The Relative Informativeness of Analysts’ Stock Return Forecasts and Rating Changes for Insurance Companies

  • Leon Chen
  • Steven W Pottier
Original Article


Stock return forecasts and financial strength ratings are supposed to represent concise and complete summary measures of the financial prospects of publicly traded insurance companies. The key questions for investors and other parties who may choose to rely on these metrics are whether they help predict actual stock returns and the relative informativeness of each metric. Ours is the first study to provide empirical evidence on these questions for insurers. Our forecasted stock returns are computed from target stock prices, which represent an explicit estimate of a firm’s future market value. We find that the mean 12-month-ahead (forecasted) stock return in our sample is around 20 per cent, while the actual mean annualised stock return is around 10 per cent, suggesting analysts’ optimism, inaccuracy, or some of both. Current period forecasted stock returns are positively correlated with past forecasted stock returns, and negatively correlated with past actual stock returns. Current period forecasted stock returns exhibit a strong positive association with future period actual stock returns, suggesting that forecasted stock returns are useful predictors of future actual stock returns. Furthermore, an increase in actual or forecasted stock returns decreases the likelihood of a rating downgrade, but has little relation to rating upgrades. These results support the usefulness of stock return forecasts to investors and rating agents.


insurer rating stock return target price analyst forecast 


  1. A.M. Best (1999–2012a) Best’s Key Rating Guide, Property-Casualty Edition, Oldwick, NJ: A.M. Best Co., Inc.Google Scholar
  2. A.M. Best (1999–2012b) Best’s Key Rating Guide, Life-Health Edition, Oldwick, NJ: A.M. Best Co., Inc.Google Scholar
  3. A.M. Best (2014) Best’s Credit Rating Methodology: Global Life and Non-Life Insurance Edition. April 2. Oldwick, NJ: A.M. Best Co., Inc.Google Scholar
  4. Ambrose, J.M. and Carroll, A. (1994) ‘Using best’s ratings in life insurer insolvency prediction’, The Journal of Risk and Insurance 61 (2): 317–327.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Ambrose, J.M. and Seward, J.A. (1988) ‘Best’s ratings, financial ratios and prior probabilities in insolvency prediction’, The Journal of Risk and Insurance 55 (2): 229–244.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Asquith, P., Mikhail, M.B. and Au, A.S. (2005) ‘Information content of equity analyst reports’, Journal of Financial Economics 75 (2): 245–282.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Beaver, W.H., Shakespeare, C. and Soliman, M.T. (2006) ‘Differential properties in the ratings of certified versus non-certified bond-rating agencies’, Journal of Accounting and Economics 42 (3): 303–334.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Boni, L. and Womack, K.L. (2006) ‘Analysts, industries, and price momentum’, The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 41 (1): 85–109.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Bonini, S., Pettinato, O. and Salvi, A. (2009) Do target prices predict rating changes, working paper.Google Scholar
  10. Brav, A. and Lehavy, R. (2003) ‘An empirical analysis of analysts’ target prices: Short-term informativeness and long-term dynamics’, The Journal of Finance 58 (5): 1933–1968.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Chen, L. and Pottier, S.W. (2014) An investigation of the short-run and long-run stock market response to insurer rating changes, working paper.Google Scholar
  12. Cummins, J.D. and Danzon, P.M. (1997) ‘Price, financial quality, and capital flows in insurance markets’, Journal of Financial Intermediation 6 (1): 3–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Cummins, J.D. and Nini, G.P. (2002) ‘Optimal capital utilization by financial firms: Evidence from the property-liability insurance industry’, Journal of Financial Services Research 21 (1/2): 15–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Da, Z. and Schaumburg, E. (2011) ‘Relative valuation and analyst target price forecasts’, Journal of Financial Markets 14 (1): 161–192.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Ederington, L.H. and Goh, J.C. (1998) ‘Bond rating agencies and stock analysts: Who knows what when?’ The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 33 (4): 569–585.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Epermanis, K. and Harrington, S.E. (2006) ‘Market discipline in property/casualty insurance: Evidence from premium growth surrounding changes in financial strength ratings’, Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 38 (6): 1515–1544.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Fama, E.F. (1998) ‘Market efficiency, long-term returns, and behavioral finance’, Journal of Financial Economics 49 (3): 283–306.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Fama, E.F. and French, K.R. (2000) ‘Forecasting profitability and earnings’, The Journal of Business 73 (2): 161–175.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Fan, D.K.K., So, R.W. and Yeh, J.J. (2006) ‘Analyst earnings forecasts for publicly traded insurance companies’, Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting 26 (2): 105–136.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Francis, J. and Soffer, L. (1997) ‘The relative informativeness of analysts’ stock recommendations and earnings forecast revisions’, Journal of Accounting Research 35 (2): 193–211.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Gaver, J.J. and Paterson, J.S. (2004) ‘Do insurers manipulate loss reserves to mask solvency problems?’ Journal of Accounting and Economics 37 (3): 393–416.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Gaver, J.J. and Pottier, S.W. (2005) ‘The role of holding company financial information in the insurer rating process: Evidence from the property-liability industry’, The Journal of Risk and Insurance 72 (1): 77–103.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Gleason, C.A., Johnson, W.B. and Li, H. (2013) ‘Valuation model use and the price target performance of sell-side equity analysts’, Contemporary Accounting Research 30 (1): 80–115.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Halek, M. and Eckles, D.L. (2010) ‘Effects of analysts’ ratings on insurer stock returns: Evidence of asymmetric responses’, The Journal of Risk and Insurance 77 (4): 801–827.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Hong, H. and Kubik, J.D. (2003) ‘Analyzing the analysts: Career concerns and biased earnings forecasts’, The Journal of Finance 58 (1): 313–351.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Miao, H., Ramchander, S. and Wang, T. (2014) ‘The response of bond prices to insurer rating changes’, The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance—Issues and Practice 39 (2): 389–413.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Morgan, D.P. (2002) ‘Rating banks: Risk and uncertainty in an opaque industry’, American Economic Review 92 (4): 874–888.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Petroni, K.R., Ryan, S.G. and Wahlen, J.M. (2000) ‘Discretionary and non-discretionary revisions of loss reserves by property-casualty insurers: Differential implications for future profitability, risk and market value’, Review of Accounting Studies 5 (2): 95–125.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Pottier, S.W. (1998) ‘Life insurer financial distress, best’s ratings and financial ratios’, The Journal of Risk and Insurance 65 (2): 275–288.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Pottier, S.W. and Sommer, D.W. (1999) ‘Property-liability insurer financial strength ratings: Differences across rating agencies’, The Journal of Risk and Insurance 66 (4): 621–642.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Pottier, S.W. and Sommer, D.W. (2006) ‘Opaqueness in the insurance industry: Why are some insurers harder to evaluate than others?’ Risk Management and Insurance Review 9 (2): 149–163.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Schweitzer, R., Szewczyk, S.H. and Varma, R. (1992) ‘Bond rating agencies and their role in bank market discipline’, Journal of Financial Services Research 6 (3): 249–263.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Singh, A.K. and Power, M.L. (1992) ‘The effects of best’s rating changes on insurance company stock prices’, The Journal of Risk and Insurance 59 (2): 310–317.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Wooldridge, J. (2002) Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data, 1st edn Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
  35. Wooldridge, J. (2013) Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach, 5th edn. Mason, OH: South-Western.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The International Association for the Study of Insurance Economics 2015

Authors and Affiliations

  • Leon Chen
    • 1
  • Steven W Pottier
    • 2
  1. 1.Department of FinanceCollege of Business, Minnesota State University at MankatoMankatoU.S.A.
  2. 2.Department of InsuranceLegal Studies, and Real Estate, Terry College of Business, University of GeorgiaAthensU.S.A.

Personalised recommendations