Implementing a customer relationship strategy: The asymmetric impact of poor versus excellent execution

  • Mark R. Colgate
  • Peter J. Danaher


The benefits of developing customer relationships are well established. However, a well-intentioned relationship marketing strategy may fail because of poor implementation. In this study, the authors look at the effects of implementing a customer relationship strategy. Specifically, they examine the implementation of a personal-banker strategy as a means to developing customer relationships in the retail banking industry. The authors show that an “excellent” personal banker can increase overall customer satisfaction and loyalty compared to customers who do not have a personal banker. However, a poorly performing personal banker can result in lower overall customer satisfaction and loyalty than if no personal banker had been available. Moreover, the effects seem to be asymmetric, with the negative effects of a poor relationship strategy exceeding the positive benefits ofan “excellent” strategy.


  1. Ahmed, Pervaiz K. and Mohammed Rafiq. 1995. “The Role of Internal Marketing in the Implementation of Marketing Strategies.”Journal of Applied Marketing Science 1 (4): 32–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Anderson, Eugene W. 1996. “Customer Satisfaction and Price Tolerance.”Marketing Letters 7 (3): 19–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. — and Mary W. Sullivan. 1993. “The Antecedents and Consequences of Customer Satisfaction for Firms.”Marketing Science 12 (Spring): 125–143.Google Scholar
  4. —, Claes Fornell, and Donald R. Lehmann. 1994. “Customer Satisfaction, Market Share, and Profitability: Findings From Sweden.”Journal of Marketing 58 (July): 53–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Anderson, James C. and James Narus. 1991. “A Partnering as a Focused Market Strategy.”California Management Review 33 (3): 95–113.Google Scholar
  6. Armstrong, J. Scott and Terry S. Overton. 1977. “Estimating Non-Response Bias in Mail Surveys.”Journal of Marketing Research 14 (3): 396–402.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Barnes, James G. 1997. “Closeness, Strength, and Satisfaction: Examining the Nature of Relationships Between Providers of Financial Services and Their Customers.”Psychology and Marketing 14 (8): 765–790.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Berry, Leonard L. 1995. “Relationship Marketing of Services—Growing Interest, Emerging Perspectives.”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 23 (4): 236–245.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Bitner, Mary Jo. 1995. “Building Service Relationships: It’s All About Promises.”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 23 (4): 246–251.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bolton, Ruth and James Drew. 1991. “A Multistage Model of Customers’ Assessment of Service Quality and Value.”Journal of Consumer Research 17 (March): 375–384.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Bonoma, Thomas V. 1985.The Marketing Edge: Making Strategies Work. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
  12. — and Victoria L. Crittenden. 1988. “Managing Marketing Implementation.”Sloan Management Review 29 (2): 7–14.Google Scholar
  13. Bring, Johan. 1994. “How to Standardize Regression Coefficients.”American Statistician 48 (August): 209–213.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Buttle, Francis. 1996. “Relationship Marketing.” InRelationship Marketing: Theory and Practice. Ed. Francis Buttle. New York: Paul Chapman, 1–16.Google Scholar
  15. Cespedes, Frank V. 1991.Organizing and Implementing the Marketing Effort. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.Google Scholar
  16. — 1993. “Coordinating Sales and Marketing in Consumer Goods Firms.”Journal of Consumer Marketing 10:37–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Colgate, Mark R. 1997. “Personal Bankers and Relationship Marketing: A New Zealand Case Study.”Journal of Financial Services Marketing 2 (1): 84–96.Google Scholar
  18. Cram, T. 1994.The Power of Relationship Marketing: Keeping Customers for Life. London: Pitman.Google Scholar
  19. Crosby, Lawrence A., Kenneth R. Evans, and Deborah Cowles. 1990. “Relationship Quality in Services Selling an Interpersonal Influence Perspective.”Journal of Marketing 54 (July): 68–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Czepiel, John A. 1990. “Service Encounters and Service Relationships: Implications for Research.”Journal of Business Research 20: 13–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Danaher, Peter J. 1997. “Using Conjoint Analysis to Determine the Relative Importance of Service Attributes Measured in Customer Satisfaction Surveys.”Journal of Retailing 73 (2): 235–260.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. — 1998. “Customer Heterogeneity in Service Management.”Journal of Service Research 1 (2): 129–139.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. — and Roland T. Rust. 1996. “Indirect Financial Benefits From Service Quality.”Quality Management Journal 3 (2): 63–75.Google Scholar
  24. DeSarbo, Wayne, Leonard Huff, Marcello Rolandelli, and Jaungwhan Choi. 1994. “On the Measurement of Perceived Service Quality: A Conjoint Measure Approach.” InService Quality: New Direction in Theory and Practice. Eds. Roland T. Rust and Richard Oliver. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 199–220.Google Scholar
  25. Devlin, Susan J., H. K. Dong, and Marbue Brown. 1993 “Selecting a Scale for Measuring Quality.”Marketing Research: A Magazine of Management and Applications 5 (3): 12–17.Google Scholar
  26. Fornell, Claes. 1992. “A National Customer Satifaction Barometer: The Swedish Experience.”Journal of Marketing 56 (January): 6–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Fournier, Susan, Susan Dobscha, and David Glen Mick. 1998. “Preventing the Premature Death of Relationship Marketing.”Harvard Business Review 76 (1): 42–44.Google Scholar
  28. Gordon, Mary E., Kim McKeage, and Mark A. Fox. 1998. “Relationship Marketing Effectiveness: The Role of Involvement.”Psychology and Marketing 15 (5): 443–459.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Gronroos, Christian. 1995. “Relationship Marketing: The Strategy Continuum.”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 23 (4): 252–254.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Gummesson, Evert. 1997 “Return on Relationships.” 5th International Colloquium on Relationship Marketing. Cranfield, UK.Google Scholar
  31. Gwinner Kevin P., Dwayne D. Gremler, and Mary Jo Bitner. 1998 “Relational Benefits in Services Industries: The Customer’s Perspective.”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 26 (2): 101–114.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Hair, Joseph F., Rolph E. Anderson, Ronald L. Tatham, and William C. Black. 1995.Multivariate Data Analysis: With Readings 4th ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
  33. Hakansson, Hakan and Ivan Senhota. 1995Developing Relationships in Business Networks. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  34. Inman, J. Jeffrey, James S. Dyer, and Jianmin Jia. 1997. “A Generalized Utility Model of Disappointment and Regret Effects on Post-Choice Valuation.”Marketing Science 16 (2): 97–111.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Jackson, Barbara B. 1985.Winning and Keeping Industrial Customers: The Dynamics of Customer Relationships. Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath.Google Scholar
  36. Meldrum, Michael. 1996. “Critical Issues in Implementing Marketing.”Journal of Marketing Practice: Applied Marketing Science 2 (3): 29–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Mittal, Vitas, William T. Ross, Jr., and Patrick M. Baldasare. 1998. “The Asymmetric Impact of Negative and Positive Attribute-Level Performance on Overall Satisfaction and Repurchase Intentions.”Journal of Marketing 62 (1): 33–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Payne, Adrian. 1994. “Relationship Marketing—Making the Consumer Count.”Managing Service Quality 4 (6): 29–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Payne, Christopher M. and David Ballantyne. 1991.Relationship Marketing. Oxford, UK: Butterworth-Heinemann.Google Scholar
  40. Peterson, Robert A. 1995. “Relationship Marketing and the Consumer.”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 23 (4): 278–281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Piercy, Nigel F. 1997.Market-Led Strategic Change: Transforming the Process of Going to Marketing. Oxford, UK: Butterworth-Heinemann.Google Scholar
  42. — 1998. “Marketing Implementation: The Implications of Marketing Paradigm Weakness for the Strategy Execution Process.”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 26 (3): 222–236.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Pine, B. Joseph II, Don Peppers, and Marta Rogers. 1995. “Do You Want to Keep Your Customers Forever?”Harvard Business Review 73 (2): 103–108.Google Scholar
  44. Reichheld, Frederick F. and W. Earl Sasser. 1990. “Zero Defections: Quality Comes to Services.”Harvard Business Review 68 (September–October): 105–111.Google Scholar
  45. Reid, David M. 1990. “Where Planning Fails in Practice.”Long Range Planning 23: 85–93.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Ricard, Line and Jean Perrien 1999. “Explaining and Evaluating the Implementation of Organizational Relationship Marketing in the Banking Industry: Client’s Perceptions.”Journal of Business Research 45: 199–209.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Rosenberg, Larry J. and John A. Czepiel. 1984. “A Marketing Approach to Customer Retention.”Journal of Consumer Marketing 1: 45–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Rueker, Robert W. and Orville C. Walker, Jr. 1987. “Marketing’s Interaction With Other Functional Units: A Conceptual Framework and Empirical Evidence.”Journal of Marketing 51 (January): 1–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Rust, Roland T., Anthony J. Zahorik, and Timothy L. Keiningham. 1994.Return on Quality; Measuring the Financial Impact of Your Company’s Quest for Quality. Chicago: Probus.Google Scholar
  50. —,— and —. 1995. “Return on Quality (ROQ): Marking Service Quality Financially Accountable.”Journal of Marketing 59 (April): 58–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Sashittal, Hemant C. and Clint Tankersley. 1997 “The Strategic Market Planning-Implementation Interface in Small and Midsized Industrial Firms: An Exploratory Study.”Journal of Marketing Theory & Practice 5 (3): 77–92.Google Scholar
  52. Shani, David and Sujana Chalasani. 1992. “Exploiting Niches Using Relationship Marketing.”Journal of Services Marketing 6 (4): 43–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Sheth, Jagdish N. and Atul Parvatiyar. 1995. “Relationship Marketing in Consumer Markets: Antecedents and Consequences.”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 23 (4): 255–271.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Slater, Stanley F. and John C. Narver. 1994.Market Orientated Isn’t Enough: Build a Learning Organization. Cambridge, MA: Marketing Science Institute.Google Scholar
  55. Stewart, Kate. 1998. “An Exploration of Customer Exit in Retail Banking.”International Journal of Bank Marketing 16 (1): 6–14.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Tjosvold, Dean, Lindsay Meredith, and Michael R. Wellwood. 1993. “Implementing Relationship Marketing: A Goal Interdependence Approach.”Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing 8 (4): 5–17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Varadarajan, P. Rajan and Satish Jayachandran. 1999. “Marketing Strategy: An Assessment of the State of the Field and Outlook.”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 27 (2): 120–143.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Walker, Orville C., Jr. and Robert W. Ruekert. 1987. “Marketing’s Role in the Implementation of Business Strategies: A Critical Review and Conceptual Framework.”Journal of Marketing. 51 (July): 15–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Webster, Frederick, Jr. 1994.Market Driven Management of Marketing. New York: John Wiley.Google Scholar
  60. Wilkinson, Ian and Louise Young. 1998. “On Competing: Firms, Relations and Networks.” InResearch Conference Proceedings: Relationship Marketing: Theory, Methods and Applications. Eds. Jagdish N. Sheth and Atul Parvatiyar. Atlanta, GA: Roberto C. Goizueta Business School, Emory University.Google Scholar
  61. Zeithaml, Valarie A., Leonard L. Berry, and A., Parasuraman. 1992. “Nature and Determinants of Customer Expectations of Service.”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 21 (1): 1–12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. —,—, and —. 1996. “The Behavioral Consequences of Service Quality.”Journal of Marketing 60 (April): 31–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Academy of Marketing Science 2000

Authors and Affiliations

  • Mark R. Colgate
    • 1
  • Peter J. Danaher
    • 1
  1. 1.University of AucklandNew Zealand

Personalised recommendations