Contesting the psychiatric framing of ME/CFS
- 338 Downloads
ME/CFS is a medically contested illness and its understanding, framing and treatment has been the subject of heated debate. This paper examines why framing the condition as a psychiatric issue—what we refer to as ‘psychiatrisation’—has been so heavily contested by patients and activists. We argue that this contestation is not simply about stigmatising mental health conditions, as some have suggested, but relates to how people diagnosed with mental illness are treated in society, psychiatry and the law. We highlight the potentially harmful consequences of psychiatrisation which can lead to people’s experiential knowledge being discredited. This stems, in part, from a psychiatric-specific form of ‘epistemic injustice’ which can result in unhelpful, unwanted and forced treatments. This understanding helps explain why the psychiatrisation of ME/CFS has become the focus of such bitter debate and why psychiatry itself has become such a significant field of contention, for both ME/CFS patients and mental health service users/survivors. Notwithstanding important differences, both reject the way psychiatry denies patient explanations and understandings, and therefore share a collective struggle for justice and legitimation. Reasons why this shared struggle has not resulted in alliances between ME and mental health activists are noted.
KeywordsMyalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS) Epistemic injustice Mental health activism Psychologisation Psychiatrisation Psychiatric field of contention
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
- Asbring, P., and A.L. Närvänen. 2002. Women’s experiences of stigma in relation to chronic fatigue syndrome and fibromyalgia. Qualitative Health Research 12: 148–160.Google Scholar
- Blease, C., and K. Geraghty. 2016b. Mind the gap: Ethical failures in the treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome. BMJ blog. http://blogs.bmj.com/medical-ethics/2016/12/06/mind-the-gap-ethical-failures-in-the-treatment-of-chronic-fatigue-syndrome/. Accessed 6 Dec 2016.
- Brindley, M. 2011. Dr Myhill is allowed to practise medicine again. http://www.meassociation.org.uk/2011/01/dr-myhill-is-allowed-to-practise-medicine-again/. Accessed 8 Jan 2011.
- Burstow, B., B.A. LeFrancois, and S. Diamond (eds.). 2014. Psychiatry disrupted: Theorizing resistance and crafting the (R)evolution. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.Google Scholar
- Crossley, N. 2006. Contesting psychiatry: Social movements in mental health. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Double, D. 2006. My tutor said to me, this talk is dangerous. Times Higher Education. https://www.timeshighereducation.com/features/my-tutor-said-to-me-this-talk-is-dangerous/202721.article. Accessed 21 Apr 2006.
- Fitzpatrick, M. 2002. The making of a new disease. The Guardian. ‘https://www.theguardian.com/education/2002/feb/07/medicalscience.healthandwellbeing. Accessed 7 Feb 2012.
- Gilderdale, K. 2011. One Last Goodbye: Sometimes only a mother’s love can help end the pain. London: Ebury Press.Google Scholar
- Hooper, R. 2006. First official UK death from chronic fatigue syndrome. New Scientist.Google Scholar
- Hossenbaccus, Z., and P.D. White. 2013. Views on the nature of chronic fatigue syndrome: Content analysis. JRSM Short Reports 2013 (4): 4.Google Scholar
- Institute of Medicine. 2015. Beyond myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome: Redefining an illness. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.Google Scholar
- Jason, L.A., R.R. Taylor, and J.A. Richman. 2002. The role of science and advocacy regarding a chronic health condition: The case of chronic fatigue syndrome. In Social psychological applications to social issues: The social psychology of politics, vol. 5, ed. V. Ottati, et al., 157–172. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.Google Scholar
- Jason, L.A. 2007. What’s in a name: Public policy implications of language. The Community Psychologist 40: 35–39.Google Scholar
- Jason, L.A., L. Nicholson, and M. Sunnquist. 2016. Patient perceptions regarding possible changes to the name and criteria for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and Myalgic Encephalomyelitis. Journal of Family Medicine & Community Health 3 (4): 1–7.Google Scholar
- Johnson, C.Y. 2015. Why the diseases that cause the most harm don’t always get the most research money. Washington Post.Google Scholar
- Kidd, I.J., and H. Carel. 2016. Epistemic injustice and illness. Journal of Applied Philosophy 3 (2): 1–19.Google Scholar
- Kitei, M. 2014. Candid conversation with Dr. Ian Lipkin. CFS Central.Google Scholar
- Liegghio, M. 2013. A denial of being: Psychiatrization as epistemic violence. In Mad matters: A critical reader in Canadian mad studies, ed. B. LeFrancois, R. Menzies, and G. Reaume, 122–129. Toronto, ON: Canadian Scholars’ Press.Google Scholar
- Lost Voices. 2008. Invest in ME. Great Britain: Wild Conversations Press.Google Scholar
- ME Association. 2015. ME/CFS/ME illness management survey results: No decisions about me without me. Patient Survey. May 2015.Google Scholar
- Millen, N. 2001. A Sociological Study of Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and the micro-politics of change in illness construction The Sociological Association of Australia Conference Health Sociology Section, Sydney University Dec 13–16th 2001.Google Scholar
- Munson, P. 2000. Stricken. Voices from the hidden epidemic of chronic fatigue syndrome. New York: The Haworth Press.Google Scholar
- National Institutes of Health (2016) Estimates of Funding for Various Research, Condition, and Disease Categories (RCDC).Google Scholar
- NICE (2007) National Institute for Clinical Excellence: Chronic fatigue syndrome/myalgic encephalomyelitis (or encephalopathy): Diagnosis and management of CFS/ME in adults and children. NHS National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence.Google Scholar
- Romme, M.A.J., S.D. Escher, J. Dillon, D. Corstens, and M. Morris. 2009. Living with voices: 50 stories of recovery. Herefordshire: PCCS Books.Google Scholar
- Scheff, T.J. 1966. Being mentally ill: A sociological theory. Chicago: Aldine.Google Scholar
- Shepherd, C. 2015. It’s time for doctors to apologise to their ME patients 07 Dec 2015 ME-patients.html.Google Scholar
- Showalter, E. 1997. Hystories: Hysterical epidemics and modern media. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
- Spandler, H. 2014. The problem of psychiatric diagnosis. In Approved Mental Health Practice: Essential themes for students and practitioners, ed. S. Matthews, P. O’Hare, and J. Hemmington, 66–85. Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
- Spandler, H. 2016. Healing the rifts between mental health workers and psychiatric survivors. http://blogs.lse.ac.uk/businessreview/2016/11/21/healing-the-rifts-between-mental-health-workers-and-psychiatric-survivors/. Accessed 21 Nov 2015.
- Steven, I.D., B. McGrath, et al. 2000. General practitioners’ beliefs, attitudes and reported actions towards chronic fatigue syndrome. Australian Family Physician 29: 80–85.Google Scholar
- Szmukler, G. 2004. Mental health legislation is discriminating and stigmatising. In Every family in the land, ed. A. Crisp. London: The Royal Society of Medicine Press.Google Scholar
- Torres-Harding, S.R., T.A. Latta, M.G. Njoku, and L.A. Jason. 2005. Chronic fatigue syndrome: Community psychologists confronting controversy 38: 11–13.Google Scholar
- Tuller, D. 2015. Trial by error the troubling case of the Pace chronic fatigue syndrome study. http://www.meassociation.org.uk/2015/10/trial-by-error-the-troubling-case-of-the-pace-chronic-fatigue-syndrome-study-final-instalment-23-october-2015/.
- Walker, M.J. 2003. Skewed: Psychiatric hegemony and the manufacture of mental illness in multiple chemical sensitivity, gulf war syndrome, myalgic encephalomyelitis and chronic fatigue syndrome. London: Slingshot Publications.Google Scholar
- Wallcraft, J., and D. Shulkes. 2012. Can psychiatry apologise for crimes against humanity? Open Mind: 12–13.Google Scholar
- Wright, N. 2016. ME affects four times as many women as men. Is that why we’re still disbelieved? The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/sep/27/me-affects-four-times-women-men-chronic-fatigue-syndrome. Accessed 27 Sept 2016.