Journal of the Operational Research Society

, Volume 63, Issue 10, pp 1457–1466

Exploring alternative routes to realising the benefits of simulation in healthcare

  • J Bowers
  • M Ghattas
  • G Mould
General Paper

Abstract

Discrete event simulation should offer numerous benefits in designing healthcare systems but the reality is often problematic. Healthcare modelling faces particular challenges: genuine, fundamental variations in practice and an opposition to any suggestion of standardisation from some professional groups. This paper compares the experiences of developing a new simulation in an Accident and Emergency (A&E) Department, a subsequent adaptation for modelling an outpatient clinic and applications of a generic A&E simulation. These studies provide examples of three distinct approaches to realising the potential benefits of simulation: the bespoke, the reuse and the generic route. Reuse has many advantages: it is relatively efficient in exploiting previous modelling experience, delivering timely results although providing scope for adaptations to local practice. Explicitly demonstrating this willingness to adapt to local conditions and engaging with stakeholders is particularly important in healthcare simulation.

Keywords

health service emergency departments simulation 

References

  1. Alexopoulos C, Goldsman D, Fontanesi J, Kopald D and Wilson JR (2008). Modeling patient arrivals in community clinics. Omega-International Journal of Management Science 36 (1): 33–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Baldwin LP, Eldabi T and Paul RJ (2004). Simulation in healthcare management: A soft approach (MAPIU). Simulation Modelling Practice and Theory 12 (7–8): 541–557.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bennett JC and Worthington DJ (1998). An example of a good but partially successful OR engagement: Improving outpatient clinic operations. Interfaces 28 (5): 56–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bevan G and Hood C (2006). Have targets improved performance in the English NHS? British Medical Journal 332: 419–422.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Bowers J, Ghattas M and Mould G (2009). Success and failure in the simulation of an accident and emergency department. Journal of Simulation 3: 171–178.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bowers J and Mould G (2002). Concentration and the variability of orthopaedic demand. Journal of the Operational Research Society 53 (2): 203–210.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Brailsford S (2007). Advances and challenges in healthcare simulation modelling. In: Henderson SG, Biller B, Hsieh M-H, Shortle J, Tew JD, and Barton RR (eds). Proceedings of the 2007 Winter Simulation Conference. Washington, DC. IEEE: Piscataway, NY, pp 1436–1448.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Brailsford S, Bolt T, Connell C, Klein J and Patel B (2009). Stakeholder engagement in health care simulation. In: Rossetti MD, Hill RR, Johansson B, Dunkin A and Ingalls RG (eds). Proceedings of the 2009 Winter Simulation Conference. Austin, TX. IEEE: Piscataway, NY, pp 1840–1849.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Carvel J (2007). Public sector targets to be scrapped. The Guardian, 18 July 2007.Google Scholar
  10. Cayirli T and Veral E (2003). Outpatient scheduling in health care: A review of literature. Production and Operations Management 12 (4): 519–549.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Clague J (1997). Improving outpatient clinic efficiency using computer simulation. International Journal of Health Care Quality Assurance Incorporating Leadership in Health Services 12 (4–5): 197–201.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Cochrane A (2010). Scots deserve a better NHS for their money. Telegraph, 21 January 2010.Google Scholar
  13. Davies R, Roderick P and Raftery J (2003). The evaluation of disease prevention and treatment using simulation models. European Journal of Operational Research 150 (1): 53–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Degeling P, Maxwell S, Kennedy J and Coyle B (2003). Medicine, management, and modernisation: A ‘danse macabre’? British Medical Journal 326 (7390): 649–652.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Delesie L (1998). Bridging the gap between clinicians and health managers. European Journal of Operational Research 105 (2): 248–256.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Edwards N, Marshall M, McLellan A and Abbasi K (2003). Doctors and managers: A problem without a solution? British Medical Journal 326 (7390): 609–610.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Eldabi T, Paul R and Young T (2007). Simulation modelling in healthcare: Reviewing legacies and investigating futures. Journal of the Operational Research Society 58 (2): 262–270.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Fletcher A, Halsall D, Huxham S and Worthington D (2007). The DH accident and emergency department model: A national generic model used locally. Journal of the Operational Research Society 58 (12): 1554–1562.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Fone D et al (2003). Systematic review of the use and value of computer simulation modelling in population health and health care delivery. Journal of Public Health Medicine 25 (4): 325–335.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Gunal MM and Pidd M (2006). Understanding accident and emergency department performance using simulation. In: Perrone LF, Wieland FP, Liu J, Lawson BG, Nicol DM, and Fujimoto RM (eds). Proceedings of the 2006 Winter Simulation Conference. Monterey, CA. IEEE: Piscataway, NY, pp 446–452.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Gunal MM and Pidd M (2007). Interconnected DES models of emergency, outpatient, and inpatient departments of a hospital. In: Henderson SG, Biller B, Hsieh M-H, Shortle J, Tew JD, and Barton RR (eds). Proceedings of the 2007 Winter Simulation Conference. Washington, DC. IEEE: Piscataway, NY, pp 1461–1466.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Harper PR and Gamlin HM (2003). Reduced outpatient waiting times with improved appointment scheduling: A simulation modelling approach. OR Spectrum 25 (2): 207–222.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Harper PR and Pitt MA (2004). On the challenges of healthcare modelling and a proposed project life cycle for successful implementation. Journal of the Operational Research Society 55 (6): 657–661.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. ISD Scotland (2011). Inpatient, day case and outpatient activity: Outpatient and A&E activity by specialty for Scotland and NHS boards of treatment. http://www.isdscotland.org/isd/4156.html, accessed 19 May 2011.
  25. Jahangirian M et al (2010). Simulation in health-care: Lessons from other sectors. Operational Research. DOI: 10.1007/s12351-010-0089-8. Online First™ available at http://www.springerlink.com/content/7615624526309606/, accessed 4 April 2011.
  26. Jun JI, Jacobson SH and Swisher JR (1999). Application of discrete-event simulation in health care clinics. Journal of the Operational Research Society 50 (2): 109–123.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Kaandorp GC and Koole G (2007). Optimal outpatient appointment scheduling. Health Care Management Science 10 (3): 217–229.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Lehaney B, Kogetsidis HJ and Clarke S (1996). A case study of patient flows using Windows-based computer simulation. Work Study 45 (6): 17–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Lehaney B, Clarke SA and Paul RJ (1999). A case of an intervention in an outpatients department. Journal of the Operational Research Society 50 (9): 877–891.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Lowery J (1994). Barriers to implementing simulation in health care. In: Manivannan MS, Tew JD, Sadowski SA and Seila AF (eds). Proceedings of the 1994 Winter Simulation Conference. Orlando, FL. Society for Computer Simulation International: San Diego, CA, pp 868–875.Google Scholar
  31. Moloney ED, Bennett K, O'Riordan D and Silke B (2006). Emergency department census of patients awaiting admission following reorganisation of an admissions process. Emergency Medicine Journal 23: 363–367.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Naseer A, Eldabi T and Jahangrian M (2008). Cross-sector analysis of simulation methods: A survey of defense and healthcare. Transforming Government 3 (2): 181–189.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Naseer A, Eldabi T and Young T (2010). RIGHT: A toolkit for selecting healthcare modelling methods. Journal of Simulation 4 (1): 2–13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement (2010). Scenario generator project. http://www.institute.nhs.uk/scenariogenerator/general/scenario_generator_project.html, accessed 26 May 2010.
  35. Ormerod RJ (2002). On the nature of OR: Taking stock. Journal of the Operational Research Society 53 (5): 475–491.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Pidd M (2001). The futures of OR. Journal of the Operational Research Society 52 (11): 1181–1190.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Pidd M (2004). Contemporary OR/MS in strategy development and policy-making: Some reflections. Journal of the Operational Research Society 55 (8): 791–800.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Pitt M, Dodds S, Bensley D, Royston G and Stein K (2009). The potential for operational research. British Journal of the Healthcare Management 15 (1): 346–351.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Proudlove NC and Black S (2007). OR and the challenge to improve the NHS: Modelling for insight and improvement in in-patient flows. Journal of the Operational Research Society 58 (2): 145–158.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Robinson S (2001). Soft with a hard centre: Discrete-event simulation in facilitation. Journal of the Operational Research Society 52 (8): 905–915.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Robinson S and Pidd M (1998). Provider and customer expectations of successful simulation projects. Journal of the Operational Research Society 49 (3): 200–209.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Robinson S, Nance RE, Paul RJ, Pidd M and Taylor SJE (2004). Simulation model reuse: Definitions, benefits and obstacles. Simulation Modelling Practice and Theory 12 (7–8): 479–494.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Scottish Executive (2005). An introduction to the unscheduled care collaborative programme. http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Resource/Doc/141079/0034895.pdf, accessed 19 May 2010.
  44. Swisher JR, Jacobson SH, Jun JB and Balci O (2001). Modeling and analyzing a physician clinic environment using discrete-event (visual) simulation. Computers and Operations Research 28 (2): 105–125.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. van der Meer RB, Rymaszewski LA, Findlay H and Curran J (2005). Using OR to support the development of an integrated musculo-skeletal service. Journal of the Operational Research Society 56 (2): 162–172.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Walshe K and Rundall TG (2001). Evidence-based management: From theory to practice in health care. Milbank Quarterly 79 (3): 429–457.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Operational Research Society 2012

Authors and Affiliations

  • J Bowers
    • 1
  • M Ghattas
    • 2
  • G Mould
    • 1
  1. 1.University of StirlingStirlingUK
  2. 2.NHS FifeKirkcaldyUK

Personalised recommendations