Abstract
The concept of granitic melt fractionation as the main process in the concentration of rare elements in granites calls for the development of a reliable method to determine the evolutionary sequences of granite series. We propose to use for this purpose a zirconium-hafnium indicator, the Zr/Hf weight ratio in granitic rocks (Zaraisky et al., 1999, 2000). By the example of three classic regions of rare-metal deposits, eastern Transbaikalia, central Kazakhstan, and Erzgebirge (Czech Republic and Germany), it was empirically shown that the Zr/Hf ratio of granites decreases during the fractional crystallization of granite magmas in the sequence granodiorite → biotite granite → leucogranite → lithium-fluorine granite. The reason is the higher affinity of Hf compared with Zr to a granite melt. This implies that the crystallization and settling of accessory zircon will cause the progressive enrichment of Hf relative to Zr in the residual melt. As a result, the Zr/Hf ratio decreases regularly in the series of sequential phases of granite intrusion related to a single magma chamber from granodiorite to biotite granite, leucogranite, and Li-F granite (from 45-30 to 10-2). Our experimental investigations supported the preferential enrichment of haplogranite melt in Hf and zircon crystals in equilibrium with melt in Zr (T= 800°C and P = 1 kbar). The Zr/Hf indicator was tested by the example of the wellknown Kukulbei rare-metal granite complex of eastern Transbaikalia (J3), which is unique in the degree of fractionation of initial granite melt with the formation of three phases of granite emplacement and vein derivatives. An important feature of the complex is its “short” differentiation trend. It was supposed that the granite magma of the first phase is parental, and the later phases forming small intrusive bodies in large massifs of biotite granites of the first phase are sequential products of its crystallization differentiation in a magma chamber. The biotite granites of the first phase are barren. The leucocratic granites of the second phase are accompanied by tin-tungsten greisen deposits (e.g., Spokoininskoe), and the upper part of cupola-like stocks of Li-F amazonite granites of the third phase host apogranite-type tantalum deposits (Orlovka, Etyka, and Achikan). In addition to three granite phases, the Kukulbei complex includes dikes of ongonites, elvans, amazonite granites, and chamber miarolitic pegmatites. All of the granitic rocks of the complex have similar isotopic ages of 142± 0.6 Ma. The Zr/Hf ratio decreases systematically from phase 1 (40–25), to phase 2 (20–10), and phase 3 (10–2). The ongonites, elvans, and pegmatites have similar Zr/Hf ratios (15-5), falling between the ranges of leucocratic muscovite granites and Li-F granites. Compared with other granite series, the granitic rocks of the Kukulbei complex show specific petrographic and geochemical features: they are strongly enriched in Rb, Li, Cs, Be, Sn, W, Mo, Ta, Nb, Bi, and F but depleted in Mg, Ca, Fe, Ti, P, Sr, Ba, V, Co, Ni, Cr, Zr, REE, and Y. From the early to late intrusion phases, the degree of enrichment and depletion in these element groups increases regularly. This is accompanied by a significant decrease (from 40 to 2) in Zr/Hf, which can be used as a reliable indicator of genetic relations, degree of fractionation, and rare-metal potential of granites. Granites with Zr/Hf values lower than 25 are promising for prospecting for Sn, W, Mo, and Be greisen deposits, whereas the formation of Ta deposits requires Zr/Hf values lower than 10.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
A. M. Aksyuk, “Experimentally Established Geofluorimeters and the Fluorine Regime in Granite-Related Fluids,” Petrologiya 10, 630–644 (2002) [Petrology 10, 557–569 (2002)].
I. V. Aleksandrov, Geochemistry of Trace and Ore Elements in Granitoids (Nauka, Moscow, 1980) [in Russian].
E. V. Barbashev and N. A. Trushchova, State Geological Map of the USSR on the Scale 1: 200000. Eastern Transbaikalia Series. Quadrangle M-50-VII (Aginskoe) (Aerogeologiya, Moscow, 1974) [in Russian].
S. M. Beskin, V. N. Larin, and Yu. B. Marin, Rare-Metal Granite Associations (Nedra, Leningrad, 1979) [in Russian].
S. M. Beskin, A. M. Grebennikov, and V. V. Matias, “Khangilai Granite Pluton and the Related Orlovka Tantalum Deposit in Transbaikalia,” Petrologiya 2(1), 68–87 (1994a).
S. M. Beskin, V. E. Zagorskii, L. G. Kuznetsova, et al., “Etyka Rare-Metal Ore Field in Eastern Transbaikalia (Eastern Siberia),” Geol. Rudn. Mestorozhd. 36(4), 310–325 (1994b).
A. A. Beus and A. A. Sitnin, “Geochemical Features of the Granitoids of the Kukulbei Intrusive Complex in Eastern Transbaikalia,” Sov. Geol., No. 9, 105–107 (1967).
A. A. Beus, E. A. Severov, A. A. Sitnin, and K. D. Subbotin, Albitized and Greisenized Granites (Apogranites) (Akad. Nauk SSSR, Moscow, 1962) [in Russian].
L. S. Borodin and L. N. Ginzburg, “Geochemistry of Peraluminous Rare-Metal Leucogranites: Evolutionary Petrochemical Trend and Correlation between Trace Elements,” Geokhimiya, No. 9, 933–945 (2002) [Geochem. Int. 40, 843–854 (2002)].
V. Yu. Chevychelov, G. P. Zaraisky, S. E. Borisovskii, and D. A. Borkov, “Effect of Melt Composition and Temperature on the Partitioning of Ta, Nb, Mn, and F between Granitic (Alkaline) Melt and Fluorine-Bearing Aqueous Fluid: Fractionation of Ta and Nb and Conditions of Ore Formation in Rare-Metal Granites,” Petrologiya 13, 339–357 (2005) [Petrology 13, 305–321 (2005)].
V. F. Efimov, Yu. I. Filippova, N. A. Akelin, et al., Criteria of Forecasting, Prospecting, and Assessment of Mineral Deposits in Rare-Metal Granites of the Calc-Alkaline Series (Methodical Recommendations) (IMGRE, Moscow, 1992) [in Russian].
B. A. Gaivoronskii, “Bukuka Deposit,” in Deposits of Transbaikalia (Geoinformmark, Chita and Moscow, 1995), Vol. 1, Book 1, pp. 146–148 [in Russian].
T. I. Getmanskaya and B. S. Chernov, Tin-Tungsten Association. Formation Conditions and Prospecting Criteria for Economic Tungsten Deposits in Transbaikalia (VIMS, Moscow, 1976) [in Russian].
A. M. Grebennikov, “Spokoininskoe Tungsten Deposits,” in Deposits of Transbaikalia (Geoinformmark, Chita and Moscow, 1995a), Vol. 1, Book 1, pp. 106–116 [in Russian].
A. M. Grebennikov, “Orlovka Tantalium Deposit” in Deposits of Transbaikalia (Geoinformmark, Chita and Moscow, 1995b), Vol. 1, Book 2, pp. 96–107 [in Russian].
V. N. Koreneva (Devyatova) and G. P. Zaraisky, “Experimental Study of the Solubility of Hafnium-Rich Zircons in F-Bearing Granite Melts,” in Proceedings of Conference on the Geochemistry of Magmatic Rocks, Apatity, Russia, 2003 (Kol’skii NTs RAN, Apatity, 2003), pp. 80–82 [in Russian].
Yu. A. Kostitsyn, G. P. Zaraiskii, A. M. Aksyuk, and V. Yu. Chevychelov, “Rb-Sr Evidence for the Genetic Links between Biotite and Li-F Granites: An Example of the Spokoinoe, Orlovka, and Etyka Deposits, Eastern Transbaikalia,” Geokhimiya, No. 9, 940–948 (2004) [Geochem. Int. 42, 822–829 (2004)].
P. V. Koval’, Petrology and Geochemistry of Albitized Granites (Nauka, Novosibirsk, 1975) [in Russian].
P. V. Koval’, Regional Geochemical Analysis of Granitoids (SO RAN NITs OIGGM, Novosibirsk, 1998) [in Russian].
V. I. Kovalenko, Petrology and Geochemistry of Rare-Metal Granitoids (Nauka, Novosibirsk, 1977) [in Russian].
V. I. Kovalenko, Yu. A. Kostitsyn, V. V. Yarmolyuk, et al., “Magma Sources and the Isotopic (Sr and Nd) Evolution of Li-F Rare-Metal Granites,” Petrologiya 7, 401–429 (1999) [Petrology 7, 383–409 (1999)].
V. I. Kovalenko, V. V. Yarmolyuk, N. V. Vladykin, et al., “Epochs of Formation, Geodynamic Setting, and Sources of Rare-Metal Magmatism in Central Asia,” Petrologiya 10, 227–353 (2002) [Petrology 10, 199–221 (2002)].
V. D. Kozlov and L. N. Svadkovskaya, Petrochemistry, Geochemistry, and Ore Potential of Granitoids in Central Transbaikalia (Nauka, Novosibirsk, 1977) [in Russian].
O. D. Levitskii, Geology of Ore Deposits of Transbaikalia (Nauka, Moscow, 1964) [in Russian].
O. D. Levitskii, V. V. Aristov, R. M. Konstantinov, and E. A. Stankeev, Etyka Tin Deposits of Eastern Transbaikalia (Akad. Nauk SSSR, Moscow, 1963) [in Russian].
R. L. Linnen, “The Solubility of Nb-Ta-Zr-Hf-W in Granitic Melt with Li and Li + F: Constrains for Mineralization in Rare Metal Granite and Pegmatite,” Econ. Geol. 93, 1013–1025 (1998).
E. N. Lishnevskii and S. M. Beskin, “Volume Structure and Spatial Position of Tin and Rare Metal Districts,” in Deep-Seated Conditions of Endogenic Ore Formation (Nauka, Moscow, 1986), pp. 60–75 [in Russian].
D. A. C. Manning, “The Effect of Fluorine on Liquidus Phase Relationship in the System Qz-Ab-Or with Excess Water at 1 kb,” Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 76, 206–215 (1981).
E. V. Negrei, A. Z. Zhuravlev, V. I. Kovalenko, et al., “Isotopic (Rb-Sr, δ18O) Studies of a Dome of Ta-Bearing Li-F Granites,” Dokl. Akad. Nauk 342, 322–325 (1995).
L. Raimbault, M. Cuney, C. Azencott, et al., “Geochemical Evidence for a Multistage Magmatic Genesis of Ta-Sn-Li Mineralization in the Granite at Beauvoir, French Massif Central,” Econ. Geol. 90, 548–576 (1995).
F. G. Reyf, R. Seltmann, and G. P. Zaraisky, “The Role of Magmatic Processes in Formation of Banded Li, Fenriched granites from the Orlovka Tantalum Deposit, Transbaikalia, Russia: Microthermometric Evidenne,” Can. Mineral. 38, 915–936 (2000).
I. G. Rutshtein, G. I. Bogach, and E. L. Vinnichenko, State Geological Map of Russian Federation at the Scale 1: 200000. Priargunskaya Series. Quadrangle M-50-IX (Kalangui) (VSEGEI, St. Petersburg, 2001) [in Russian].
L. F. Syritso, Mesozoic Granitoids of Eastern Transbaikalia and Problems of Rare-Metal Ore Formation (SPbU, St. Petersburg, 2002) [in Russian].
L. V. Tauson, Geochemical Types and Ore Potential of Granitoids (Nauka, Moscow, 1977) [in Russian].
L. V. Tauson, G. M. Gundobin, and L. D. Zorina, Geochemical Fields of Magmatic Ore Systems (Nauka SO, Novosibirsk, 1987) [in Russian].
S. R. Taylor and S. M. McLennan, The Continental Crust: Its Composition and Evolution (Blackwell, Oxford, 1985; Mir, Moscow, 1988).
Yu. P. Troshin, “Petrochemical Features of the Basic-Intermediate Magmatic Rocks Which are Associated with Rare-Metal Plumasitic Granites,” in Petrochemistry, Genesis, and Ore Potential of the Magmatic Complexes of Siberia (Nauka, Novosibirsk, 1985), pp. 216–225 [in Russian].
Yu. P. Troshin, V. I. Grebenshchikova, and S. M. Boiko, Geochemistry and Petrology of Rare-Metal Plumasitic Granites (Nauka, Novosibirsk, 1983) [in Russian].
N. A. Trushcheva and K. K. Anashkina, State Geological Map of the USSR at the Scale 1: 200000. Eastern Transbaikalia Series. Quadrangles M-50-XV and XXI (Borzya, Dauria) (Aaerogeologiya, Moscow, 1981) [in Russian].
G. P. Zaraisky, “Formation Conditions of Rare-Metal Deposits Related to Granitoid Magmatism,” in Smirnov Volume 2004 (Smirnov Foundation, Moscow, 2004), pp. 105–192 [in Russian].
G. P. Zaraisky, “Problems of Formation of Tantalum Deposits in the Domes of Li-F Granites and Evidence from Experimental Data,” in Applied Geochemistry. Genetic Types of Deposits (IMGRE, Moscow, 2005), Vol. 7, Book 2, pp. 144–161 [in Russian].
G. P. Zaraisky, “Origin of Rare-Metal Granites in the Areas of Postorogenic Activation of Central Kazakhstan and Eastern Transbaikalia,” in Proceedings of International Scientific Conference on the Geodynamics of the Formation of Mobile Belts on Earth (Inst. Geol. Geokhim. UrO RAN, Yekaterinburg, 2007), pp. 104–108 [in Russian].
G. P. Zaraisky and A. M. Aksyuk, “Petrogenesis of Rare-Metal Calc-Alkaline Granites,” in Proceedings of 10th All-Russia Petrographic Conference. Petrography of the 21th Century. Petrology and Ore Potential of CIS Regions and the Baltic Shield, Apatity, Russia, 2005 (Apatity, 2005), pp. 93–95 [in Russian].
G. P. Zaraisky, A. M. Aksyuk, Yu. B. Shapovalov, et al., “Petrography and Geochemistry of Li-F Granites and Pegmatite-Aplite Banded Rocks from the Orlovka and Etyka Tantalum Deposits in Eastern Transbaikalia, Russia,” in Proceedings of 4th SGA Meeting. Mineral Deposits: Research and Exploration. Where do They Meet? (Balkema, Rotterdam, 1997), pp. 695–698.
G. P. Zaraisky, A. M. Aksyuk, and R. Seltmann, “Zr/Hf Ratio as an Indicator of the Differentiation of Rare-Metal Granites,” in Problems of Magmatic and Metamorphic Petrology (MGGA, Moscow, 1999), p. 15 [in Russian].
G. P. Zaraisky, A. M. Aksyuk, R. Seltmann, and A. V. Fed’kin, “Evolution of Rare-Metal Granites and Zr/Hf Ratio as an Indicator of the Degree of Their Crystallization Differentiation,” in Proceedings of 2nd All-Russia Petrographic Conference: Petrography at the Beginning of the 21th Century. Results and Prospects (Syktyvkar, 2000), Vol. 3, pp. 47–50 [in Russian].
G. P. Zaraisky, V. S. Korzhinskaya, and N. P. Kotova, “The Problem of Hydrothermal Transport of Tantalum and Niobium in ‘Apogranites’ on Experimental Data,” in 12th Quadrennial IAGOD Symposium. Understanding the Genesis of Ore Deposits to Meet the Demands of the 21st Century, 2006, Moscow (Moscow, 2006), CD-043.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Zaraisky, G.P., Aksyuk, A.M., Devyatova, V.N. et al. Zr/Hf ratio as an indicator of fractionation of rare-metal granites by the example of the Kukulbei complex, eastern Transbaikalia. Petrology 16, 710–736 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1134/S0869591108070047
Received:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1134/S0869591108070047