Comparison of the clinical and radiographic appearance of the cervical vertebrae with histological and anatomical findings in an eight-month old warmblood stallion suffering from cervical vertebral stenotic myelopathy (CVSM)
- 128 Downloads
Cervical vertebral stenotic myelopathy (CVSM) remains one of the most important abnormalities of the cervical spine resulting in neurological deficits in horses. The aim of the following study was to compare the results of the clinical and neurological examination, the results of myelography and the post mortem anatomical and histological appearance of the spinal cord and cervical vertebrae in a horse with CVSM.
The following study describes a clinical case of an eight-month-old stallion with ataxia. Plain cervical radiographs indicated narrowing of the spinal canal. Conservative therapy using NSAIDs did not result in any improvement in the gait of the horse. Due to economic constraints, surgical intervention was excluded. The owner chose to humanely euthanise the horse. Immediately after euthanasia, post mortem myelography was performed, and measurements of the myelographic dye column were taken. They revealed a 67% DMC reduction and a 64% DD reduction at the C3/C4 level. Afterwards, an anatomical dissection was performed. The cervical vertebrae and vertebral canal were macroscopically inspected and measured and indicated a 44% narrowing of the canal at the C3/C4 level. The spinal cord was removed and underwent histological evaluation after staining. Microscopic lesions were visible at the level of the compression and included axonal degeneration with partial or complete loss of myelin in the white matter of the lateral and dorsal funiculi as well as the formation of dysfunctional so-called “spongy structures”. An increase in the number of microglial cells and collagen was also observed. The formation of glial scars was excluded. Immunohistochemical studies revealed a negative transmembrane glycoprotein CD68(−) – monocyte response and a negative tumor necrosis alpha TNFα (−) reaction.
CVSM may be difficult to diagnose, even for experienced veterinary surgeons. Currently, an ex vivo histopathologic examination of the spinal cord is thought to be the gold standard in the diagnosis of CVSM. Our histological examination revealed no CVSM-specific glial scar formation and a CD68(−) negative and TNF-α negative reaction, which have not been previously reported. Histological lesions in CVSM may vary depending show inter-individual variability and on the treatment, which further hinders ex-vivo diagnostics.
KeywordsSpinal cord compression Cervical vertebral stenosis Ataxia Horses
Cervical Vertebral Malformation
Cervical Vertebral Stenotic Myelopathy
Dorsal Myelographic Column
Hematoxylin and Eosin
Non-Steroidal Anti-Inflammatory Drugs
Cervical vertebral stenotic myelopathy (CVSM), also known as wobbler syndrome or cervical vertebral malformation or malarticulation (CVM) can affect both young and old equine patients [5, 17, 18, 21, 24]. The disease is divided into a dynamic (type I) or static (type II) type, depending on the type, location and nature of the lesions as well as the age of the patient [27, 31, 37]. Clinical symptoms can vary from slight hypermetria, through lack of balance, neck and back stiffness, incoordination to spontaneous falling. As horses continue to be important companion and sport animals, their owners have become more aware of their health. Equine ataxia affects a relatively large number of horses. However, there are limited diagnostic methods that allow its correct identification [6, 20, 22, 38]. The prognosis associated with ataxia is usually poor, and the costs of treatment of horses with ataxia, including surgical intervention, are usually very high [10, 26, 34]. The correct diagnosis of CVSM in horses is particularly important, given that there are only a few facilities in Europe that are able to manage the disorder surgically [34, 39]. The aim of the study was to present the results of the clinical, orthopedic, neurological, radiological examinations of a young horse suffering from CVSM. Due to poor prognosis, the horse was euthanized and tissue sections were collected post-mortem, enabling a histological assessment of the spinal cord. This prompted us to assess the correlation between symptoms of ataxia and the histological lesions of the spinal cord. The obtained results differed from available data and encourage further investigation of equine CVSM, considering that spinal cord histological studies were considered the ex-vivo gold standard of CVSM diagnosis in horses.
An eight-month-old warmblood stallion was presented for examination due to ataxia manifested by problems with coordination, stumbling and spontaneous falling. The symptoms were first observed at the pasture when the horse grazed with other colts. There were no direct signs of any trauma at pasture. There was no history of ataxic horse in the family, the horse was raised in one location and was not transported. It did not have contact with unknown horses/ animals or sport horses.
Clinical and diagnostic findings
Measurements of inter-, intravertebral ratio, DMC and DD reduction according to plain radiographs and the myelogram
Sagittal intervertebral ratio
Sagittal intravertebral ratio
Dorsal Myelographic Column
33% (67% red.)
36% (64% red.)
Due to financial constraints, conservative therapy was attempted, and included an administration of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (flunixin meglumin 1.1 mg/kg BW q24h),1 a high dose of vitamin E2 (10,000 IU/day) and exercise restriction. A control examination performed after a month of treatment did not reveal any improvement in the horse’s clinical findings. At that stage, it was clear that the horse would not be fit for sport use and the owner did not agree to further examinations. Due to the high degree of ataxia of the horse, which posed a threat to the animal itself as well as its caregivers and no possibility of effective treatment, the animal was euthanised. General anaesthesia was induced by diazepam3 (0.02 mg/kg IV) and ketamine4 (2.2 mg/kg IV), after achieving sufficient sedation with xylazine5 (1.1 mg/kg IV), and euthanasia performed by administration of pentobarbital sodium6 (140 mg/kg IV after receiving sufficient anaesthesia).
Real scenario measurements of vertebral canal taken at the level from C3 to C5
Measurement in mm
Histopathologic and morphologic examination
All the samples were fixed in 4% buffered formalin and embedded in paraffin blocks. Five μm paraffin sections were obtained using a rotary microtome, and they were stained with hematoxylin and eosin (HE) and Masson trichrome (MTC) according to the relevant histological protocols. Section analysis was carried out with an optical microscope (Axio Imager A1; Carl Zeiss).
For immunohistochemistry analysis, the paraffin embedded tissue was cut into 4 μm thick section, placed on silanized slides (Dako, S 3003) and dried for 12 h in an incubator at 37 °C. The dried sections were then dehydrated and they were pre-treated with 0.01 M citrate buffer solution at a higher pH in an incubator at 97 °C for 20 min to unmask the antigenic sites. The sections were rinsed in 0.01% phosphate buffered saline (PBS). Then, they were treated with enzyme block FLEX peroxidase for 5 min, rinsed in PBS and subsequently overlaid by the primary antibody CD68/KP1 (Dako). Next, the slides were rinsed in PBS, labelled using a Polymer Flex/HRP for 20 min, rinsed in PBS for 5 min and covered by Chromogen Flex DAB with Subchromogen for 10 min. After rinsing the slides in PBS, they were counterstained using FLEX Hematoxylin for 5 min, washed with deionized water and PBS and analysed with an optical microscope (Zeiss Axio Scope A1; Carl Zeiss). A positive and a negative control were performed for each sample.
Immunostaining was performed using a standard technique, according to protocols designed at the Department of Experimental Biology, Faculty of Biology and Animal Science at the Wroclaw University of Environmental and Life Sciences . The tissue samples were cut into 3 μm-thick sections, deparaffinised in xylene and washed in a series of decreasing alcohol concentrations from 100 to 50%. An EnVision System (Dako) was used to visualize the antigen-antibody reaction. Immunoperoxidase labelling was performed using polyclonal antibodies against TNF-α (R&D Systems, USA). Antigen heat-induced retrieval was performed by incubating the slides with a target retrieval solution (pH 9.0; Dako) for 20 min at 96 °C. The endogenous peroxidase activity was blocked with 3% hydrogen peroxide, and the tissue sections were then washed with Tris-buffered saline (TBS) for 5 min at room temperature. Next, the slides were labelled with primary antibodies for 20 min at 20 °C. The antibodies were diluted to 1:10. Then the sections were counterstained with Mayer’s hematoxylin for 1 min, washed with tap water, and rehydrated in increasing ethanol concentrations from 50 to 100%, closed in a mounting medium with coverslips and analysed using an optical microscope (Axio Imager A1; Carl Zeiss).
Discussion and conclusions
This case describes a young male horse presenting severe gait deficits. Cervical vertebral stenotic myelopathy (CVSM), aberrant parasite migration and equine degenerative myeloencephalopathy (EDM) were considered in the differential diagnostics. Due to the geographic location, equine protozoal meningitis (EPM) was excluded. The histological lesions and the results of the examinations excluded other diseases, such as EDM or a nematode infection. EDM affects animals that are genetically predisposed to the disease, that have disorders of vitamin E absorption, limited access to pasture or excess exposure to insecticides, all of which were excluded in the presented case [3, 25]. The histological lesions visible in the course of EDM affect the dorsal grey column, while those in CVSM affect the white matter. EDM features neuroaxonal dystrophy with axonal-dendritic edema and neuronal atrophy, which results from lipofuscin accumulation. The histological findings in the case of chronic, eosinophilic encephalomyelitis caused by nematodes from the Protostrongylidae family are characteristic . Most migration routes are present in the white matter or on the border between the grey and white matter and lead to hemorrhagic lesions, large eosinophilic infiltrations and infiltrations of multinucleated giant cells, lymphocytes and hemosiderin-laden macrophages. Adult parasites are found mainly in the brain, while larvae are present in the thoracic and lumbar spinal cord and are located mainly in the dorsal grey columns . Cellular vacuolization and axonal spheroids indicate cellular lesions and occur in various neurological diseases. Parasytoses caused by cerebrospinal nematodes such as Parelaphostrongylus tenuis lead to dorsal grey column and lateral white column lesions, but are not reported in our geographical region. Our results indicated a significant reduction in the functionality of the spinal cord nerve tissue following loss of neurons which is similar to some other diseases. At the same time the lack of haemorrhagic lesions, lipofuscin deposits or hemosiderin-laden cells excludes those diseases. The presence of neuronal degeneration, numerous microglial cells and unmyelinated dysfunctional so-called “spongy structure” areas all suggest CVSM, which was confirmed in the radiological findings. Most studies reporting age and breed correlations of CVSM describe the condition in young fast-growing males [15, 18, 19, 26, 27, 34, 39]. The latest research indicates that the traditional 50% reduction of DMC  rule is ineffective in diagnosing CVSM, particularly in the flexed neck position [27, 31, 34, 37]. Other studies report the principle of diagnosis based on comparing the intra- and intervertebral ratio measured on cervical spine lateral radiographic projections. However, such measurements are limited due to observer bias. Nevertheless, static and dynamic CVSM are distinguished [27, 34, 37]. A 70% DMC reduction instead of a 50% one has already been proposed to avoid false positive results [22, 37, 38]. Therefore, radiographs and myelograms should be evaluated with caution and always in correlation with the results of the clinical examinations. Moreover, the lateral view is useful only in detecting dorso-ventral compression [31, 38]. In the described stallion, the compression, understood as a reduction of the DMC equal or higher than 50%, was only detected at the C3/C4 level. The measured DMC reduction in this colt was 67%, which is thought to be responsible for the clinical symptoms. A 20% DD reduction has been described as potentially significant enough to reflect dural sac narrowing due to vertebral canal malformation [27, 37, 38]. In the presented study, the obtained DD reduction was 64% at the C3/C4 level. Contrary to hypothetic results based on the radiographs, the post-mortem measurements revealed a 44% diameter reduction of the vertebral canal. These measurements were taken in a neutral position of the spine. It is clear that the measurements taken post mortem are more accurate than the radiographic analysis as they were collected in a neutral position of the cervical spine following confirmation of dynamic changes. Interestingly, the percentage reduction was lower than CVSM gold standard value, while the clinical symptoms were described as moderate to strong. Hence we expected a higher reduction rate based on measurements performed on anatomical sections. The intra- and intervertebral ratio in the C4/C5 section should be taken into account with reference to the available literature . We focused on the C3/C4 compression due to the lowest intravertebral ratio at this site with a simultaneous reduction of the DD and DMC as well as measurements carried out macroscopically. Despite the fact that the value of the intravertebral ratio at the C4/C5 site was lower than 48.5%, and that the intervertebral ratio considered more specific was lower than at C3/C4, which, based on the cited study, could have high diagnostic value, was not confirmed in the measurements performed during the myelography [8, 9]. This may have been caused by differences in the assessment of the cervical radiographs . However, myelography is considered an important intravital diagnostic tool that enables the qualification of patients for cervical vertebral stabilisation surgery, therefore our study focused on the C3/C4 analysis. CSF analysis which is also a valuable tool concerning protozoal or verminous infection has not been performed due to its high costs and low diagnostic value in the case of suspected CVSM . CT and MR are also valuable tools that enable the analysis of the cervical spine. Due to technical constraints, MR can be currently used to assess only the cranial section of the cervical spine and enables high quality soft tissue analysis of the studied area. Computed tomography and myelo-CT are valuable diagnostic methods but require an appropriate gantry size . Unfortunately, high-field imaging of the cervical spine using MR or appropriate CT is not available in Poland. We decided to carry out a histologic study, which is thought to be the most appropriate tool in the diagnosis of CVSM [27, 37] although it is not applicable in in vivo studies. The typical histologic changes described in horses with CVSM are observed within the white matter . Commonly described primary changes consist of an increased number of macrophages, perivascular collagen , the presence of “digestive chambers” [36, 40] partial/total loss of myelin, axonal degeneration [13, 40, 41] and gliosis [41, 42]. Our results were slightly different as they did not include some of the commonly described histologic changes such as the formation of a glial scar or spheroids characteristic of CVSM (only oedematose axons were found). This may result from an early NSAIDs therapy, which inhibited the inflammatory process, the age of the animal or the relatively short interval between symptom recognition and euthanasia. The results of the immunohistochemical study, which was not performed by other authors, did not confirm inflammation. In the case of CD68, the lack of reaction may indicate non-specificity of the used antibody  or the occurrence of a very weak reaction at the limit of detection , which is difficult to interpret. However, the negative TNFα reaction indicates an absence of the tumor necrosis factor representative of inflammation, produced by the activated tissue macrophages [32, 36]. As a result of the administration of anti-inflammatory drugs, the inflammatory reaction was suppressed or the histologic changes did not develop sufficiently due to a rapid diagnosis of the disease as evidenced by the lack of gliosis. Nevertheless, it would be useful to collect a sample from the spinal cord both above and below the place of the compression while performing a histologic examination. However, a complete histological and immunohistochemical analysis of the entire cervical spinal cord is very difficult technically. An analysis of spinal cord samples above and below the described lesion may have been performed to confirm or exclude co-existing diseases. In addition, a wider sample analysis may have facilitated the identification of an area with lesions typical of CVSM and an analysis of their severity depending on their distance from the site of greatest compression.
CVSM is a common, non-infectious equine disease that is caused by narrowing of the cervical spinal canal and myelocompression, leading to ataxia. Despite numerous studies on CVSM, it is still unclear how the risk of the disease can be minimised. Effective treatment is time-consuming, cost-intensive and difficult, reducing the chance of a full recovery. The diagnosis of CVSM in the equine patient remains challenging. Apart from a thorough orthopaedic and neurologic examination, plain radiographs and myelograms remain the only available tool for in vivo CVSM diagnostics. Even though histopathology is currently thought to be the most appropriate tool in CVSM diagnosis, it can only be carried out post-mortem. Our findings suggest the histological lesions in CVSM may differ between individuals and depend on the type of treatment, which limits ex-vivo diagnosis of the disease. In the described case, the histological analysis excluded the presence of a glial scar specific for CVSM. In addition, CD68(−) negative and TNF-α negative reactions were detected, which have not been reported previously. Furthermore, most CT or MRI devices are not available for cervical vertebral examinations due to size constraints. Hence, if only possible, in our opinion routine post-mortem histological and immunohistochemical analyses should be performed in horses euthanized due to CVSM for further examination of the disease.
Vet Agro, Lublin, Poland
Vetoquinol Biowet Sp. z o.o., Gorzow Wielkopolski, Poland
Warszawskie Zakłady Farmaceutyczne POLFA S.A., Warszawa, Poland
Vetoquinol Biowet Sp. z o.o., Gorzow Wielkopolski, Poland
Vet Agro, Lublin, Poland
Veterinary Pharmaceutical Industry, Ozzano Emilia, Italy
GE Healthcare, Little Chalfont, UK
MSz contributed to the study design and its execution, the data analysis and interpretation. MSz and AL contributed to the writing of the manuscript. AL was responsible for carrying out the histological study, data analysis and its interpretation. MS participated in the design of the study and its execution, in the sample collection and in the analysis and interpretation of data. AN, MJ, KM conceived the study, participated in its design and coordination and helped to draft the manuscript. All the authors were involved in a continuous discussion regarding the manuscript. All the authors read and approved the final version of the manuscript.
The research was financially supported by statutory research and development activity funds assigned to Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Wroclaw University of Environmental and Life.
Sciences -covering the costs of publication. The post mortem study (anatomical dissection, histopathologic and morphologic examination) has been executed at the Department of Animal Physiology and Biostructure, Wroclaw University of Environmental and Life Sciences -using the dissection room and laboratories including reagents and equipment.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
All husbandry and experimental procedures do not require acceptance of the Local Ethics Committee of Wroclaw University of Environmental and Life Sciences, Poland.
Consent for publication
The consent for publication and post mortem examination was obtained from the owner and do not require acceptance of the Local Ethics Committee.
Decision to euthanize the horse was made due to the lack of improvement in the horse’s movement and danger that the animal created (incoordination, spontaneous falling).
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
- 14.Johnson AL. How to Perform a Complete Neurologic Examination in the Field and Identify Abnormalities, AAEP Proceedings 2010. p. 331–37.Google Scholar
- 16.Kristoffersen M. Experiences with computed tomographic imaging of neck pathology. In: Proceedings of the European College of Veterinary Surgeons 2016.Google Scholar
- 19.Levine JM, Scrivani PV, Divers TJ, Furr M, Mayhew IJ, Reed S, Levine GJ, Foreman JH, Boudreau C, Credille BC, Tennent-Brown B, Cohen ND. Multicenter case-control study of signalement, diagnostic features, and outcome associated with cervical vertebral malformation-malarticulation in horses. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2010;237:812–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 20.RJ MK. Nervous System. Diagnostic Procedures. In: Auer JA, Stick JA, editors. Equine Surgery. St. Louis: Saunders Elsevier; 2006. p. 642–59.Google Scholar
- 21.Mayhew IG, De Lahunta A, Whitlock RH. Spinal cord diseases in the horse. Cornell Vet Suppl. 1978;6:11–207.Google Scholar
- 22.Mayhew J, Green SL. Radiographic Diagnosis Of Equine Cervical Vertebral Malformation. In: Proceedings of the 20th Meeting of the American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine. Dallas; 2002. p. 382–383.Google Scholar
- 23.Mayhew J. Neurologic examination. In: Mayhew J, editor. Large animal neurology. Iowa: Wiley Blackwell; 2009. p. 11–47.Google Scholar
- 24.Mayhew J. Multifactorial and idiopathic disorders. In: Mayhew J, editor. Large animal neurology. Iowa: Wiley Blackwell; 2009. p. 394–404.Google Scholar
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.