Advertisement

Rights of Pachamama: The emergence of an earth jurisprudence in the Americas

  • David HumphreysEmail author
Article

Abstract

Earth jurisprudence represents an alternative approach to the law based on the belief that nature has rights. In this view, a river has the right to flow, species have the right to continue to exist in the wild, and ecosystems have the right to adapt and evolve over time. Proponents of Earth jurisprudence argue that, by treating nature as exploitable resources, contemporary legal systems actively promote environmental harms. Recognising rights of nature, they argue, will transform core values and inspire social changes that promote economic development which respects nature’s limits. Since 2006, rights of nature have been recognised by some sub-federal public bodies in the United States and by the governments of Ecuador and Bolivia. This paper sets out to answer two questions. First, what explains the legal recognition of rights of nature in Ecuador and Bolivia? Second, what factors impede a wider adoption and implementation of Earth jurisprudence? Amongst the constraints, it will be argued, is that Ecuador and Bolivia continue to pursue an extractivist economic development model, with assertions of national sovereignty over natural resources tending to prevail over Earth jurisprudence and environmental conservation.

Keywords

buen vivir ethnopopulism neoliberalism Pachamama rights of nature sovereignty 

Notes

Acknowledgments

The author is grateful to three anonymous referees whose incisive and supportive criticisms and suggestions for additional source material greatly improved an earlier draft of this paper.

References

  1. Agostino, Ana and Franziska Dübgen (2012) ‘Buen vivir and beyond: Searching for a new paradigm of action’, paper presented at the Degrowth Conference, workshop ‘Real Utopias: From Solidarity to the Buen Vivir’, available at http://www.venezia2012.it/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/WS_55_AGOSTINO-DUEBGEN.pdf (accessed 1 July, 2015).
  2. Aguirre, Jessica Camille and Elizabeth Sonia Cooper (2010) ‘Evo Morales, climate change and the paradoxes of a social movement presidency’, Latin American Perspectives 37(4): 238–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Albro, Robert (2010) ‘Confounding cultural citizenship and constitutional reform in Bolivia’, Latin American Perspectives 37(3): 71–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Alexander, Samuel (2014) ‘Wild law from below: Examining the anarchist challenge to earth jurisprudence’, in Michelle Maloney and Peter Burdon, eds, Wild lawIn practice, 31–44, Abingdon: Routledge.Google Scholar
  5. Amin, Samir (1977) Imperialism and Unequal Development, New York: Monthly Review Press.Google Scholar
  6. Andolina, Robert (2003) ‘The sovereign and its shadow: Constituent assembly and indigenous movement in Ecuador’, Journal of Latin American Studies 35(4): 721–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Angotti, Thomas (1981) ‘The political implications of dependency theory’, Latin American Perspectives 8(3–4): 124–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Arsel, Murat (2012) ‘Between “Marx and markets”? The state, the “left turn” and nature in Ecuador’, Tijdschrift voor Economische en Social Geografie (Journal of Economic and Social Geography) 103(2): 150–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Atkinson, Adrian (1991) Principles of political ecology, Chichester: John Wiley and Sons.Google Scholar
  10. Bassi, Michelle P. (2009) ‘La Naturaleza O Pacha Mama de Ecuador: What Doctrine Should Grant Trees Standing?’ Oregon Review of International Law 11: 461–77.Google Scholar
  11. Baude, Patrick L. (1973) ‘Sierra Club v. Morton: Standing trees in a thicket of justiciability’, Indiana Law Journal 48(2): 197–215.Google Scholar
  12. BBC (2013) ‘Bolivian President Evo Morales expels USAID’, BBC, 1 May, available at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-latin-america-22371275 (accessed 3 July, 2015).
  13. Bebbington, Anthony and Denise Humphreys Bebbington (2011) ‘An Andean Avatar: Post-Neoliberal and Neoliberal Strategies for Securing the Unobtainable’, New Political Economy 16(1): 131–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Becker, Marc (2011) ‘Correa, indigenous movements, and the writing of a new constitution in Ecuador’, Latin American Perspectives 38(1): 47–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Becker, Marc (2013) ‘The stormy relations between Rafael Correa and social movements in Ecuador’, Latin American Perspectives 40(3): 43–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Bello, Alvaro (2004) Etnicidad y ciudadanía en América Latina: La acción colectiva de los pueblos indígenas, Santiago: CEPAL.Google Scholar
  17. Berry, Thomas (1999) The great work: Our way into the future, New York: Bell Tower.Google Scholar
  18. Berry, Thomas (2006) Evening thoughts: Reflecting on Earth as sacred community, edited by Mary Evelyn Tucker, San Francisco: Sierra Club.Google Scholar
  19. Berry, Thomas (2011) ‘Rights of the earth: We need a new legal framework which recognises the rights of all living beings’, in Peter Burdon, ed., Exploring Wild Law: The Philosophy of Earth Jurisprudence, 227–29, Kent Town, Australia: Wakefield.Google Scholar
  20. Bodenheimer, Susanne (1971) ‘Dependency and Underdevelopment: The Roots of Latin American Underdevelopment’, Politics and Society 1(3): 327–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Bolivia Law of the Rights of Mother Earth (2010) English translation, World Future Fund, available at http://www.worldfuturefund.org/Projects/Indicators/motherearthbolivia.html (accessed 7 July, 2015). Spanish version available at http://www.planificacion.gob.bo/sites/folders/marco-legal/Ley%20N%C2%B0%20071%20DERECHOS%20DE%20LA%20MADRE%20TIERRA.pdf (accessed 7 July, 2015).
  22. Bowen, James D. (2011) ‘Multicultural market democracy: elites and indigenous movements in contemporary Ecuador’, Journal of Latin American Studies 43: 451–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Burbach, Roger, Michael Fox and Federico Fuentes (2013) Latin America’s turbulent transitions: the future of twenty-first century socialism, London: Zed.Google Scholar
  24. Carruthers, David V. (2008) ‘Introduction: Popular environmentalism and social justice in Latin America’, in David V. Carruthers, ed., Environmental Justice in Latin America: Problems, Promise and Practice, 1–22, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund (CELDF) (2006) ‘Tamaqua Borough corporate waste and local control ordinance’, available at http://www.celdf.org/article.php?id=439 (accessed 27 June, 2015).
  26. Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund (CELDF) (2008) ‘CELDF assists Ecuador Constitutional Assembly’, available at http://celdf.org/-1-4 (accessed 5 July, 2015).
  27. Constitution of the Plurinational State of Bolivia (2009) translated by L. Francisco Valle V, printed in San Bernadino, California, Spanish version available at http://pdba.georgetown.edu/constitutions/bolivia/bolivia09.html (accessed 5 July, 2015).
  28. Constitution of the Republic of Ecuador (2008) English translation from Political Database of the Americas, Georgetown University, available at http://pdba.georgetown.edu/Constitutions/Ecuador/english08.html (accessed 5 July, 2015), Spanish version available at http://pdba.georgetown.edu/Constitutions/Ecuador/ecuador08.html (accessed 5 July, 2015).
  29. Cullinan, Cormac (2002) Wild law: Governing people for earth, Claremont, South Africa: SiberInk.Google Scholar
  30. Cullinan, Cormac (2011) ‘A history of wild law’, in Peter Burdon, ed., Exploring wild law: The philosophy of earth jurisprudence, 12–23, Kent Town, Australia: Wakefield.Google Scholar
  31. Daly, Erin (2012) ‘The Ecuadorian exemplar: The first ever vindications of constitutional rights of nature’, Review of European Community and International Environmental Law (RECIEL), 21(1): 63–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Dellert, Christine (2010) ‘Protecting the “other”: Ecological citizenship under Ecuador’s constitution’, International Journal of Environmental, Cultural, Economic and Social Sustainability 6(6): 117–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Drake, Paul W. (2005) ‘The hegemony of U.S. economic doctrines in Latin America’, in Valpy Fitzgerald and Rosemary Thorp, eds, Economic Doctrines in Latin America: Origins, Embedding and Evolution, 72–96, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
  34. Eckstein, Susan Eva and Timothy P. Wickham-Crowley (2003) ‘Struggles for justice in Latin America’, in Susan Eva Eckstein and Timothy P. Wickham Crowley, eds, What Justice? Whose Justice: Fighting for fairness in Latin America, 1–32, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  35. Farthing, Linda (2009) ‘Bolivia’s Dilemma: Development confronts the legacy of extraction’, NACLA Report on the Americas September/October: 25–40.Google Scholar
  36. Flores-Macias, Gustavo A. (2012) After Neoliberalism? The Left and Economic reforms in Latin America, Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Fontana, Lorenza Belinda (2013) ‘On the Perils and Potentialities of Revolution: Conflict and Collective Action in Contemporary Bolivia’, Latin American Perspectives 40(3): 26–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Frank, Andre Gunder (1966) ‘The development of underdevelopment’, Monthly Review 18(4): 17–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Frank, Andre Gunder (1969) Latin America: Underdevelopment or RevolutionEssays on the Development of Underdevelopment and the Immediate Enemy, New York: Monthly Review Press.Google Scholar
  40. Gaia Foundation (2015) ‘Earth jurisprudence – Earth law’, Gaia Foundation, available at http://www.gaiafoundation.org/earth-centred-law (accessed 20 July, 2015).
  41. Gaillard, Emmanuel (2007) ‘The denunciation of the ICSID Convention’, New York Law Journal 237(122), 26 June, available at http://www.shearman.com/files/Publication/a4ce24f1-83de-445d-a50a-b82baf2f89fc/Presentation/PublicationAttachment/ce3cbe9a-ca49-4eaa-b3f5-d0a26ba0680c/IA_NYLJ%20Denunciation%20ICSID%20Convention_040308_17.pdf (accessed 16 July, 2015).
  42. Galeano, Eduardo (1973) Open Veins of Latin America: Five Centuries of the Pillage of a Continent, London: Serpent’s Tail.Google Scholar
  43. Galtung, Johan (1971) ‘A structural theory of imperialism’, Journal of Peace Research 8(2): 81–117.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Gill, Sam D. (1987) Mother Earth: An American story, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  45. Global Alliance for the Rights of Nature (2013) ‘Ecuador government dissolves Fundación Pachamama’, Global Alliance for the Rights of Nature, 6 December, available at http://therightsofnature.org/latin-america/support-fundacion-pachamama/ (12 July, 2015).
  46. Goodin, Robert E. (1992) Green political theory, Cambridge: Polity.Google Scholar
  47. Graham, Nicole (2011) ‘Owning the earth’, in Peter Burdon, ed., Exploring wild law: The philosophy of earth jurisprudence, 259–69, Kent Town, Australia: Wakefield.Google Scholar
  48. Green Left Weekly (2006) ‘Bolivia: From neoliberalism to a homeland for all’ [excerpts from speech by Evo Morales], available at https://www.greenleft.org.au/node/34404 (accessed 12 July, 2015).
  49. Gudynas, Eduardo (2011) ‘Buen vivir: Today’s tomorrow’, Development 54(4): 441–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Gustafson, Bret (2009) ‘Manipulating cartographies: Plurinationalism, autonomy, and indigenous resurgence in Bolivia’, Anthropological Quarterly 82(4): 985–1016.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Gustafson, Bret (2010) ‘When states act like movements: Dismantling local power and seating sovereignty in post-neoliberal Bolivia’, Latin American Perspectives 37(4): 48–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Hale, Charles R. (1994) ‘Between Che Guevara and the Pachamama: Mestizos, Indians and identity politics in the anti-quincentenary campaign’, Critique of Anthropology 14(1): 9–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Harvey, David (1996) Justice, Nature and the Geography of Difference, Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
  54. Hey, Jeanne A.K. and Thomas Klak (1999) ‘From protectionism towards neoliberalism: Ecuador across four administrations (1981–1996)’, Studies in Comparative International Development 34(3): 66–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Higginbottom, Andy (2013) ‘The political economy of foreign investment in Latin America: Dependency revisited’, Latin American Perspectives 190(40): 184–206.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Hills, Jill (1994) ‘Dependency theory and its relevance today. International institutions in telecommunications and structural power’, Review of International Studies 20(2): 169–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Hippolyte, Antonius R. (2012) ‘Negative environmental sovereignty in the third world: A TWAIL analysis of ICSID’s disregard for environmental justice in the south’, Social Sciences Research Network, available at http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2124645 (accessed 15 July, 2015).
  58. Hochstetler, Kathryn and Margaret E. Keck (2007) Greening Brazil: Environmental activism in state and society, Durham: Duke University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Hogan, Marguerite (2007) ‘Standing for nonhuman animals: Developing a guardianship model from the dissents in Sierra Club v. Morton’, California Law Review 95(2): 513–34.Google Scholar
  60. Inter-American Court of Human Rights (2012) Case of the Kichwa indigenous people of Sarayaku v. Ecuador, available at http://www.escr-net.org/sites/default/files/Court%20Decision%20_English_.pdf (accessed 16 July, 2015).
  61. Karl, Terry Lynn (2003) ‘The vicious cycle of inequality in Latin America’, in Susan Eva Eckstein and Timothy P. Wickham-Crowley, eds, What Justice? Whose Justice: Fighting for Fairness in Latin America, 133–57, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  62. Kay, Cristóbal, ed. (1989) Latin American theories of development and underdevelopment, London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  63. Keck, Margaret E. and Kathryn Sikkink (1998) Activists Beyond Borders: Advocacy Networks in International Politics, Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
  64. Kennard, Matt (2015) The racket: A rogue reporter versus the masters of the universe, London: Zed.Google Scholar
  65. Kennemore, Amy and Gregory Weeks (2011) ‘Twenty-first century socialism? The elusive search for a post-neoliberal development model in Bolivia and Ecuador’, Bulletin of Latin American Research 30(3): 267–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Kohl, Benjamin and Rosalind Bresnahan (2010) ‘Introduction: Bolivia under Morales – National agenda, regional challenges and the struggle for hegemony’, Latin American Perspectives 37(4): 5–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Kohl, Benjamin and Linda Farthing (2012) ‘Material constraints to popular imaginaries: The extractive economy and resource nationalism in Bolivia’, Political Geography 31: 225–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Koons, Judith E. (2008) ‘Earth jurisprudence: The moral value of nature’, Pace Environmental Law Review 25: 1–77.Google Scholar
  69. Koons, Judith E. (2009) ‘What is earth jurisprudence? Key principles to transform law for the health of the planet’, Penn State Environmental Law Review 18: 47–69.Google Scholar
  70. Koons, Judith E. (2012) ‘At the tipping point: Defining an Earth jurisprudence for social and ecological justice’, Loyola Law Review 58: 349–90.Google Scholar
  71. Leopold, Aldo (1949) A sand county almanacand sketches here and there, Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  72. Lucero, José Antonio (2009) ‘Decades lost and won: Indigenous movements and multicultural neoliberalism in the Andes’, in John Burdick, Philip Oxhorn and Kenneth M Roberts, eds, Beyond neoliberalism in Latin America: Societies and Politics at the Crossroads, 63–81, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
  73. Madrid, Raúl L. (2012) The Rise of Ethnic Politics in Latin America, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Madrid, Raúl L., Wendy Hunter and Kurt Weyland (2010) ‘The policies and performance of the contestatory and moderate left’, in Kurt Weyland, Raúl Madrid and Wendy Hunter, eds, Leftist governments in Latin America: Successes and shortcomings, 140–80, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Maloney, Michelle (2014) ‘Ecological limits, planetary boundaries and earth jurisprudence’, in Michelle Maloney and Peter Burdon, eds, Wild lawIn practice, 193–212, Abingdon: Routledge.Google Scholar
  76. Mamani-Bernabé, Vicenta (2015) ‘Spirituality and the Pachamama in the Andean Aymara worldview’, in Ricardo Rozzi, F. Stuart Chapin III, J. Baird Callicott, S. T. A. Pickett, Mary E. Power, Juan J. Armesto and Roy H. May, eds, Earth stewardship: Linking ecology and ethics in theory and practice, 65–76, Heidelberg: Springer.Google Scholar
  77. Martin, Pamela L. (2011) ‘Global governance from the Amazon: Leaving oil underground in Yasuní National Park, Ecuador’, Global Environmental Politics 11(4): 22–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Miller, Shawn William (2007) An environmental history of Latin America, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Mittelstadt, Michael C. (1995) ‘Non mos, non ius: Tacitus on the moral dimensions of political freedom’, International Social Sciences Review 70(1/2): 34–42.Google Scholar
  80. Nash, June (1989) ‘Cultural resistance and class consciousness in Bolivian tin-mining communities’, in Susan Eckstein, ed., Power and Popular Protest: Latin American Social Movements, 182–202, Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  81. Nash, Roderick Frazier (1989) The rights of nature: A history of environmental ethics, Madison: University of Wisconsin.Google Scholar
  82. Newell, Peter (2008) ‘Contesting Trade Politics in the Americas: The Politics of Environmental Justice’, in David V. Carruthers, ed., Environmental Justice in Latin America: Problems, Promise and Practice, 49–73, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
  83. Painter, Michael (1995) ‘Upland-lowland production linkages and land degradation in Bolivia’, in Michael Painter and William H Durham, eds, The social causes of environmental destruction in Latin America, 133–68, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
  84. Perreault, Tom (2008) ‘Popular protest and unpopular policies: State restructuring, resource conflict, and social justice in Bolivia’, in David V. Carruthers, ed., Environmental Justice in Latin America: Problems, Promise and Practice, 239–62, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
  85. Petras, James and Henry Veltmeyer (2011) Social movements in Latin America: Neoliberalism and popular resistance, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Pittsburgh Pennsylvania Code of Ordinances (2013) ‘Code of Ordinances City of Pittsburgh Pennsylvania. Codified through Ordinance No. 12-2013’, 19 April, available at http://library.municode.com/index.aspx?clientID=13525&stateID=38&statename=Pennsylvania (accessed 19 July, 2015).
  87. Postero, Nancy (2010) ‘Morales’s MAS government: Building indigenous popular hegemony in Bolivia’, Latin American Perspectives 37(3): 18–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. Regalsky, Pablo (2010) ‘Political processes and the reconfiguration of the state in Bolivia’, Latin American Perspectives 37(3): 35–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Rice, Roberta (2012) The new politics of protest: Indigenous mobilization in Latin America’s neoliberal era, Tucson, AZ: University of Arizona Press.Google Scholar
  90. Robinson, William I. (2008) Latin America and Global Capitalism: A Critical Globalization Perspective, Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
  91. Rose, Carol M. (1994) ‘Given-ness and Gift: Property and the Quest for Environmental Ethics’, Environmental Law 24(1): 1–31.Google Scholar
  92. Schilling-Vacoflor, Almut (2011) ‘Bolivia’s new constitution: Towards participatory democracy and political pluralism’, European Review of Latin American and Caribbean Studies 90: 3–22.Google Scholar
  93. Silva, Eduardo (2009) Challenging Neoliberalism in Latin America, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  94. Sivak, Martin (2008) Evo Morales: the extraordinary rise of the first indigenous president of Bolivia, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
  95. Stober, Spencer (2010) ‘Ecuador: Mother Nature’s utopia’, International Journal of Environmental, Cultural, Economic and Social Sustainability 6(2): 229–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  96. Stone, Christopher D. (1972) Should trees have standing? Towards legal rights for natural objects’, Southern California Law Review 45: 450–501.Google Scholar
  97. Stone, Christopher D. (2010) Should trees have standing? Law, morality and the environment, Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  98. Tanasescu, Mihnea (2013) ‘The rights of nature in Ecuador: the making of an idea’, International Journal of Environmental Studies 70(6): 846–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  99. USLegal.com (2015) Legal Definitions Home > Standing, available at http://definitions.uslegal.com/l/locus-standi/ (accessed 1 July, 2015).
  100. Van Cott, Donna Lee (2007) ‘Latin America’s Indigenous Peoples’, Journal of Democracy 18(4): 127–41.Google Scholar
  101. Verhaeghe, Paul (2014) What about me? The struggle for identity in a market-based society, London: Scribe.Google Scholar
  102. Villalba, Unai (2013) ‘Buen vivir vs development: A paradigm shift in the Andes?’, Third World Quarterly 34(8): 1427–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  103. Washington Post (2015) ‘What Eduardo Galeano had to say about the United States’, Washington Post (13 April), available at http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldviews/wp/2015/04/13/what-eduardo-galeano-had-to-say-about-the-united-states/ (accessed 4 July, 2015).
  104. Watts, Jonathon (2013) ‘Oil drilling to start in pristine Amazon as eco fund fails’, Guardian (17 May): 13.Google Scholar
  105. Weaver, Jace, ed. (1996) Defending Mother Earth: Native American perspectives on environmental justice, Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books.Google Scholar
  106. Webber, Jeffrey R. (2012) ‘Popular movements, political economy, and the state in Bolivia: An interview with Oscar Olivera and Freddy Villagómez’, Capitalism Nature Socialism 23(3): 6–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  107. Weiler, Todd (2001) ‘Metalclad v. Mexico: A play in three parts’, Journal of World Investment 2(4): 685–711.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  108. Whittemore, Mary Elizabeth (2011) ‘The problem of enforcing nature’s rights under Ecuador’s constitution: Why the 2008 environmental amendments have no bite’, Pacific Rim Law and Policy Journal 20(3): 659–91.Google Scholar
  109. Williams, Mark Eric (2011) Understanding US-Latin American Relations: Theory and History, London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  110. Yashar, Deborah J (2005) Contesting citizenship in Latin America: The rise of indigenous movements and the postliberal challenge, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Macmillan Publishers Ltd 2016

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Geography Department, Faculty of Arts and Social SciencesThe Open UniversityMilton KeynesUK

Personalised recommendations