Advertisement

British Politics

, Volume 13, Issue 2, pp 171–194 | Cite as

Tales of the unexpected: The selection of British party leaders since 1963

  • Andrew Denham
  • Peter Dorey
Original Article

Abstract

Jeremy Corbyn’s election as Leader of the Labour Party in 2015 stunned observers and practitioners of British politics alike. In this article, we first outline a theoretical framework that purports to explain why political parties operating in parliamentary systems choose the leaders they do. We then examine 32 leadership successions involving five major British parties since 1963, and note that many of these were unexpected, in that they were triggered by unforeseen circumstances, such as the sudden death or resignation of the incumbent. Examining each party in turn, we briefly explain why the winners won and identify at least eight cases (a quarter of our sample) where a candidate widely expected to prevail at the outset was ultimately defeated by a ‘dark horse’, ‘second favourite’ or even ‘rank outsider’. Of these, Corbyn’s election in 2015 was the most unexpected and, consistent with the findings of studies of party leadership conventions in other parliamentary systems, namely Canada and Spain, suggests that ideological and policy concerns are sometimes more important than considerations of party unity and electability, especially when a leadership contest is dominated by party activists.

Keywords

political parties party leaders leadership selection parliamentary systems Members of Parliament (MPs) 

References

  1. Alderman, K. (1996) The Conservative Party leadership election of 1995. Parliamentary Affairs 49(2): 316–332.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Alderman, K. (1998) The Conservative Party leadership election of 1997. Parliamentary Affairs 51(1): 1–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Alderman, K. and Carter, N. (1991) A very Tory coup: The ousting of Mrs Thatcher’. Parliamentary Affairs 44(2): 125–139.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Alderman, K. and Carter, N. (1993) The Labour Party leadership and deputy leadership elections of 1992. Parliamentary Affairs 46(1): 49–65.Google Scholar
  5. Alderman, K. and Carter, N. (1995) The Labour Party leadership and deputy leadership elections of 1994. Parliamentary Affairs 48(3): 438–455.Google Scholar
  6. Alderman, K. and Carter, N. (2000) The Liberal Democrat leadership election of 1999. Parliamentary Affairs 53(2): 311–327.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Alderman, K. and Carter, N. (2002) The Conservative Party leadership election of 2001. Parliamentary Affairs 55(3): 569–585.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Allern, E.H. and Karlsen, R. (2014) Unanimous, by acclamation? Party leadership selection in Norway’. In: J.-B. Pilet and W.P. Cross (eds.) The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies: A Comparative Study. Abingdon: Routledge, 47–61.Google Scholar
  9. Bailey, M. and Cowley, P. (2015) The conventional wisdom is wrong. As Tory leader, Thatcher stood for ideology – right from the start, Conservativehome 23 March, available at http://www.conservativehome.com/platform/2015/03/matthew-bailey-and-philip-cowley-the-conventional-wisdom-is-wrong-as-tory-leader-thatcher-stood-for-ideology-right-from-the-start.html.
  10. Bale, T, and Webb, P. (2014) The selection of party leaders in the UK. In: J.-B. Pilet and W.P. Cross (eds.) The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies: A Comparative Study. Abingdon: Routledge, 12–29.Google Scholar
  11. Barbera, O., Rodriguez-Teruel, J., Barrio, A. and Baras, M. (2014) The selection of party leaders in Spain. In: J.-B. Pilet and W.P. Cross (eds.) The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies: A Comparative Study. Abingdon: Routledge, 108–123.Google Scholar
  12. Bartram, P. (1981) David Steel: His Life and Politics. London: W.H. Allen.Google Scholar
  13. Baston, L. (2004) Reggie: The Life of Reginald Maudling. Stroud: Sutton Publishing.Google Scholar
  14. Beaumont, T. (1997) The election of Jeremy Thorpe to the Liberal leadership. Liberal Democrat History Group Newsletter 15, 5–6.Google Scholar
  15. Bloch, M. (2014) Jeremy Thorpe. London: Little, Brown.Google Scholar
  16. Branigan, T. (2007) ‘All still to play for in Liberal Democrats’ leadership race. The Guardian, 23 November.Google Scholar
  17. Callaghan, J. (1988) Time and Chance. London: Fontana.Google Scholar
  18. Campbell, J. (2015) Roy Jenkins. In: D. Brack, R.Ingham and T. Little (eds.) British Liberal Leaders: Leaders of the Liberal Party, SDP and Liberal Democrats since 1828. London: Biteback Publishing, 335–349.Google Scholar
  19. Chiru, M. and Gherghina, S. (2014) Let’s not risk too much: The selection of party leaders in Romania. In: J.-B. Pilet and W.P. Cross (eds.) The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies: A Comparative Study. Abingdon: Routledge, 141–155.Google Scholar
  20. Cole, M. (2011) Richard Wainwright, the Liberals and the Liberal Democrats: Unfinished Business. Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Cowley, P. (1999) How did he do that? The second round of the 1990 Conservative leadership contest. In: D.M. Farrell, D. Broughton, D. Denver and J. Fisher (eds.) British Elections and Parties Yearbook 1996. London: Frank Cass, 198–216.Google Scholar
  22. Cowley, P. and Bailey, M. (2000) Peasants’ uprising or religious war? Re-examining the 1975 Conservative leadership contest. British Journal of Political Science 30: 599–629.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Cowley, P. and Garry, J. (1998) The British Conservative Party and Europe: The choosing of John Major. British Journal of Political Science 28(3): 473–499.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Crewe, I. and King, A. (1995) SDP: The Birth, Life and Death of the Social Democratic Party. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  25. Cross, W.P. (2014) Party Leadership in Canada. In: J.-B. Pilet and W.P. Cross (eds.) The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies: A Comparative Study. Abingdon: Routledge, 171–188.Google Scholar
  26. Cross, W.P. and Blais, A. (2012a) Who selects the party leader? Party Politics 18(2): 127–150.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Cross, W.P. and Blais, A. (2012b) Politics at the Centre: The Selection and Removal of Party Leaders in the Anglo Parliamentary Democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Denham, A. and Dorey, P. (2006) A tale of two speeches? The Conservative leadership election of 2005. Political Quarterly 77(1): 35–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Denham, A. and Dorey, P. (2007) The ‘caretaker’ cleans up: The Liberal Democrat leadership election of 2006. Parliamentary Affairs 60(1): 26–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Denham, A. and O’Hara, K. (2008) Democratising Conservative Leadership Selection: From Grey Suits. Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
  31. Detterbeck, K. and Rohlfing, I. (2014) Party leader selection in Germany’. In: J.-B. Pilet and W.P. Cross (eds.) The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies: A Comparative Study. Abingdon: Routledge, 77–92.Google Scholar
  32. Dommett, K. (2015) The theory and practice of party modernisation: The conservative party under David Cameron, 2005–2015. British Politics 10(2): 249–266.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Dorey, P. and Denham, A. (2011) ‘O, brother, where art thou?’ The Labour Party leadership election of 2010. British Politics 6(3): 286–316.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Dorey, P. and Denham, A. (2016) ‘The longest suicide vote in history’: The Labour Party leadership election of 2015. British Politics 11(3): 259–282.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Drucker, H.M. (1976) Leadership selection in the Labour Party. Parliamentary Affairs 29(4): 378–395.Google Scholar
  36. Drucker, H.M. (1981) Changes in the Labour Party leadership. Parliamentary Affairs 34(4): 369–391.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Drucker, H.M. (1984) Intra-Party democracy in action: The election of leader and deputy leader of the Labour Party in 1983. Parliamentary Affairs 37(3): 283–300.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Dunford, D. and Kirk, A. (2016) Tory leadership contest. How Theresa’s May’s victory over Andrea Leadsom and unfolded. The Telegraph, 11th July, available at http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/0/who-are-the-favourites-to-become-prime-minister-after-the-brexit/.
  39. Ennser-Jedenastik, L. and Muller, W.C. (2014) The selection of party leaders in Austria: Channelling ambition effectively. In: J.-B. Pilet and W.P. Cross (eds.) The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies: A Comparative Study. Abingdon: Routledge, 62–76.Google Scholar
  40. Ford Library. (1975a) White House Central File CO160, Box 56, George Springsteen to Brent Scowcroft, 4 February (Thatcher Foundation Archives - http://www.margaretthatcher.org/document/110507).
  41. Ford Library. (1975b) White House NSC Country File Box 15, George Springsteen to Brent Scowcroft, 11 February (Thatcher Foundation Archives, http://www.margaretthatcher.org/document/110508.
  42. Francis, M. (2010) The “bland leading the bland”: Electing the Liberal Democrat leader, 1988–2007. Representation 46(1): 91–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Francis, M. and Denham, A. (2015) Tim Farron wins Liberal Democrat leadership election. The Conversation, 16th July.Google Scholar
  44. Gilmour, I. and Garnett, M. (1997) Whatever Happened to the Tories? The Conservative Party since 1945. London: Fourth Estate.Google Scholar
  45. Hailsham, Lord. (1975) The Door Wherein I Went. London: Collins.Google Scholar
  46. Heath, E. (1998) The Course of My Life: My Autobiography. London: Hodder & Stoughton.Google Scholar
  47. Heppell, T. (2008) Choosing the Tory Leader: Conservative Party Leadership Elections from Heath to Cameron. London: I.B. Tauris.Google Scholar
  48. Heppell, T. (2010a) The Labour Party leadership election of 1963: Explaining the unexpected election of Harold Wilson. Contemporary British History 24(2): 151–171.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Heppell, T. (2010b) Choosing the Labour Leader: Labour Party Leadership Elections from Wilson to Brown. London: I.B. Tauris.Google Scholar
  50. Heppell, T. and Crines, A. (2011) How Michael Foot won The Labour leadership. Political Quarterly 82(1): 81–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Heppell, T., Crines, A. and Nicholls, R. (2010) Ideological alignments within the Parliamentary Labour Party and the leadership election of 1976. British Politics 5(1): 65–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Heppell, T. and Hill, M. (2008) The Conservative Party Leadership Election of 1997: An analysis of the voting motivations of Conservative Parliamentarians. British Politics 3(1): 63–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Heppell, T. and Hill, M. (2009) Transcending Thatcherism? Ideology and the Conservative Party Leadership Mandate of David Cameron. The Political Quarterly 80(3): 388–399.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Heppell, T. and Hill, M. (2010) The Voting Motivations of Conservative Parliamentarians in the Conservative Party Leadership Election of 2001. Politics 30(1): 36–51.Google Scholar
  55. Home, Lord. (1976) The Way the Wind Blows. London: Collins.Google Scholar
  56. Hurst, G. (2006) Charles Kennedy: A Tragic Flaw. London: Politico’s.Google Scholar
  57. Ilonszki, G. and Varnagy. R. (2014) Stable leadership in the context of party change: The Hungarian case. In: J.-B. Pilet and W.P. Cross (eds.) The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies: A Comparative Study. Abingdon: Routledge, 156–170.Google Scholar
  58. Ingham, R. (2015) Jeremy Thorpe. In: D. Brack, R.Ingham and T. Little (eds.) British Liberal Leaders: Leaders of the Liberal Party, SDP and Liberal Democrats since 1828. London: Biteback Publishing, 311–319.Google Scholar
  59. Jenkins, R. (1991) A Life at the Centre. London: Macmillan.Google Scholar
  60. Jobson, R. and Wickham-Jones, M. (2011) Reinventing the block vote? Trade unions and the 2010 Labour Party leadership election. British Politics 6(3): 317–344.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Johnston, R. (1988) The final choice: Its social, organizational, and ideological bases. In: G. Perlin (ed.), Party Democracy in Canada: The Politics of National Party Conventions. Scarborough: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
  62. Kenig, O. (2009) Democratization of party leadership selection: Do wider selectorates produce more competitive contests? Electoral Studies 28(2): 240–247.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Kerr, P. (2007) Cameron Chameleon and the current state of Britain’s consensus. Parliamentary Affairs 60(1): 46–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Kerr, P. and Hayton, R. (2015) Whatever happened to Conservative Party modernisation? British Politics 10(2) 114–130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Lisi, M. and Freire, A. (2014) The selection of party leaders in Portugal. In: J.-B. Pilet and W.P. Cross (eds.) The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies: A Comparative Study. Abingdon: Routledge, 124–140.Google Scholar
  66. Macmillan, H. (1973) At the End of the Day, 1961–1963. London: Macmillan.Google Scholar
  67. Merrick, J. (2008) Meet the real leader of the Liberal Democrats. Independent on Sunday, 6th April.Google Scholar
  68. Norton, P. (1990) Choosing a leader: Margaret Thatcher and the Parliamentary Conservative Party, 1975–1990. Parliamentary Affairs 43(3): 249–259.Google Scholar
  69. Pemberton, H. and Wickham-Jones, M. (2013) Brothers all: The operation of the Electoral College in the 2010 Labour leadership contest. Parliamentary Affairs 66(4): 708–731.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Pilet, J.-B. and Cross, W.P. (eds.) (2014) The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies: A Comparative Study. Abingdon: Routledge.Google Scholar
  71. Pilet, J.-B., and Wauters, B. (2014) The selection of party leaders in Belgium. In: J.-B. Pilet and W.P. Cross (eds.) The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies: A Comparative Study. Abingdon: Routledge, 30–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Prior, J. (1986) A Balance of Power. London: Hamish Hamilton.Google Scholar
  73. Punnett, R.M. (1992) Selecting the Party Leader: Britain in Comparative Perspective. Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Quinn, T. (2010) Membership ballots in party leadership elections in Britain. Representation 46(1): 101–117.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Quinn, T. (2012) Electing and Ejecting Party Leaders in Britain. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Quinn, T. (2016) The British Labour Party’s leadership election of 2015. British Journal of Politics and International Relations 18(4): 759–778.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Sandri, G., Seddone, A. and Venturino, F. (2014) The selection of party leaders in Italy, 1989–2012. In: J.-B. Pilet and W.P. Cross (eds.) The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies: A Comparative Study. Abingdon: Routledge, 93–107.Google Scholar
  78. Sjoblom, G. (1968) Party Strategies in a Multi-Party System. Lund: Studentlitteratur.Google Scholar
  79. Smith, H. (1999) The 1988 leadership campaign. Journal of Liberal Democrat History 24 (Autumn): 18–22.Google Scholar
  80. Stark, L.P. (1996) Choosing a Leader: Party Leadership Contests in Britain from Macmillan to Blair. Basingstoke: Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Steel, D. (1989) Against Goliath: David Steel’s Story. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson.Google Scholar
  82. Thorpe, J. (1999) In My Own Time. London: Politico’s.Google Scholar
  83. Wallace, W. (1983) Survival and revival. In: V. Bogdanor (ed.) Liberal Party Politics. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 43–72.Google Scholar
  84. Whitelaw, W. (1989) The Whitelaw Memoirs, London: Aurum Press.Google Scholar
  85. Wickham-Jones, M. (1997) Right turn: A revisionist account of the 1975 Conservative leadership election. Twentieth Century British History 8(1): 74–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. YouGov. (2006) Survey of Liberal Democratic party members. Poll for John Stevens, 7–9 February, available at http://www.yougov.co.uk.
  87. You Gov. (2007) Liberal Democrat leadership contest. Poll for Sky News, 3 December, available at http://www.yougov.co.uk.

Copyright information

© Macmillan Publishers Ltd., part of Springer Nature 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.School of Politics and International RelationsUniversity of NottinghamNottinghamUK
  2. 2.School of Law and PoliticsCardiff UniversityCardiffUK

Personalised recommendations