The ambiguities of ‘social’ egg freezing and the challenges of informed consent
Abstract
Fertility clinics (and some employers) in the UK and other high-income countries have recently started to offer egg freezing to women concerned about their age-related fertility decline. Because the use of egg freezing for this purpose is new, there is no reliable evidence of its usefulness, or otherwise. There are no guarantees that egg freezing will work, and for many and perhaps most women, their frozen eggs will never be used. It is also unclear whether egg freezing is a positive development for women in general. It offers an additional choice, and it may enable some women to have genetically related children more easily in the future. At the same time, it could be argued that egg freezing individualises and medicalises the social problem of a mismatch between female fertility and when women and men feel ready to have children. This article suggests that egg freezing is an ambiguous technology, whose benefits are as yet speculative, and that women therefore need as much clear and frank information as possible in order to navigate this new and by no means straightforward choice.
Keywords
egg freezing fertility informed consent medicalisation egg donationNotes
References
- Adams, V., Murphy, M. and Clarke, A.E. (2009) Anticipation: Technoscience, life, affect, temporality. Subjectivity 28: 246–265.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Alter, C., Tsai, D. and Trianni, F. (2015) What you really need to know about egg freezing. Time. July 16.Google Scholar
- Arie, S. (2015) Is too much hope placed in egg freezing? British Medical Journal 351: h5955.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- ASRM (2014) Can I Freeze My Eggs to Use Later if I’m Not Sick? Alabama: ASRM.Google Scholar
- Baldwin, K., Culley, L., Hudson, N. and Mitchell, H. (2014) Reproductive technology and the life course: Current debates and research in social egg freezing. Human Fertility 17: 170–179.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Baldwin, K., Culley, L., Hudson, N., Mitchell, H. and Lavery, S. (2015) Oocyte cryopreservation for social reasons: Demographic profile and disposal intentions of UK users. Reproductive BioMedicine Online 31: 239–245.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Baylis, F. (2015) Left out in the cold: Arguments against non-medical oocyte cryopreservation. Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Canada 37: 64–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Baylis, F. and McLeod, C. (2007) The stem cell debate continues: The buying and selling of eggs for research. Journal of Medical Ethics 33: 726–731.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Becker, G. (2000) The Elusive Embryo: How Women and Men Approach New Reproductive Technologies. Los Angeles: University of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Beeson, D. and Lippman, A. (2006) Egg harvesting for stem cell research: Medical risks and ethical problems. Reproductive BioMedicine Online 13: 573–579.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Bennett, J. (2014) Company-paid egg freezing will be the great equalizer. Time October 15: 1–2.Google Scholar
- Bewley, S. (2016) Shock! Horror! Or business as usual? Bionews. 6 June.Google Scholar
- Bretherick K.L. et al (2010) Fertility and aging: Do reproductive-aged women know what they need to know? Fertility and Sterility 93: 2162–2168.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Callahan, J.C. and Roberts, D.E. (1996) Feminist social justice approach to reproduction-assisting technologies: A case study on the limits of liberal theory. Kentucky Law Journal 84: 1197.Google Scholar
- Carbone, J. and Cahn, N. (2013) Gender/class divide: Reproduction, privilege, and the workplace. Florida International University Law Review 8: 287.Google Scholar
- Carbone, J. and Cahn, N. (2015) The triple system for regulating women’s reproduction. The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 43: 275–288.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Chen, C. (1986) Pregnancy after human oocyte cryopreservation. The Lancet 327: 884–886.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Daly, I and Bewley, S. (2013) Reproductive ageing and conflicting clocks: King Midas’ touch. Reproductive BioMedicine Online 27: 722–732.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Daniluk, J.C. (2015) “Sleepwalking into Infertility”: The need for a gentle wake-up call. The American Journal of Bioethics 15: 52–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Daniluk J.C. and Koert, E. (2013) The other side of the fertility coin: A comparison of childless men’s and women’s knowledge of fertility and assisted reproductive technology. Fertility and Sterility 99: 839–846.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Department of Health (2009) Impact Assessment for the Human Fertilisation and Embryology (Statutory Storage Period for Gametes and Embryos) Regulations. London: Department of Health.Google Scholar
- Dunson, D.B., Colombo, B. and Baird, D.D. (2002) Changes with age in the level and duration of fertility in the menstrual cycle. Human Reproduction 17: 1399–1403.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ericson, R. (2005) Governing through risk and uncertainty. Economy and Society 34: 659–672CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ericson, R., Barry, D. and Doyle, A. (2000) The moral hazards of neoliberalism: Lessons from the private insurance industry. Economy and Society 29: 532–558.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- ESHRE Task Force on Ethics and Law (2012) Oocyte cryopreservation for age-related fertility loss. Human Reproduction 27: 1231–1237.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Evers, J.H. (2016) Santa Claus in the fertility clinic. Human Reproduction 31: 1381–1382.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Franklin, S. (1997) Embodied Progress: A Culture Account of Assisted Conception. Routledge: London.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Goold I. and Savulescu, J. (2009) In favour of freezing eggs for non-medical reasons. Bioethics 23: 47–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Hammarberg, K. and Clarke, V.E. (2005) Reasons for delaying childbearing – A survey of women aged over 35 years seeking assisted reproductive technology. Australian Family Physician 34: 187–189.Google Scholar
- Hammarberg, K. et al (2013) Knowledge about factors that influence fertility among Australians of reproductive age: A population-based survey. Fertility and Sterility 99: 502–507.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Harper, J. et al (2012) When and how should new technology be introduced into the IVF laboratory? Human reproduction 27:303–313.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Hartouni, V. (1997) Cultural Conceptions: On Reproductive Technologies and the Remaking of Life. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
- Harwood, K. (2009) Egg freezing: A breakthrough for reproductive autonomy? Bioethics 23: 39–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Hass, N. (2011) Time to chill? Egg-freezing technology offers women a chance to extend their fertility. Vogue. April 28.Google Scholar
- Hodes-Wertz, B. et al, (2013) What do reproductive age women who undergo oocyte cryopreservation think about the processes as means to preserve fertility? Fertility and Sterility 100:1343–1349.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (2015) General Directions 0006 version 4 Import and Export of Gametes and Embryos. London: HFEA.Google Scholar
- Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (2016) Fertility Treatment 2014: Trends and Figures. London: HFEA.Google Scholar
- Inhorn, MC (2013) Women, consider freezing your eggs. CNN April 9.Google Scholar
- Irons, B. and Hepburn, C. (2007) Regret theory and the tyranny of choice. Economic Record 83: 191–203.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Jackson, E. (2016) ‘Social’ egg freezing and the UK’s statutory storage time limits. Journal of Medical Ethics. Online First: 23 August 2016.Google Scholar
- Karpin, I.A., Millbank, J., Stuhmcke, A. and Chandler, E., (2013) Analysing IVF participant understanding of, involvement in, and control over embryo storage and destruction in Australia. Journal of Law and Medicine 20: 811–830.Google Scholar
- Klein, J. et al, (2006) P-486: Preliminary experience of an oocyte cryopreservation program: Are patients presenting too late? Fertilty and Sterility 86: S315.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Krähmer, D. and Stone, R. (2013) Anticipated regret as an explanation of uncertainty aversion. Economic Theory 52: 709–728.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Kuleshova, L. et al. (1999) Birth following vitrification of a small number of human oocytes: Case Report. Human Reproduction 14:3077–3079.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lemoine, M.E. and Ravitsky, V. (2015) Sleepwalking into infertility: The need for a public health approach toward advanced maternal age. The American Journal of Bioethics 15: 37–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lockwood, G.M. (2011) Social egg freezing the prospect of reproductive “immortality” or a dangerous delusion? Reproductive BioMedicine Online 23: 334–340.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- London Egg Bank website (2016) http://www.londoneggbank.com/how-do-i-freeze-my-eggs/freeze-and-share accessed 14 September 2016.
- Loomes G. and Sugden, R (1982) Regret theory: An alternative theory of rational choice under uncertainty. The Economic Journal 92: 805–824.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lowe, P. (2016) Reproductive Health and Maternal Sacrifice: Women, Choice and Responsibility. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Maheshwari, A., Porter, M., Shetty, A. and Bhattacharya, S. (2008) Women’s awareness and perceptions of delay in childbearing. Fertility and Sterility 90: 1036–1042.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Martin, L.J. (2010) Anticipating infertility: Egg freezing, genetic preservation, and risk. Gender and Society 24: 526–545.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- McBride, C. (2013) I’m so glad I’ve frozen my eggs. The Guardian, 14 December 2013.Google Scholar
- Mertes, H. (2011) Social egg freezing: For better, not for worse’. Reproductive BioMedicine Online 23: 824–829.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Mertes, H. (2015) Does company-sponsored egg freezing promote or confine women’s reproductive autonomy? Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics 32: 1205–1209.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Mertes, H. (2016) The role of anticipated decision regret and the patient’s best interest in sterilisation and medically assisted reproduction Journal of Medical Ethics Online First: 7 October 2016.Google Scholar
- Mertes, H. and Pennings, G. (2011) Social egg freezing: For better, not for worse. Reproductive BioMedicine Online 23: 824–829.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Mertes, H. and Pennings, G. (2012) Elective oocyte cryopreservation: Who should pay? Human Reproduction 27: 9–13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Mertes, H., Pennings, G., Dondorp, W. and de Wert, G. (2012) Implications of oocyte cryostorage for the practice of oocyte donation. Human Reproduction 27: 2886–2893.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Mesen, T.B. et al. (2015) Optimal timing for elective egg freezing. Fertility and Sterility 2013: 1551-6 e1-4.Google Scholar
- Mohapatra, S. (2014) Using egg freezing to extend the biological clock: Fertility insurance or false hope? Harvard Law and Policy Review 8: 382.Google Scholar
- Moynihan, R (2010) Prediseases: Who benefits from treating prehypertension? British Medical Journal 341: c4442.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (2013) Fertility: Assessment and Treatment for People with Fertility Problems. London: NICE.Google Scholar
- Nekkebroeck J., Stoop, D. and Devroey, P. (2010) A preliminary profile of women opting for oocyte cryopreservation for non-medical reasons. Human Reproduction 25: i14–i17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Office of National Statistics (2015) Births by Parents’ Characteristics in England and Wales: 2014. London: ONS.Google Scholar
- Peck, S. (2014) Egg freezing: The perfect 30th birthday gift for women. The Daily Telegraph, 27 October 2014.Google Scholar
- Pennings, G. (2000) What are the ownership rights for gametes and embryos? Advance directives and the disposition of cryopreserved gametes and embryos. Human Reproduction 15: 979–989.Google Scholar
- Petersen, K.B., Hvidman, H.W., Sylvest, R., Pinborg, A., Larsen, E.C., Macklon, K.T., Andersen, A.N. and Schmidt, L., Birch Petersen, K. et al (2015) Family intentions and personal considerations on postponing childbearing in childless cohabiting and single women aged 35–43 seeking fertility assessment and counselling. Human Reproduction 30: 2563–2574.Google Scholar
- Petropanagos, A. (2015) Is advanced maternal age a public health issue?’ The American Journal of Bioethics 15: 56–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Petropanagos, A., Cattapan, A., Baylis, F. and Leader, A. (2015) Social egg freezing: Risk, benefits and other considerations. Canadian Medical Association Journal 187: 666–669.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Petryna, A. (2013) Life Exposed: Biological Citizens After Chernobyl. Princeton: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Politi, M.C., Clark, M.A., Ombao, H., Dizon, D. and Elwyn, G. (2011) Communicating uncertainty can lead to less decision satisfaction: A necessary cost of involving patients in shared decision making? Health Expectations 14: 84–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Practice committees of the SART and ASRM (2013) Mature Oocyte Cryopreservation: A Guideline. Alabama: ASRM.Google Scholar
- Rapp, R. (1999) Testing Women, Testing the Fetus: The Social Impact of Amniocentesis in America. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Richards, S.E. (2013a) Why i froze my eggs (and you should, too). The Wall Street Journal, May 3.Google Scholar
- Richards, S.E. (2013b) Motherhood, Rescheduled: The New Frontier of Egg Freezing and the Women Who Tried It. New York: Simon and Schuster.Google Scholar
- Richards, S.E. (2013c) Freezing eggs – is this what we’re all doing now? Cosmopolitan, 15 June.Google Scholar
- Rienzi et al. L. (2010) Embryo development and gestation using fresh and vitrified oocytes. Human Reproduction 25: 1192–1198.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Robertson, J. (2014) Egg freezing and egg banking: Empowerment and alienation in assisted reproduction. Journal of Law and the Biosciences 1:113–136.Google Scholar
- Rose, N. and Novas, C. (2004) Biological citizenship. In: Ong, A. and Collier S.J. (eds.) Global Assemblages: Technology, Politics, and Ethics as Anthropological Problems. Oxford, Blackwell Publishing. pp 439–463.Google Scholar
- Rosen, C. (2013) The ethics of egg freezing. Wall Street Journal 4 May.Google Scholar
- Sandberg, T. and Conner, M. (2008) Anticipated regret as an additional predictor in the theory of planned behaviour: A meta-analysis. British Journal of Social Psychology 47: 589–606.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Sarner, M. (2015) I’m 29, should I free my eggs? The Guardian 14 August.Google Scholar
- Skene, L. (2012) Proprietary interests in human bodily material: Yearworth, recent Australian cases on stored semen and their implications: Kate Jane Bazley v Wesley Monash IVF Pty Ltd [2010] QSC 118; Jocelyn Edwards; Re the estate of the late Mark Edwards [2011] NSWSC 478. Medical Law Review 20: 227–245.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Slaughter, A.M. (2012) Why women still can’t have it all. The Atlantic, June 13.Google Scholar
- Stoop, D. (2010) Social oocyte freezing. Facts, Views and Vision in ObGyn 2:31–34.Google Scholar
- Stoop, D. et al (2015) Does oocyte banking for anticipated gamete exhaustion influence future relational and reproductive choices? A follow-up of bankers and non-bankers. Human Reproduction 30: 338–344.Google Scholar
- ter Keurst, A., Boivin, J. and Gameiro, S. (2016) Women’s intentions to use fertility preservation to prevent age-related fertility decline. Reproductive Biomedicine Online 32: 121–131.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Tsafrir, A. et al. (2015) Ovarian stimulation for oocyte cryopreservation for prevention of age-related fertility loss: One in five is a low responder. Gynecological Endocrinology 31: 779–782.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Tymstra, T. (1989) The imperative character of medical technology and the meaning of “Anticipated Decision Regret”. International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 5: 207–213.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Tymstra, T. (2007) “At least we tried everything”: About binary thinking, anticipated decision regret, and the imperative character of medical technology. Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics and Gynecology 28: 131.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Van de Wiel, L. (2014) For whom the clock ticks: Reproductive ageing and egg freezing in Dutch and British news media. Studies in the Maternal 6(1).Google Scholar
- Van de Wiel, L. (2015) Freezing in anticipation: Eggs for later. Women Studies International Forum 53: 119–128.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Waldby, C. (2015a) The oocyte market and social egg freezing: From scarcity to singularity. Journal of Cultural Economy 8: 275–291.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Waldby, C. (2015b). ‘Banking time’: Egg freezing and the negotiation of future fertility. Culture, Health and Sexuality 17: 470–482.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- WhatClinic.com (2015) Demand for Private Fertility Treatments in UK More than Doubles in One Year. (available at http://www.whatclinic.com/about/press/, accessed 13 September 2016).
- Wyndham, N., Figueira, P.G.M. and Patrizio, P. (2012) A persistent misperception: Assisted reproductive technology can reverse the “aged biological clock”. Fertility and Sterility 97: 1044–1047.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Zeelenberg, M. (1999) Anticipated regret, expected feedback and behavioural decision making. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 12: 93–106.CrossRefGoogle Scholar