Abstract
In many liberal democracies today, foreign policy is the subject of increasing political contestation. Recent studies have demonstrated that political parties cluster predictably when voting on military deployments. In the economic left/right dimension, support for military deployments is highest for centrist and centre-right parties, and decreases towards the (far) left and (far) right. This pattern is not as robust in the non-economic GAL/TAN dimension, which pits parties with green, alternative and libertarian (GAL) values against those with traditional, authoritarian and nationalist ones (TAN). This article addresses the dimensionality of foreign and security policy by analysing 57 votes on military deployments in the Dutch parliament between 1998 and 2019. The results show that even in the Netherlands, where the GAL/TAN dimension is most likely to explain party–political contestation, foreign and security policy remains more attuned to the left/right cleavage. These findings contribute to analyses of party–political contestation in other Western European democracies.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Andeweg, Rudy B., Galen A. Irwin, and Tom Louwerse. 2020. Governance and Politics of the Netherlands, 5th ed. London: Red Globe Press.
Arena, Philip, and Glenn Palmer. 2009. Politics or the Economy? Domestic Correlates of Dispute Involvement in Developed Democracies. International Studies Quarterly 53 (4): 955–975.
Auerswald, David, Philippe Lagassé, and Stephen M. Saideman. 2023. Some Assembly Required: Explaining Variation in Legislative Oversight over the Armed Forces. Foreign Policy Analysis 19 (1): orac034.
Balfour, Rosa, Janis A. Emmanouilidis, Catherine Fieschi, Heather Grabbe, Christopher Hill, Timo Lochocki, Marie Mendras, Cas Mudde, Marie K. Niemi, Juliane Schmidt, and Corina Stratulat. 2016. Europe’s Troublemakers: The Populist Challenge to Foreign Policy. Brussels: European Policy Centre.
Beasley, Ryan K., and Juliet Kaarbo. 2014. Explaining Extremity in the Foreign Policies of Parliamentary Democracies. International Studies Quarterly 58 (4): 729–740.
Bertoli, Andrew, Allan Dafoe, and Robert F. Trager. 2019. Is There a War Party? Party Change, the Left-Right Divide, and International Conflict. Journal of Conflict Resolution 63 (4): 950–975.
Bjereld, Ulf, and Marie Demker. 2000. Foreign Policy as Battlefield: A Study of National Interest and Party Motives. Scandinavian Political Studies 23 (1): 17–36.
Böller, Florian. 2022. Vandenberg Vanished: US Congress and the Politicisation of Military Interventions. Parliamentary Affairs 75 (3): 676–696.
Cicchi, Lorenzo, Diego Garzia, and Alexander H. Trechsel. 2020. Mapping Parties’ Positions on Foreign and Security Issues in the EU, 2009–2014. Foreign Policy Analysis 16 (4): 532–546.
Clare, Joe. 2010. Ideological Fractionalization and the International Conflict Behavior of Parliamentary Democracies. International Studies Quarterly 54 (4): 965–987.
Coticchia, Fabrizio, and Francesco N. Moro. 2020. Peaceful Legislatures? Parliaments and Military Interventions after the Cold War: Insights from Germany and Italy. International Relations 34 (4): 482–503.
Coticchia, Fabrizio, and Valerio Vignoli. 2020. Italian Political Parties and Military Operations: An Empirical Analysis on Voting Patterns. Government and Opposition 55 (3): 456–473.
Vries, De., and E. Catherine. 2018. The Cosmopolitan-Parochial Divide: Changing Patterns of Party and Electoral Competition in the Netherlands and Beyond. Journal of European Public Policy 25 (11): 1541–1565.
Vries, De., E. Catherine, Armen Hakhverdian, and Bram Lancee. 2013. The Dynamics of Voters’ Left/Right Identification: The Role of Economic and Cultural Attitudes. Political Science Research and Methods 1 (2): 223–238.
Dieterich, Sandra, Hartwig Hummel and Stefan Marschall (2008), Strengthening Parliamentary “War Powers” in Europe: Lessons from 25 National Parliaments. Policy paper 27, Geneva Centre for the Democratic Control of Armed Forces, 1–25.
Dieterich, Sandra, Hartwig Hummel, and Stefan Marschall. 2015. Bringing Democracy Back In: The Democratic Peace, Parliamentary War Powers and European Participation in the 2003 Iraq War. Cooperation and Conflict 50 (1): 87–106.
Farrell, David M. 2011. Electoral Systems: A Comparative Introduction, 2nd ed. London: Red Globe Press.
Fermann, Gunnar, and Per Marius Frost-Nielsen. 2019. Conceptualizing Caveats for Political Research: Defining and Measuring National Reservations on the Use of Force during Multinational Military Operations. Contemporary Security Policy 40 (1): 56–69.
Fonck, Daan, and Yf. Reykers. 2018. Parliamentarisation as a Two-Way Process: Explaining Prior Parliamentary Consultation for Military Interventions. Parliamentary Affairs 71 (3): 674–696.
Daan, Fonck, Tim Haesebrouck, and Yf. Reykers. 2019. Parliamentary Involvement, Party Ideology and Majority-Opposition Bargaining: Belgian Participation in Multinational Military Operations. Contemporary Security Policy 40 (1): 85–100.
Frost-Nielsen, Per Marius. 2017. Conditional Commitments: Why States Use Caveats to Reserve Their Efforts in Military Coalition Operations. Contemporary Security Policy 38 (3): 371–397.
Gowa, Joanne. 1998. Politics at the Water’s Edge: Parties, Voters, and the Use of Force Abroad. International Organization 52 (2): 307–324.
Greene, Toby. 2022. Fitting National Interests with Populist Opportunities: Intervention Politics on the European Radical Right. International Relations. https://doi.org/10.1177/00471178221112480.
Haesebrouck, Tim, and Patrick A. Mello. 2020. Patterns of Political Ideology and Security Policy. Foreign Policy Analysis 16 (4): 565–586.
Haesebrouck, Tim, Yf. Reykers, and Daan Fonck. 2022. Party Politics and Military Deployments: Explaining Political Consensus on Belgian Military Intervention. European Security 31 (1): 76–96.
Hix, Simon, Abdul Noury, and Gérard. Roland. 2005. Power to the Parties: Cohesion and Competition in the European Parliament, 1979–2001. British Journal of Political Science 35 (2): 209–234.
Hofmann, Stephanie C., and Benjamin Martill. 2021. The Party Scene: New Directions for Political Party Research in Foreign Policy Analysis. International Affairs 97 (2): 305–322.
Hooghe, Liesbet, Gary Marks, and Carole J. Wilson. 2002. Does Left/Right Structure Party Positions on European Integration? Comparative Political Studies 35 (8): 965–989.
Incerti, Trevor, Daniel Mattingly, Frances Rosenbluth, Seiki Tanaka, and Jiahua Yue. 2021. Hawkish Partisans: How Political Parties Shape Nationalist Conflicts in China and Japan. British Journal of Political Science 51 (4): 1494–1515.
Jeong, Gyung-Ho., and Paul J. Quirk. 2019. Division at the Water’s Edge: The Polarization of Foreign Policy. American Politics Research 47 (1): 58–87.
Jolly, Seth, Ryan Bakker, Liesbet Hooghe, Gary Marks, Jonathan Polk, Jan Rovny, Marco Steenbergen, and Milada Anna Vachudova (2022), Chapel Hill Expert Survey Trend File, 1999–2019. Electoral Studies 75.
Joly, Jeroen, and Régis. Dandoy. 2018. Beyond the Water’s Edge: How Political Parties Influence Foreign Policy Formulation in Belgium. Foreign Policy Analysis 14 (4): 512–535.
Kaarbo, Juliet. 2008. Coalition Cabinet Decision Making: Institutional and Psychological Factors. International Studies Review 10 (1): 57–86.
Kaarbo, Juliet. 2015. A Foreign Policy Analysis Perspective on the Domestic Turn in IR Theory. International Studies Review 17 (2): 189–216.
Kesgin, Baris. 2020. Features of Foreign Policy Birds: Israeli Prime Ministers as Hawks and Doves. Cooperation and Conflict 55 (1): 107–126.
Kiratli, Osman Sabri. 2021. Where Do Hawks and Doves Fly When Shots Are Fired? Party Politics 27 (6): 1172–1183.
Kreps, Sarah E. 2010. Elite Consensus as a Determinant of Alliance Cohesion: Why Public Opinion Hardly Matters for NATO-led Operations in Afghanistan. Foreign Policy Analysis 6 (3): 191–215.
Kriesi, Hanspeter, Edgar Grande, Romain Lachat, Martin Dolezal, Simon Bornschier, and Timotheos Frey. 2006. Globalization and the Transformation of the National Political Space: Six European Countries Compared. European Journal of Political Research 45 (6): 921–956.
Kristic, Anamarija (2012), De Staten-Generaal en de Inzet van de Nederlandse Krijgsmacht: Een Onderzoek naar de Parlementaire Betrokkenheid bij de Besluitvorming over Deelname aan Internationale Militaire Operaties. PhD dissertation, Deventer: Kluwer.
Krouwel, André, and Paul Lucardie. 2008. Waiting in the Wings: New Parties in the Netherlands. Acta Politica 43 (2): 278–307.
Louwerse, Tom, and Simon Otjes. 2019. How Populists Wage Opposition: Parliamentary Opposition Behaviour and Populism in the Netherlands. Political Studies 67 (2): 479–495.
Louwerse, Tom, Simon Otjes, and Cynthia van Vonno. 2017. The Dutch Parliamentary Behaviour Dataset. Acta Politica 53 (1): 149–166.
Lubbers, Marcel, Simon Otjes, and Niels Spierings. 2023. What Drives the Propensity to Vote for Ethnic-Minority-Interest Parties? Acta Politica. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41269-023-00309-3.
Manning, Bayless. 1977. The Congress, the Executive and Intermestic Affairs: Three Proposals. Foreign Affairs 55 (2): 306–324.
Marks, Gary, Liesbet Hooghe, Moira Nelson, and Erica Edwards. 2006. Party Competition and European Integration in the East and West: Different Structure. Same Causality. Comparative Political Studies 39 (2): 155–175.
Mello, Patrick A. 2012. Parliamentary Peace or Partisan Politics? Democracies’ Participation in the Iraq War. Journal of International Relations and Development 15 (3): 420–453.
Mudde, Cas. 2007. Populist Radical Right Parties in Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mügge, Liza, Maria Kranendonk, Floris Vermeulen, and Nermin Aydemir. 2021. Migrant Votes ‘Here’ and ‘There’: Transnational Electoral Behavior of Turks in the Netherlands. Migration Studies 9 (3): 400–422.
Oktay, Sibel. 2018. Chamber of Opportunities: Legislative Politics and Coalition Security Policy. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations 20 (1): 104–120.
Oktay, Sibel. 2022. Governing Abroad. Coalition Politics and Foreign Policy in Europe. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Onuki, Janina, Pedro Feliú Ribeiro, Amâncio. Jorge, and de Oliveira,. 2009. Political Parties, Foreign Policy, and Ideology: Argentina and Chile in Comparative Perspective. Brazilian Political Science Review 3 (2): 127–154.
Ostermann, Falk, and Bernhard Stahl. 2022. Theorizing Populist Radical-Right Foreign Policy: Ideology and Party Positioning in France and Germany. Foreign Policy Analysis 18 (3): orac006.
Ostermann, Falk, and Wolfgang Wagner. 2023. Introducing the Parliamentary Deployment Votes Database. Journal of Peace Research. https://doi.org/10.1177/00223433221116655.
Palmer, Glenn, Tamar London, and Patrick Regan. 2004. What’s Stopping You? The Sources of Political Constraints on International Conflict Behavior in Parliamentary Democracies. International Interactions 30 (1): 1–24.
Pellikaan, Huib, Sarah L. de Lange, and Tom van der Meer. 2007. Fortuyn’s Legacy: Party System Change in the Netherlands. Comparative European Politics 5 (3): 282–302.
Pellikaan, Huib, Sarah L. de Lange, and Tom van der Meer. 2018. The Centre Does Not Hold: Coalition Politics and Party System Change in the Netherlands, 2002–12. Government and Opposition 53 (2): 231–255.
Pennings, Paul, and Hans Keman. 2008. The Changing Landscape of Dutch Politics Since the 1970s: A Comparative Exploration. Acta Politica 43 (2): 154–179.
Peters, Dirk, and Wolfgang Wagner. 2011. Between Military Efficiency and Democratic Legitimacy: Mapping Parliamentary War Powers in Contemporary Democracies, 1989–2004. Parliamentary Affairs 64 (1): 175–192.
Peters, Dirk, and Wolfgang Wagner. 2014. Executive Privilege or Parliamentary Proviso? Exploring the Sources of Parliamentary War Powers. Armed Forces and Society 40 (2): 310–331.
Rathbun, Brian. 2004. Partisan Interventions: European Party Politics and Peace Enforcement in the Balkans. London: Cornell University Press.
Raunio, Tapio, and Wolfgang Wagner. 2017. Towards Parliamentarisation of Foreign and Security Policy? West European Politics 40 (1): 1–19.
Raunio, Tapio, and Wolfgang Wagner. 2020a. The Party Politics of Foreign and Security Policy. Foreign Policy Analysis 16 (4): 515–531.
Raunio, Tapio, and Wolfgang Wagner. 2020b. Contestation over Development Policy in the European Parliament. Journal of Common Market Studies 59 (1): 20–36.
Saideman, Stephen M., and David P. Auerswald. 2012. Comparing Caveats: Understanding the Sources of National Restrictions upon NATO’s Mission in Afghanistan. International Studies Quarterly 56 (1): 67–84.
Schultz, Kenneth. 2013. Domestic Politics in International Relations. In Handbook of International Relations, 2nd ed., ed. Walter Carlsnaes, Thomas Risse, and Beth A. Simmons, 478–502. London: Sage Publishers.
Schultz, Kenneth A. 2005. The Politics of Risking Peace: Do Hawks or Doves Deliver the Olive Branch? International Organization 59 (1): 1–38.
Schuster, Jürgen., and Herbert Maier. 2006. The Rift: Explaining Europe’s Divergent Iraq Policies in the Run-Up of the American-led War on Iraq. Foreign Policy Analysis 2 (3): 223–244.
Verbeek, Bertjan, and Andrej Zaslove. 2015. The Impact of Populist Radical Right Parties on Foreign Policy: The Northern League as a Junior Coalition Partner in the Berlusconi Governments. European Political Science Review 7 (4): 525–546.
Verbeek, Bertjan, and Andrej Zaslove. 2017. Populism and Foreign Policy. In The Oxford Handbook of Populism, ed. Cristóbal Rovira. Kaltwasser, Paul A. Taggart, Paulina Ochoa Espejo, and Pierre Ostiguy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Verbeek, Bertjan, and Anna van der Vleuten. 2008. The Domesticization of the Foreign Policy of the Netherlands (1989–2007): The Paradoxical Result of Europeanization and Internationalization. Acta Politica 43 (2–3): 357–377.
Vermeulen, Floris, Eelco Harteveld, Anja van Heelsum, and Aad van der Veen. 2020. The Potential of Immigrant Parties: Insights from the Dutch Case. Acta Politica 55 (3): 432–453.
Vignoli, Valerio. 2019. Where Are the Doves? Explaining Party Support for Military Operations Abroad in Italy. West European Politics 43 (7): 1455–1479.
Vignoli, Valerio. 2021. The Barking Dogs: Junior Coalition Partners and Military Operations Abroad in Italy. Italian Political Science Review/rivista Di Scienza Politica 51 (1): 25–41.
Wagner, Wolfgang. 2020. The Democratic Politics of Military Interventions: Political Parties, Contestation, and Decisions to Use Force Abroad. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Wagner, Wolfgang, Anna Herranz-Surrallés, Juliet Kaarbo, and Falk Ostermann (2017), Politicization, Party Politics and Military Missions: Deployment Votes in France, Germany, Spain, and the United Kingdom. Discussion paper SP IV 2016–111, WZB Berlin Social Science Centre.
Wagner, Wolfgang, Anna Herranz-Surrallés, Juliet Kaarbo, and Falk Ostermann. 2018. Party Politics at the Water’s Edge: Contestation of Military Operations in Europe. European Political Science Review 10 (4): 537–563.
Wheeler, Nicholas J. 2000. Saving Strangers. Humanitarian Intervention in International Society. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
On behalf of all authors, the corresponding author states that there is no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Appendices
Appendix
Appendix 1
List of Dutch political parties and scores on left/right and GAL/TAN.
Full name | Acronym | Years in parliament* | Votes participated | Left/right** | GAL/TAN** |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
50PLUS | 50PLUS | 2012–2019 | 20 | 5.17 | 4.97 |
Christian Democratic Appeal | CDA | 1998–2019 | 57 | 6.22 | 6.84 |
Christian Union | CU | 2000–2019 | 55 | 5.70 | 8.09 |
Democrats 66 | D66 | 1998–2019 | 57 | 4.86 | 1.69 |
DENK | DENK | 2017–2019 | 6 | 4.36 | 7.55 |
Forum for Democracy | FvD | 2017–2019 | 6 | 9.54 | 8.33 |
GreenLeft | GL | 1998–2019 | 57 | 2.42 | 1.59 |
Reformed Political League | GVP | 1998–2000 | 2 | 6.70 | 8.64 |
Liveable Netherlands | LN | 2 | Not scored | Not scored | |
List Pim Fortuyn | LPF | 16 | 8.38 | 5.44 | |
Reformatory Political Federation | RPF | 2 | 6.80 | 8.55 | |
Labour Party | PvdA | 1998–2019 | 57 | 3.78 | 3.44 |
Party for the Animals | PvdD | 2006–2019 | 39 | 2.88 | 3.02 |
Party for Freedom | PVV | 2006–2019 | 39 | 8.84 | 7.18 |
Reformed Political Party | SGP | 1998–2019 | 57 | 8.03 | 9.48 |
Socialist Party | SP | 1998–2019 | 57 | 1.40 | 4.53 |
People’s Party for Freedom and Democracy | VVD | 1998–2019 | 57 | 7.52 | 5.08 |
Appendix 2
List of deployment votes per administration.
Administration | In office | Coalition parties (seats in parliament upon instalment) | Number of votes |
---|---|---|---|
Kok II | 1998–2002 | PvdA (45)—VVD (38)—D66 (14) | 2 |
Balkenende I | 2002–2003 | CDA (43)—LPF (26)—VVD (24) | 8 |
Balkenende II | 2003–2006 | CDA (44)—VVD (28)—D66 (6) | 5 |
Balkenende III | 2006–2007 | CDA (44)—VVD (28) | 3 |
Balkenende IV | 2007–2010 | CDA (41)—PvdA (33)—CU (6) | 10 |
Rutte I | 2010–2012 | VVD (31)—CDA (21)—PVV* (24) | 9 |
Rutte II | 2012–2017 | VVD (41)—PvdA (38) | 14 |
Rutte III** | 2017–2021 | VVD (33)—CDA (19)—D66 (19)—CU (5) | 6 |
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Sonneveld, R. The politics of military deployments: contestation of foreign and security policy in the Netherlands. Int Polit (2024). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41311-024-00556-x
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41311-024-00556-x