British Politics

, Volume 5, Issue 4, pp 525–548 | Cite as

Gripped by the past: Nostalgia and the 2010 Labour party leadership contest

  • Richard Jobson
  • Mark Wickham-Jones
Original Article

Abstract

Ed Miliband was elected to the Labour leadership claiming that ‘the past is another country’. In this article, we assess Labour's transition from office to opposition in 2010 and we address the nostalgic dimension of the party's politics through an examination of the 2010 contest for the party leadership. We scrutinise the role of nostalgia in shaping Labour politics and evaluate its contribution to debates within the party. Historically, Labour has been identified as a nostalgic party, one deeply attached to the past. New Labour, however, claimed to have broken with such an outlook. During the 2010 contest for the party leadership, both leading candidates, David Miliband and Ed Miliband, also claimed to reject a nostalgic orientation. An examination of their campaigns indicates, however, that both, along with two other contestants, Ed Balls and Andy Burnham, made reference to the past in the orientation of their candidacies. All four male candidates offered signals locating themselves within Labour's history. We conclude that nostalgia shaped the 2010 leadership contest: it hindered the development of any candidate developing the kind of modernising appeal on which New Labour was based; it helped to define the locations of the candidates; and it moulded the claims and counter-claims made by the Miliband brothers against each other. Labour's relationship with the present remains defined, in part, by its complicated historical understanding of the past. As far as the Labour party is concerned, the past is rarely another country.

Keywords

history identity Labour party leadership election nostalgia social democracy 

References

  1. Adams, T. (2010) When politics is in the blood. The Observer, 5 September: 8.Google Scholar
  2. Anstead, N. and Straw, W. (eds.) (2009) The Change We Need. London: Fabian Society.Google Scholar
  3. Asthana, A. and Wyatt, D. (2010) John Smith's widow backs Ed Miliband. The Observer, 18 July: 6.Google Scholar
  4. Balls, E. (2009) Bring it on. New Statesman, 17 September, www.newstatesman.com/uk-politics/2009/09/labour-state-choice-tax-tories.
  5. Balls, E. (2010a) There is an alternative. speech, Bloomberg, 27 August, http://www.edballs4labour.org/blog/?p=907.
  6. Balls, E. (2010b) Ed Balls’. In The Labour Leadership. London: The Fabians, pp. 15–28, http://www.fabians.org.uk/images/Labour_Leadership_Essays.pdf.Google Scholar
  7. Balls, E. (2010c) Statement. Tribune, 29 May, www.tribunemagazine.co.uk/2010/05/29/ed-balls-statement.
  8. Balls, E. (2010d) Defending our values, fighting for fairness. Letter to Labour party members, 2010.Google Scholar
  9. Balls, E. (2010e) Urgent campaign message – leadership 2010. email Labour party members, 17 June 2010.Google Scholar
  10. Balls, E. (2010f) Ed Balls for leader. letter to Labour party members, 2010.Google Scholar
  11. Baskerville, S. and Stears, M. (2010) London citizens and the Labour tradition. Renewal 18 (34): 65–70.Google Scholar
  12. Benn, T. (2002) Free at Last. London: Hutchinson.Google Scholar
  13. Blair, T. (1995) Speech Labour Party Annual Conference Report 1994. London, Labour party.Google Scholar
  14. Blair, T. (1996) Towards a decent, responsible society. The Times, 4 November.Google Scholar
  15. Blair, T. (2010) A Journey. London: Hutchinson.Google Scholar
  16. Boym, S. (2001) The Future of Nostalgia. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
  17. Bright, M. (2009) The history boys. New Statesman, 20 September, http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/martin-bright/2007/09/conference-brown-party.
  18. Burnham, A. (2004) Speech Labour Party Annual Conference Report 2003. London, Labour party.Google Scholar
  19. Burnham, A. (2010a) Andy Burnham. In The Labour Leadership. London: The Fabians, pp. 29–40, http://www.fabians.org.uk/images/Labour_Leadership_Essays.pdf.Google Scholar
  20. Burnham, A. (2010b) Why I can reconnect Labour – Leadership 2010, email to Labour party members, 11 June.Google Scholar
  21. Burnham, A. (2010c) Speech Labour Party Conference, 29 September.Google Scholar
  22. Campbell, A. (2007) The Blair Years. London: Arrow books.Google Scholar
  23. Cook, R. (1996) Goodbye to nostalgia. The Guardian, 14 October: 16.Google Scholar
  24. Cronin, J. (2004) New Labour's Pasts. Harlow, UK: Longman.Google Scholar
  25. D'Ancona, M. (2010a) This is no fresh start. Evening Standard, 27 September.Google Scholar
  26. D'Ancona, M. (2010b) His brother's jealously could make a leader of Miliband. The Sunday Telegraph, 28 August: 18.Google Scholar
  27. Drucker, H. (1978) Doctrine and Ethos in the Labour Party. London: George Allen and Urwin.Google Scholar
  28. EdBallsMP. (2010) Ed Balls visits Cornwall … and drums with his penpal Davi. 9 September 2010 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sp9g8TMW5-Y.
  29. Electoral Commission. (2010) Register of donations to regulated donees. 8 July 2010, 12 August 2010 and 9 September, http://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/party-finance/database-of-registers.
  30. Evening Standard. (2010) David Miliband wins the backing of London big hitters. 2 July.Google Scholar
  31. Fairclough, N. (2000) New Labour New Language? London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  32. Ferguson, M. (2010) Do we have the courage to change. Interview with Ed Miliband, 23 August 2010, Labour List, http://www.labourlist.org/mark-ferguson-ed-miliband-interview-leadership-courage-change.
  33. Fielding, S. (2000) New Labour and the past. In: D. Tanner, P. Thane and N. Tiratsoo (eds.) Labour's First Century. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pp. 367–392.Google Scholar
  34. Freedland, J. (2010) Comment: Labour needs the credibility of David and the freshness of Ed. The Guardian, 1 September: 31.Google Scholar
  35. Gerrard, E. (2009) When we fight we win. email to Labour party members, 18 November.Google Scholar
  36. Gerrard, E. (2010) Ellie's story. video upload at http://www.youtube.com/user/theuklabourpartyp/search/0/KsWdZwtfzsk.
  37. Ginsburg, C. (2001) ‘“Your country needs you”: A case study in political iconography’. History Workshop Journal 52: 1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Goodwin, S. (1995) Labour in Brighton. The Independent, 2 October: 8.Google Scholar
  39. Gould, P. (1998) The Unfinished Revolution. London: Little Brown.Google Scholar
  40. Grice, A. (2010a) Cruddas opts to back David Miliband. The Independent, 26 August: 10.Google Scholar
  41. Grice, A. (2010b) Ed Miliband hits back at brother's criticism. The Independent, 27 August: 8.Google Scholar
  42. Hasan, M. (2010) Hooray for Diane Abbott. The Guardian, 21 May: 6.Google Scholar
  43. Hay, C. (1999) The Political Economy of New Labour Labouring Under False Pretences. Manchester, UK: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
  44. Heisler, M. (2008) The political currency of the past: History, memory and identity. The Annals of the American of Political and Social Science 617: 14–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Hirsch, M. and Spitzer, L. (2003) ‘We would never have come without you’: Generations of nostalgia. In: K. Hodgkin and S. Radstone (eds.) Contested Pasts: The Politics of Memory. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  46. Hobsbawn, E. and Ranger, T. (eds.) (1983) The Invention of Tradition. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  47. Hutton, W. (2010) Made in Dagenham shows why Ed Miliband shouldn’t lead Labour. The Observer, 19 September: 32.Google Scholar
  48. Ibreck, R. (2009) Remembering Humanity. The Politics of Genocide Memorialisation in Rwanda. PhD thesis, University of Bristol.Google Scholar
  49. King, D. and Wickham-Jones, M. (1999) ‘Blair and Clinton: The democratic (party) origins of welfare to work’, with Desmond King. Political Quarterly 70 (1): 62–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Labour party. (1996) New Life for Britain. London: Labour party.Google Scholar
  51. Labour party. (2009) Fighters and believers. political broadcast at http://il.youtube.com/watch?v=iOYlDmVB3tM.
  52. Labour party. (2010a) Candidate Booklet. London: Labour party.Google Scholar
  53. Labour party. (2010b) The Labour Party Internal Elections 2010. London: Labour party.Google Scholar
  54. Lawrence, J. (2000) Labour – The myths it has lived by. In: D. Tanner, P. Thane and N. Tiratsoo (eds.) Labour's First Century. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pp. 341–367.Google Scholar
  55. MacIntyre, S. (1995) Who are the true believers? Labour History 68: 155–167.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Maguire, K. (2010) Will the miners ever meet Miliband minor? New Statesman, 8 July.Google Scholar
  57. Mandelson, P. (2002) The Blair Revolution Revisited. London: Politicos.Google Scholar
  58. Mandelson, P. and Liddle, R. (1996) The Blair Revolution. London: Faber.Google Scholar
  59. Marquand, D. (1988) Labour must break with labourism to provide a socialist alternative for Britain. The Guardian, 29 March.Google Scholar
  60. Marr, A. (1994) Blair dares where Gaitskell failed. The Independent, 5 October.Google Scholar
  61. McElvoy, A. (1995) The killing of clause 4. The Times, 22 April.Google Scholar
  62. Miliband, D. (2010a) Keir Hardie memorial lecture. Cynon Valley, 9 July 2010. http://www.davidmiliband.net/2010/07/09/keir-hardie-lecture-2010/.
  63. Miliband, D. (2010b) Introducing ‘Keir Hardie day’. Statement, http://www.davidmiliband.net/2010/07/09/introducing-keir-hardie-day/.
  64. Miliband, D. (2010c) Statement. Tribune, 27 May 2010, http://www.tribunemagazine.co.uk/2010/05/27/david-miliban.
  65. Miliband, D. (2010d) The change Britain needs. speech, 25 August 2010, http://www.davidmiliband.net/2010/08/25/the-change-britain-needs-speech-at-king-solomon-academy/.
  66. Miliband, D. (2010e) David Miliband. In The Labour Leadership. London: The Fabians, pp. 41–54, http://www.fabians.org.uk/images/Labour_Leadership_Essays.pdf.Google Scholar
  67. Miliband, E. (2008) The key is respect. speech, Compass, 14 June 2008 New Statesman, 19 June 2008. www.newstatesman.com/uk-politics/2008/06/government-change-progressive.
  68. Miliband, E. (2010a) Speech, Labour party conference, 28 September.Google Scholar
  69. Miliband, E. (2010b) Change to win. Statement, 2010, http://edmiliband.org/learnmore/we-need-to-change-to-win-eds-fabian-essay/.
  70. Miliband, E. (2010c) A mandate for change. Speech, 27 August 2010, http://edmiliband.org/learnmore/speeches/a-mandate-for-change/.
  71. Miliband, E. (2010d) Why I’m standing. Speech, Leeds, 10 June 2010, http://edmiliband.org/learnmore/speeches/3-why-im-standing/.
  72. Miliband, E. (2010e) Statement. Tribune, 2 June 2010, www.tribunemagazine.co.uk/2010/06/02/ed-milibands-statement.
  73. Minkin, L. (1980) The Labour Party Conference. Manchester, UK: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
  74. Mulgan, G. (1993) Desperately seeking strategy. The Guardian, 27 September: 20.Google Scholar
  75. Mulholland, H. (2010) You are buying the Labour leadership, Abbott accuses Miliband. The Guardian, 3 August: 4.Google Scholar
  76. Newsnight. (2010) Labour leadership husting. June 2010, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lnBhEJLy0oM.
  77. Prince, R. (2010) Ed Miliband: Lord Mandelson book should ‘close chapter’ on New Labour. The Daily Telegraph, 13 July, http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/7888311/Ed-Miliband-Lord-Mandelson-book-should-close-chapter-on-New-Labour.html.
  78. Randall, N. (2009) Time and British politics: Memory, the present and teleology in the politics of New Labour. British Politics 4 (2): 188–216.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Richards, S. (2010) The dawn of generation Ed. The Independent, 29 September: 1.Google Scholar
  80. Robinson, E. (2010) ‘Our historic mission’ party political pasts and futures in contemporary Britain. PhD thesis, Goldsmiths College, University of London.Google Scholar
  81. Roy, E. (2010) Ed's Govan moment. 29 September 2010, newsnetscotland, http://newsnetscotland.com/speakers/706-eds-govan-moment.
  82. Samuel, R. (1994) Theatres of Memory: Volume One Past and Present in Contemporary Culture. London: Verso.Google Scholar
  83. Santesso, A. (2006) A Careful Longing: The Poetics and Problems of Nostalgia. Newark, NJ: University of Delaware Press.Google Scholar
  84. Shaw, E. (1996) The Labour Party since 1945. Oxford, UK: Blackwell.Google Scholar
  85. Shipton, M. (2010) Our labour of love. Wales on Sunday, 4 July: 36.Google Scholar
  86. Sparrow, A. (2010) Labour conference live, guardian.co.uk, 26 September 2010, http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/blog/2010/sep/26/labour-labourconference.
  87. Strangleman, T. (1999) The nostalgia of organisations and the organisation of nostalgia: Past and present in the contemporary railway industry. Sociology 33 (4): 725–746.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. Stratton, A. (2010a) Ed Miliband rehearses ‘good society’ guru's lines in conference speech, guardian.co.uk, 28 September 2010. http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2010/sep/28/ed-miliband-speech-maurice-glasman.
  89. Stratton, A. (2010b) Labour leadership race. The Guardian, 16 August: 4.Google Scholar
  90. Stratton, A. and Wintour, P. (2010) Burnham bases labour leadership push on a return to socialist values. The Guardian, 2 July: 13.Google Scholar
  91. Stratton, A., Watt, N. and Wintour, P. (2010) Ed Miliband backers accused over ballot mail-out. The Guardian, 25 September: 6–7.Google Scholar
  92. Tallentire, M. (2010) Thousands fill streets for 126th big meeting. The Northern Echo, 12 July: 4.Google Scholar
  93. Watson, R. (2010) In my mind new labour lost its way in the second term. The Times, 5 June: 22–23.Google Scholar
  94. Watt, N. (2010a) Rivals turn on Milibands. The Guardian, 27 August: 14.Google Scholar
  95. Watt, N. (2010b) David Miliband attack risks rift with brother. The Guardian, 25 August: 11.Google Scholar
  96. Webb, B. (2010) Whither Labour's working class heritage. Tribune, 7 August. www.tribunemagazine.co.uk/2010/08/07/working-class-labou/.
  97. Wheeler, B. (2010) Labour's contenders: Andy Burnham. BBC News, 19 July 2010. www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-10561765.
  98. White, M. (2010) Burnham launches blitz on ‘metropolitan elite’. The Guardian, 23 August: 4.Google Scholar
  99. Wickham-Jones, M. (2005) Signalling credibility: Electoral strategy and New Labour in Britain. Political Science Quarterly 120: 653–673.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  100. Wintour, P., Stratton, A. and, Watt, N. (2010) Labour leadership race. The Guardian, 24 September: 6.Google Scholar
  101. Young, H. (1993) Thinking or sinking together. The Guardian, 14 January: 20.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Ltd 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  • Richard Jobson
    • 1
  • Mark Wickham-Jones
    • 2
  1. 1.Department of Historical StudiesUniversity of BristolBristolUK
  2. 2.School of Sociology, Politics and International RelationsBristolUK

Personalised recommendations