Measuring pain as the 5th vital sign does not improve quality of pain management
BACKGROUND: To improve pain management, the Veterans Health Administration launched the “Pain as the 5th Vital Sign” initiative in 1999, requiring a pain intensity rating (0 to 10) at all clinical encounters.
OBJECTIVE: To measure the initiative’s impact on the quality of pain management.
DESIGN: We retrospectively reviewed medical records at a single medical center to compare providers’ pain management before and after implementing the initiative and performed a subgroup analysis of patients reporting substantial pain (≥4) during a postimplementation visit.
PARTICIPANTS: Unique patient visits selected from all 15 primary care providers of a general medicine outpatient clinic.
MEASUREMENTS: We used 7 process indicators of quality pain management, based on appropriately evaluating and treating pain, to assess 300 randomly selected visits before and 300 visits after implementing the pain initiative.
RESULTS: The quality of pain care was unchanged between visits before and after the pain initiative (P>.05 for all comparisons): subjective provider assessment (49.3% before, 48.7% after), pain exam (26.3%, 26.0%), orders to assess pain (11.7%, 8.3%), new analgesic (8.7%, 11.0%), change in existing analgesics (6.7%, 4.3%), other pain treatment (11.7%, 13.7%), or follow-up plans (10.0%, 8.7%). Patients (n=79) who reported substantial pain often did not receive recommended care: 22% had no attention to pain documented in the medical record, 27% had no further assessment documented, and 52% received no new therapy for pain at that visit.
CONCLUSIONS: Routinely measuring pain by the 5th vital sign did not increase the quality of pain management. Patients with substantial pain documented by the 5th vital sign often had inadequate pain management.
Key wordspain quality of health care outcome and process assessment (health care) pain measurement quality indicators
- 1.Kirsch B, Berdine H, Zablotsky D, et al. Management strategy: identifying pain as the fifth vital sign. VHSJ. 2000;49–59.Google Scholar
- 2.Health Care Advisory Board. Pain Management in the VA and the Private Sector. Washington, DC: The Advisory Board Company; 1998.Google Scholar
- 3.Jacox A, Carr DB, Payne R, et al. Management of Cancer Pain. Clinical Practice Guideline No.9. AHCPR Publication No. 94-0592. Rockville, MD. Agency for Health Care Policy and Research, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Public Health Service, March 1994.Google Scholar
- 5.American Pain Society. Principles of Analgesic Use in the Treatment of Acute Pain and Cancer Pain. 4th edn. Glenview, IL: American Pain Society; 1999.Google Scholar
- 6.Veterans Health Administration National Pain Management Strategy. November 12, 1998.Google Scholar
- 7.Department of Veterans Affairs. VHA Directive 2003-021: Pain Management. May 2, 2003. Available at: http://www1.va.gov/pain_management/docs/VHAPainDirective_03.pdf. Accessed January 2005.Google Scholar
- 8.Veterans Health Administration Memorandum: Pain as the Fifth Vital Sign. March 1, 1999.Google Scholar
- 9.Veterans Health Administration. Pain as the 5th vital sign toolkit. October 2000, revised edition. Geriatrics and Extended Care Strategic Healthcare Group, National Pain Management Coordinating Committee. Available at: http://www.va.gov/oaa/pocketcard/pain.asp. Accessed January 2005.Google Scholar
- 11.JCAHO. Pain Assessment and Management Standards [online]. Available at: www.jcaho.org/standard/pm. Accessed July 16, 2002.Google Scholar
- 12.Doyle D, Hanks GWG, MacDonald N, eds. Oxford Textbook of Palliative Medicine. 2nd edn. Oxford, U.K.: Oxford University Press; 1998.Google Scholar
- 13.Hintze J. PASS User’s Guide. Kaysville, UT: NCSS; 2000.Google Scholar
- 15.Oxman AD, Thomson MA, Davis DA, Haynes RB. No magic bullets: a systematic review of 102 trials of interventions to improve professional practice. Can Med Assoc J. 1995;153:1423–31.Google Scholar
- 20.Opioid therapy for chronic pain—clinical practice guidelines. Available at: http://www.oqp.med.va.gov/cpg/cot/ot_base.htm. Accessed January 23, 2005.Google Scholar
- 21.Department of Veterans Affairs. VHA Pain Outcomes Toolkit. February 2003. National VA Pain Outcomes Working Group, National VA Pain Management Coordinating Committee.Google Scholar
- 22.Craine M, Kerns RD. Pain management improvement strategies in the Veteran’s Health Administration. APS Bull. 2003;13 Available at: http://www.ampainsoc.org/pub/bulletin/sep03/articlel.htm. Accessed February 22, 2005.Google Scholar
- 24.Kerr EA, Gerzoff RB, Krein SL, et al. Diabetes care quality in the Veterans Affairs Health Care System and commercial managed care: the TRIAD study. Ann Intern Med. 2004;17, 141:272–81.Google Scholar