Advertisement

Journal of Public Health Policy

, Volume 31, Issue 3, pp 342–354 | Cite as

Problems, policies and politics: A comparative case study of contraband tobacco from the 1990s to the present in the Canadian context

  • Robert SchwartzEmail author
  • Teela Johnson
Original Article

Abstract

Contraband tobacco has been and continues to be a global public health policy concern, with special manifestations in Canada. Over the past 20 years, in two noteworthy instances the Canadian government has battled contraband – in the early 1990s, and for much of the past decade. In the 1990s, when contraband cigarettes flooded the Canadian market, the government rapidly responded, using policy measures such as implementing a tobacco export tax and cutting domestic sales tax. Unfortunately, contraband made a strong comeback in recent years, but this time the government has hesitated to act, owing to a change in the source of the contraband. Using John Kingdon's streams theory to frame our arguments, we suggest that lack of congruence between different policy stakeholder groups’ perceptions of the problem, policy solutions, and political feasibility has road-blocked the implementation of anti-contraband policy in the 2000s.

Keywords

contraband tobacco policy streams tobacco tax 

References

  1. Framework Convention Alliance. (2008) How big was the global illicit tobacco trade problem in 2006? http://www.fctc.org/docs/documents/fca-2008-inb-illicit-trade-inb1-factsheet-how-big-was-illicit-trade-2006-en.pdf, accessed 25 April 2008.
  2. The Ottawa Citizen. (2009) $1.4M haul of cigarettes sets record; Seizure shows scope of smuggling problem police say. May 5.Google Scholar
  3. Marsden, W. (2009) Gazette exclusive: Mohawks gangs and tobacco. The Gazette 28 March, Sect. B.1.Google Scholar
  4. Royal Canadian Mounted Police. (2008) Contraband tobacco enforcement strategy, http://www.rcmp-grc.gc.ca/ce-da/tobacco-tabac-strat-2008-eng.htm, accessed 1 May 2009.Google Scholar
  5. Kingdon, J.W. (2003) Agendas, Alternatives, Public Policies, 2nd edn. New York: Longman Classics.Google Scholar
  6. Pralle, S.B. (2006) Timing and sequence in agenda-setting and policy change: A comparative study of lawn care pesticide politics in Canada and the US. Journal of European Public Policy 13 (7): 987–1005.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Driedger, M. (2003) Charting uncertainty in science-policy discourses: The construction of the chlorinated drinking-water issue and cancer. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 21 (3): 429–444.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Schwartz, R. and McConnell, A. (2009) Do crises help remedy regulatory failure? A comparative study of the Walkerton water and Jerusalem banquet hall disasters. Canadian Public Administration 52 (1): 91–112.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Sweeting, J., Johnson, T. and Schwartz, R. (2009) Anti-contraband Policies: Evidence for Better Practice. Toronto: The Ontario Tobacco Research Unit.Google Scholar
  10. Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security. (2008) 39th Parliament, 2nd Session, Number 028. Enforcement/Government, http://cmte.parl.gc.ca/Content/HOC/Committee/392/SECU/Evidence/EV3476622/SECUEV28-E.PDF, accessed 1 May 2009.
  11. Non-Smokers’ Rights Association/Smoking and Health Action Foundation. (2006) It's Time for Action on Tobacco Smuggling and Contraband. Toronto: Non-Smokers’ Rights Association/Smoking and Health Action Foundation.Google Scholar
  12. Cunningham, R. (1996) Smoke and Mirrors: The Canadian Tobacco War, Chapter 11 Taxation and Smuggling. Ottawa: International Development Research Centre.Google Scholar
  13. Kelton, M. and Givel, M. (2008) Public policy implications of tobacco industry smuggling through Native American reservations into Canada. International Journal of Health Services 38 (3): 471–487.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Woods, A. and Campion-Smith, B. (2008) Big tobacco pays the price. Toronto Star 1 August, http://www.thestar.com/article/470904, accessed 17 June 2009.
  15. Marsden, W. (1999) Tobacco insider talks part 1 – Major firms were deeply involved in cross-border smuggling, former executive says. The Gazette 18 December, Sect. A.1.Google Scholar
  16. Her Majesty in Right of Canada. (2008) Federal-provincial agreement, http://www.cra-arc.gc.ca/gncy/tbcc/fpe-eng.pdf, accessed 17 June 2009.
  17. Breton, E., Richard, L., Gagnon, F., Jacques, M. and Bergeron, P. (2005) Fighting a tobacco tax rollback: A political analysis of the 1994 cigarette contraband crisis in Canada. Journal of Public Health Policy 27 (1): 77–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Zhang, B., Cohen, J., Ferrence, R. and Jurgern, R. (2006) The impact of tobacco tax cuts on smoking initiation among Canadian young adults. American Journal of Preventative Medicine 30 (6): 474–479.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Canadian Press. (1994) Cigarette sales soar following tax cuts: War on smuggling right move, tobacco lobbyist says. Canadian Press 19 March, Sect. 03.Google Scholar
  20. Kondro, W. (2007) Coalition urges crackdown on contraband cigarettes. Canadian Medical Association Journal 176 (11): 1569.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. The Gazette. (2009) Where's the will to fight cigarette smugglers? The Gazette 31 March, Sect. A.14.Google Scholar
  22. Authier, P. (2009) Tobacco crackdown; following revelations by Gazette, minister promises tighter controls. The Gazette 8 April, Sect. A.1.Google Scholar
  23. De Souza, R.J. (2007) How Canada's natives became cigarette smugglers [National edition]. National Post 16 August, Sect. A.17.Google Scholar
  24. Luk, R., Cohen, J.E. and Ferrence, R. (2007) Contraband Cigarettes in Ontario. Toronto: Ontario Tobacco Research Unit.Google Scholar
  25. Physicians for a Smoke-Free Canada. (2007) Towards Effective Tobacco Control in First Nations and Inuit Communities. Ottawa: Physicians for a Smoke-Free Canada.Google Scholar
  26. Royal Canadian Mounted Police. (2008) Tobacco operational priorities – Statistics, http://www.rcmp-grc.gc.ca/ce-da/tobacco-tabac-stats-eng.htm, accssed 3 June 2009.Google Scholar
  27. Ontario Auditor General. (2008) 2008 Annual Report, http://www.auditor.on.ca/en/reports_en/en08/ar_en08.pdf, accssed 7 May 2009.
  28. Luk, R., Cohen, J.E., Ferrence, R., McDonald, P.W., Schwartz, R. and Bondy, S. (2009) Prevalence and correlates of purchasing contraband cigarettes on First Nations in Ontario, Canada. Addiction 103 (3): 448–495.Google Scholar
  29. The GFK Group. (2008) Illegal tobacco trade: 2008 study for the Canadian Tobacco manufacturers’ council, http://www.imperialtobaccocanada.com/onewebca/sites/IMP_5TUJVZ.nsf/vwPagesWebLive/DO65HJNQ?opendocument&SID=&DTC=&TMP=1, accssed 4 May 2009.
  30. Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security. (2008) 39th Parliament, 2nd Session, Number 035, Growers, http://www2.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx?DocId=3488836&Language=E&Mode=1&Parl=39&Ses=2, accssed 1 May 2009.
  31. Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat. (2008) Federal tobacco control strategy: Planning, spending, and results, 6 March 2008, http://www.tbs-sct.gc.ca/hidb-bdih/initiative-eng.aspx?Org=41&Hi=34, accssed 12 June 2009.
  32. Department of Finance Canada. (2009) About finance Canada. 11 May, http://www.fin.gc.ca/afc/index-eng.asp, accessed 12 June 2009.
  33. Health Canada. (2008) About tobacco control, role of governments: Federal, http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/hc-ps/tobac-tabac/about-apropos/role/federal/index-eng.php, accssed 11 June 2009.
  34. Public Safety Canada. (2008) Minister Day announces an action plan to help stop the trade of illicit tobacco by criminal organizations. 7 May, http://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/media/nr/2008/nr20080507-eng.aspx?rss=true, accssed 15 June 2009.
  35. Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security. (2008) 39th Parliament, 2nd Session, Number 030, Interest groups, http://www2.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx?DocId=3504971&Language=E&Mode=1&Parl=39&Ses=2, accssed 1 May 2009.
  36. Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security. (2008) 39th Parliament, 2nd Session, Number 029, Tobacco Industry, http://www2.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx?DocId=3488836&Language=E&Mode=1&Parl=39&Ses=2, accssed 1 May 2009.
  37. Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security. (2008) 39th Parliament, 2nd Session, Number 034, First Nations, http://www2.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx?DocId=3488836&Language=E&Mode=1&Parl=39&Ses=2, accssed 1 May 2009.
  38. Public Safety Canada. (2009) Van Loan and Napolitano successfully conclude their first high-level border meeting. 27 May, http://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/media/nr/2009/nr20090527-2-eng.aspx, accssed 15 June 2009.
  39. Public Safety Canada. (2009) Integrated Border Enforcement Teams. 6 February, http://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/prg/le/bs/ibet-eng.aspx, accssed 15 June 2009.
  40. Minister of Finance. (2008) Bill C-50: An act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on February 26, 2008 and to enact provisions to preserve the fiscal plan set out in that budget, http://www2.parl.gc.ca/content/hoc/Bills/392/Government/C-50/C-50_1/C-50_1.PDF, accssed 11 June 2009.
  41. Department of Finance Canada. (2008) Federal government moves to strengthen Canada's tax advantage and protect the fiscal framework, http://www.fin.gc.ca/n08/08-027-eng.asp, accssed 7 May 2009.
  42. Ontario Ministry of Finance. (2008) Ontario budget 2009: Chapter 3, http://www.fin.gov.on.ca/english/budget/ontariobudgets/2008/chpt3.html, accssed 7 May 2009.
  43. Raymond Chabot Grant Thornton. (2008) Tax bulletin: Staying the course despite the storm, http://www.rcgt.com/wmfichiers/Quebec_Budget_March_2008.pdf, accssed 7 May 2009.

Copyright information

© Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Ltd 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.The Ontario Tobacco Research Unit, Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of TorontoTorontoCanada
  2. 2.Faculty of Medicine, Queen's UniversityKingstonCanada

Personalised recommendations