Advertisement

Conservative soft power: liberal soft power bias and the ‘hidden’ attraction of Russia

Article

Abstract

The study of soft power in international relations suffers from a liberal democratic bias. Throughout the literature, liberal concepts and values are assumed to be universal in their appeal. This bias has led scholars to underestimate Russian soft power by instrumentalising it, that is, to see it purely as the effect of government-sponsored programmes, and to focus primarily on the cultural pillar of soft power. This paper argues, alternatively, that Russia’s conservative values and illiberal governance models generate admiration and followership, even outside of what Russia claims to be its post-Soviet sphere of influence. Crucially, this admiration and followership perform the traditional function of soft power: generating support for controversial Russian foreign policy decisions. Admitting that soft power can be based on conservative values is necessary not only to understand Russia’s foreign policy potential, but also the ability of non-Western states to challenge successfully the Western liberal order.

Keywords

conservatism liberalism russia soft power 

Notes

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank Sten Rynning, Peter Viggo Jakobsen, Chiara de Franco, Olivier Schmitt, Jon Rahbek-Clemmensen and Amelie Theussen at the Center for War Studies, University of Southern Denmark, for their insightful comments on earlier drafts of this paper. The authors would also like to thank the anonymous reviewers for their constructive engagement and comments, which we have acknowledged in the text.

References

  1. Acharya, Amitav (2014) The End of American World Order, Cambridge: Polity.Google Scholar
  2. Alduy, Cécile and Stéphane Wahnich (2015) Marine Le Pen prise aux mots: Décryptage du nouveau discours frontiste, Paris: Seuil.Google Scholar
  3. Allen-Ebrahimian, Bethany (2015) Chinese Netizens Are Cheering Putin’s Syria Campaign, Foreign Policy, http://foreignpolicy.com/2015/10/16/china-syria-putin-russia-isis-america-assad-airstrikes/ (accessed 31 March, 2016).
  4. Altunışık, Meliha Benli (2008) ‘The Possibilities and Limits of Turkey’s Soft Power in the Middle East’, Insight Turkey 10(2): 41–54.Google Scholar
  5. Amann, Melanie and Pavel Lokshin (2016) Moscow’s Fifth Column: German Populists Forge Ties with Russia, Spiegel Online, http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/german-populists-forge-deeper-ties-with-russia-a-1089562.html (accessed 13 May, 2016).
  6. Andreev, Andrei (2016) ‘“Myagkaya sila”: aranzhirovka smyslov v rossiiskom ispolnenii’ [‘Soft power’: the arrangement of meanings in Russia], Polis. Politicheskiye issledovaniya 5: 122–33.Google Scholar
  7. Arfi, Fabrice and Antoine Perraud (2015) Jean-Luc Mélenchon joue à saute-cadavre, Mediapart, https://www.mediapart.fr/journal/france/050315/jean-luc-melenchon-joue-saute-cadavre (accessed 31 March, 2016).
  8. Azar, Ilya (2015) Europe’s far right flocks to Russia International conservative forum held in St. Petersburg, Meduza, https://meduza.io/en/feature/2015/03/24/europe-s-far-right-flocks-to-russia (accessed 10 November, 2016).
  9. Bashkatova, Anastasiya (2013) Gosudarstvennyi kapitalizm v Rossii vstrevozhil Zapad [State capitalism in Russia alarmed the West], Nezavisimaya Gazeta, http://www.ng.ru/economics/2013-01-23/4_kapitalizm.html (accessed 23 March, 2016).
  10. BBC Monitoring Europe (2014) ‘Italian party leader visits Russia, Crimea, slams western sanctions’, Corriere della Sera, 13 October.Google Scholar
  11. Bechev, Dimitar (2015) Playing the Putin Card, Foreign Policy, http://foreignpolicy.com/2015/04/08/playing-the-putin-card-greece-alexis-tsipras-in-moscow/ (accessed 28 March, 2016).
  12. Beeson, Mark (2013) ‘Can China Lead?’, Third World Quarterly 34(2): 233–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Blue, Miranda (2013) Globalizing Homophobia, Part 1: How The American Right Came to Embrace Russia’s Anti-Gay Crackdown, Right Wing Watch, http://www.rightwingwatch.org/content/globalizing-homophobia-part-1-how-american-right-came-embrace-russia-s-anti-gay-crackdown (accessed 6 March, 2016).
  14. Bogomolov, Alexander and Oleksandr Lytvynenko (2012) A Ghost in the Mirror: Russian Soft Power in Ukraine, London: Chatham House.Google Scholar
  15. Boyle, Michael J. (2016) ‘The Coming Illiberal Order’, Survival 58(2): 35–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Bratersky, Maxim (2016) ‘The Evolution of National Security Thinking in Post-Soviet Russia’, Strategic Analysis 40(6): 513–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Bremmer, Charles and David Charter (2014) French Far-Right Signs Up to Take Putin’s Shilling, Times, http://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/news/world/europe/article4277142.ece (accessed 8 August, 2016).
  18. Buchanan, Patrick (2014) Whose Side Is God on Now?, Creators, https://www.creators.com/read/pat-buchanan/04/14/whose-side-is-god-on-now (accessed 10 November, 2016).
  19. Burlinova, Natalia (2015) Russian soft power is just like Western soft power, but with a twist, Russia Direct, http://www.russia-direct.org/opinion/russian-soft-power-just-western-soft-power-twist (accessed 29 March, 2016).
  20. Centre for East European Policy Studies (2009) The “Humanitarian Dimension” of Russia Foreign Policy Toward Georgia, Moldova, Ukraine, and the Baltic States, http://www.ape.md/download.php?file=cHVibGljL3B1YmxpY2F0aW9ucy84ODkxNTZfbWRfcmVzZWFyY2hfMjAwOS5wZGY%3D (accessed 26 December, 2016).
  21. Chawryło, Katarzyna (2015) The altar and the throne alliance. The Russian Orthodox Church vs. the government in Russia, Warsaw: Centre for Eastern Studies.Google Scholar
  22. Chebankova, Elena (2013) ‘Russian Fundamental Conservatism: In Search of Modernity’, Post-Soviet Affairs 29(4): 287–313.Google Scholar
  23. Chebankova, Elena (2016) ‘Contemporary Russian Conservatism’, Post-Soviet Affairs 32(1): 28–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Cho, Young Nam and Jong Ho Jeong (2008) ‘China’s Soft Power: Discussions, Resources, and Prospects’, Asian Survey 48(3): 453–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Dennison, Susi and Dina Paradijs (2016) The world according to Europe’s insurgent parties: Putin, migration and people power, European Council on Foreign Relations, http://www.ecfr.eu/page/-/ECFR_181_-_THE_WORLD_ACCORDING_TO_EUROPES_INSURGENT_PARTIES_NEW.pdf (accessed 11 December, 2016).
  26. Deutsche Welle (2015) In Dresden, Russian flags of protest against Islam and Merkel, http://www.dw.com/en/in-dresden-russian-flags-of-protest-against-islam-and-merkel/a-18865803 (accessed 3 May, 2016).
  27. Evans, Natalie, Steve Holland and Emily Stephenson (2015) Donald Trump “would back Putin 100% over Syria” but comes under fire at Republican Presidential Debate, Mirror, http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/donald-trump-would-back-putin-6808223 (accessed 10 August, 2016).
  28. Famularo, Julia (2015) The China-Russia NGO Crackdown, Diplomat, http://thediplomat.com/2015/02/the-china-russia-ngo-crackdown/ (accessed 1 June, 2016).
  29. Feklyunina, Valentina (2016) ‘Soft Power and Identity: Russia, Ukraine and the “Russian world(s)”’, European Journal of International Relations 22(4): 773–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Francetv Info (2014) Marine Le Pen dit partager des “valeurs communes” avec Poutine, http://www.francetvinfo.fr/monde/europe/marine-le-pen-dit-partager-des-valeurs-communes-avec-poutine_603281.html (accessed 12 March, 2016).
  31. Front National (2012) UDT 2012 – La Baule : Discours de Marine Le Pen, http://www.frontnational.com/videos/udt-2012-la-baule-intervention-de-marine-le-pen/ (accessed 12 March, 2016).
  32. Fronte Nazionale (2013) Io Sto Con Putin! [I’m with Putin], http://www.frontenazionale.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=82:io-sto-con-putin&catid=41:manifesti&Itemid=760 (accessed 10 November, 2016).
  33. Gerber, Theodore P. and Jane Zavisca (2016) ‘Does Russian Propaganda Work?’, Washington Quarterly 39(2): 79–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Global Times (2014) China’s Putin fever, http://www.globaltimes.cn/content/868575.shtml (accessed 13 February, 2016).
  35. Graham, David A (2016) The Right’s Putin Derangement Syndrome, Atlantic, http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/09/trumps-24-hours-of-putinphilia/499310/ (accessed 10 November, 2016).
  36. Grigas, Agnia (2012) Legacies, Coercion and Soft Power: Russian Influence in the Baltic States, London: Chatham House.Google Scholar
  37. Hall, Ian and Frank Smith (2013) ‘The Struggle for Soft Power in Asia: Public Diplomacy and Regional Competition’, Asian Security 9(1): 1–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Hanson, Stephen E. (2007) ‘The uncertain future of Russia’s weak state authoritarianism’, East European Politics & Societies 21(1): 67–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Hart, Andrew F. and Bruce D. Jones (2010) ‘How do Rising Powers Rise?’, Survival 52(6): 63–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Hawkins, Ross (2016) Around 50% “hold authoritarian views”, BBC News, http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/amp/36043219 (accessed 10 August, 2016).
  41. Herbert, Dean (2014) ‘Salmond: Why I Admire Putin’, Scottish Express, 28 April, 1.Google Scholar
  42. Hill, Fiona (2006) ‘Moscow Discovers Soft Power’, Current History 105(693): 341–47.Google Scholar
  43. Hooper, Melissa and Grigory Frolov (2016) Russia’s Bad Example, Washington: Free Russia Foundation and Human Rights First.Google Scholar
  44. Horvath, Robert (2016) ‘The Reinvention of “Traditional Values”: Nataliya Narotschnitskaya and Russia’s Assault on Universal Human Rights’, Europe-Asia Studies 68(5): 868–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Huang, Yanzhong and Sheng Ding (2006) ‘Dragon’s Underbelly: An Analysis of China’s Soft Power’, East Asia 23(4): 22–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Ikenberry, G. John (2008) ‘The rise of China and the future of the West: can the liberal system survive?’, Foreign Affairs 87(1): 23–37.Google Scholar
  47. Ikenberry, G. John (2010) ‘The liberal international order and its discontents’, Millennium 38(3): 509–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Ikenberry, G. John (2014) Power, Order, and Change in World Politics, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Ioffe, Julia (2010) ‘What Is Russia Today? The Kremlin’s propaganda outlet has an identity crisis’, Columbia Journalism Review, http://www.cjr.org/feature/what_is_russia_today.php (accessed 12 March, 2016).
  50. Jackson, Nicole J. (2010) ‘The role of external factors in advancing nonliberal democratic forms of political rule: a case study of Russia’s influence on Central Asian regimes’, Contemporary Politics 16(1): 101–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Jaffré, Yannick (2014) Vladimir Bonaparte Poutine: Essai sur la naissance des républiques, Paris: Perspectives Libres.Google Scholar
  52. Jobbik (2013a) Gábor Vona had a lecture at Lomonosov University in Russia, http://www.jobbik.com/g%C3%A1bor_vona_had_lecture_lomonosov_university_russia (accessed 10 November, 2016).
  53. Jobbik (2013b) Gábor Vona: Euro-Atlanticism must be replaced by Eurasianism, http://www.jobbik.com/g%C3%A1bor_vona_euro-atlanticism_must_be_replaced_eurasianism (accessed 14 November, 2016).
  54. Kalin, İbrahim (2011) ‘Soft Power and Public Diplomacy in Turkey’, Perceptions 16(3): 5–23.Google Scholar
  55. Karaganov, Sergey (2014) My Vernulis’ V XIX Vek, New Times, http://newtimes.ru/stati/temyi/e31289584a822bf60e7be9c742493c85-sergei-karaganov-mi-vernylus-v-xix-vek.html (accessed 3 November, 2016).
  56. Kastouéva-Jean, Tatiana (2010) “ Soft power’ russe: discours, outils, impact, IFRI, http://www.ifri.org/sites/default/files/atoms/files/ifrikastuevajeanrussiasoftpoweroct2010.pdf (accessed 26 December, 2016).
  57. Kiseleva, Yulia (2015) ‘Russia’s Soft Power Discourse: Identity, Status and the Attraction of Power’, Politics 35(3–4): 316–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Kosachev, Konstantin (2012) The Specifics of Russian Soft Power, Russia in Global Affairs, http://eng.globalaffairs.ru/number/The-Specifics-of-Russian-Soft-Power-15683 (accessed 6 March, 2015).
  59. Krekó, Péter, Lóránt Győri and Attila Juhász (2015) ‘Russia’s Far-Right Friends in Europe-Hungary’, Russian Analytical Digest 167.Google Scholar
  60. Kudors, Andis (2010) ‘Russia’s Soft Power Approach to Compatriots Policy’, Russian Analytical Digest 81: 2–4.Google Scholar
  61. Kupchan, Charles (2014) ‘The normative foundations of hegemony and the coming challenge to Pax Americana’, Security Studies 23(2): 219–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Lankina, Tomila and Kinga Niemczyk (2015) ‘Russia’s Foreign Policy and Soft Power’, in David Cadier and Margot Light, eds, Russia’s Foreign Policy. Ideas, Domestic Politics and External Relations, 97–113, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
  63. Laruelle, Marlene (2015a) ‘Russia’s bedfellowing policy and the European far right’, Russian Analytical Digest 167.Google Scholar
  64. Laruelle, Marlene (2015b) The “Russian World”. Russia’s Soft Power and Geopolitical Imagination, Center on Global Interests, http://globalinterests.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/FINAL-CGI_Russian-World_Marlene-Laruelle.pdf (accessed 19 September, 2016).
  65. Layne, Christopher (2010) ‘The Unbearable Lightness of Soft Power’, in Inderjeet Parmar and Michael Cox, eds, Soft Power and US Foreign Policy: Theoretical, Historical and Contemporary Perspectives, 51–82, Milton Park: Routledge.Google Scholar
  66. Le Monde (2014) Marine Le Pen salue Vladimir Poutine avec qui elle défend des “valeurs communes”, http://www.lemonde.fr/europeennes-2014/article/2014/05/18/marine-le-pen-salue-vladimir-poutine-avec-qui-elle-defend-des-valeurs-communes_4420810_4350146.html (accessed 31 March, 2015).
  67. Leichtova, Magda (2014) Misunderstanding Russia, Farnham: Ashgate.Google Scholar
  68. Lo, Bobo (2015) Russia and the New World Disorder, London: Chatham House.Google Scholar
  69. Makarychev, Andrei and Stefano Bragiroli (2016) ‘Rossiya i ee ponimayushchiye soyuzniki: Diskursy, kommunikatsiya, posledstviya’ [Russia and its understanding allies: discourses, communication and consequences], PONARS Policy Memo 435.Google Scholar
  70. Malone, David M. (2011) ‘Soft Power in Indian Foreign Policy’, Economic & Political Weekly 46(36): 35–39.Google Scholar
  71. Manners, Ian (2002) ‘Normative power Europe: a contradiction in terms?’, JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 40(2): 235–58.Google Scholar
  72. Manning, Luke (2006) ‘One-on-One with George Galloway’, Moscow News, 10 March, 8.Google Scholar
  73. Mantyla, Kyle (2013) Fischer: Russia’s Anti-Gay Law Is Exactly The Sort Of “Public Policy That We’ve Been Advocating”, Right Wing Watch, http://www.rightwingwatch.org/content/fischer-russias-anti-gay-law-exactly-sort-public-policy-weve-been-advocating#sthash.kXcB0g71.dpuf (accessed 19 March, 2016).
  74. Martin, James (2016) Donald Trump to Viktor Orbán: What’s the appeal of “respectable extremists”?, openDemocracy, https://www.opendemocracy.net/james-martin/attractions-of-respectable-extremism (accessed 5 June, 2016).
  75. Martin, Jonathan and Amy Chozick (2016) Donald Trump’s Campaign Stands By Embrace of Putin, New York Times, http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/09/us/politics/hillary-clinton-donald-trump-putin.html (accessed 10 November, 2016).
  76. Meyers, Steven Lee (2016) Trump’s Love for Putin: a Presidential Role Model, New York Times, http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/09/us/politics/donald-trump-vladimir-putin.html (accessed 10 November, 2016).
  77. Milić, Jelena (2016) Eyes Wide Shut: Russian Soft Power Gaining Strength in Serbia: Goals, Instruments, and Effects, Center for Euro-Atlantic Studies, https://www.ceas-serbia.org/images/publikacije/CEAS_Studija_-_%C5%A0irom_zatvorenih_o%C4%8Diju__ENG.pdf (accessed 26 December, 2016).
  78. Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation (2013) Concept of the Foreign Policy of the Russian Federation, http://www.mid.ru/en/foreign_policy/official_documents/-/asset_publisher/CptICkB6BZ29/content/id/122186 (accessed 12 February, 2013).
  79. Morozova, Natalia (2009) ‘Geopolitics, Eurasianism and Russian Foreign Policy Under Putin’, Geopolitics 14(4): 667–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Mudde, Cas (2016) On Extremism and Democracy in Europe, London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  81. Narlikar, Amrita (2013) ‘Negotiating the rise of new powers’, International Affairs 89(3): 561–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Nikitin, Vadim (2016) ‘From Russia with love – how Putin is winning over hearts and minds’, National, 4 February.Google Scholar
  83. Nye Jr., Joseph S. (2004) Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics, New York: Public Affairs.Google Scholar
  84. Nye Jr., Joseph S. (2008) ‘Public Diplomacy and Soft Power’, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 616: 94–109.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Nye Jr., Joseph S. (2013) What China and Russia Don’t Get About Soft Power, Foreign Policy, http://foreignpolicy.com/2013/04/29/what-china-and-russia-dont-get-about-soft-power/ (accessed 6 March, 2016).
  86. Orbán, Viktor (2014) Prime Minister Viktor Orbán’s Speech at the 25th Bálványos Summer Free University and Student Camp, http://www.kormany.hu/en/the-prime-minister/the-prime-minister-s-speeches/prime-minister-viktor-orban-s-speech-at-the-25th-balvanyos-summer-free-university-and-student-camp (accessed 12 July, 2016).
  87. Pabst, Adrian (2016) ‘Is Liberal Democracy Sliding into “Democratic Despotism”?’, Political Quarterly 87(1): 91–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. Page, Jeremy (2014) ‘Why Russia’s President Is “Putin the Great” in China’, Wall Street Journal, 1 October.Google Scholar
  89. Pearce, James (2015) Putin’s Western Popularity Explained, ReadRussia, http://readrussia.com/2015/11/10/putins-western-popularity-explained/ (accessed 2 March, 2016).
  90. Pengelly, Martin and Lauren Gambino (2016) Clinton blames Russia for DNC hack as Trump seems to back annex of Crimea, Guardian, https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/jul/31/clinton-blaming-russia-emails-dnc-hack (accessed 8 August, 2016).
  91. Pickering, Adam and John Holm (2014) Hungary’s Crackdown on NGOs – Part of Global Trend, Nonprofit Quarterly, http://nonprofitquarterly.org/2014/10/16/hungary-s-illiberal-crackdown-on-foreign-funding-of-ngos/ (accessed 31 March, 2016).
  92. Polis Journal (2013) ‘Obraz Rossii: defitsit myagkoi sily. Kruglyi stol zhurnala Polis’ [The image of Russia: a soft power deficit. Polis journal round table], Polis. Politicheskiye issledovaniya 4: 88–99.Google Scholar
  93. Polyakova, Alina (2014) ‘Strange bedfellows: Putin and Europe’s far right’, World Affairs 177(3): 36–41.Google Scholar
  94. Polyakova, Alina (2016a) Putinism and the European Far Right, Institute of Modern Russia, http://imrussia.org/en/analysis/world/2500-putinism-and-the-european-far-right (accessed 12 December, 2016).
  95. Polyakova, Alina (2016b) Why Europe Is Right to Fear Putin’s Useful Idiots, Foreign Policy, http://foreignpolicy.com/2016/02/23/why-europe-is-right-to-fear-putins-useful-idiots/ (accessed 13 May, 2016).
  96. Pomerantsev, Peter (2015) ‘The Kremlin’s Information War’, Journal of Democracy 26(4): 40–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  97. Popescu, Nicu (2006) Russia’s Soft power Ambitions, Brussels: Centre for European Policy Studies.Google Scholar
  98. Popescu, Nicu and Andrew Wilson (2009) The Limits of Enlargement-Lite: European and Russian Power in the Troubled Neighbourhood, European Council on Foreign Relations, http://www.ecfr.eu/page/-/ECFR14_The_Limits_of_Enlargement-Lite._European_and_Russian_Power_in_the_Troubled_Neighbourhood.pdf (accessed 26 December, 2016).
  99. Prentice, Alessandra (2014) France’s Le Pen, in Moscow, blames EU for new “Cold War”, Reuters, http://www.reuters.com/article/us-ukraine-crisis-le-pen-russia-idUSBREA3B09I20140412 (accessed 13 May, 2016).
  100. Putin, Vladimir (2012a) Meeting with Russian ambassadors and permanent representatives in international organisations, http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/15902 (accessed 2 April, 2016).
  101. Putin, Vladimir (2012b) Rossiya i meniyayushchiisiya mir [Russia and the changing world], Moskovskiie Novosti, http://www.mn.ru/politics/78738 (accessed 2 April, 2016).
  102. Putin, Vladimir (2013) Presidential Address to the Federal Assembly, http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/19825 (accessed 2 April, 2016).
  103. Putin, Vladimir (2014a) Reception to mark National Unity Day, http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/46916 (accessed 13 April, 2016).
  104. Putin, Vladimir (2014b) Security Council Meeting, http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/46305 (accessed 14 April, 2016).
  105. Putin, Vladimir (2015a) 70th session of the UN General Assembly, Russian Federation, http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/50385 (accessed 14 April, 2016).
  106. Putin, Vladimir (2015b) Gala reception marking Heroes of the Fatherland Day, http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/50901 (accessed 14 April, 2016).
  107. Reuters (2016) Donald Trump Would Consider Alliance with Russia’s Vladimir Putin Against ISIS, Newsweek, http://europe.newsweek.com/donald-trump-vladimir-putin-isis-syria-iraq-moscow-islamic-state-democratic-483826 (accessed 10 August, 2016).
  108. Reuters (2015) Hungary PM rapped by Romania over territorial “revisionism”, http://www.reuters.com/article/us-romania-hungary-idUSKCN0Q113T20150727 (accessed 31 March, 2016).
  109. Reuters (2014) Orban renews autonomy call for ethnic Hungarians in Ukraine, http://www.reuters.com/article/us-ukraine-crisis-hungary-autonomy-idUSBREA4G04520140517 (accessed 31 March, 2016).
  110. Rogin, Josh (2016) Trump campaign guts GOP’s anti-Russia stance on Ukraine, Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/global-opinions/trump-campaign-guts-gops-anti-russia-stance-on-ukraine/2016/07/18/98adb3b0-4cf3-11e6-a7d8-13d06b37f256_story.html (accessed 10 August, 2016).
  111. Romanova, Tatiana (2016) ‘Russian Challenge to the EU’s Normative Power: Change and Continuity’, Europe-Asia Studies 68(3): 371–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  112. Roselle, Laura, Alister Miskimmon and Ben O’Loughlin (2014) ‘Strategic narrative: A new means to understand soft power’, Media, War & Conflict 7(1): 70–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  113. Rossiiskaya Federatsiya (2013) Vneseny izmeneniya v zakon o zashchite detei ot informatsii, prichinyayushchei vred ikh zdorov’yu i razvitiyu [Amendments to the law on the protection of children from information that causes harm to their health and development], http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/18423 (accessed 12 December, 2016).
  114. RT (2016) Merkel agreement with Turkish President Erdogan “real treason” – Marine Le Pen, https://www.rt.com/news/339477-erdogan-treason-le-pen/ (accessed 13 May, 2016).
  115. Rukhadze, Vasili (2016) Russia’s Soft Power in Georgia: How Does It Work?, Eurasia Daily Monitor, http://www.jamestown.org/single/?tx_ttnews%5Btt_news%5D=45116 (accessed 25 March, 2016).
  116. RWW News (2015) Bryan Fischer Again Calls For Enacting Russian-Style Anti-Gay “Propaganda” Laws, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZTzL-dQ358 (accessed 3 November, 2016).
  117. Sadecki, Andrzej (2016) Orban in Moscow: it’s not only about energy, OSW Analysis, Centre for Eastern Studies, https://www.osw.waw.pl/en/publikacje/analyses/2016-02-24/orban-moscow-its-not-only-about-energy (accessed 30 March, 2016).
  118. Savino, Giovanni (2015) ‘The Italian russophile rightist parties: a new love for Moscow?’, Russian Analytical Digest 167.Google Scholar
  119. Schmitt, Olivier (2016) Pourquoi Poutine est notre Allié? Anatomie d’une Passion Française [Why is Putin our Ally? The anatomy of a French passion], Lille: Hikari Éditions.Google Scholar
  120. Sergunin, Alexander and Leonid Karabeshkin (2015) ‘Understanding Russia’s Soft Power Strategy’, Politics 35(3–4):347–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  121. Shekhovtsov, Anton (2014) The Kremlin’s marriage of convenience with the European far right, Open Democracy, https://www.opendemocracy.net/od-russia/anton-shekhovtsov/kremlin%E2%80%99s-marriage-of-convenience-with-european-far-right (accessed 31 March, 2016).
  122. Sherr, James (2013) Hard Diplomacy and Soft Coercion, Washington: Brookings Institution Press.Google Scholar
  123. Sierakowski, Slawomir (2014) Putin’s Useful Idiots, New York Times, http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/29/opinion/sierakowski-putins-useful-idiots.html (accessed 13 May, 2016).
  124. Skriba, Andrei (2016) ‘Russian Strategy towards the Post-Soviet Space in Europe: Searching for Balance between Economy, Security, and Great Power Attractiveness’, Strategic Analysis 40(6): 604–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  125. Snyder, Timothy (2016) Trump’s Putin Fantasy, New York Review of Books, http://www.nybooks.com/daily/2016/04/19/trumps-putin-fantasy/ (accessed 13 May, 2016).
  126. Sputnik International (2015a) Marine Le Pen Accused US for Trying to Discredit Actions of Vladimir Putin, http://sputniknews.com/politics/20151001/1027871070/france-party-leader-accused-us-anti-russian-propaganda.html (accessed 13 May, 2016).
  127. Sputnik International (2015b) A Question of Trust: Serbia Prefers “Alpha” Putin Over Own Prime Minister, http://sputniknews.com/europe/20151123/1030614543/serbia-trust-putin-leader.html (accessed 31 March, 2016).
  128. Suzuki, Shogo (2009) ‘Chinese Soft Power, Insecurity Studies, Myopia and Fantasy’, Third World Quarterly 30(4): 779–93.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  129. Tafuro, Eleonora (2014) ‘Fatal attraction? Russia’s soft power in its neighbourhood’, FRIDE Policy Brief 181.Google Scholar
  130. Tandon, Aakriti (2016) ‘Transforming the Unbound Elephant to the Lovable Asian Hulk: Why is Modi Leveraging India’s Soft Power?’, Round Table 105(1): 57–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  131. Tétrault-Farber, Gabrielle (2014) Far-Right Europe Has a Crush on Moscow, Moscow Times, http://www.themoscowtimes.com/news/article/far-right-europe-has-a-crush-on-moscow/511827.html (accessed 12 March, 2016).
  132. Tsygankov, Andrei P. (2006) ‘If not by tanks, then by banks? The role of soft power in Putins foreign policy’, Europe-Asia Studies 58(7): 1079–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  133. Venice Commission (2011) Opinion on the new Constitution of Hungary, adopted by the Venice Commission at its 87th Plenary Session (Venice, 17 and 18 June, 2011), edited by European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commisson).Google Scholar
  134. Vojtíšková, Vladislava, Vít Novotný, Hubertus Schmid-Schmidsfelden and Potapova Potapova (2016) The Bear in Sheep’s Clothing: Russia’s Government-Funded Organisations in the EU, Brussels: Wilfried Martens Centre for European Studies.Google Scholar
  135. Walker, Christopher (2016) ‘The Hijacking of “Soft Power”’, Journal of Democracy 27(1): 49–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  136. Wilson, Jeanne L. (2015a) ‘Russia and China Respond to Soft Power: Interpretation and Readaptation of a Western Construct’, Politics 35(3–4): 287–300.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  137. Wilson, Jeanne L. (2015b) ‘Soft Power: A Comparison of Discourse and Practice in Russia and China’, Europe-Asia Studies 67(8): 1171–202.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  138. Worldwide Independent Network of Market Research and Gallaup International (2015) Two Global Leaders with Very Different Global Perceptions, http://www.wingia.com/web/files/richeditor/filemanager/Final_WINGIA_GLOBAL_Leaders_release_4.pdf (accessed 8 May, 2016).
  139. Yi, Xing (2014) Readers of Leaders, China Daily USA, http://usa.chinadaily.com.cn/epaper/2014-10/29/content_18821695.htm (accessed 31 March, 2016).

Copyright information

© Macmillan Publishers Ltd 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  • Vincent Charles Keating
    • 1
  • Katarzyna Kaczmarska
    • 2
  1. 1.Center for War StudiesUniversity of Southern DenmarkOdenseDenmark
  2. 2.Department of International PoliticsAberystwyth UniversityCeredigionUK

Personalised recommendations