Advertisement

BioSocieties

, Volume 11, Issue 2, pp 152–174 | Cite as

Vaccine resistances reconsidered: Vaccine skeptics and the Jenny McCarthy effect

  • Samantha D Gottlieb
Original Article

Abstract

Recent data and increased vaccine-preventable disease outbreaks suggest that a growing number of US parents choose not to vaccinate their children. Popular media have responded to this phenomenon by emphasizing refusers’ moral failings and irrational fears. This article explores vaccine skeptics’ objections and argues that their critics miss fundamental reasons for resistances. Drawing on ethnographic research with a community of vaccine skeptics in southern California, a consideration of a leading vaccine researcher’s responses to vaccine critics and an analysis of Jenny McCarthy’s condemnation of current vaccine practices, this research considers why even parents who have accepted some vaccines, but not all, distrust vaccines and their proponents. Parents’ skepticism merits new forms of engagement by physicians and other vaccine advocates. As with any health intervention, vaccines can present some risks to a small number of recipients; when public health and clinical messages minimize parents’ fears, they may increase parental doubt. The voices of parents who choose to opt out of or to alter the normal vaccine schedule reveal important expressions of biomedical resistance.

Keywords

vaccines parental resistance Jenny McCarthy 

Notes

Acknowledgements

I appreciate the anonymous reviewers for their time and insightful feedback. I wish to thank Abigail Baim-Lance, William Muraskin, and Lauren Heidbrink for reading and commenting on earlier versions of this article. Hadley Leach and Richard Gottlieb have contributed useful editorial comments. I want to acknowledge all the research participants, especially those who shared their families’ lives and intimate details with me during fieldwork.

This research was funded by the Wenner-Gren Foundation grant #7754 and the National Science Foundation grant # 0724616. The author declares no conflict of interest.

References

  1. Applbaum, K. (2009) ‘Consumers are patients!’ Shared decision-making and treatment non-compliance as business opportunity. Transcultural Psychiatry 46 (1): 107–130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Associated Press (2015) Obama addresses vaccinations, other issues in NBC interview. NPR, http://www.npr.org/2015/02/02/383188121/obama-addresses-vaccinations-other-issues-in-nbc-interview, accessed 5 March 2015.
  3. Atwell, J.E. et al (2013) Nonmedical vaccine exemptions and pertussis in California, 2010. Pediatrics 132 (4): 624–630.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Baker, J.P. (2003) The pertussis vaccine controversy in Great Britain, 1974–1986. Vaccine 21 (25–26): 4003–4010.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Bandura, A. (1994) Social cognitive theory and exercise of control over HIV infection. In: R.J. DiClemente and J.L. Peterson (eds.) Preventing AIDS. New York: Springer, pp. 25–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bartholomaus, D. (n.d.) Anti-vaccine body count. http://www.jennymccarthybodycount.com/Anti-Vaccine_Body_Count/FAQ.html, formerly known as http://www.jennymccarthybodycount.com, originally accessed 2 February 2010.
  7. Black, C.L., Yankey, D. and Kolasa, M. (2012) National, state, and local area vaccination coverage among children aged 19–35 months – United States, 2011. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 61 (35): 689–696.Google Scholar
  8. Black, C.L., Yankey, D. and Kolasa, M. (2013) National, state, and local area vaccination coverage among children aged 19–35 months – United States, 2012. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 62 (36): 733–737.Google Scholar
  9. Blinder, A. (2015) Mississippi, a vaccination leader, stands by its strict rules. The New York Times, 4 February.Google Scholar
  10. Blume, S.S. (2005) Lock in, the state and vaccine development: Lessons from the history of the polio vaccines. Research Policy 34 (2): 159–173.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Blume, S. (2006) Anti-vaccination movements and their interpretations. Social Science & Medicine 62 (3): 628–642.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Blume, S. and Zanders, M. (2006) Vaccine independence, local competences and globalisation: Lessons from the history of pertussis vaccines. Social Science & Medicine 63 (7): 1825–1835.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Boholm, A. (2003) The cultural nature of risk: Can there be an anthropology of uncertainty? Ethnos 68 (2): 159–178.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Brownlie, J. and Howson, A. (2005) Leaps of faith and MMR: An empirical study of trust. Sociology 39 (2): 221–239.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Brunson, E.K. (2013) The impact of social networks on parents’ vaccination decisions. Pediatrics 131 (5): e1397–e1404.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. California Department of Public Health, Immunization Branch (2015) 2014–2015 Kindergarten immunization assessment results, http://www.cdph.ca.gov/programs/immunize/Documents/2014-15%20CA%20Kindergarten%20Immunization%20Assessment.pdf, accessed 12 March 2015.
  17. Campion, E.W. (2002) Suspicions about the safety of vaccines. New England Journal of Medicine 347 (19): 1474–1475.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Caplan, A.L., Hoke, D., Diamond, N.J. and Karshenboyem, V. (2012) Free to choose but liable for the consequences: Should non-vaccinators be penalized for the harm they do? Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 40 (3): 606–611.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Carlat, B.D. (2007) Dr. Drug rep. New York Times, 25 November.Google Scholar
  20. Centers for Disease Control (n.d.(a)) About ACIP – Vaccines, http://www.cdc.gov: http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/acip/about.html, accessed 3 April 2015.
  21. Centers for Disease Control (n.d.(b)) Measles cases and outbreaks. http://www.cdc.gov: http://www.cdc.gov/measles/cases-outbreaks.html, accessed 15 March 2015.
  22. Colgrove, J.K. (2006) State of Immunity: The Politics of Vaccination in Twentieth-Century America. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  23. DeStefano, F., Price, C.S. and Weintraub, E.S. (2013) Increasing exposure to antibody-stimulating proteins and polysaccharides in vaccines is not associated with risk of autism. Journal of Pediatrics 163 (2): 561–567.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Diekema, D.S. (2005) Responding to parental refusals of immunization of children. Pediatrics 115 (5): 1428–1431.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Diekema, D.S. (2012) Improving childhood vaccination rates. New England Journal of Medicine 366 (5): 391–393.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Douglas, M. and Wildavsky, A. (1983) Risk and Culture: An Essay on the Selection of Technological and Environmental Dangers. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  27. Dumit, J. (2012) Drugs for Life: How Pharmaceutical Companies Define our Health. Durham and London: Duke University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Elam-Evans, L.D. et al (2014) National, regional, state, and selected local area vaccination coverage among adolescents aged 13–17 years – United States, 2013. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 63 (29): 625–633.Google Scholar
  29. Farley, T. (2014) A butterfly flaps its wings on twitter, and a vaccine map goes viral. http://skeptools.wordpress.com/2014/01/27/butterfly-flaps-wings-twitter-vaccine-map-viral-cfr-denialism/, accessed 29 January 2014.
  30. Feudtner, C. and Marcuse, E.K. (2001) Ethics and immunization policy: Promoting dialogue to sustain consensus. Pediatrics 107 (5): 1158–1164.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Fischetti, M. (2013) Too many children go unvaccinated. Scientific American 308 (6), 14 May http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/too-many-children-go-unvaccinated/, accessed 23 March 2015.
  32. Generation Rescue (n.d.) Resources: Vaccination, http://www.generationrescue.org/resources/vaccination, accessed 5 May 2014.
  33. Glanz, J.M. et al (2013) A population-based cohort study of undervaccination in 8 managed care organizations across the United States. JAMA Pediatrics 167 (3): 274–281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Gottlieb, S.D. (forthcoming) ‘Protecting Life’: The Case of Texas Legislation and Resistances to Gardasil, the HPV Vaccine. In: N. Bulled (ed.) Speaking to Power: Resisting the Biomedical Hegemony During an Age of Advanced Biomedical Technologies. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press, in press.Google Scholar
  35. Grady, D. (2015) Vaccinations are states’ call. The New York Times, 16 February.Google Scholar
  36. Harris, G. (2008) Deal in an autism case fuels debate on vaccine. The New York Times, 8 March.Google Scholar
  37. Hassidim, A. et al (2008) Outbreak of measles – San Diego, California, January–February 2008. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 57 (08): 203–206.Google Scholar
  38. Hilton, S., Hunt, K. and Petticrew, M. (2006) Gaps in parental understandings and experiences of vaccine-preventable diseases: A qualitative study. Child: Care, Health and Development 33 (2): 170–179.Google Scholar
  39. Hiltzik, M. (2014) The toll of the anti-vaccination movement, in one devastating graphic. Los Angeles Times, 20 January, http://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-mh-antivaccination-movement-20140120-story.html, accessed 22 January 2014.
  40. Hobson-West, P. (2003) Understanding vaccination resistance: Moving beyond risk. Health, Risk & Society 5 (3): 273–283.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Hobson-West, P. (2007) Trusting blindly can be the biggest risk of all: Organised resistance to childhood vaccination in the UK. Sociology of Health & Illness 29 (2): 198–215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Hollywood Life Staff (2010) New report says: Jenny McCarthy’s son may not have had autism after all. http://hollywoodlife.com/2010/02/26/jenny-mccarthy-says-her-son-evan-never-had-autism/, accessed 3 January 2014.
  43. Hubert-Allen, O. and Aliferis, L. (2013) More California parents opting out of vaccines; look up your school online, http://blogs.kqed.org/stateofhealth/2013/09/06/more-california-parents-opting-out-of-vaccines-look-up-your-school-online/, accessed 10 September 2013.
  44. Institute of Medicine (2013) Report Brief: The Childhood Immunization Schedule and Safety Stakeholder Concerns, Scientific Evidence, and Future Studies. Washington DC: The National Academies Press.Google Scholar
  45. Johnston, R.D. (2004) The Politics of Healing: Histories of Alternative Medicine in Twentieth-Century North America. New York and London: Psychology Press.Google Scholar
  46. Kata, A. (2012) Anti-vaccine activists, web 2.0, and the postmodern paradigm – An overview of tactics and tropes used online by the anti-vaccination movement. Vaccine 30 (25): 3778–3789.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Kaufman, S.R. (2010) Regarding the rise in autism: Vaccine safety doubt, conditions of inquiry, and the shape of freedom. Ethos 38 (1): 8–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Kirkland, A. (2012) Credibility battles in the autism litigation. Social Studies of Science 42 (2): 237–261.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Krieger, L.M. and Calefati, J. (2015) Measles outbreak: Vaccination exemption would end under proposed California law. San Jose Mercury News, 5 February, http://www.mercurynews.com/health/ci_27458564/legislation-introduced-repeal-opt-out-provision-vaccination-law, accessed 16 February 2015.
  50. Kutner, J. (2015) Sorry again, anti-vaxxers: HPV vaccine works, doesn’t lead young women to have crazy unsafe sex. Salon.com, http://www.salon.com/2015/02/10/sorry_again_anti_vaxxers_hpv_vaccine_works_doesnt_lead_young_women_to_have_crazy_unsafe_sex/, accessed 17 February 2015.
  51. Leach, M. and Fairhead, J. (2007) Vaccine Anxieties: Global Science, Child Health and Society, Science in Society. London: Earthscan.Google Scholar
  52. Levi, B.H. (2007) Addressing parents’ concerns about childhood immunizations: A tutorial for primary care providers. Pediatrics 120 (1): 18–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Luhmann, N. (1993) Communication and Social Order: Risk: A Sociological Theory. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.Google Scholar
  54. Lupton, D. and Tulloch, J. (2002) ‘Life would be pretty dull without risk’: Voluntary risk-taking and its pleasures. Health, Risk & Society 4 (2): 113–124.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. McGreevy, P. (2015) Bill would abolish vaccination exemption for parents’ personal beliefs. Los Angeles Times, 4 February http://www.latimes.com/local/political/la-me-pc-lawmakers-propose-to-increase-vaccinations-of-schoolchildren-story.html, accessed 16 February 2015.
  56. Mnookin, S. (2011) An early cure for parents’ vaccine panic. The Washington Post, 10 June.Google Scholar
  57. Mnookin, S. (2012) The whole cell pertussis vaccine, media malpractice, and the long-term effects of avoiding difficult conversations. PLOS blogs networkhttp://blogs.plos.org/blog/2012/09/13/the-whole-cell-pertussis-vaccine-media-malpractice-and-the-long-term-effects-of-avoiding-difficult-conversations/, accessed 1 July 2014.
  58. Montaño, D.E., Kasprzyk, D. and Taplin, S.H. (1996) The theory of reasoned action and the theory of planned behavior. In: K. Glanz, B.K. Rimer and K. Viswanath (eds.) Health behavior and Health Education: Theory, Research, and Practice. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.Google Scholar
  59. Muraskin, W.A. (2012) Polio Eradication and its Discontents: An Historian’s Journey Through an International Public Health (UN) Civil War. New Delhi: Orient Blackswan.Google Scholar
  60. Murch, S.H. et al (2004) Retraction of an interpretation. Lancet 363 (9411): 750.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Nagourney, A. and Goodnough, A. (2015) Measles cases linked to Disneyland rise, and debate over vaccinations intensifies. The New York Times, 21 January.Google Scholar
  62. Nyhan, B., Reifler, J., Richey, S. and Freed, G.L. (2014) Effective messages in vaccine promotion: A randomized trial. Pediatrics 133 (4): e835–e842.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Offit, P.A. (2008) Inoculated against facts. The New York Times, 31 March.Google Scholar
  64. Oldani, M.J. (2004) Thick prescriptions: Toward an interpretation of pharmaceutical sales practices. Medical Anthropology Quarterly 18 (3): 325–356.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Orenstein, W.A., Papania, M.J. and Wharton, M.E. (2004) Measles elimination in the United States. Journal of Infectious Diseases 189 (Supplement 1): S1–S3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Panter-Brick, C. (2014) Health, risk, and resilience: Interdisciplinary concepts and applications. Annual Review of Anthropology 43: 431–448.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Parikh, R. (2012) Will Olympics spread measles? Salon.com., 26 July, http://www.salon.com/2012/07/26/will_olympics_spread_measles/, accessed 27 May 2014.
  68. Perry, D. (2013) Jenny McCarthy and fear-based parenting. CNN.com., http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/17/opinion/perry-jenny-mccarthy-autism/, accessed 28 August 2013.
  69. Pollack, A. and Saul, S. (2007) Merck to Halt Lobbying for Vaccine for Girls. The New York Times 21 February.Google Scholar
  70. Robertson, A. (2001) Biotechnology, political rationality and discourses on health risk. Health 5 (3): 293–309.Google Scholar
  71. Rose, D. and Blume, S. (2005) Citizens as users of technology: An exploratory study of vaccines and vaccinations. In: N. Oudshoorn and T. Pinch (eds.) How Users Matter: The Co-Construction of Users and Technology. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
  72. Salmon, D.A., Teret, S.P., MacIntyre, C.R., Salisbury, D., Burgess, M.A. and Halsey, N.A. (2006) Compulsory vaccination and conscientious or philosophical exemptions: Past, present, and future. The Lancet 367 (9508): 436–442.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. SB-277 (2015) An act to amend Sections 120325, 120335, 120370, and 120375 of, to add Section 120338 to, and to repeal Section 120365 of, the Health and Safety Code, relating to public health.Google Scholar
  74. Senier, L. (2008) ‘It’s your most precious thing’: Worst-case thinking, trust, and parental decision making about vaccinations. Sociological Inquiry 78 (2): 207–229.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Smith, S.L. (1997) The effective use of fear appeals in persuasive immunization: An analysis of national immunization intervention messages. Journal of Applied Communication Research 25 (4): 264–292.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Smoker, K. (2008) Horton hears an ‘ow!’. Las Cruces Sun-News, 19 March.Google Scholar
  77. Standen, A. and Brooks, J. (2013) Marin vaccination opt-outs increase, despite the science. KQED News Fix, 21 August, http://blogs.kqed.org/newsfix/2013/08/21/marin-vaccinations/, accessed 26 August 2013.
  78. Streefland, P., Chowdhury, A.M.R. and Ramos-Jimenez, P. (1999) Patterns of vaccination acceptance. Social Science & Medicine 49 (12): 1705–1716.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Streefland, P.H. (2001) Public doubts about vaccination safety and resistance against vaccination. Health Policy 55 (3): 159–172.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Taylor, G. (2007) Adventures in autism: Jenny McCarthy on Oprah: Vaccine injury finally. http://adventuresinautism.blogspot.com/2007/09/jenny-mccarthy-on-oprah-vaccine-injury.html, accessed 23 November 2013.
  81. Wakefield, A.J. et al (1998) RETRACTED: Ileal-lymphoid-nodular hyperplasia, non-specific colitis, and pervasive developmental disorder in children. The Lancet 351 (9103): 637–641.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Yaqub, O., Castle-Clarke, S., Sevdalis, N. and Chataway, J. (2014) Attitudes to vaccination: A critical review. Social Science & Medicine 112: 1–11.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© The London School of Economics and Political Science 2015

Authors and Affiliations

  • Samantha D Gottlieb
    • 1
    • 2
  1. 1.University of California, Berkeley, Center for Science, Technology, Medicine and SocietyCAUSA
  2. 2.Department of AnthropologyGeography, and Environmental Studies, California State University, East BayHaywardUSA

Personalised recommendations