Radiographic analysis of subclinical appearances of the hip joint among patients with labral tears
- 136 Downloads
Labral tears can be complicated by hip diseases, including osteoarthritis or femoral acetabular impingement. To accurately plan hip arthroscopy or subsequent conversion to total hip arthroplasty, the presence of bony abnormalities in the hip joint must be evaluated. This study aimed to elucidate the utility of multiplanar reconstruction computed tomography (mCT) for the detection of subclinical coincidence of osteoarthritis or femoral acetabular impingement with a labrum tear.
Materials and methods
We retrospectively analysed 34 patients (36 hips) with labrum tears without apparent osteoarthritis or hip dysplasia from 2012 to 2015. The joint spaces were calculated using radiographs or mCT, and the detection rates of degenerative cyst and herniation pit were compared.
Narrow joint spaces (< 2 mm) were more clearly detected in mCT (p < 0.05, chi-square analysis) than in radiographs. The detection rate of cysts in the acetabulum was 8.3% using radiographs and 36.1% using mCT (p < 0.001, chi-square analysis). Additionally, the detection of herniation pit was 8.3% and 25.0% using radiographs and mCT, respectively (p = 0.053, chi-square analysis).
We performed the radiographic analysis of patients with labral tears using radiographs and mCT. The mCT allowed for fine detection of narrow joint spaces and subtle subclinical appearances. The results of this study may provide surgeons with more appropriate strategies for the treatment of labral tears.
KeywordsHip arthroscopy Labral tear Multiplanar reconstruction CT Femoral acetabular impingement
Femoral acetabular impingement
Japanese Orthopaedic Association
Multiplanar reconstruction computed tomography
Magnetic resonance imaging
Total hip arthroplasty
The acetabular labrum is an essential structure for hip joint stability . The loss of integrity of the structure induces micro-instability, subluxation, or hip pain . The injury can be preceded by osteoarthritis (OA), hip dysplasia, or femoral acetabular impingement (FAI) [3, 4]. With progress in minimally invasive surgery, arthroscopic surgery has been indicated for the treatment of labral tear. However, the incidence of OA with labral tear adversely affects the outcomes following arthroplasty . To evaluate the osteoarthritic changes in the joint, the “2-mm rule” was proposed by Philippon et al. for the prediction of poor outcomes after hip arthroscopic surgery . The joint space is measured at the hip joint, and the 2-mm cut-off value predicts the necessity to perform total hip arthroplasty (THA) after arthroscopic surgery . Originally, the 2-mm rule was evaluated using radiographs. However, in clinical settings, diagnostic imaging is often performed by other multimodal approaches. Computed tomography (CT) is considered more sensitive than radiographs for the precise detection of bone cysts, including herniation pits which indicate cam-type FAI , and subchondral cysts of the acetabulum, which indicate OA changes. Further, a multiplanar reconstruction CT (mCT) image can precisely measure the joint space and reduce intra-observer error. This study aimed to elucidate the utility of mCT for the detection of subclinical coincidence of OA or FAI with a labrum tear.
Clinical and treatment characteristics of patients
Age at diagnosis, years
41.6 ± 10.7 (mean ± standard deviation)
JOA score at diagnosis
72.8 ± 18.2 (mean ± standard deviation)
Harris Hip Score at diagnosis
76.9 ± 14.2 (mean ± standard deviation)
Measurement of joint space in the hip joint
Detection of degenerative cysts in the hip joint
We also analysed the cystic changes in the acetabulum owing to OA and herniation pit, which is defined as a cystic lesion underneath the anterior cortex at the antero-superior femoral head-neck junction with clear demarcation and diameter of > 3 mm using radiographs and mCT (coronal view) [9, 10].
Indication of operation
First, all patients underwent conservative therapy with stretching of the flexor muscles of the hip joint and core muscle training of the trunk and pelvis for at least 6 months. If the symptoms did not improve enough to allow for participation in desired sports activities and if there were still barriers to activities of daily life, school attendance, or employment, the labrum was repaired with arthroscopic assistance. The procedures of the surgery were performed in accordance with those reported by Kelly et al. . Furthermore, osteoplasty of the femoral head was added for cases of cam-type FAI.
Phase 1 (0–4 weeks): in this period, the aim was to protect the sutured labrum tear and achieve joint movement. Weight-bearing was restricted for 2 weeks after surgery and gradually increased from 1/3 partial weight-bearing with 1/3 augmentations per week. With respect to passive training for the range of motion, 60° flexion and 30° abduction of the hip joint were permitted during the first week postoperatively. For the second week after surgery, 90° flexion and 30° external rotation of the hip joint were permitted, with no restriction on abduction and internal rotation. Three weeks after surgery, 120° flexion was permitted, and abduction and external and internal rotation were not restricted. Phillipon hip brace (BREG, Carlsbad, CA) was used at night and at rest until 2 weeks after surgery. Moreover, the physical therapist massaged the soft tissues and aided in the mobilisation of the operative scar tissue.
Phase 2 (4–8 weeks): in this period, the aim was stabilisation of movement and achievement of weight-bearing. Active flexion, abduction, and external rotation were performed, including the use of the exercise bike, underwater walking, performing plank exercise, and training of the quadriceps and gluteus medius.
Phase 3 (8–12 weeks): in this period, the aim was to augment the muscle strength. Therefore, regular exercises were combined with closed kinetic chain hip strengthening, one-third knee bends, slide-to-slide lateral movement, and forward box lunge.
Phase 4 (after 12 weeks): in this period, the aim was to return to sports activity. Sports-specific training was performed, and the functionality for the return to sports activity was assessed.
A p value < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. All values were presented either as mean ± standard deviation or median with range, depending on the distribution. All statistical analyses were conducted using SPSS version 24 (IBM, Chicago, IL). Radiographical images were evaluated independently and cross-checked by two orthopaedic surgeons (H.A. and N.W.), who were blinded to all other patient information. The kappa value was then calculated to evaluate the intra-observer (N.W., over a 1-month interval) and inter-observer (H.A. and N.W.) error. The comparisons of numeric values were performed by paired t test or Mann-Whitney U test based on the distributions.
Measurement of the joint space from the AP radiographs and the coronal or sagittal CT
Analysis of joint space with different modalities (coronal CT)
Detection of narrow joint space (coronal CT)
Joint space calculated by multiplanar computed tomography (coronal)
Joint space calculated by radiographs
< 2 mm
≥ 2 mm
< 2 mm
≥ 2 mm
Analysis of joint space with different modalities (sagittal CT)
Detection of narrow joint space (sagittal CT)
Joint space calculated by multiplanar computed tomography (sagittal)
Joint space calculated by radiographs
< 2 mm
≥ 2 mm
< 2 mm
≥ 2 mm
Subclinical appearance of the hip with labrum tear (presence of cysts by CT)
Detection of the degenerative cyst in the acetabulum
Presence of cysts by CT (length of cyst; mm)
Presence of cysts by radiographs
3 (11.1 ± 3.6)*
10 (3.5 ± 1.5)
Validation of degenerative cysts in the acetabulum
We analysed the cysts in the acetabulum using radiographs and mCT images. The detection rate was 8.3% (3/36) in the radiographs and 36.1% (13/36) in mCT. Based on the chi-square analysis, there was a statistical difference in the detection rate in both modalities (p < 0.001). The average length of the cyst in the radiograph-negative case (n = 10) was 3.5 mm (SD 1.5 mm), indicating the presence of the detection limit of the radiographs (Table 4). For the detection of degenerative cysts, the intra-observer errors (N.W., over a 1-month interval) were 0.65 and 0.68 (radiographs and mCT, respectively) and the inter-observer errors (N.W. and H.A.) were 0.53 and 0.46 (radiographs and mCT, respectively).
Validation of the herniation pit in the femoral head
Subclinical appearance of the hip with labrum tear (presence of herniation pit cysts by CT)
Detection of the herniation pit
Presence of herniation pit cysts by CT
Presence of herniation pit by radiographs
Clinical outcomes of the cohort
In this cohort, regardless of operation or conservative treatment, almost all patients had improved JOA and Harris Hip Scores. Moreover, THA after hip arthroscopy was only performed in one patient, owing to fracture and dislocations of the hip joint secondary to a traffic accident. However, because almost all patients with or without surgery showed improved functionality, the effect of the length of joint space and the detection of OA change and herniation pit were not strongly related to the poor outcomes of the patients (Additional file 1: Table S1).
We investigated the subclinical deformities in patients with an acetabular labral tear. First, we validated the application of mCT for measurement of the joint space. Moreover, to assist in the diagnosis of OA or cam-type FAI, we compared the cystic changes in the acetabulum and femoral head (herniation pit) using radiographs and mCT. The lengths of the joint spaces measured by mCT tended to be smaller than those calculated by radiographs. This might be due to the sensitivity of mCT, allowing measurements at any point. Specifically, mCT can measure where the size of the femoral head is the largest and the joint space smallest. Additionally, as was expected, the cyst in the acetabulum and the herniation pits were more sharply detected using mCT. These results provided thorough subclinical details of the concurrent OA or FAI and more prudent preoperative planning before hip arthroscopy.
It is difficult to clearly distinguish between these concurrent hip diseases. The cohort of asymptomatic men (n = 244) elucidated that the cam-type deformity was related to the herniation pit, labrum tear, and decrease in the cartilage thickness . A cross-sectional Japanese population study revealed that the rate of coexistence of acetabular dysplasia was 23.4% in patients with FAI . On the contrary, owing to the mechanical stress to the labrum, the dysplastic hip is at risk for abnormal thickening of the labrum . Thus, subclinical deformities of the hip should be assessed using multiple diagnostic techniques prior to making treatment decisions .
Joint space is one of the factors that affects the outcome after surgery. Philippon et al. reported that the conversion rate to THA after hip arthroscopy was 39 times higher in patients with < 2-mm joint space than those with ≥ 2 mm . McCormick et al. also stated the importance of the 2-mm rule in that the conversion rate to THA after hip surgery was higher in patients with < 2-mm joint space (86% versus 16%) . However, in this study, the 2-mm rule was not related to the symptoms at diagnosis, clinical outcomes, or conversion rate. This is partially because we excluded patients with apparent OA change (Tonnis grade ≥ 2), resulting in a lower conversion rate to THA. However, we should be careful when considering the predisposing factors for poor prognosis prior to treatment.
In this study, we did not prove the relation between patient-reported outcomes and prevalence of subclinical hip deformities. Generally, with the narrowing of the joint space and the progression of OA change, the range of motion and hip pain become worse . In addition, according to the Copenhagen City Heart Study, a joint space < 2-mm was strongly related to coxalgia (odds 3.2–3.3) and more severe OA change correlated with coxalgia (odds 17.4) . However, moderate changes were only mildly related to pain (odds 1.4), especially in the younger population (under 50 years). This result was similar to that of the current study, partially because the present cohort included mainly a younger population (mean age 41.6 years). Thus, it was postulated that subclinical findings in the hip joint did not apparently affect patient-reported outcomes; however, careful attention must be paid to subtle changes in the hip joint, paying attention specifically to long-term effects.
This study has limitations that might have affected the results. First, selection bias is present. We included patients with labral tears observed in radial MRI with a contrast agent, and patients with apparent OA were excluded from this study. Further, the population who responded well to conservative therapy was exclusively selected. Second, the study analysis was dependent on the resolution of the software and hardware. This might relate to measurement error and influence external validity. Third, the number of the population was relatively smaller, and the adequacy of the follow-up periods was still unclear. Despite these limitations, the detection of narrow joint space and degenerative cysts should be fully assessed with mCT to differentiate concomitant hip diseases.
We performed radiographic analysis of patients with labral tears using radiographs and mCT. Using mCT, narrow joint spaces and subtle subclinical appearances were finely detected. These findings may provide surgeons with more appropriate strategies for the treatment of labral tears.
We thank the Department of Radiology for the mCT and radial MRI. Further, we thank the hospitals nearby for the referral of patients with labral tears.
This article has been edited to ensure that the language is clear and free of errors. The edit was performed by professional editors at an outside agency.
HA contributed to the software, validation, visualisation, formal analysis, data curation, and original draft. NW contributed to the conceptualisation, main surgeon, methodology, and supervision. MF helped in the review, editing, and supervision. IW contributed to the radiological assessment and conceptualisation. HM helped in the review, editing, project administration, and conceptualisation. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
There was no funding for this study.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
All procedures performed in studies involving human participants were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional and/or national research committee and with the 1964 Helsinki Declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards.
Consent for publication
Written informed consent for the publication of identifying images and information was given by the parent/legal guardian for those under 16 years old. Patients over 16 years old gave their own consent.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.