Journal of Public Health Policy

, Volume 27, Issue 1, pp 77–99 | Cite as

Fighting a Tobacco-Tax Rollback: A Political Analysis of the 1994 Cigarette Contraband Crisis in Canada

  • Eric Breton
  • Lucie Richard
  • France Gagnon
  • Marie Jacques
  • Pierre Bergeron
Article and Commentary

Abstract

We identify factors that led a regional government (Quebec, Canada) to opt for a reduction of its tobacco tax to combat tobacco smuggling. Then we explore the fallout of Quebec's tobacco-tax rollback on its tobacco control policy. We conducted qualitative research using a case-study design and multiple sources of data. We applied the Advocacy Coalition Framework in respect of data collection and analysis. Advocates of the tobacco-tax rollback framed the contraband problem in a way that won the support of an array of actors. However, anti-tobacco activists succeeded in convincing the government to invest more in tobacco control. The new resources were instrumental in enhancing the activists' ability to promote legislative measures. Our approach sheds light on the tobacco industry's strategy to have governments reducing their tobacco tax. Quebec offers an example of how tobacco control activists can transform defeat into the cornerstone of a comprehensive tobacco control policy.

Keywords

advocacy taxes tobacco industry Quebec 

References

  1. Gouvernement du Québec. Plan d'action pour enrayer le commerce illégal du tabac. Québec: Gouvernement du Québec; 1994.Google Scholar
  2. House of Commons of Canada. Debates of the House of Commons of Canada (Hansard) Thirty-fifth Parliament, First Session, Tuesday, February 8 1994.Google Scholar
  3. Joossens L, Raw M . Turning off the tap: the real solution to cigarette smuggling. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2003;7:214–222.Google Scholar
  4. Shafey O, Cokkinides V, Cavalcante TM, Teixeira M, Vianna C, Thun M . Case studies in international tobacco surveillance: cigarette smuggling in Brazil. Tobacco Control. 2002;11:215–219.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Joossens L . Vietnam: smuggling adds value. Tobacco Control. 2003;12:119–120.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Tsai Y, Sung H, Yang C, Shih S . The behaviour of purchasing smuggled cigarettes in Taiwan. Tobacco Control. 2003;12:28–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Joossens L . From public health to international law: possible protocols for inclusion in the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control. Bull World Health Org. 2000;78:930–937.Google Scholar
  8. Leverett M, Ashe M, Gerard S, Jenson J, Woollery T . Tobacco use: the impact of prices. J Law Med Ethics. 2002;30:88–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Kaplan RM, Ake CF, Emery SL, Navarro AM . Simulated effect of tobacco tax variation on population health in California. Am J Public Health. 2001;91:239–244.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Townsend J . The role of taxation policy in tobacco control. In: Abedian I, van der Merwe R, Wilkins N, et al., editors. The economics of tobacco control. Towards an optimal policy mix. Cape Town: University of Cape Town; 1998. pp. 85–101.Google Scholar
  11. Thompson F . Cigarette smuggling and public health. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2003;7:207.Google Scholar
  12. Galbraith JW, Kaiserman M . Taxation, smuggling and demand for cigarettes in Canada: evidence from time-series data. J Health Econ. 1997;16:287–301.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Joossens L, Raw M . Cigarette smuggling in Europe: who really benefits? Tobacco Control. 1998;7:66–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Joossens L, Raw M . How can cigarette smuggling be reduced? BMJ. 2000;321:947–950.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Sabatier PA, Jenkins-Smith HC . Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach. Boulder, CO: Westview Press; 1993.Google Scholar
  16. Sabatier PA, Jenkins-Smith HC . The Advocacy coalition framework. An assessment. In: Sabatier PA, editor. Theories of the Policy Process. Boulder, CO: Westview Press; 1999. pp. 117–166.Google Scholar
  17. Cunningham R . Smoke & Mirrors. The Canadian Tobacco War. International Development Research Centre: Ottawa; 1996.Google Scholar
  18. Ministère des Affaires Sociales. Politique de prévention des problèmes reliés au tabagisme. Ministère des Affaires Sociales: Québec; 1983.Google Scholar
  19. Québec. Ministère de la santé et des services sociaux. La politique de la santé et du bien-être. Ministère de la santé et des services sociaux: Québec; 1992.Google Scholar
  20. Cornellier M . PC. La GRC concentrera ses efforts autour d'Akwesasne. Le Soleil. 1994, February 9; Sect. A2.Google Scholar
  21. Tremblay F . PC. Les détaillants en alimentation demandent une baisse de 70% des taxes sur les cigarettes. La Presse. 1993, February 3; Sect. D5.Google Scholar
  22. Noël A . Les épiciers ont créé de toutes pièces le mouvement des “dépanneurs généreux”. La Presse. 1994, January 27; Sect. A1.Google Scholar
  23. Dubuc A . Les fausses pistes de l'anti-tabagisme. La Presse. 1994, February 1; Sect. B2.Google Scholar
  24. Le Groupe Léger & Léger. Évaluation des perceptions des Québécoises et Québécois à l'égard de la contrebande de cigarettes au Québec et au niveau de taxation des cigarettes et exploitation du marché noir par les fumeurs et les ex-fumeurs. Montréal: Le Groupe Léger & Léger; 1993, Janvier.Google Scholar
  25. Anonyme. Une majorité de Canadiens favorables à la réduction des taxes sur les cigarettes. La Presse. 1994, February 28; Sect. A5.Google Scholar
  26. Statistics Canada. Housing Family and Social Statistics Division. Health status of Canadians: report of the 1991 General Social Survey. 1994.Google Scholar
  27. Pépin A . Les libéraux prévoient un dur match électoral. La Presse. 1994, January 19; Sect. C8.Google Scholar
  28. Canadian Cancer Society. Protecting Health and Revenue: An Action Plan to Control Contraband and Tax-Exempt Tobacco. Ottawa: Canadian Cancer Society; 1994, January.Google Scholar
  29. Québec. Ministère de la Santé et des Services sociaux. État de la situation du tabagisme chez les jeunes au Québec. Québec: Ministère de la Santé et des Services sociaux. Direction générale de santé publique; 1996.Google Scholar
  30. Gagné SD . Examen critique de trois sondages sur la consommation de la cigarette chez les jeunes du secondaire. Présenté au Conseil canadien des fabricants de produits du tabac: Soucy D. Gagné & Associés; 1998, Mars.Google Scholar
  31. Assemblée nationale. Journal des débats. Commission permanente des affaires sociales. Trente-cinquième législature, deuxième session, le jeudi 28 mai, Cahier no. 127 1998, pp. 1–60.Google Scholar
  32. Roy P . Le paquet à $3 fait réfléchir plus d'un fumeur. LaPresse. 1986, February 6; Sect. A3.Google Scholar
  33. Mintrom M, Vergari S . Advocacy coalitions, policy entrepreneurs, and policy change. Policy Stud J. 1996;24:420–438.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Schlager E . Policy Making and collective action: defining coalitions within the advocacy coalition framework. Policy Sci. 1995;28:243–270.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Lemieux V . Les coalitions: liens, transactions et contrôles. Paris: Presses universitaires de France; 1998.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Palgrave Macmillan Ltd 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  • Eric Breton
    • 1
  • Lucie Richard
  • France Gagnon
  • Marie Jacques
  • Pierre Bergeron
  1. 1.School of Health & Social Development, Deakin UniversityBurwoodAustralia

Personalised recommendations