The High Costs of UBI are not Financial: They are Real
When considering the viability of universal basic income (UBI) and other large-scale federal programs, we would do well to look at the real, rather than financial costs. This shift in perspective is useful because, as the Federal Reserve has reminded us time and again, taxes are not a funding operation for the federal government.
In an important piece titled ‘Taxes for Revenue are Obsolete,’ NY Federal Reserve Chairman Ruml (1946) stressed that the crucial consideration when imposing taxes is their social and economic consequences, not their funding capacity. While tax revenue ensures the solvency of state and local governments, this is not true for the federal government, whose spending is operationally unconstrained due to the elimination of currency convertibility and advances in Central Bank management (ibid.). Other Federal Reserve papers and statements corroborate this analysis (e.g., Bernanke 2002, 2009; Fawley and Juvenal 2011). The realimpact of taxes on the economy is their...
- Bernanke, Ben. 2002. Deflation: Making sure ‘it’ doesn’t happen here. Speech before the National Economists Club, Washington, D.C. 21 Nov.Google Scholar
- Bernanke, Ben. 2009. Ben Bernanke’s greatest challenge. 60 Minutes interview. 15 Mar.Google Scholar
- Fawley, Brett, and Juvenal, Luciana. 2011. Why health care matters and the current debt does not. The Regional Economist. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. 4–5 Oct.Google Scholar
- Greenspan, Alan. 2005. Economic outlook and fiscal issues: Congressional testimony. https://www.c-span.org/video/?c3886511/2005-greenspan-ryan-024200. 2 Mar.
- Murray, Charles. 2016. A guaranteed income for every American. The Wall Street Journal. 3 Jun.Google Scholar
- Ruml, Beardsley. 1946. Taxes for revenue are obsolete. American Affairs 8(1): 35–39.Google Scholar
- Standing, Guy. 2011. The precariat: The new dangerous class. London: Bloomsbury Publishing.Google Scholar
- Tcherneva, Pavlina R. 2013. The job guarantee: Delivering the benefits that basic income only promises. Journal of Basic Income Studies 7(2): 66–87.Google Scholar
- Tcherneva, Pavlina R. 2017. At issue: Should the United States adopt a universal basic income? Congressional Quarterly Researcher 27(31): 741.Google Scholar