Skip to main content

The regulation of credit rating agencies: A realistic view

Abstract

There is a widespread agreement on the proposition that the performance of the credit rating agencies has not been that great and that their ratings and downgrades played pivotal roles in the global financial crisis and the European sovereign debt crisis. Yet most of the regulatory proposals to deal with them are no more than tweaks around the edges because of the belief that it is difficult to disentangle the regulatory process from the views of the rating agencies in a framework that was put in place in the 1930s. In this paper it is argued that taking the rating agencies out of the regulatory framework is not as problematic as it is portrayed to be and that the task should not carried out without other fundamental regulatory changes.

This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.

Notes and References

  1. Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission (2011) The Financial Crisis Inquiry Report. Washington DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

  2. A settlement was reached in February 2015 whereby Standard and Poor’s paid over $1 billion in compensation.

  3. Altman, E.I., Oncu, S., Schmeits, A. and White, L.J. (2010) What should be done about the credit rating agencies? 6 April, http://w4.stern.nyu.edu/blogs/regulatingwallstreet/2010/04/what-should-be-done-about-the.html, 21 February 2015.

  4. According to David Sicilia (2012), the criteria for achieving NRSRO status were not defined for many years.

  5. In its report on the global financial crisis, the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission presents some interesting facts and figures about Moody’s performance in the heyday of structured products when rating CDOs was a lucrative business. Moody’s rated 220 deals in 2004, 363 in 2006, 749 in 2006 and 717 in 2007. The value of those deals rose from $90 billion in 2004 to $162 billion in 2005, $337 billion in 2006 and $326 billion in 2007. The reported revenues of Moody’s from structured products grew from $199 million in 2000, or 33 per cent of Moody’s revenues, to $837 million in 2006 or 44 per cent of overall corporate revenue. The boom years of structured finance coincided with a company-wide surge in revenue and profits. From 2000 to 2006, Moody’s revenues surged from $602 million to $2 billion while its profit margin climbed from 26 to 37per cent.

  6. Sicilia, D. (2011) Roots of credit rating agency shortcomings, University of Maryland, 24 May, http://blogs.rhsmith.umd.edu/financialpolicy/commentary/roots-of-credit-rating-agency-shortcomings/, accessed 24 January 2015.

  7. The Economist (2014) Credit where Credit’s Due. 19 April.

  8. Naturally, the probability of default is determined not only by the accounts of the issuer but also by the overall macroeconomic and financial environment. It is not clear if the rating agencies take into consideration anything more than the financial statements of the rated firms because of the lack of transparency about their models.

  9. Teather, D. (2003) SEC seeks rating sector clean-up. Guardian 28 January.

  10. Wall Street Journal (2009) A triple-A idea – Ending the rating oligopoly. 15 April.

  11. Nicolas, M. and Firzli, J. (2011) A critique of the basel committee on banking supervision, Revue Analyse Financière, 10 November 2011/Q1 2012.

  12. It is interesting to note that the CRAs do not charge sovereign borrowers for rating their debt but they make the information publicly available. This is the ‘public relations’ part of the business.

  13. OECD (2010) Competition and credit rating agencies, http://www.oecd.org/competition/sectors/46825342.pdf, accessed 13 January.

  14. Moosa, I.A. (2015) Good Regulation, Bad Regulation: The Anatomy of Financial Regulation. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

    Book  Google Scholar 

  15. Krap, G. (2011) Ratings game: Power of S&P, Other top credit agencies, Grew from Government Action. Chicago Tribune 14 August.

  16. The Economist (2011) Making Financial Markets Less Reliant on Ratings will not be Straightforward. 13 August.

  17. Mahlmann, T. (2008) Rating agencies and the role of rating publication rights. Journal of Banking and Finance 32(11): 2414–2422.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  18. Skreta, V. and Veldkamp, L. (2008) Ratings Shopping and Asset Complexity: A Theory of Ratings Inflation, Working Paper, New York: Stern School of Business.

  19. Bolton, P., Freixas, X. and Shapiro, J. (2008) The Credit Ratings Game, Working Paper, Barcelona: Columbia Business School and Universitat Pompeu Fabra.

  20. Mathis, J., Mcandrews, J. and Rochet, J.-C. (2008) Rating The Raters: Are Reputation Concerns Powerful Enough to Discipline Rating Agencies? Working Paper, Toulouse: Toulouse School of Economics and Federal Reserve Bank of New York.

  21. Stolper, A. (2009) Regulation of credit rating agencies. Journal of Banking and Finance 33(7): 1266–1273.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  22. For example, it has been suggested that the CRAs ‘do make astrologers and bone casters look extraordinarily accurate’ and that they are ‘opportunistically inefficient’. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eErg78D6GoA.

  23. This reminds me of similar stories in sport. For example, a footballer earning half a million dollars a week misses penalty kicks regularly because he is ‘nervous under pressure’. Another example is a golfer who gets paid $2 million as an appearance fee for missing the hole from a distance of 2 feet because ‘putting is difficult’ or ‘it was windy’. One would imagine that these people get paid exuberant amounts and elevated to celebrity status (financed by ordinary people) because they can do what ordinary people cannot do. The footballer is paid half a million dollars a week to convert a penalty kick under pressure. The golfer is paid what he is paid presumably because he can putt the ball even though putting is difficult, particularly under windy conditions.

  24. McLean, B. and Nocera, J. (2011) All the Devils are Here. New York: Penguin Publishing Group.

    Google Scholar 

  25. The downgrade was precipitated by Warren Buffett’s telling CNBC that he had ‘passed on an opportunity to help the troubled mortgage giant’, See International Herald Tribune (2008) Freddie Mac Courts Investors, Buffett Passes, 22 August.

  26. Kliger, D. and Sarig, O. (2002) The information value of bond ratings. Journal of Finance 55(6): 2879–2902.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  27. Hawkins, J. and Turner, P. (2000) International Financial Reform: Regulatory and other Issues, Paper Presented at a Conference on International Financial Contagion, Washington DC, 3–4 February.

  28. They also point out that ‘one particular danger of reliance on external credit assessment agencies is that developing countries that are downgraded in a crisis would be hit twice: once via higher risk-weights used by international lending banks and secondly via high risk-weights for domestic bank lending to major corporations which also may be downgraded in a crisis’.

  29. Rodriguez, L.J. (2002) International banking regulation: Where’s the market discipline in Basel II? Policy Analysis 455(October), Cato Institute: Washington DC.

  30. Sinclair, T.J. (2005) The New Masters of Capital: American Bond Rating Agencies and the Politics of Creditworthiness. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

    Google Scholar 

  31. Madura, J. (2011) Financial Markets and Institutions. Mason, OH: South-Western Cengage Learning.

    Google Scholar 

  32. Granting the AAA designation to a security does not necessarily make it AAA. One can put lipstick on a pig, but it will still be a pig.

  33. Casey, K.L. (2009) In search of transparency, Accountability, and Competition: The Regulation of Credit Rating Agencies, Speech by SEC Commissioner. Washington DC, 6 February.

  34. Lippert, J. (2010) Credit ratings can’t claim free speech in law giving new risks. Bloomberg Markets Magazine 7 December.

  35. Jones, A. (2009) A first amendment defense for the rating agencies? Wall Street Journal 21 April.

  36. The Economist (2013) Free Speech or Knowing Misrepresentation? 5 February.

  37. The Economist (2007) Credit and Blame: The Rating Agencies Operate on Shaky Foundations. 6 September.

  38. The Economist (2007) Debt Ratings: AAAsking for Trouble. 12 July.

  39. White, L.J. (2010) Markets: The credit rating agencies. Journal of Economic Perspectives 24(2): 244–226.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  40. Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations (2011) Wall Street and the Financial Crisis – Anatomy of a Financial Collapse. Washington DC: United States Senate.

  41. Utzig, S. (2010) The Financial Crisis and the Regulation of Credit Rating Agencies: A European Banking Perspective, Tokyo: Asian Development Bank Institute, Working Papers, No 188.

  42. Financial Stability Forum (2008) Report of the Financial Stability Form on Enhancing Market and Institutional Resilience. Basel, 7 April.

  43. Lewis, M. (2010) The Big Short: Inside the Doomsday Machine. New York: Norton.

    Google Scholar 

  44. Partnoy, F. (1999) The Siskel and Ebert of financial markets?: Two thumbs down for the credit rating agencies. Washington University Law Review 77(3): 620–677.

    Google Scholar 

  45. Council on Foreign Relations (2015) The credit rating controversy, http://www.cfr.org/financial-crises/credit-rating-controversy/p22328, accessed 19 March 2015.

  46. The Economist (2012) The mathematics of markets. 14 January.

  47. Ramiah, V., Zhao, Y., Moosa, I.A. and Graham, M. (2015) A behavioural finance approach to working capital management. European Journal of Finance doi:10.1080/1351847X.2014.883549.

  48. Danielsson, J. et al (2001) An Academic Response to Basel II. London: LSE Financial Markets Group, Special Paper No 130.

  49. The Economist (2005) Who Rates the Raters? 26 May.

  50. This statement was made in a documentary entitled ‘Crash: The Next Depression’, which was shown on the History Channel in June 2009.

  51. Cifuentes, A. (2007) Weak Basel II may not be enough to calm credit fears. Financial Times 18 December.

  52. Department of Justice (2013) Department of justice sues standard & poor’s for Fraud in rating mortgage-backed securities in the years leading up to the financial crisis, News Release, 5 February, http://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/department-justice-sues-standard-poor-s-fraud-rating-mortgage-backed-securities-years-leading, accessed 24 March 2015.

  53. It is not clear why the demise of Lehman Brothers and other financial institutions was blamed mostly on short sellers. It was actually caused by the strategic error of accumulating billions of dollars worth of structured products, believing in the wisdom of the CRAs, which in turn inflicted tremendous damage on those institutions which became insolvent as a result of abrupt downgrading. Merrill Lynch suffered a similar fate for the same strategic error, having fired anyone with a dissenting voice who dared oppose the ‘strategic vision’ of senior management (typically one person who happens to be the ‘king of the mountain’).

  54. Lewis, M. (2009) The man who crashed the world. Vanity Fair, August.

  55. SEC (2014) Credit Rating Agencies, 5 September, http://www.sec.gov/spotlight/dodd-frank/creditratingagencies.shtml, accessed 28 January 2015.

  56. As pointed out earlier, the CRAs do not get paid for soverign ratings, which means that they do not have to please a paying customer. This is why the CRAs (particularly S&P) have been quicker in downgrading sovereign borrowers than paying corporate borrowers such as Enron.

  57. BBC (2011) Greece crisis: S&P warns of debt default. 4 July, http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-14010726, accessed 22 January 2015.

  58. The Economist (2012) The wait is over. 17 May.

  59. Müller, P., Sauga, M. and Schult, C. (2011) Breaking the power of the ‘big three’: German firm wants to set up new rating agency. Speigel Online International, 11 July.

  60. Cullen, A. (2013) European rating agency plan founders on lack of financing. Bloomberg Business, 29 April. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-04-29/european-rating-agency-plan-founders-on-lack-of-financing, accessed 5 March 2015.

  61. European Commission (2014) Credit rating agencies: commission adopts regulatory technical standards to implement stricter new rules, Press Release, 30 September, http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-14-1060_en.htm, accessed 4 January 2015.

  62. Roig-Franzia, M. (2009) Credit Crisis Cassandra: Brooksley Born’s Unheeded Warning is a Refuel 10 Years on, Washington Post 26 May.

  63. Cole, H.L. and Cooley, T.F. (2014) Rating Agencies, NBER Working Papers, No 19972.

  64. Richardson, M. and White, L. (2009) The rating agencies: Is regulation the answer? Financial Markets, Institutions & Instruments 18(2): 146–148.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  65. Katz, J., Salinas, E. and Stephanou, C. (2009) Credit Rating Agencies: No Easy Regulatory Solutions. Washington DC: The World Bank Group, October.

    Google Scholar 

  66. Securities and Exchange Board of India (2009) Report of the Committee on Comprehensive Regulation for Credit Rating Agencies, Mumbai, December.

  67. Fennell, D. and Medvedev, A. (2011) An Economic Analysis of Credit Rating Agency Business Models and Ratings Accuracy. London: Financial Services Authority.

    Google Scholar 

  68. Greenwood, J. (2012) Wiki joins rating game. Financial Post 28 January.

  69. It has been suggested that there is a real independent and transparent alternative to the common rating agencies, which is Wikirating, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eErg78D6GoA.

Download references

Author information

Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Imad A Moosa.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Moosa, I. The regulation of credit rating agencies: A realistic view. J Bank Regul 18, 180–200 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1057/jbr.2015.9

Download citation

Keywords

  • credit rating agencies
  • global financial crisis
  • European debt crisis
  • Dodd-frank act