Advertisement

BioSocieties

, Volume 14, Issue 2, pp 179–204 | Cite as

Performativity and a microbe: Exploring Mycobacterium bovis and the political ecologies of bovine tuberculosis

  • Philip A. RobinsonEmail author
Original Article

Abstract

Mycobacterium bovis, the bacterium responsible for causing bovine tuberculosis (bTB) in cattle, displays what I call ‘microbial performativity’. Like many other lively disease-causing microorganisms, it has an agency which is difficult to contain, and there is a need for fresh thinking on the challenges of dealing with this slippery and indeterminate microbe. As a practising veterinary scientist who side-stepped mid-career into a parallel training in the social sciences to view bTB from an alternative perspective, I create an interdisciplinary coming-together where veterinary science converges with a political ecology of (animal) health influenced by science and technology studies (STS) and social science and humanities scholarship on performativity. This suitably hybridized nexus creates a place to consider the ecologies of a pathogen which could be considered as life out of control. I consider what this means for efforts to eradicate this disease through combining understandings from the published scientific literature with qualitative interview-based fieldwork with farmers, veterinarians and others involved in the statutory bTB eradication programme in a high incidence region of the UK. This study demonstrates the value of life scientists turning to the social sciences to re-view their familiar professional habitus—challenging assumptions, and offering alternative perspectives on complex problems.

Keywords

Bacterium Bovine tuberculosis Microbial ethnography Performativity Political ecology of health Veterinary science 

Notes

Acknowledgements

Grateful acknowledgement is given to Prof. Peter Atkins, Prof. Gavin Bridge and Prof. Divya Tolia-Kelly for their support throughout the course of my doctoral research. The paper was first presented at the Lived and Material Cultures Research Cluster workshop entitled Locating Performance and the Political in the Geography Department of Durham University, and the comments of the organisers and participants, particularly Prof. Paul Langley, are gratefully acknowledged. I also sincerely thank the editor and reviewers for their very helpful comments on the paper. I dedicate the paper to the late Dr Sydney Neill—a bacteriologist who knew M. bovis better than most.

Funding

This research was generously funded at Durham University by a doctoral scholarship from the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) in N. Ireland. Additional funding for fieldwork expenses was provided by the Dudley Stamp Memorial Fund through the Royal Geographical Society.

References

  1. Abernethy, D.A., P. Upton, I.M. Higgins, G. McGrath, A.V. Goodchild, S.J. Rolfe, and S.J. More. 2013. Bovine Tuberculosis Trends in the UK and the Republic of Ireland, 1995–2010. Veterinary Record 172: 312.  https://doi.org/10.1136/vr.100969.Google Scholar
  2. Allen, A.R. 2017. One Bacillus to Rule Them All?—Investigating Broad Range Host Adaptation in Mycobacterium bovis. Infection, Genetics and Evolution 53: 68–76.Google Scholar
  3. Atkins, P.J. 2000. Milk Consumption and Tuberculosis in Britain, 1850–1950. In Order and Disorder: The Health Implications of Eating and Drinking in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries, ed. A. Fenton, 83–95. East Linton: Tuckwell Press.Google Scholar
  4. Atkins, P.J. 2016. A History of Uncertainty: Bovine Tuberculosis in Britain 1850 to the Present. Winchester: Winchester University Press.Google Scholar
  5. Atkins, P.J., and P.A. Robinson. 2013a. Coalition Culls and Zoonotic Ontologies. Environment and Planning A 45: 1372–1386.Google Scholar
  6. Atkins, P.J., and P.A. Robinson. 2013b. Bovine Tuberculosis and Badgers in Britain: Relevance of the Past. Epidemiology and Infection 141: 1437–1444.Google Scholar
  7. Attenborough, F. 2010. The Monad and the Nomad: Medical Microbiology and the Politics and Possibilities of the Mobile Microbe. Cultural Geographies 18: 91–114.Google Scholar
  8. Austin, J.L. 1970. [1961] Performative Utterances. Philosophical Papers, 233–252. London: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  9. Austin, J.L. 1975. [1962] How to do Things with Words. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
  10. Aznar, I., K. Frankena, S.J. More, J. O’Keeffe, G. McGrath, and M.C.M. de Jong. 2018. Quantification of Mycobacterium bovis Transmission in a Badger Vaccine Field Trial. Preventive Veterinary Medicine 149: 29–37.Google Scholar
  11. Baehr, P. 2006. Susan Sontag, Battle Language and the Hong Kong SARS Outbreak of 2003. Economy and Society 35: 42–64.Google Scholar
  12. Barbier, E., B. Chantemesse, M. Rochelet, L. Fayolle, L. Bollache, M.L. Boschiroli, and A. Hartmann. 2016. Rapid Dissemination of Mycobacterium bovis from Cattle Dung to Soil by the Earthworm Lumbricus terrestris. Veterinary Microbiology 186: 1–7.Google Scholar
  13. Bennett, J. 2007. Edible Matter. New Left Review 45: 133–145.Google Scholar
  14. Bennett, J. 2010. Vibrant Matter: A Political Ecology of Things. Durham: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
  15. Bhuachalla, D.N., L.A.L. Corner, S.J. More, and E. Gormley. 2015. The Role of Badgers in the Epidemiology of Mycobacterium bovis Infection (Tuberculosis) in Cattle in the United Kingdom and the Republic of Ireland: Current Perspectives on Control Strategies. Veterinary Medicine: Research and Reports 6: 27–38.Google Scholar
  16. Biek, R., A. O’Hare, D. Wright, T. Mallon, C. McCormick, R.J. Orton, S. McDowell, H. Trewby, R.A. Skuce, and R.R. Kao. 2012. Whole Genome Sequencing Reveals Local Transmission Patterns of Mycobacterium bovis in Sympatric Cattle and Badger Populations. PLoS Pathogens 8 (11): e1003008.  https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.ppat.1003008.Google Scholar
  17. Biehler, D.D. 2009. Permeable Homes: A Historical Political Ecology of Insects and Pesticides in US Public Housing. Geoforum 40: 1014–1023.Google Scholar
  18. Bingham, N., and S. Lavau. 2012. The Object of Regulation: Tending the Tensions of Food Safety. Environment and Planning A 44: 1589–1606.Google Scholar
  19. Bourne, F.J., C.A. Donnelly, D.R. Cox, G. Gettinby, J.P. McInerney, W.I. Morrison, and R. Woodroffe. 2007. Bovine TB: The Scientific Evidence. Final Report of the Independent Scientific Group on Cattle TB. London: DEFRA.Google Scholar
  20. Braun, B. 2008. Environmental Issues: Inventive Life. Progress in Human Geography 32: 667–679.Google Scholar
  21. Braun, B. 2011. Governing Disorder: Biopolitics and the Molecularization of Life. In Global Political Ecology, ed. R. Peet, P. Robbins, and M. Watts, 389–411. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  22. Broughan, J.M., J. Judge, E. Ely, R.J. Delahay, G. Wilson, R.S. Clifton-Hadley, A.V. Goodchild, H. Bishop, J.E. Parry, and S.H. Downs. 2016. A Review of Risk Factors for Bovine Tuberculosis Infection in Cattle in the UK and Ireland. Epidemiology and Infection 144: 2899–2926.Google Scholar
  23. Brown, S.P., and A. Buckling. 2008. A Social Life for Discerning Microbes. Cell 135: 600–603.Google Scholar
  24. Brunton, L.A., C.A. Donnelly, H. O’Connor, A. Prosser, S. Ashfield, A. Ashton, P. Upton, A. Mitchell, A.V. Goodchild, J.E. Parry, and S.H. Downs. 2017. Assessing the Effects of the First 2 years of Industry-Led Badger Culling in England on the Incidence of Bovine Tuberculosis in Cattle in 2013–2015. Ecology and Evolution 7: 7213–7230.Google Scholar
  25. Buddle, B.M., N.A. Parlane, D.N. Wedlock, and A. Heiser. 2013. Overview of Vaccination Trials for Control of Tuberculosis in Cattle, Wildlife and Humans. Transboundary and Emerging Diseases 60: 136–146.Google Scholar
  26. Byrne, A.W., S. McBride, A. Lahuerta-Marin, M. Guelbenzu, J. McNair, R.A. Skuce, and S.J. McDowell. 2016. Liver Fluke (Fasciola hepatica) Infection in Cattle in Northern Ireland: A Large-Scale Epidemiological Investigation Utilising Surveillance Data. Parasites & Vectors 9: 209.  https://doi.org/10.1186/s13071-016-1489-2.Google Scholar
  27. Byrne, A.W., M. Guelbenzu-Gonzalo, S.A.J. Strain, S. McBride, J. Graham, A. Lahuerta-Marin, R. Harwood, D.A. Graham, and S.J. McDowell. 2017. Assessment of Concurrent Infection with Bovine Viral Diarrhoea Virus (BVDV) and Mycobacterium bovis: A Herd-Level Risk Factor Analysis from Northern Ireland. Preventive Veterinary Medicine 141: 38–47.Google Scholar
  28. Callon, M., Lascoumes, P., and Barthe, Y. 2011. Acting in an Uncertain World: An Essay on Technical Democracy (Trans: Burchell, G.). Cambridge, MA and London: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
  29. Canguilhelm, G. 1978 [1966]. On the Normal and the Pathological (Trans: Fawcett, C.R.). Dordrecht, Boston, London: Reidel Publishing Company.Google Scholar
  30. Casal, C., A. Díez-Guerrier, J. Álvarez, S. Rodriguez-Campos, A. Mateos, R. Linscott, E. Martel, J.C. Lawrence, C. Whelan, J. Clarke, A. O’Brien, L. Dominguez, and A. Aranaz. 2014. Strategic Use of Serology for the Diagnosis of Bovine Tuberculosis After Intradermal Skin Testing. Veterinary Microbiology 170: 342–351.Google Scholar
  31. Cassidy, A. 2015. ‘Big Science’ in the Field: Experimenting with Badgers and Bovine TB, 1995–2015. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 37: 305–325.Google Scholar
  32. Cassidy, J.P., D.G. Bryson, J.M. Pollock, R.T. Evans, F. Forster, and S.D. Neill. 1999. Lesions in Cattle Exposed to Mycobacterium bovis-Inoculated Calves. Journal of Comparative Pathology 121: 321–337.Google Scholar
  33. Claridge, J., P. Diggle, C.M. McCann, G. Mulcahy, R. Flynn, J. McNair, S. Strain, M. Welsh, M. Baylis, and D.J.L. Williams. 2012. Fasciola hepatica is Associated with the Failure to Detect Bovine Tuberculosis in Dairy Cattle. Nature Communications 3: 853.Google Scholar
  34. Clark, N. 2003. Feral Ecologies: Performing Life on the Colonial Periphery. In Nature Performed: Environment, Culture and Performance, ed. B. Szerszynski, W. Heim, and C. Waterton, 163–182. Oxford and Malden: Blackwell Publishing.Google Scholar
  35. Clark, N. 2013. Mobile Life: Biosecurity Practices and Insect Globalization. Science as Culture 22: 16–37.Google Scholar
  36. Closser, S. 2012. ‘We Can’t Give Up Now’: Global Health Optimism and Polio Eradication in Pakistan. Medical Anthropology 31: 385–403.Google Scholar
  37. Connolly, D.J., P.J. Dwyer, J. Fagan, M. Hayes, E.G. Ryan, E. Costello, A. Kilroy, and S.J. More. 2008. Tuberculosis in Alpaca (Lama pacos) on a Farm in Ireland, 2, Results of an Epidemiological Investigation. Irish Veterinary Journal 61: 533–537.Google Scholar
  38. Corner, L.A., L. Melville, K. McCubbin, K.J. Small, B.S. McCormick, P.R. Wood, and J.S. Rothel. 1990. Efficiency of Inspection Procedures for the Detection of Tuberculous Lesions in Cattle. Australian Veterinary Journal 67: 389–392.Google Scholar
  39. Corner, L.A.L., D. O’Meara, E. Costello, S. Lesellier, and E. Gormley. 2012. The Distribution of Mycobacterium bovis Infection in Naturally Infected Badgers. The Veterinary Journal 194: 166–172.Google Scholar
  40. Cosma, C.L., O. Humbert, D.R. Sherman, and L. Ramakrishnan. 2008. Trafficking of Superinfecting Mycobacterium Organisms into Established Granulomas Occurs in Mammals and is Independent of the Erp and ESX-1 Mycobacterial Virulence Loci. The Journal of Infectious Diseases 198: 1851–1855.Google Scholar
  41. DAERA. 2018. Bovine TB statistics. Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs. https://www.daera-ni.gov.uk/sites/default/files/publications/daera/Tuberculosis%20-%20internet%20monthly%20statistics%20-%20January%202018.pdf. Accessed 9 April 2018.
  42. Daniel, R., H. Evans, S. Rolfe, R. de la Rua-Domenech, T. Crawshaw, R.J. Higgins, A. Schock, and R. Clifton-Hadley. 2009. Outbreak of Tuberculosis Caused by Mycobacterium bovis in Golden Guernsey Goats in Great Britain. Veterinary Record 165: 335–342.Google Scholar
  43. Dean, G.S., S.G. Rhodes, M. Coad, A.O. Whelan, P.J. Cockle, D.J. Clifford, R.G. Hewinson, and H.M. Vordermeier. 2005. Minimum Infective Dose of Mycobacterium bovis in Cattle. Infection and Immunity 73: 6467–6471.Google Scholar
  44. DEFRA. 2014. The Strategy for Achieving Officially Bovine Tuberculosis Free Status for England. April 2014. London: Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.Google Scholar
  45. de Kantor, I.N., and J.D. Roswurm. 1978. Mycobacteria Isolated from Nasal Secretions of Tuberculin Test Reactor Cattle. American Journal of Veterinary Research 39: 1233–1234.Google Scholar
  46. de la Rua-Domenech, R., A.T. Goodchild, H.M. Vordermeier, R.G. Hewinson, K.H. Christiansen, and R.S. Clifton-Hadley. 2006. Ante Mortem Diagnosis of Tuberculosis in Cattle: A Review of the Tuberculin Tests, γ-Interferon Assay and Other Ancillary Diagnostic Techniques. Research in Veterinary Science 81: 190–210.Google Scholar
  47. Dewsbury, J.-D. 2000. Performativity and the Event: Enacting a Philosophy of Difference. Environment and Planning D 18: 473–496.Google Scholar
  48. Engel, N. 2012. New Diagnostics for Multi-drug Resistant Tuberculosis in India: Innovating Control and Controlling Innovation. BioSocieties 7: 50–71.Google Scholar
  49. Enticott, G. 2008a. The Spaces of Biosecurity: Prescribing and Negotiating Solutions to Bovine Tuberculosis. Environment and Planning A 40: 1568–1582.Google Scholar
  50. Enticott, G. 2008b. The Ecological Paradox: Social and Natural Consequences of the Geographies of Animal Health Promotion. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 33: 433–446.Google Scholar
  51. Enticott, G. 2012. The Local Universality of Veterinary Expertise and the Geography of Animal Disease. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 37: 75–88.Google Scholar
  52. Enticott, G., A. Franklin, and S. van Winden. 2012. Biosecurity and Food Security: Spatial Strategies for Combating Bovine Tuberculosis in the UK. The Geographical Journal 178: 327–337.Google Scholar
  53. European Commission. 2013. Working Document on Eradication of Bovine Tuberculosis in the EU Accepted by the Bovine Tuberculosis Subgroup of the Task Force on Monitoring Animal Disease Eradication. SANCO/10067/2013, https://ec.europa.eu/food/sites/food/files/animals/docs/diseases_erad_tb_workingdoc2006_en.pdf. Accessed 10 April 2018.
  54. Evans, J.T., E.G. Smith, A. Banerjee, R.M.M. Smith, J. Dale, J.A. Innes, D. Hunt, A. Twedell, A. Wood, C. Anderson, R.G. Hewinson, N.H. Smith, P.M. Hawkey, and P. Sonnenberg. 2007. Cluster of Human Tuberculosis Caused by Mycobacterium bovis: Evidence for Person-to-Person Transmission in the UK. Lancet 369: 1270–1276.Google Scholar
  55. Faulkner, A. 2012. Law’s Performativities: Shaping the Emergence of Regenerative Medicine Through European Union Legislation. Social Studies of Science 42: 753–774.Google Scholar
  56. Federle, M.J., and B.L. Bassler. 2003. Interspecies Communication in Bacteria. The Journal of Clinical Investigation 112: 1291–1299.Google Scholar
  57. Fleck, L. 1979. [1935] Genesis and Development of a Scientific Fact. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  58. Gallagher, J., and D.M. Horwill. 1977. A Selective Oleic Acid Albumin Agar Medium for the Cultivation of Mycobacterium bovis. Journal of Hygiene 79: 155–160.Google Scholar
  59. Gannon, B.W., C.M. Hayes, and J.M. Roe. 2007. Survival Rate of Airborne Mycobacterium bovis. Research in Veterinary Science 82: 169–172.Google Scholar
  60. Ginn, F., U. Beisel, and M. Barua. 2014. Flourishing with Awkward Creatures: Togetherness, Vulnerability, Killing. Environmental Humanities 4: 113–123.Google Scholar
  61. Glaser, B.G., and A.L. Strauss. 2008. The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research. New Brunswick and London: Aldine Transaction.Google Scholar
  62. Goffman, E. 1990. [1959] The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
  63. Grant, W. 2009. Intractable Policy Failure: The Case of Bovine TB and Badgers. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations 11: 557–573.Google Scholar
  64. Gregson, N. 2011. Performativity, Corporeality and the Politics of Ship Disposal. Journal of Cultural Economy 4: 137–156.Google Scholar
  65. Gregson, N. 2012. Projected Futures: the Political Matter of UK Higher Activity Radioactive Waste. Environment and Planning A 44: 2006–2022.Google Scholar
  66. Gregson, N., and G. Rose. 2000. Taking Butler Elsewhere: Performativities, Spatialities and Subjectivities. Environment and Planning A 18: 433–452.Google Scholar
  67. Gregson, N., H. Watkins, and M. Calestani. 2010. Inextinguishable fibres: demolition and the vital materialisms of asbestos. Environment and Planning A 42: 1065–1083.Google Scholar
  68. Gupta, A., A. Kaul, A.G. Tsolaki, U. Kishore, and S. Bhakta. 2012. Mycobacterium Tuberculosis: Immune Evasion, Latency and Reactivation. Immunobiology 217: 363–374.Google Scholar
  69. Harrison, S., S. Pile, and N. Thrift. 2004. Patterned Ground: Entanglements of Nature and Culture. London: Reaktion Books.Google Scholar
  70. Hausermann, H.E. 2015. ‘I Could Not be Idle Any Longer’: Buruli Ulcer Treatment Assemblages in Rural Ghana. Environment and Planning A 47: 2204–2220.Google Scholar
  71. Hinchliffe, S. 2007. Geographies of Nature: Societies, Environments, Ecologies. London, Thousand Oaks, New Delhi, Singapore: Sage Publications Ltd.Google Scholar
  72. Hinchliffe, S., and S. Whatmore. 2006. Living Cities: Towards a Politics of Conviviality. Science as Culture 15: 123–138.Google Scholar
  73. Hinchliffe, S., and S. Lavau. 2013. Differentiated Circuits: The Ecologies of Knowing and Securing Life. Environment and Planning D 31: 259–274.Google Scholar
  74. Hird, M.J. 2009. The Origins of Sociable Life: Evolution After Science Studies. Basingstoke and New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
  75. Hird, M.J. 2010. Meeting with the Microcosmos. Environment and Planning D 28: 36–39.Google Scholar
  76. Hlokwe, T.M., P. van Helden, and A.L. Michel. 2014. Evidence of Increasing Intra and Inter-Species Transmission of Mycobacterium bovis in South Africa: Are We Losing the Battle? Preventive Veterinary Medicine 115: 10–17.Google Scholar
  77. Hodgetts, T., and J. Lorimer. 2015. Methodologies for Animals’ Geographies: Cultures, Communication and Genomics. Cultural Geographies 22: 285–295.Google Scholar
  78. Hoffmann, C., A. Leis, M. Niederweis, J.M. Plitzko, and H. Engelhard. 2008. Disclosure of the Mycobacterial Outer Membrane: Cryo-Electron Tomography and Vitreous Sections Reveal the Lipid Bilayer Structure. Proceedings of National Academy of Sciences 105: 3963–3967.Google Scholar
  79. Homer. 1946. The Odyssey (Trans: Rieu, E.V.). London: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
  80. Houlihan, M.G., F.W. Dixon, and N.A. Page. 2008. Outbreak of Bovine Tuberculosis Featuring Anergy to the Skin Test, Udder Lesions and Milkborne Disease in Young Calves. Veterinary Record 163: 357–361.Google Scholar
  81. Humblet, M.F., M.L. Boschiroli, and C. Saegerman. 2009. Classification of Worldwide Bovine Tuberculosis Risk Factors in Cattle: A Stratified Approach. Veterinary Research 40: 1–24.Google Scholar
  82. Ingram, M. 2007. Disciplining Microbes in the Implementation of US Federal Organic Standards. Environment and Planning A 39: 2866–2882.Google Scholar
  83. Jackson, P., and A.H. Neely. 2015. Triangulating Health: Toward a Practice of a Political Ecology of Health. Progress in Human Geography 39: 47–64.Google Scholar
  84. Jee, B.D., D.H. Uttal, A. Spiegel, and J. Diamond. 2015. Expert-Novice Differences in Mental Models of Viruses, Vaccines, and the Causes of Infectious Disease. Public Understanding of Science 24: 241–256.Google Scholar
  85. Johnson, L.K., E. Liebana, A. Nunez, Y. Spencer, R. Clifton-Hadley, K. Jahans, A. Ward, A. Barlow, and R. Delahay. 2008. Histological Observations of Bovine Tuberculosis in Lung and Lymph Node Tissues from British Deer. The Veterinary Journal 175: 409–412.Google Scholar
  86. Jones, S. 2004. Mapping a Zoonotic Disease: Anglo-American Efforts to Control Bovine Tuberculosis Before World War 1. Osiris 19: 133–148.Google Scholar
  87. Kao, R.R., M.B. Gravenor, B. Charleston, J.C. Hope, M. Martin, and C.J. Howard. 2007. Mycobacterium bovis Shedding Patterns from Experimentally Infected Calves and the Effect of Concurrent Infection with Bovine Diarrhoea Virus. Journal of the Royal Society, Interface 4: 545–551.Google Scholar
  88. Kelly, A.M. 2005. Veterinary Medicine in the 21st Century: The Challenge of Biosecurity. ILAR Journal 46: 62–64.Google Scholar
  89. Khatri, B.L., M. Coad, D.J. Clifford, R.G. Hewinson, A.O. Whelan, and H.M. Vordermeier. 2012. A Natural-Transmission Model of Bovine Tuberculosis Provides Novel Disease Insights. Veterinary Record 171: 448.  https://doi.org/10.1136/vr.101072.Google Scholar
  90. King, D. 2007. Bovine Tuberculosis in Cattle and Badgers. A Report by the Chief Scientific Adviser, Sir David King, http://www.bovinetb.info/docs/RBCT_david_%20king_report.pdf. Accessed 10 April 2018.
  91. King, H.C., A. Murphy, P. James, E. Travis, D. Porter, Y.-J. Hung, J. Sawyer, J. Cork, R.J. Delahay, W. Gaze, O. Courtenay, and E.M. Wellington. 2015. The Variability and Seasonality of the Environmental Reservoir of Mycobacterium bovis Shed by Wild European Badgers. Scientific Reports.  https://doi.org/10.1038/srep12318.Google Scholar
  92. Langlitz, N. 2014. Lessons and Conversions: Reading Across Disciplinary Boundaries. BioSocieties 9: 218.Google Scholar
  93. Latimer, J., and M. Miele. 2013. Naturecultures? Science, Affect and the Non-human. Theory, Culture & Society 30: 5–31.Google Scholar
  94. Latour, B. 1993. We Have Never Been Modern. Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.Google Scholar
  95. Latour, B. 2000. When Things Strike Back: A Possible Contribution of ‘Science Studies’ to the Social Sciences. British Journal of Sociology 51: 107–123.Google Scholar
  96. Law, J. 2006. Disaster in Agriculture: Or Foot and Mouth Mobilities. Environment and Planning A 38: 227–239.Google Scholar
  97. Law, J., and A. Mol. 2008. Globalisation in Practice: On the Politics of Boiling Pigswill. Geoforum 39: 133–143.Google Scholar
  98. Law, J., and A. Mol. 2010. The Actor-Enacted: Cumbrian Sheep in 2001. In Material Agency: Towards a Non-anthropocentric Approach, ed. C. Knappett and L. Malafouris, 57–77. Dusseldorf: Springer.Google Scholar
  99. Law, J., and A. Mol. 2011. Veterinary Realities: What is Foot and Mouth Disease? Sociologica Ruralis 51: 1–16.Google Scholar
  100. Lin, P.L., and J.L. Flynn. 2010. Understanding Latent Tuberculosis: A Moving Target. Journal of Immunology 185: 15–22.Google Scholar
  101. Lorimer, J. 2012. Multinatural Geographies for the Anthropocene. Progress in Human Geography 36: 593–612.Google Scholar
  102. Loxley, J. 2008. Performativity: The New Critical Idiom. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  103. Mansnerus, E. 2009. The Lives of ‘Facts’ in Mathematical Models: A Story of Population-Level Disease Transmission of Haemophilus influenzae Type B Bacteria. BioSocieties 4: 207–222.Google Scholar
  104. Mather, C., and A. Marshall. 2011. Living with Disease? Biosecurity and Avian Influenza in Ostriches. Agriculture and Human Values 28: 153–165.Google Scholar
  105. McCulloch, S.P., and M.J. Reiss. 2017. Bovine Tuberculosis and Badger Control in England: Science, Policy and Politics. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 30: 469–484.Google Scholar
  106. Medeiros, L.S., C.D. Marassi, E.E.S. Figueiredo, J. Leite, A.M.R. Ferreira, and W. Lilenbaum. 2012. Assessing the Histopathology to Depict the Different Stages of Bovine Tuberculosis Infection in a Naturally Infected Herd. Brazilian Journal of Veterinary Research 32: 135–139.Google Scholar
  107. Menzies, F.D., and S.D. Neill. 2000. Cattle-to-Cattle Transmission of Bovine Tuberculosis. The Veterinary Journal 160: 92–106.Google Scholar
  108. Monies, R.J. 2000. Tuberculous Pneumonia and BVD in Housed Calves. Cattle Practice 8: 119–125.Google Scholar
  109. Moore, V.A. 1913. Bovine Tuberculosis and its Control. Ithaca, NY: Carpenter and Company.Google Scholar
  110. Moore, L.J., and M. Kosut. 2014. Among the Colony: Ethnographic Fieldwork, Urban Bees and Intra-Species Mindfulness. Ethnography 15: 516–539.Google Scholar
  111. More, S.J., T.A. Clegg, G. McGrath, J.D. Collins, L.A.L. Corner, and E. Gormley. 2009. Does Reactive Culling Lead to an Increase in Tuberculosis in Cattle? Veterinary Record 161: 208–209.Google Scholar
  112. Napier, A.D. 2012. Nonself Help: How Immunology Might Reframe the Enlightenment. Cultural Anthropology 27: 122–137.Google Scholar
  113. Neely, A.H. 2015. Internal Ecologies and the Limits of Local Biologies: A Political Ecology of Tuberculosis in the Time of AIDS. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 105: 791–805.Google Scholar
  114. Neill, S.D., J. Hanna, J.J. O’Brien, and R.M. McCracken. 1989. Transmission of Tuberculosis from Experimentally Infected Cattle to In-Contact Calves. Veterinary Record 124: 269–271.Google Scholar
  115. Neill, S.D., J.J. O’Brien, and J. Hanna. 1991. A Mathematical Model for Mycobacterium bovis Excretion from Tuberculous Cattle. Veterinary Microbiology 28: 103–109.Google Scholar
  116. NI Assembly. 2012. Review into Bovine Tuberculosis, Volume 1, Together with the Minutes of Proceedings of the Committee Relating to the Summary, the Minutes of Evidence and Correspondence. Agriculture and Rural Development Committee NIA 83/11-15 13 November 2012.Google Scholar
  117. Noy, C. 2008. Sampling Knowledge: The Hermeneutics of Snowball Sampling in Qualitative Research. International Journal of Social Research Methodology 11: 327–344.Google Scholar
  118. Olea-Popelka, F.J., P. Fitzgerald, P. White, G. McGrath, J.D. Collins, J. O’Keefe, D.F. Kelton, O. Berke, S. More, and S.W. Martin. 2009. Targeted Badger Removal and the Subsequent Risk of Bovine Tuberculosis in Cattle Herds in County Laois, Ireland. Preventive Veterinary Medicine 88: 178–184.Google Scholar
  119. Olea-Popelka, F., Z. Freeman, P. White, E. Costello, J. O’Keefe, K. Frankena, W. Martin, and S. More. 2012. Relative Effectiveness of Irish Factories in the Surveillance of Slaughtered Cattle for Visible Lesions of Tuberculosis, 2005–2007. Irish Veterinary Journal 65: 2.Google Scholar
  120. Olea-Popelka, F., A. Muwonge, A. Perera, A.S. Dean, E. Mumford, E. Erlacher-Vindel, S. Forcella, B.J. Silk, L. Ditiu, A. El Idrissi, M. Raviglione, O. Cosivi, P. LoBue, and P.I. Fujiwara. 2017. Zoonotic Tuberculosis in Human Beings Caused by Mycobacterium bovis—A Call for Action. Lancet Infectious Diseases 17: e21–e25.Google Scholar
  121. Palmer, M.V., W.R. Waters, and D.L. Whipple. 2004. Investigation of the Transmission of Mycobacterium bovis from Deer to Cattle Through Indirect Contact. American Journal of Veterinary Research 65: 1483–1489.Google Scholar
  122. Pattison, I. 1984. The British Veterinary Profession, 1791–1948. London: JA Allen.Google Scholar
  123. Paxson, H. 2008. Post-Pasteurian Cultures: The Microbiopolitics of Raw-Milk Cheese in the United States. Cultural Anthropology 23: 15–47.Google Scholar
  124. Pfeiffer, D.U. 2013. Epidemiology Caught in the Causal Web of Bovine Tuberculosis. Transboundary and Emerging Diseases 60: 104–110.Google Scholar
  125. Pickering, A. 1995. The Mangle of Practice: Time, Agency, and Science. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  126. Pollock, J.M., and S.D. Neill. 2002. Mycobacterium bovis Infection and Tuberculosis in Cattle. Veterinary Journal 163: 115–127.Google Scholar
  127. Porter, N. 2016. Ferreting Things Out: Biosecurity, Pandemic Flu and the Transformation of Experimental Systems. BioSocieties 11: 22–45.Google Scholar
  128. Pritchard, D.G. 1988. A Century of Bovine Tuberculosis 1888–1988: Conquest and Controversy. Journal of Comparative Pathology 99: 357–399.Google Scholar
  129. Rivière, J., K. Carabin, Y. Le Strat, P. Hendrikx, and B. Dufour. 2014. Bovine Tuberculosis Surveillance in Cattle and Free-Ranging Wildlife in EU Member States in 2013: A Survey-Based Review. Veterinary Microbiology 173: 323–331.Google Scholar
  130. Robbins, P., R. Farnsworth, and J.P. Jones III. 2008. Insects and Institutions: Managing Emergent Hazards in the U.S. Southwest. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning 10: 95–112.Google Scholar
  131. Roberts, T., C. O’Connor, J. Nunez-Garcia, R. de la Rua-Domenech, and N.H. Smith. 2014. Unusual Cluster of Mycobacterium bovis Infection in Cats. Veterinary Record 174: 326.Google Scholar
  132. Robins, R. 2012. The Controversy over GM Canola in Australia as an Ontological Politics. Environmental Values 21: 185–208.Google Scholar
  133. Robinson, P.A. 2015. A History of Bovine Tuberculosis Eradication Policy in Northern Ireland. Epidemiology and Infection 143: 3182–3195.Google Scholar
  134. Robinson, P.A. 2017a. Farmers and Bovine Tuberculosis: Contextualising Statutory Disease Control Within Everyday Farming Lives. Journal of Rural Studies 55: 168–180.Google Scholar
  135. Robinson, P.A. 2017b. Framing Bovine Tuberculosis: A ‘Political Ecology of Health’ Approach to Circulation of Knowledge(s) About Animal Disease Control. The Geographical Journal 183: 285–294.Google Scholar
  136. Robinson, P.A., L.A.L. Corner, E.A. Courcier, J. McNair, M. Artois, F.D. Menzies, and D.A. Abernethy. 2012. BCG Vaccination Against Tuberculosis in European Badgers (Meles meles): A Review. Comparative Immunology, Microbiology and Infectious Diseases 35: 277–287.Google Scholar
  137. Sayes, E. 2014. Actor-Network Theory and Methodology: Just What Does it Mean to Say that Nonhumans have Agency? Social Studies of Science 44: 134–149.Google Scholar
  138. Scanlon, M.P., and P.J. Quinn. 2000. Inactivation of Mycobacterium bovis in Cattle Slurry by Five Volatile Chemicals. Journal of Applied Microbiology 89: 854–861.Google Scholar
  139. Schroeder, E.C., and Cotton, W.E. 1907. The danger from tubercle bacilli in the environment of tuberculous cattle Bulletin No. 99. Washington, DC: United States Department of Agriculture Bureau of Animal Industry.Google Scholar
  140. Schuurman, N., and A. Franklin. 2015. Performing Expertise in Human–Animal Relationships: Performative Instability and the Role of Counter Performance. Environment and Planning D 33: 20–34.Google Scholar
  141. Shaw, I.G.R. 2012. Towards an Evental Geography. Progress in Human Geography 36: 613–627.Google Scholar
  142. Shrikrishna, D., R. de la Rua-Domenech, N.H. Smith, A. Colloff, and I. Coutts. 2009. Human and Canine Pulmonary Mycobacterium bovis Infection in the Same Household: Re-emergence of an Old Zoonotic Threat? Thorax 64: 89–91.Google Scholar
  143. Skuce, R.A., T.R. Mallon, C.M. McCormick, S.H. McBride, G. Clarke, A. Thompson, C. Couzens, A.W. Gordon, and S.W. McDowell. 2010. Mycobacterium bovis Genotypes in Northern Ireland: herd-level surveillance (2003 to 2008). Veterinary Record 167: 684–689.Google Scholar
  144. Sontag, S. 1979. Illness as Metaphor. London: Allen Lane.Google Scholar
  145. Stoller, P. 2012. Immunology and the Between. Cultural Anthropology 27: 175–180.Google Scholar
  146. Sullivan, R. 2011. Geography Speaks: Performative Aspects of Geography. Farnham and Burlington: Ashgate Publishing Ltd.Google Scholar
  147. Szerszynski, B., W. Heim, and C. Waterton. 2003. Nature Performed: Environment, Culture and Performance. Oxford and Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.Google Scholar
  148. Testa, G. 2013. European Lives: New Vistas Across the Social Sciences and Biomedical Humanities. In: Horizons for Social Sciences and Humanities Conference Report. Vilnius, pp. 64–68.Google Scholar
  149. Thrift, N. 1997. The Still Point: Resistance, Expressive Embodiment and Dance. In Geographies of Resistance, ed. S. Pile and M. Keith, 124–151. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  150. Thrift, N., and J.-D. Dewsbury. 2000. Dead Geographies and How to Make Them Live. Environment and Planning D 18: 411–432.Google Scholar
  151. Trewby, H., D. Wright, E.L. Breadon, S.J. Lycett, T.R. Mallon, C. McCormick, P. Johnson, R.J. Orton, A.R. Allen, J. Galbraith, P. Herzyk, R.A. Skuce, R. Biek, and R.R. Kao. 2016. Use of Bacterial Whole-Genome Sequencing to Investigate Local Persistence and Spread in Bovine Tuberculosis. Epidemics 14: 26–35.Google Scholar
  152. van der Burgt, G.M., F. Drummond, T. Crawshaw, and S. Morris. 2012. An Outbreak of Tuberculosis in Lleyn Sheep in the UK Associated with Clinical Signs. Veterinary Record 172: 69.Google Scholar
  153. van Loon, J. 2005. Epidemic Space. Critical Public Health 15: 39–52.Google Scholar
  154. Wallmann, S. 1998. Ordinary Women and Shapes of Knowledge: Perspectives on the Context of STD and AIDS. Public Understanding of Science 7: 169–185.Google Scholar
  155. Waters, W.R., M.F. Maggioli, M.V. Palmer, T.C. Thacker, J.L. McGill, H.M. Vordermeier, L. Berney-Meyer, W.R. Jacobs, and M.H. Larsen. 2016. Interleukin-17A as a Biomarker for Bovine Tuberculosis. Clinical and Vaccine Immunology 23: 168–180.Google Scholar
  156. Washer, P. 2011. Lay Perceptions of Emerging Infectious Diseases: A Commentary. Public Understanding of Science 20: 506–512.Google Scholar
  157. Woodroffe, R., C.A. Donnelly, C. Ham, S.Y.B. Jackson, K. Moyes, K. Chapman, N.G. Stratton, and S.J. Cartwright. 2016. Badgers Prefer Cattle Pasture But Avoid Cattle: Implications for Bovine Tuberculosis Control. Ecology Letters 19: 1201–1208.Google Scholar
  158. World Health Organisation. 2017. Global Tuberculosis Report. Geneva: World Health Organisation.Google Scholar
  159. Wright, N., and B. Nerlich. 2006. Use of the Deficit Model in a Shared Culture of Argumentation: the Case of Foot and Mouth Science. Public Understanding of Science 15: 331–342.Google Scholar
  160. Zanini, M.S., E.C. Moreira, M.T. Lopes, P. Mota, and C.E. Salas. 1998. Detection of Mycobacterium bovis in Milk by Polymerase Chain Reaction. Journal of Veterinary Medicine Series B 45: 473–479.Google Scholar
  161. Ziman, J. 2001. Getting Scientists to Think About What They are Doing. Science and Engineering Ethics 7: 165–176.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Macmillan Publishers Ltd., part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Animal Production, Welfare and Veterinary SciencesHarper Adams UniversityNewportUK

Personalised recommendations