event, MMA was left unbound for at least 70 years , leading to the damage of the manuscript’s first three layers (folios 1–12). Around the year 1600, they were rewritten on paper by Prior Leonhard Wagner, who still disposed of the original parchment leaves, as evidenced by an imprint of the last canon table on folio 10r which exactly corresponds to Wagner’s division. A paper folio with the texts of John 20:31–21:14 was also added at the end. The rest of the Gospel of John is missing. Consequently, today MMA contains 330 parchment and 47 paper folios.
A new cover made of pressed, partly gilded silver with 26 stones was given to the codex before the year 1600 under Abbot Johannes Spindler (1589–1600). His coat of arms occupies the corners of the front cover. Central is the figure of the Lord of the World, to whom Kremsmuenster Abbey has been dedicated since its foundation. In 1953, the red velvet of the book covers was replaced by red goat leather. Later on and according to a medieval custom, four charters were entered on empty pages in minuscule copies of the 12th century.
Even today, MMA is still in liturgical use. In remembrance of the monastery’s founder, a solemn requiem is held every year on the 11th of December, in which the Gospels are sung from MMA.
In contrast to MMA, the younger Codex Millenarius Minor (henceforth MMI) is no longer in practical use except for rare exhibitions . This manuscript represents a plenary in Carolingian minuscule. It is commonly dated to the last quarter of the ninth century and was given to the monastery under Abbot Snelpero (888–893). Written by various hands and probably only later combined to a plenary, MMI contains 224 parchment and 21 paper folios. Of the miniature paintings only Saint Mark is completely preserved, while the bottom part of Saint John’s miniature are lost. Here, too, the decoration of the book is limited to the initials at the beginning of the Gospels. Completely preserved are the canon tables at the beginning of the book. At the end of the manuscript (fols. 207r–225r) an instruction of the Gospel readings is added—a clear indication that the book was used for the holy sacrifice of the mass.
Similarly to MMA, some charters were included into MMI, and—for us even more interesting—a treasure inventory deriving from the year 1032, in which one entry has been erased. The restoration of the legibility of this erased text is one of the desiderata of our project.
The cover of MMI resembles the one of MMA. Instead of the redeemer, however, the front cover shows a representation of Saint Mary with Child. Between the silver panel and the wooden covers some relics are stored, including those of the monastery’s patron Agapitus. These relics were inscribed in the 13th century. In the inventory of the relics dating from the 10th/11th century, also present in the codex, Agapitus is not mentioned.
Our analysis of the two codices described above mainly aims at the identification of the colors and inks used for their make-up. From its results a better understanding of their evolution can be expected, especially regarding their provenance.
In order to study the materials used for manuscripts of this kind, non-destructive and non-invasive techniques are essential. This also implies the possibility of performing the measurements in situ. Since the two codices were studied during different phases of the project, different analytical techniques were accessible for the analyses. As these codices were only available for the investigations in a limited period of time it was not possible to do all examinations that would have been necessary and it was essential to focus on capable methods.
Our investigations comprised a combination of several complementary methods: on the one hand, X-ray Fluorescence analysis (XRF) was used for elemental analysis; on the other hand Fourier transform infrared spectrometry in the reflection mode (rFTIR) and Raman spectrometry were performed in order to obtain compound specific information. Thus, codex MMI was analyzed by XRF and rFTIR spectrometry (the Raman instrument was not yet available), whereas XRF and Raman spectrometry were applied in the case of codex MMA (because of the limited time it was not possible to do rFTIR measurements for these investigations so far). In doing so, the XRF analysis was always carried out first to classify the elements present in the areas of interest and give preliminary information for the interpretation of the compound specific data to be gained in the complementary analyses [14, 15]. Comparable instruments [16, 17, 18, 19, 20] as well as additional methods and other combinations of those [21, 22, 23, 24] were used for the research of manuscripts in other projects or research groups.
Due to the different period of the investigations the XRF analysis for the elemental identification of the pigments applied for the illuminations as well as the inks used for the text were carried out with two different portable XRF instruments available at the Institute of Science and Technology in Art, Academy of Fine Arts Vienna (ISTA). Both are equipped with a primary beam spot size of about 1 µm in diameter and two laser pointers for a precise positioning. These instruments are mounted on a tripod in order to measure in a position most suitable for the object. X-ray radiation has a certain penetration depth because of the comparatively high energy of the primary beam. This leads to the obstacle, that the element detection does not only refer to the surface layer (e.g., pigment or ink), but is the result of all elements present in all layers including the components of the parchment and the possible material of the verso-side of the folio. As the analyses are carried out in air, elements with an atomic number lower than silicon (Si) cannot be detected. To describe this, the well-known pigment ultramarine blue can be taken as a good example, as its elemental composition is based on a sodalite cage of sodium (Na) and silicon (Si), elements which cannot be detected in air at all. In general, the spectrum obtained has to be compared with the one of the (bare) support material, here parchment. The correlation to an ink or pigment is not always an easy task; sometimes the results are even impossible to verify.
Codex MMI was examined with our self-built XRF instrument, which was developed and built within the framework of a Ph.D.-thesis for the application in the fields of art and archaeology . It is equipped with an X-ray rhodium (Rh) tube with a maximum power of 50 kV and a silicon drift chamber detector. The measurement parameters chosen for the relevant manuscript analyses are a tube voltage of 35 kV and a tube current of 0.8 mA for 100 s acquisition time.
For codex MMA a new instrument, purchased during the HRSM project, was employed. The X-ray spectrometer ELIO  is a device well designed for the application in the field of arts. The system head consists of a 4 Watt X-ray rhodium (Rh) tube together with a silicon drift chamber detector (SDD) of an active area of 25 mm2. The settings for the measurements of the codex were of 40 kV, 20 µA and 100 s measurement time. In previous investigations it was possible to study objects which were investigated with the self-built XRF instrument to compare the results of these two devices. The results fitted perfectly to allow a direct comparison of these two instruments. So far there was no opportunity for Codex MMI to do further investigations.
In addition to XRF, FTIR-spectrometry was applied for codex MMI in order to gain also information about the compounds or even some organic mixtures as well as binding media. The available instrument is a portable Bruker ALPHA FTIR-spectrometer  with a spot size of approximately 4 µm in diameter. Total reflection spectra (specular and diffuse reflection) were collected in situ in the range of 4000–400 cm−1 with a resolution of 4 cm−1 over 64–128 scans. The background was acquired using a gold mirror as reference sample. The total reflection spectra were transformed to absorption index spectra applying the Kramers–Kronig algorithm , which is included in the software package OPUS, version 6.5, used for controlling the ALPHA instrument as well as the data acquisition and evaluation. After the transformation, a baseline correction was carried out to the absorption index spectra. For evaluation the spectra were compared to the database IRUG (Infrared and Raman Users Group ) with spectra mainly obtained in the transmission mode as well as to a database of the ISTA with spectra obtained from the individual material collection in transmission and reflection mode.
However, a great disadvantage of rFTIR is that inks such as carbon black or iron gall inks or mixtures of both cannot be identified. Raman spectrometry, acquired mainly for the analysis of these inks in a later period of the project, was performed for the analysis of the codex MMA. This compound specific method, similar to FTIR spectrometry, was carried out in situ with the Pro-Raman-L-Dual-G , a fully integrated and transportable instrument. The excitation sources applied for the investigations were Diode Lasers at 785 nm (~ 350 mW) and 532 nm (~ 50 mW) with narrow line-widths of 2.0 and 1.5 cm−1, respectively. The instrument is based on a two dimensional CCD array detector, which is temperature regulated (− 60 °C). To memorize the measurement spot, the instrument is equipped with an integrated microscope (1.3 Mpixel CMOS camera with an in-line LED illumination). The spot size of the excitation lasers is very small compared to XRF and rFTIR and varies depending on the applied laser as well as the objective lens of the microscope. Using an objective lens of, e.g., 40× magnification, the spot size is about 50 µm in diameter for the 785 nm laser, whereas for the 535 nm laser the analyzed area is reduced to 35 µm in diameter. The spectra were evaluated by comparison to a reference database of ISTA, created by mockups of the pigment collection in the institute.
Results and discussion
The aim of these investigations was to identify the inks as well as the pigments and binding media used for both codices. A comparison of the materials applied for both codices seems to be highly appropriate as their time of origin does not differ widely. Final evaluation has been obtained by combining the various results of the complementary analyses performed. Of each codex more than ten folios were examined, which were selected by philologists (either recto or verso of a folio). Main focus was given to folios with either text and initials or large illuminations at the beginning of the four Gospels.
The selected areas of interest for the measurements on parchment were mostly located on the margins or between the columns to ensure that no ink, pigment, etc. is located on this point as well as on the reverse side of this area (important for XRF investigations).
The main elements detected in the parchment with XRF were potassium (K), calcium (Ca) and iron (Fe); sometimes traces of phosphorus (P) and sulfur (S) were identified as well. Small amounts of lead (Pb) could be registered only in cod. MMA (fols. 18r, 108r, 111r, 175r, 276v), whereas small intensities of silver (Ag) were determined on some folios in both manuscripts (Cim. 1, fol. 278r; Cim. 2, fols. 9v and 183r). In cod. MMI two different types of parchment were characterized by rFTIR: some with calcium carbonate from whitening the support together with few silicates from polishing (fols. 9v, 17v, 73v, 111r, 167v, 183r), others without these two materials (fols. 19v, 219v). Low values of potassium (K) are intrinsic for the chemical composition of the parchment as well as phosphorus (P) and sulfur (S). Iron (Fe) is certainly present due to the preparation (removal of the hair and polishing of the skin) . Small amounts of lead (Pb) are possibly from lead white—these folia appear in a pale shade—which cannot be confirmed here. The silver (Ag) amount can be attributed to the abrasion of the metal implementation of the initials on these folia. The surface treatment could not be confirmed by Raman analysis.
Due to the dark-brown, almost black color of the text ink it is possible that the iron gall ink is mixed with carbon black. However, by the methods XRF and rFTIR it is not possible to detect this kind of writing material—carbon (C) cannot be detected by XRF in air and it does not absorb mid infrared radiation. In general, Raman spectrometry would allow the identification of carbon black, but the interference with the bands of the support material (parchment) did not yield clear results. Therefore, a possible mixture of iron gall ink with carbon black cannot be excluded.
Red and blue/green inks
In cod. MMA also green ink was applied as a writing material for headings and initials (Fig. 3a), in contrast to cod. MMI. In this case by XRF copper (Cu) was detected as the main element, together with traces of calcium (Ca) and lead (Pb), which indicates the use of a copper based green pigment, possibly mixed with lead white and/or calcium carbonate to brighten up the color. Unfortunately, due to high fluorescence interference no distinct identification with Raman spectrometry (532 nm laser was used) could be achieved.
Materials in illuminations and decorations
Identified pigments in the illuminations of the investigated manuscripts
Codex Millenarius Maior
Codex Millenarius Minor
Lead or calcium based pigments
Lead white (2PbCO3·Pb(OH)2)
Orpiment/realgar as well as iron oxide
Orpiment (As2S3) as well as iron oxide
Minium (= red led, Pb3O4)
Minium (= red led, Pb3O4)
Minium (= red led, Pb3O4)
Iron oxide (FeO(OH))
Lapis lazuli (Na8…10[Al6Si6O24]S2…4)
Copper based green pigment
Copper(II)-hydroxyl chloride (Cu2Cl(OH)3)
Iron based brown pigment (brown ochre)
Iron based brown pigment (brown ochre)
Codex Millenarius Maior
Codex Millenarius Minor
According to Thompson , the basic standard binding medium for illuminations in medieval times was glare, which is made from egg white, processed to a watery liquid by certain methods. Furthermore, Arabic gum as well as protein based binders, mostly prepared from parchment, were applied. However, no binding media could be identified in our studies. The main reason may be the chemical similarities of egg white and parchment, since both are proteins and, due to the overlapping of the significant bands in the mid infrared of these compounds, no identification can be achieved by rFTIR. For Raman spectrometry binding media show in general a strong fluorescence.
Two outstanding codices could be investigated non-invasively by the combination of XRF, rFTIR, and Raman spectrometry. Unfortunately, the period of time for the investigations was limited to several days in contrast to other comparable studies in literature [3, 6]. The characterization of the precious illuminations of the saints as well as the used inks is of historical importance, as no studies have been carried out so far and no references of investigations of other codices from the Carolingian period could be found.
For the characterization of the parchment only rFTIR spectrometry provided some information about the manufacturing process and treatment of the different folios, e.g., the identification of calcium carbonates and silicates on the surface of the parchment. CaCO3 is an indicator for the liming or whitening of the animal skin, the silicates are due to polishing the surface with pumice. The combination of XRF and Raman spectrometry enabled the characterization of black/brown inks in the text as iron gall ink as well as vermilion and red lead as red inks in the initials of both codices. In some of the black/brown inks oxalates were detected by rFTIR, which indicates degradation of the binding media by mold fungi. The use of complementary methods allowed the identification of typical pigments in illuminations such as lead white, orpiment/realgar, red lead, vermilion and red iron oxides as well as azurite and indigo, together with the rather rare copper chloride hydroxide. The experimental results showed as well that the same palette was used throughout the entire codex.
In general, XRF provided significant information about the elemental composition, which was important for the evaluation of rFTIR as well as Raman spectra allowing the identification of several inorganic pigments. A draw-back of XRF is the lack of compound specific information and the disability to identify organic materials. Furthermore, the penetration depth of X-rays is high, so that the material on the verso side of the analyzed folios contributes to the signal as well. In contrast, compound specific rFTIR was well as Raman spectrometry signals derive mainly from the uppermost surface. However, the identification of various inorganic materials is still not always possible with these methods. rFTIR, e.g., does not detect important metal oxides and sulfide pigments such as vermilion, red lead and orpiment/realgar. On the other hand, rFTIR was the only method allowing the identification of compounds such as calcium oxalate or silicates. During the investigations it turned out that only Raman spectrometry allowed a clear identification of iron gall ink , whereas rFTIR did not, although it was possible in sample studies with reference inks.
The scientific data collected from the manuscripts underlined the authenticity of these codices. As the aim of the CIMA-project lies in a general study of different manuscripts and not only in the examination of the codices MMI and MMA, the limited period of time of several days was not sufficient to answer all questions. However, the results obtained so far could yield data which are useful for the historic and philological studies and it seems to extend the analysis with further complementary methods like fiber optic reflectance spectroscopy (FORS) to complete the results.
Which means: “This one is definitely a millennial codex”.
BF analysis heritage science objects with XRF and interprets results of XRF, Raman and rFTIR with the help of CF, WV and MS; is the lead author of the article. CF performs the Raman spectroscopy and WV the FTIR spectroscopy in the reflection mode. Both help writing the analysis results. MS is the coordinator of the project and helps with the interpretation of results, preparation and corrections of this paper. FP is the head of the library in Kremsmuenster Abbey and provides information about the historical background of the analyzed objects. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
This project was realized in the frame of CIMA, an interuniversity research institution with an interdisciplinary approach to the investigation of cultural heritage. The authors are grateful to their partners in the project, especially to Prof. Dr. Heinz Miklas, Prof. Dr. Robert Sablatnig and DI Fabian Hollaus. Special thanks are also due to Prof. Miklas for the proof reading and discussion of the manuscript.
The authors declared that they have no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
- 1.CIMA is an interuniversity research institution with an interdisciplinary approach aiming at the investigation of cultural heritage and was founded in 2014, see http://hrsm.caa.tuwien.ac.at/. Accessed 22 Feb 2017.
- 2.Hochschulraum-Strukturfonds—HRSM project “Analysis and Conservation of Cultural Heritage—Modern Imaging and Material Analysis Methods for the Visualization, Documentation and Classification of Historical Written Material (Manuscripts)”. Financial support by the Federal Ministry of Science, Research and Economy; 2013.Google Scholar
- 7.Krenn M, Winterer C. Mit Pinsel und Federkiel: Geschichte der mittelalterlichen Buchmalerei. Darmstadt: WBG, Primusverlag; 2009.Google Scholar
- 8.Brown MP. Illuminated manuscripts: a guide to technical terms. London: Getty Museum and British Library Board; 1994.Google Scholar
- 9.Holter K, Neumüller W. Der Codex Millenarius. In: Forschungen zur Geschichte Oberösterreichs Band 6, Linz: Oberösterreichisches Landesarchiv; 1959.Google Scholar
- 10.Neumüller W. Der Codex Millenarius und sein historischer Umkreis. In: Jahresbericht des Stiftsgymnasiums Kremsmünster 1960:7–49.Google Scholar
- 11.Holter K, Neumüller W. Markus und der Löwe. Die Evangelisten und ihre Symbole im Codex Millenarius. Graz: Akademische Druck- und Verlagsanstalt (ADEVA); 1977Google Scholar
- 12.Holter K. Die alten Bestände der Stiftsbibliothek Kremsmünster. In: Der österreichische Bibliothekarstag 1980. Biblos—Schriften 114. Wien 1981:46–60.Google Scholar
- 13.Fill H: Katalog der Handschriften des Benediktinerstiftes Kremsmünster. I. Von den Anfängen bis in die Zeit des Abtes Friedrich von Aich (ca. 800–1325). Wien: Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, phil.-hist. Klasse, Denkschriften 166. Veröffentlichungen der Kommission für Schrift- und Buchwesen des Mittelalters II.3.1 1984.Google Scholar
- 14.Guedes A, Prieto AC. Raman spectroscopy for the characterisation of inks on written documents. In: Chalmers JM, Edwards HGM, Hargreaves MD, editors. Infrared and Raman spectroscopy in forensic science. Weinheim: Wiley; 2011.Google Scholar
- 15.Derrick M, Stulik D, Landry JM. Infrared spectroscopy in conservation science. Los Angeles: The Getty Conservation Institute; 1999.Google Scholar
- 19.Pessanha S, Manso M, Carvalho ML. Application of spectroscopic techniques to the study of illuminated manuscripts: a survey. Spectrochimica Acta Part B. 2012;71–72:4–61.Google Scholar
- 20.Hahn O. Analyses of iron gall and carbon inks by means of X-ray fluorescence analysis: a non-destructive approach in the field of archaeometry and conservation science. Restaurator. 2010;31(1):41–64.Google Scholar
- 21.Ricciardi P, Delaney JK, Facini M, Glinsman L. Use of imaging spectroscopy and in situ analytical methods for the characterization of the materials and techniques of 15th century illuminated manuscripts. J Am Inst Conserv. 2013;52(1):13–29. https://doi.org/10.1179/0197136012Z.0000000004.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 22.Ricciardi P, Delaney JK, Glinsman L, Thourya M, Facinia M, Riea E. Use of visible and infrared reflectance and luminescence imaging spectroscopy to study illuminated manuscripts: pigment identification and visualization of underdrawings. Optics Arts Architecture Archaeol. 2009. https://doi.org/10.1117/12.827415.Google Scholar
- 26.XGLab S.R.L.—Spinoff del Politechnico di Milano, Milano. 2017. http://www.xglab.it/. Accessed 22 Feb 2017.
- 27.Bruker Optics, Ettlingen, Germany. 2017. https://www.bruker.com/products/infrared-near-infrared-and-raman-spectroscopy/ft-ir-routine-spectrometers/alpha/overview.html/. Accessed 22 Feb 2017.
- 28.Griffiths PR, de Haseth JA. Fourier transform infrared spectrometry. In: Winefordner JD, editor. 2nd ed. Hoboken: Wiley; 2007.Google Scholar
- 29.Infrared and Raman Users Group (IRUG), Philadelphia, USA. 2017. http://irug.org/. Accessed 22 Feb 2017.
- 30.Enwave Optronics, Irvine, USA. 2017. http://www.tsi.com/raman-spectrometers/. Accessed 22 Feb 2017.
- 31.Thompson D. The materials and techniques of medieval painting. New York: Dover Publications; 1956.Google Scholar
- 33.Bicchieri M, Monti M, Piantanida G, Sodo A. All that is iron-ink is not always iron-gall! Raman Spectrosc. 2009;36:1074–8.Google Scholar
- 36.Daniel F, Mounier A. Alteration of gildings on mediaeval mural paintings. Proceedings of the ICOM-CC joint interim meeting multidisciplinary conservation: a holistic view of historic interiors. Rome 2010. http://www.icom-cc.org/54/document/alteration-of-gildings-on-mediaeval-mural-paintings/?id=797. Accessed 20 Feb 2018.
- 38.Martin E, Eveno M, Resort C: L’órnement métallique et ses alterations, Maitre de Burgo de OSam, La Vierge et l’Efant entourés d’anges, St. Amboise. Techné. 1998;7:105–8Google Scholar
- 41.Castro K, Sarmiento A, Martínez-Arkarazo I, Madariaga JM, Fernández LA. Green copper pigments biodegradation in cultural heritage: from malachite to moolooite, thermodynamic modeling, X-ray fluorescence, and Raman evidence. Anal Chem. 2008;80(11):4103–10. https://doi.org/10.1021/ac800255w.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.