The European Union is often presented as an entity that has ‘moved beyond’ the model of organising political life along the way of the modern sovereign state. This paper questions this understanding by engaging a set of texts that could be understood as exemplary of the EU's official discourse of Europe: EU's failed Constitutional Treaty and Javier Solana's collected speeches. A paradox is herein identified: the values that are said to sustain Europe's identity and upon which Europe is founded are simultaneously presented as distinctly European and universal. It is suggested that Europe is being crafted in a pendular oscillation between particularising and universalising the values upon which Europe allegedly rests. By drawing on critical International Relations theory, the paper suggests that this very contradictory oscillation between particularising and universalising Europe's values to an important extent mirrors modern statecraft. One should therefore think twice before announcing the construction of the European Union as something qualitatively different from, or ‘gentler’ than, modern statecraft.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
I am throughout the paper using ‘crafting’ instead of ‘writing’, to avoid any confusion about narrowly associating the enactment of Europe only with linguistic practices. In addition, since the texts I examine use ‘Europe’ and ‘the European Union’ interchangeably, so do I.
Throughout the paper, ‘Europe’ is textually understood as a contested signifier whose bounds and referents must always be put in quotation marks. However, for stylistic reasons I will not always do so. To place a concept within quotation marks or under erasure means to resist essentialising the concept. It is also to recognise the necessity of provisionally retaining it in order to be able to examine the discursive field in which it is deployed (see Spivak's preface to Of Grammatology in Derrida 1976: xiv).
Many contributions to the debate on ‘normative power Europe’ would here qualify. See Manners (2002) and Sjursen (2006). For a critique, see Diez (2005) and Manners’ (2006) response. A more theoretical form of arguing for the novelty of the EU is to argue that the EU's constitutive outside resides solely in its own past, and that the EU does not (any longer) engage in inscribing otherness in spatial entities. For a convincing argument about the impossibility of decoupling spatial and temporal forms of othering, see Prozorov (2011).
Reflecting on the achievements of neo-functionalism towards the end of his life, Haas indeed characterised his thought as an attempt to reflect upon ‘how human collectivities can move beyond the nation state’ (Haas 2001: 24).
An important exception is found in Bartolini's work, who writes that the EU ‘can be defined as a state-formation attempt that is characterized to date by limited administrative capabilities, by strong regulatory powers in selected fields, by very weak fiscal capabilities, and by strong jurisdictional capabilities that have grown from the early spheres of competences. From the historical point of view, there is nothing exceptional or new in this configuration of subsystemic differentiation’ (2005: xiii, my emphasis).
For the following discussion, I am indebted to Rick Ashley and Leo E. Figueroa-Helland.
For how the Westphalian international system differs from two Asian systems, see Ringmar (2012).
Throughout the text, all emphases in Solana's speeches are inserted by the author.
Thanks to Rick Ashley for elaborating on this point.
Albert, Mathias and Lothar Brock (2001) ‘What Keeps Westphalia Together? Normative Differentiation in the Modern System of States’, in Mathias Albert, David Jacobson and Yosef Lapid, eds, Identities, Borders, Orders: Rethinking International Relations Theory, 29–49, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Anderson, Stephanie (2008) Crafting EU Security Policy: In Pursuit of a European Identity, London: Lynne Rienner.
Ashley Richard, K. (1987) ‘Foreign Policy as Political Performance’, International Studies Notes 13 (2): 51–54.
Ashley Richard, K. (1988) ‘Untying the Sovereign State: A Double Reading of the Anarchy Problematic’, Millennium: Journal of International Studies 17 (2): 227–262.
Ashley Richard, K. (1989) ‘Living on Border Lines: Man, Poststructuralism, and War’, in James Der Derian and Michael J. Shapiro, eds, International/Intertextual Relations: Postmodern Readings of World Politics, 259–321, Lexington: Lexington Books.
Austin, John (1962) How to Do Things with Words, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Badie, Bertrand (2000) The Imported State: The Westernization of the Political Order, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Bartolini, Stefano (2005) Restructuring Europe: Centre Formation, System Building and Political Structuring between the Nation-state and the European Union, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Bátora, Jozef and Monika Mokre, eds (2011) Culture and External Relations: Europe and Beyond, Surrey: Ashgate.
Braun, Mats (2008) ‘Talking Europe: The Dilemma of Sovereignty and Modernization’, Cooperation and Conflict 43 (4): 397–420.
Burca, Gráinne (2004) ‘The Drafting of a Constitution for the European Union: Europe's Madisonian Moment or a Moment of Madness?’ Washington and Lee Law Review 61: 555–583.
Burgess, Peter J. (2007) ‘The Evolution of European Union Law and Carl Schmitt's Theory of the Nomos of Europe’, in Louiza Odysseos and Fabio Petitio, eds, The International Political Thought of Carl Schmitt: Terror, Liberal War and the Crisis of Global Order, 185–201, New York: Routledge.
Campbell, David (1998) Writing Security: United States Foreign Policy and the Politics of Identity 2nd edn., Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Cederman, Lars-Erik, ed. (2001) Constructing Europe's Identity: The External Dimension, Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
Chakrabarty, Dipesh (2000) Provincializing Europe: Postcolonial Thought and Historical Difference, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Critchley, Simon (1992) The Ethics of Deconstruction: Derrida and Levinas, Oxford: Blackwell Publishers.
Derrida, Jacques (1976) Of Grammatology, Baltimore, MD and London: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Derrida, Jacques (1988) Limited Inc., Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.
Derrida, Jacques (1992) The Other Heading: Reflections on Today's Europe, Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
Derrida, Jacques (1994) Specters of Marx: The State of the Debt, the Work of Mourning, and the New International, London: Routledge.
Derrida, Jacques (2002) ‘Declarations of Independence’, in Elizabeth G. Rottenberg, ed., Negotiations: Interventions and Interviews, 1971–2001, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Diez, Thomas (2001a) ‘Speaking ‘Europe’: The Politics of Integration Discourse’, in Thomas Christiansen, Knud Erik Jorgensen and Antje Wiener, eds, The Social Construction of Europe, 85–100, London: SAGE.
Diez, Thomas (2001b) ‘Europe as a Discursive Battleground: Discourse Analysis and European Integration Studies’, Cooperation and Conflict 36 (1): 5–38.
Diez, Thomas (2005) ‘Constructing the Self and Changing Others: Problematising the Concept of ‘Normative Power Europe’’, Millennium: Journal of International Studies 33 (3): 613–636.
Doty, Roxanne (1996) Imperial Encounters: The Politics of Representation in North–South Relations, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Haas, Ernst B. (1964) Beyond the Nation-State: Functionalism and International Organization, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Haas, Ernst B. (2001) ‘Does Constructivism Subsume Neo-functionalism?’, in Thomas Christiansen, Knud Erik Jörgensen and Antje Wiener, eds, The Social Construction of Europe, 22–31, London: Sage.
Habermas, Jürgen (2001) ‘A Constitution for Europe?’ New Left Review 11 (September/October): 5–26.
Habermas, Jürgen and Jacques Derrida (2003) ‘February 15, or What Binds Europeans Together: A Plea for a Common Foreign Policy, Beginning in the Core of Europe’, Constellations 10 (3): 291–297.
Hansen, Lene (2006) Security as Practice: Discourse Analysis and the Bosnian War, London and New York: Routledge.
Hansen, Lene and Michael Williams (1999) ‘The Myths of Europe: Legitimacy, Community and the “Crisis” of the EU’, Journal of Common Market Studies 37 (2): 233–249.
Held, David (2006) ‘Reframing Global Governance: Apocalypse Soon or Reform!’, New Political Economy 2 (11): 157–176.
Honig, Bonnie (1991) ‘Declarations of Independence: Arendt and Derrida on the Problem of Founding a Republic’, The American Political Science Review 85 (1): 97–113.
Hülsse, Rainer (2006) ‘Imagine the EU: The Metaphorical Construction of a Supra-nationalist Identity’, Journal of International Relations and Development 9 (4): 396–421.
Inayatullah Naeem and David Blaney (2004) International Relations and the Problem of Difference, London and New York: Routledge.
Laclau, Ernesto (1996) Emancipation(s), London and New York: Verso.
Laclau, Ernesto and Chantal Mouffe (1985) Hegemony and Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics, London and New York: Verso.
Manners, Ian (2002) ‘Normative Power Europe: A Contradiction in Terms?’ Journal of Common Market Studies 40 (2): 235–258.
Manners, Ian (2006) ‘The European Union as a Normative Power: A Response to Thomas Diez’, Millennium: Journal of International Studies 35 (1): 167–180.
Naas, Michael (1992) ‘Introduction: For Example’, in Jacques Derrida, ed., The Other Heading: Reflections on Today's Europe, vii–iix, Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
Näsström, Sofia (2003) ‘What Globalization Overshadows’, Political Theory 31 (6): 808–834.
Neumann, Iver B. (1998) ‘European Identity, EU Expansion and the Integration/Exclusion Nexus’, Alternatives 23 (3): 397–416.
Neumann, Iver B. (1999) Uses of the Other: The ‘East’ in European Identity Formation, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Olsen, Tore (2004) ‘Europe — United under God? Or Not?’, in Lynn Dobson and Andreas Follesdal, eds, Political Theory and the European Constitution, 75–90, New York: Routledge.
Probst, Lothar (2003) ‘Founding Myths in Europe and the Role of the Holocaust’, New German Critique 90: 45–58.
Prozorov, Sergei (2011) ‘The Other as Past and Present: Beyond the Logic of Temporal Othering in International Relations’, Review of International Studies 37 (3): 1273–1293.
Ringmar, Erik (2012) ‘Performing International Systems: Two East-Asian Alternatives to the Westphalian Order’, International Organization 66 (1): 1–25.
Rogers, James (2009) ‘From “Civilian Power” to “Global Power”: Explicating the European Union's “Grand Strategy” through the Articulation of Discourse Theory’, Journal of Common Market Studies 47 (4): 831–862.
Ruggie, John G. (1993) ‘Territoriality and Beyond: Problematizing Modernity in International Relations’, International Organization 47 (1): 139–174.
Rumelili, Bahar (2004) ‘Constructing Identity and Relating to Difference: Understanding EU's Mode of Differentiation’, Review of International Studies 30 (1): 27–47.
Rumelili, Bahar (2007) Constructing Regional Community and Order in Europe and Southeast Asia, Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
Shore, Cris (1996) ‘Transcending the Nation-State?: The European Commission and the (Re)-Discovery of Europe’, Journal of Historical Sociology 9 (4): 473–496.
Shore, Cris (2000) Building Europe: The Cultural Politics of European Integration, London and New York: Routledge.
Shore, Cris (2004) ‘Whither European Citizenship? Eros and Civilization Revisited’, European Journal of Social Theory 7 (1): 27–44.
Sjursen, Helene, ed. (2006) ‘What Kind of Power? European Foreign Policy in Perspective’, special issue of Journal of European Public Policy 13 (2): 169–327.
Solana, Javier (1999a) ‘Appearance of Dr. Javier Solana, Secretary-General/EU High Representative for the CFSP, before the European Parliament’, 17 November, Strasbourg.
Solana, Javier (1999b) ‘The Development of a Common European Security and Defence Policy: The Integration Project of the Next Decade’, 17 December, Berlin.
Solana, Javier (2000a) ‘The Development of a Common Foreign and Security Policy and the Role of the High Representative’, Danish Institute of International Affairs, 11 February, Copenhagen.
Solana, Javier (2000b) ‘Speech by Dr. Javier Solana’, 5 February, München.
Solana, Javier (2000c) ‘The Development of a Common Foreign and Security Policy and the Role of the High Representative’, Institute of European Affairs, 30 March, Dublin.
Solana, Javier (2000d) ‘Speaking Notes for Dr. Javier Solana at the Regional Funding Conference for South-East Europe’, 29 March, Brussels.
Solana, Javier (2000e) ‘Summary of Intervention by Dr. Javier Solana before the European Parliament’, 21 March.
Solana, Javier (2000f) ‘Statement by Secretary General/High Representative for Common Foreign and Security Policy, Javier Solana, to the Africa-Europe Summit’, 3–4 April, Cairo.
Solana, Javier (2000g) ‘Intervention by Dr. Javier Solana, Representative of the Common Foreign and Security Policy, to the General Affairs Council, Debate on Western Balkans’, 10 July, Brussels.
Solana, Javier (2000h) ‘Where Does the EU Stand on Common Foreign and Security Policy?’, presented at the Forschumgsinstitut Der Deutschen Gesellschaft Fuer Auswaertige Politik, 14 November, Berlin.
Solana, Javier (2001a) ‘ESDP after Nice, Where Do We Stand? Where Do We Go?’, address to the Austrian Institute for European Security Studies, 18 January, Vienna.
Solana, Javier (2001b) ‘EU Foreign Policy’, Hendrik Brugmans Memorial, 25 April, Bruges.
Solana, Javier (2002a) ‘Public Meeting on the Situation in Africa’, 29 January, New York.
Solana, Javier (2002b) ‘Intervention by Javier Solana’, Friends of Nieuwspoort Dinner, International Press Centre Nieuwspoort, Ridderzaal, 22 January, The Hague.
Solana, Javier (2002c) ‘Intervention by Dr. Javier Solana, Representative of the Common Foreign and Security Policy, Launch of CER Publications by Steven Everts ‘Shaping an Effective EU Foreign Policy’’, 19 February, Brussels.
Solana, Javier (2002d) ‘Intervention by Javier Solana at the inaugural session of the 2002 Conference of Ambassadors’, 24 July, Rome.
Solana, Javier (2002e) ‘Summary of the Intervention of Javier Solana at the Regional EU Conference on Conflict Prevention’, 30 August, Helsingborg.
Solana, Javier (2004) ‘The European Union and China: Strategic Partners’, Tsinghua University, 17 March, Beijing.
Solana, Javier (2005) ‘Driving Forwards the China-EU Strategic Partnership’, 6 September, Shanghai.
Solana, Javier (2006a) ‘Speech by Javier Solana at the Sound of Europe Conference’, 27 January, Salzburg.
Solana, Javier (2006b) ‘Speech by Javier Solana at the Annual Conference of the Institute for Security Studies of the European Union’, 6 October, Paris.
Solana, Javier (2006c) ‘Acceptance Speech of Javier Solana on the Occasion of Receiving the Carnegie-Wateler Peace Prize’, 23 November, The Hague.
Solana, Javier (2007) ‘Speech by Dr. Javier Solana’, Charlemagne Award 2007, 17 May, Aachen.
Spiering, Menno and Michael Wintle, eds (2011) European Identity and the Second World War, Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
Stavrakakis, Yannis (2005) ‘Passions of Identification: Discourse, Enjoyment, and European Identity’, in David Howarth and Jacob Torfing, eds, Discourse Theory in European Politics: Identity, Policy and Governance, 68–92, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Stern, Maria (2011) ‘Gender and Race in the European Security Strategy: Europe as a “Force for Good”?’ Journal of International Relations and Development 14 (1): 28–59.
Tully, James (1995) Strange Multiplicity: Constitutionalism in the Age of Diversity, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tuveson, Ernest Lee (1980) Redeemer Nation: The Idea of America's Millennial Role, Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
Waever, Ole (1998) ‘Insecurity, Security, and a Security in the West European Non-war Community’, in Emanuel Adler and Michael Barnett, eds, Security Communities, 69–118, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Waever, Ole (2009) ‘Discursive Approaches’, in Thomas Diez and Antje Wiener, eds, European Integration Theory, 2nd edn., 163–180, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Walker, Robert B.J. (1993) Inside/Outside: International Relations as Political Theory, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Walker, Robert B.J. (2000) ‘Europe Is Not Where It Is Supposed To Be’, in Morten Kelstrup and Michael Williams, eds, International Relations and the Politics of European Integration, 14–32, London and New York: Routledge.
Walker, Robert B.J. (2010) After the Globe, Before the World, London and New York: Routledge.
Zielonka, Jan (2006) Europe as Empire: The Nature of the Enlarged European Union, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
For extensive comments and discussion, I am indebted to Leonardo E. Figueroa-Helland, Richard K. Ashley, Roxanne L. Doty, Jessica Auchter, Brian Blanchard as well as two anonymous reviewers. On earlier versions of this project, I also acknowledge feedback from discussants and panellists at ISA 2008, ISA-North East 2008, ISA 2010, and members of a workshop on interpretive and relational research methodologies at ISA-North East 2008. Among those, I particularly extend my thanks to William Wolfgram, Jennifer Mitzen, Patrick Thaddeus Jackson, Rosemary Shinko, Renee Marlin-Bennett, Amy Skonieczny, and Thomas Diez. The usual disclaimer applies.
About this article
Cite this article
Borg, S. European integration and the problem of the state: universality, particularity, and exemplarity in the crafting of the European Union. J Int Relat Dev 17, 339–366 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1057/jird.2013.8
- EU foreign policy
- European Constitutional Treaty
- European integration
- the state