Truth, justice, and reconciliation on the ground: normative divergence in the Western Balkans
- 208 Downloads
The article contributes to the ‘second wave’ norm diffusion literature by offering a new theoretical lens through which to explain unexpected policy outcomes of international normative interventions. Specifically, the article aims to challenge the international norms scholarship by questioning what power international norms actually have in domestic politics of adopting states. To answer this question I analyse the process of diffusion, contestation, and localisation of transitional justice norms — ways of dealing with legacies of past violence — in the Western Balkans. I choose three principal transitional justice concepts — truth, justice, and reconciliation — and analyse how their local meaning in the Western Balkans diverged normatively from that of international transitional justice advocates, and to what political effect. I trace the processes of normative divergence of international transitional justice norms to demonstrate how the domestic understanding of international norms produced new meanings and practices and fundamentally challenged the principal assumptions behind the global governance of post-conflict reconstruction.
Keywordsinternational norms justice reconciliation transitional justice truth Western Balkans
I thank Filip Ejdus, Krenar Gashi, Jamie Rowen, the staff at the Humanitarian Law Centre in Belgrade, guest editors of the special issue Simone Tholens and Lisa Gross, editors of the Journal of International Relations and Development, and three anonymous reviewers for very helpful comments and suggestions.
- Ahmetašević, Nidžara and Tanja Matić (2014) ‘Democratization of Media in Post-conflict Situations: Reporting on ICTY War Crimes Trials in Serbia’, in Clara Ramirez-Barat, ed., Transitional Justice, Culture, and Society: Beyond Outreach 211–246, New York: Social Science Research Council.Google Scholar
- Ainley, Kirsten (2014) ‘Transitional Justice in Cambodia: The Coincidence of Power and Principle’, in Renee Jeffery and Hun Joon Kim eds, Transitional Justice in the Asia-Pacific, 125–56, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Aliu, Fatmir (2012) ‘Kosovo Kids Taught False History, Study Shows’, Balkan Insight, 24 September, available at http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/kosovo-kids-taught-wrongly-a-study-shows (accessed 9 February, 2015).
- Amnesty International (2012) ‘Kosovo: If They Are Not Guilty, Who Committed the War Crimes?’, 29 November, available at http://www.amnesty.org/en/news/kosovo-if-they-are-not-guilty-who-committed-war-crimes-2012-11-29 (accessed 5 December, 2012).Google Scholar
- B92 (2012) ‘University Students Organize Protest against Hague’, 4 December, available at http://www.b92.net/eng/news/society-article.php?yyyy=2012&mm=12&dd=04&nav_id=83477 (accessed 31 October, 2014).Google Scholar
- Barbour, Stephanie A. (2014) ‘Making Justice Visible: Bosnia and Herzegovina’s Domestic War Crimes Trials Outreach’, in Clara Ramirez-Barat, ed., Transitional Justice, Culture, and Society: Beyond Outreach, 97–140, New York: Social Science Research Council.Google Scholar
- Bass, Gary Jonathan (2000) Stay the Hand of Vengeance: The Politics of War Crimes Tribunals, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Bytyci, Fato (2014) ‘Kosovo Parliament Votes for a New War Crimes Court’, Reuters (23 April), available at http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/04/23/us-kosovo-warcrimes-idUSBREA3M0YD20140423 (accessed 20 March 2015).
- Cohen, Stanley (2001) States of Denial: Knowing about Atrocities and Suffering, Cambridge: Polity.Google Scholar
- Croatian Parliament (2006) Deklaracija o Oluji, [Declaration on Operation Storm] in Narodne novine (76–2000), Zagreb.Google Scholar
- Davis, Laura (2010) The European Union and Transitional Justice, New York: International Center for Transitional Justice, June.Google Scholar
- Documenta (2012) ‘Statement on the Occasion of Non-appealable Judgment to General Gotovina and Markač’, 16 November, available at http://www.documenta.hr/en/statement-on-the-occassion-of-non-appealable-judgment-to-generals-gotovina-and-marka%C4%8D.html (accessed 5 December, 2012).
- Dragović-Soso, Jasna (2013) ‘The Parting of Ways: Public Reckoning with the Recent Past in Post-Milošević Serbia’, in Timothy William Waters, ed., The Milošević Trial: An Autopsy, 389–408, New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Ford, Stuart (2012) ‘A Social Psychology Model of the Perceived Legitimacy of International Criminal Courts: Implications for the Success of Transitional Justice Mechanisms’, Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law 45: 405–76.Google Scholar
- Freeman, Mark (2004) Bosnia and Herzegovina: Selected Developments in Transitional Justice, New York: International Center for Transitional Justice, October.Google Scholar
- Gibson, James L. (2004) Overcoming Apartheid: Can Truth Reconcile a Divided Nation? New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
- Hansen, Thomas Obel (2011) ‘Transitional Justice in Kenya — An Assessment of the Accountability Process in Light of Domestic Politics and Security Concerns’, California Western International Law Journal 42 (1): 1–36.Google Scholar
- Hayner, Priscilla B. (2001) Unspeakable Truths: Confronting State Terror and Atrocity, New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Hedl, Drago (2014) ‘Croatia Whitewashes War Crimes After Joining EU’, Balkan Insight, 11 June, available at http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/croatia-whitewashes-war-crimes-after-joining-eu (accessed 31 October, 2014).
- Helsinki Committee for Human Rights in Serbia (2011) Human Rights in Serbia 2010: Human Rights Reflect Institutional Impotence, Belgrade: HCHRS.Google Scholar
- Helsinki Committee for Human Rights in Serbia (2012) Human Rights in Serbia 2011: European Option Obstructed, Belgrade: HCHRS.Google Scholar
- Helsinki Committee for Human Rights in Serbia (2013) Human Rights in Serbia 2012: Populism Entropy of Democracy, Belgrade: HCHRS.Google Scholar
- Human Rights Watch (2014) ‘Kosovo: Approve Special Court for Serious Abuses’, 11 April, available at http://www.hrw.org/news/2014/04/11/kosovo-approve-special-court-serious-abuses (accessed 14 April, 2014).
- Humanitarian Law Center (2013a) Report on War Crimes Trials in Serbia in 2012, Belgrade: HLC.Google Scholar
- Humanitarian Law Center (2013b) Transitional Justice in Post-Yugoslav Countries: Report for 2010–2011, Belgrade: HLC.Google Scholar
- International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (2003) Prosecutor vs. Biljana Plavšić, IT-00-39&40/1- S, ICTY Sentencing Judgment, 27 February.Google Scholar
- Ivanović, Josip (2014) ‘Post-war Reconciliation in Croatia “Stalled”, Report Warns’, Balkan Insight, 14 April, available at http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/croatian-ngos-deep-divisions-within-croatian-society (accessed 31 October, 2014).
- Kostovicova, Denisa (2005) Kosovo: The Politics of Identity and Space, London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Kostovicova, Denisa (2013) ‘Airing Crimes, Marginalizing Victims: Political Expectations and Transitional Justice in Kosovo’, in Timothy William Waters, ed., The Milošević Trial: An Autopsy, 249–59, New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Lakić, Nikola (2013) ‘History Education and the Security Community Building in the Western Balkans: A Critical View’, Journal of Regional Security 8 (2): 115–36.Google Scholar
- Lamont, Christopher K. (2009) International Criminal Justice and the Politics of Compliance, Burlington, VT: Ashgate Pub.Google Scholar
- Lamont, Christopher K. (2012) ‘Forging Transitional Justice: The Reconciliation of Law and Transition in Macedonia’, in Zhidas Daskalovski and Marija Risteska, eds., The Macedonian Question: 20 Years of Political Struggle into European Integration Structures, 76–94, Rangendingen, Germany: Libertas.Google Scholar
- Malazogu, Leon, Milan Nič, Filip Ejdus and Tomasz Zornaczuk (2014) Integration or Isolation? Northern Kosovo in 2014 Electoral Limbo, Bratislava: Central European Policy Institute, 13 February.Google Scholar
- Manojlović Pintar, Olga (2010) ‘Rat i nemir’, [Peace and Uncertainty] in Dubravka Stojanović, Radina Vučetić, Sanja Petrović Todosijević, Olga Manojlović Pintar and Radmila Radić, eds., Novosti iz prošlosti: Znanje, neznanje, upotreba i zloupotreba istorije [News from the Past: Knowledge, Ignorance, Use and Misuse of History] Belgrade: Belgrade Centre for Human Rights.Google Scholar
- Marusic, Sinisa Jakov (2013) ‘Macedonia Spies Probe “Has Become a Witch-Hunt”’, Balkan Insight, 30 July, available at http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/macedonian-lustration-deemed-witch-hunt (accessed 31 October, 2014).
- McMahon, Patrice C. and Jon Western (2009) ‘The Death of Dayton’, Foreign Affairs, 17 August.Google Scholar
- Mihr, Anja (2013) ‘Transitional Justice and the Quality of Democracy’, International Journal of Conflict and Violence 7 (2): 298–313.Google Scholar
- Minow, Martha (1998) Between Vengeance and Forgiveness: Facing History after Genocide and Mass Violence, Boston, MA: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
- Mladjenovic, Lepa (2004) ‘The ICTY: The Validation of the Experiences of Survivors’, in Steven R. Ratner and James L. Bischoff, eds., International War Crimes Trials: Making A Difference? Austin: University of Texas,, 59–65.Google Scholar
- Nettelfield, Lara J. and Sarah E. Wagner (2014) Srebrenica in the Aftermath of Genocide, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights (2006) Rule-of-Law Tools for Post-conflict States, New York: OHCHR.Google Scholar
- Olsen, Tricia D., Leigh A. Payne and Andrew G. Reiter (2010) Transitional Justice in Balance: Comparing Processes, Weighing Efficacy, Washington: U.S. Institute of Peace.Google Scholar
- Orentlicher, Diane F. (2008) Shrinking the Space for Denial: The Impact of the ICTY in Serbia, New York: Open Society Institute, May.Google Scholar
- Orentlicher, Diane F. (2010) That Someone Guilty Be Punished: The Impact of the ICTY in Bosnia, New York: Open Society Justice Initiative and International Center for Transitional Justice.Google Scholar
- Pavelić, Boris (2013) ‘Croatian Court: State Responsible for Serbs’ Murder’, Balkan Insight, 24 January, available at http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/croatian-court-procclaims-state-responsible-for-killed-serbs (accessed 31 October, 2014).
- Peci, Edona (2014) ‘Kosovo Asks EU to Set Up New Tribunal’, Balkan Insight, 14 April, available at http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/kosovo-asks-eu-for-war-crime-tribunal (accessed 14 April, 2014).
- Perry, Valery (2013) ‘Classrooms as a Battleground for Hearts and Minds: Efforts to Reform and Transform Education in Post-war Bosnia and Herzegovina’, in Ola Listhaug and Sabrina P. Ramet, eds., Civic and Uncivic Values in Bosnia–Herzegovina: The Record since Dayton, Ravenna: Longo Editore.Google Scholar
- Ramirez-Barat, Clara, ed. (2014) Transitional Justice, Culture, and Society: Beyond Outreach, New York: Social Science Research Council.Google Scholar
- Ristić, Marija (2014) ‘Serbia Welcomes New Kosovo War Crimes Court’, Balkan Insight, 24 April, available at http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/serbia-welcomes-new-kosovo-war-crimes-court (accessed 31 October, 2014).
- Sikkink, Kathryn (2009) ‘From State Responsibility to Individual Criminal Accountability: A New Regulatory Model for Core Human Rights Violations’, in Walter Mattli and Ngaire Woods, eds., The Politics of Global Regulation, 121–50, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Sikkink, Kathryn (2011) The Justice Cascade: How Human Rights Prosecutions Are Changing World Politics, New York: WW Norton.Google Scholar
- Simpson, Eileen (2004) ‘Stop to the Hague: Internal versus External Factors Suppressing the Advancement of the Rule of Law in Serbia’, Georgetown Journal of International Law 36 (1): 1255–88.Google Scholar
- Subotić, Jelena (2009) Hijacked Justice: Dealing with the Past in the Balkans, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
- Teitel, Ruti (2003) ‘Transitional Justice Genealogy’, Harvard Human Rights Journal 16: 69–94.Google Scholar
- Teitel, Ruti (2005) ‘The Law and Politics of Contemporary Transitional Justice’, Cornell International Law Journal 38 (3): 837–62.Google Scholar
- Thomas, Daniel C. (2001) The Helsinki Effect: International Norms, Human Rights, and the Demise of Communism, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Tolbert, David (2014) ‘Transitional Justice Should Be Part of Serbia’s Accession to the EU’, Through Accession Toward Justice (2): 1–3.Google Scholar
- UN Secretary General (2004) The Rule of Law and Transitional Justice in Conflict and Postconflict Societies, New York: United Nations.Google Scholar
- United Nations Security Council (1993) Resolution 827, New York: UN Security Council, 25 May.Google Scholar
- Vinjamuri, Leslie and Aaron P. Boesenecker (2007) Accountability and Peace Agreements: Mapping Trends from 1980 to 2006, Geneva: Centre for Humanitarian Dialogue, September.Google Scholar
- Waldorf, Lars (2006) ‘Mass Justice for Mass Atrocity: Rethinking Local Justice as Transitional Justice’, Temple Law Review 79 (1): 1–88.Google Scholar