Energy for the masses? Exploring the political logics behind the Desertec vision

  • Delf Rothe
Article

Abstract

Desertec has become known as a label for a keen vision: the large-scale installation of solar thermal and wind-power plants in the deserts of North Africa and the Middle East to power this region and Europe with clean energy. In recent years, this vision has received considerable political attention. Especially strong was the project’s resonance at the level of the European Union, which integrated the idea of a renewable energy partnership as one of six priority projects into the Union for the Mediterranean founded in 2008. This article explores the question of how and why the private initiative of a few German scientists and minor solar businesses could finally be translated into a political project taken up by the EU. Applying the logics of critical explanations framework to the case of Desertec, this article studies the discursive strategies and storylines backing this project. It qualifies the success of the Desertec vision by studying its perception in public discourses on both sides of the Mediterranean and it discusses the impact of the recent political upheavals in the region. In doing so, it charts new ground by showing the merit of a discourse-analytical approach in a policy field seemingly dominated by strong material interests, such as energy policy.

Keywords

Arab spring European Union Middle East and North Africa poststructuralism renewable energy securitisation 

References

  1. Academy of Sciences and Technology in Berlin (1991) Sonnenenergie: Herausforderung für Forschung, Entwicklung und internationale Zusammenarbeit, Berlin and New York: De Gruyter.Google Scholar
  2. Algerien Heute (2013) ‘Desertec: Algeriens Energieriese SONELGAZ zweifelt an die Bereitschaft der Europäische Union, das Desertec-Projekt ernsthaft umzusetzen’, http://algerien-heute.com/wirtschaft/1256-desertec-energieriese-algeriens-sonelgaz-zweifelt-an-die-bereitschaft-der-europaeische-union-dieses-projekt-umzusetzen.html (accessed 5 August, 2014).
  3. Altvater, Elmar (2007) ‘The Social and Natural Environment of Fossil Capitalism’, Socialist Register 43: 37–59.Google Scholar
  4. Balser, Martin (2011) ‘Wüstenstrom nach der Revolution’, Süddeutsche Zeitung Online 11 April, http://www.sueddeutsche.de/wirtschaft/desertec-in-tunesien-wuestenstrom-nach-der-revolution-1.1083604 (accessed 5 August, 2014).
  5. Bicchi, Federica (2004) ‘The European Origins of Euro-Mediterranean Practices’, Berkeley: Institute of European Studies Working Paper No. AY0406–12, http://www.escholarship.org/uc/item/8c44c395 (accessed 31 July, 2014).
  6. Blum, Wolfgang (1999) ‘Sonnenkraft auf Kreta’, Die Zeit, http://www.zeit.de/1999/07/199907.solarthermie_.xml (accessed 5 August, 2014).
  7. Brauch, Hans Günter, ed. (1997) ‘Energieoptionen für eine langfristige Nord-Süd-Energiepartnerschaft im westlichen Mittelmeer’, in Energiepolitik: Technische Entwicklung, politische Strategien, Handlungskonzepte zu erneuerbaren Energien und zur rationalen Energienutzung, 487–505, Berlin: Springer.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Brauch, Hans Günter (2010) Climate Change and Mediterranean Security: International, National, Environmental and Human Security Impacts for the Euro-Mediterranean Region in the 21st Century, IEMed Barcelona, Papers IEMed, No. 9.Google Scholar
  9. Brauch, Hans Günter, Gregor Czisch and Franz Trieb (1999) ‘Klimaschutz und Arbeitsplätze durch Solarthermische Kraftwerke: Das Synthesis Programm bis 2010’, in Gerhard Knies, Gregor Czisch and Hans Günther Brauch, eds, Regenerativer Strom für Europa durch Fernübertragung elektrischer Energie, 69–76, Mosbach: Afes Press.Google Scholar
  10. Brüderle, Rainer (2011) ‘Desertec — Von der Vision zur Realität: Rede des Bundesministers für Wirtschaft und Technologie Rainer Brüderle anlässlich des Parlamentarischen Abends der Desertec-Industrieinitiative (Dii)’, Berlin, http://www.bmwi.de/DE/Presse/reden,did=380208.html (accessed 5 August, 2014).
  11. Buzan, Barry and Ole Wæver (2003) Regions and Powers: The Structure of International Ssecurity, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Campbell, David (1992) Writing Security: US Foreign Policy and the Politics of Identity, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
  13. Clute-Simon, Egon (1994) ‘Wann geht die Sonne auf?’ Die Zeit (18 November): 77.Google Scholar
  14. Der Derian, James and Michael J. Shapiro, eds, (1989) International/Intertextual Relations: Postmodern Readings of World Politics, Lexington: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
  15. Der Spiegel (1998) ‘Absprung vom Zug’, Der Spiegel (9 February): 178–180.Google Scholar
  16. Derrida, Jacques (1976) Of Grammatology, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
  17. Desertec Foundation (2009) ‘Clean Power from Deserts — The Desertec Concept for Energy, Water and Climate Security’, http://www.desertec.org/fileadmin/downloads/DESERTEC-WhiteBook_en_small.pdf (accessed 26 August, 2014).
  18. Dii (2012) Desert Power 2050, http://www.dii-eumena.com/fileadmin/flippingbooks/dp2050_exec_sum_engl_web.pdf (accessed 26 August, 2014).
  19. Ehlert, Percy (1999) ‘Aussichten für Almeria’, Die Tageszeitung (4 September): 7.Google Scholar
  20. EurActiv (2011) ‘EU-Energiegemeinschaft mit Nordafrika: Chance für Desertec’, 11 March, http://www.euractiv.de/energie-und-klimaschutz/artikel/eu-energiegemeinschaft-mit-nordafrika-chance-fr-desertec-004490 (accessed 5 August, 2014).
  21. European Union (2010) ‘Identification Mission for the Mediterranean Solar Plan’, http://ec.europa.eu/energy/international/international_cooperation/doc/2010_01_solar_plan_report.pdf (accessed 26 August, 2014).
  22. Ferrero-Waldner, Benita (2009) ‘The Mediterranean Solar Plan — A Necessity, not an Option’, Brussels, http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_SPEECH-09-60_en.htm?locale=en (accessed 18 June, 2014).
  23. Fischer, Severin (2010) ‘Internal and External Regionalisation of Energy Policies: The European Union’s Market Governance Approach’, Institute for European Politics, Berlin: IEP Working Papers 03/10.Google Scholar
  24. Foucault, Michel (1972) ‘The Confession of the Flesh’, in Colin Gordon ed., Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, 194–228, Brighton, Sussex: Harvester Press.Google Scholar
  25. Foucault, Michel (1977) Discipline & Punish, New York: Random House.Google Scholar
  26. Geden, Oliver and Severin Fischer (2008) Die Energie — und Klimapolitik der Europäischen Union: Bestandsaufnahme und Perspektiven, Baden-Baden: Nomos-Verl.-Ges.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. German Aerospace Centre (2000) ‘Company Profile on Solar Thermal Power — Consulting, Research and Development’, Stuttgart: German Aerospace Centre, http://www.dlr.de/Portaldata/41/Resources/dokumente/institut/system/publications/profile-2000-s.PDF (accessed 31 July, 2014).
  28. Glaser, Barney G. and Anselm L. Strauss (1967) The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research, New York: Aldine.Google Scholar
  29. Glynos, Jason and David R. Howarth (2007) Logics of Critical Explanation in Social and Political Theory, London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  30. Gnad, Oliver and Marcel Viëtor (2011) ‘Mehr als Wüstenstrom: Desertec als Pilotprojekt einer integrierten Energiepolitik’, Internationale Politik 19 (4): 35–41.Google Scholar
  31. Gramsci, Antonio (1971) Selections from the Prison Notebooks of Antonio Gramsci, New York: International Publishers.Google Scholar
  32. Greenpeace (2005) Concentrated Solar Power Now! Amsterdam: Greenpeace International.Google Scholar
  33. Greenpeace International, SolarPACES and ESTELA (2009) ‘Concentrating Solar Power Global Outlook 2009 — Why Solar Energy is Hot’, http://www.greenpeace.org/international/Global/international/planet-2/report/2009/5/concentrating-solar-power-2009.pdf (accessed 26 August, 2014).
  34. Guyton, Patrick (2012) ‘Wüstenstrom bleibt Fata Morgana’, Der Tagesspiegel (22 June): 13.Google Scholar
  35. Hajer, Maarten A. (1995) The Politics of Environmental Discourse: Ecological Modernization and the Policy Process, Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
  36. Hajer, Maarten A. (2006) ‘Doing Discourse Analysis: Coalitions, Practices, Meaning’, in Margo van den Brink and Tamara Metze, eds, Words Matter in Policy and Planning: Discourse Theory and Method in the Social Sciences, 65–74, Utrecht: Netherlands Geographical Studies.Google Scholar
  37. Harrison, Roger (2009) ‘Easy Solar Energy: Is the Writing on the Wall for Fossil Fuel?’ Arab News, 29 August, http://www.arabnews.com/node/327514?quicktabs_stat2=1 (accessed 5 August, 2014).
  38. Heese, Benjamin (2009) Die Union für das Mittelmeer — Zwei Schritte vor, einen zurück? Münster, Hamburg and London: Lit-Verlag.Google Scholar
  39. Hickman, Leo (2011) ‘Could the Desert Sun Power the World?’, The Guardian (11 December): 10.Google Scholar
  40. Hindess, Barry (2005) ‘Politics as Government: Michel Foucault’s Analysis of Political Reason’, Alternatives: Global, Local, Political 30 (4): 389.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Horst, Jakob (2013) ‘Free Trade, Development and Authoritarianism in a Rentier Economy: Intentions and Reality of the EU’s Logic of Action in Algeria’, in Jakob Horst, Annette Jünemann and Delf Rothe, eds, Euro-Mediterranean Relations after the Arab Spring: Persistence in Times of Change, 79–102, Farnham: Ashgate.Google Scholar
  42. Howarth, David (2010) ‘Power, Discourse, and Policy: Articulating a Hegemony Approach to Critical Policy Studies’, Critical Policy Studies 3 (3–4): 309–335.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Howarth, David and Steven Griggs (2008) ‘Metaphor, Catachresis and Equivalence: The Rhetoric of Freedom to Fly in the Struggle Over Aviation Policy in the United Kingdom’, in Terell Carver and Jernej Pikalo, eds, Political Language and Metaphor, 197–211, London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  44. Jünemann, Annette and Eva-Maria Maggi (2010) ‘The End of External Democracy Promotion? The Logics of Action in Building the Union for the Mediterranean’, L’Europe en formation 356: 9–24.Google Scholar
  45. Keller, Rainer (2006) Diskursforschung, Wiesbaden: VS Verlag.Google Scholar
  46. Kirschbaum, Erik (2011) ‘Arab Spring helps Desertec’s solar energy plan’, Reuters, 3 November, http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/11/03/us-climate-desertec-idUSTRE7A26YA20111103 (accessed 26 August, 2014).
  47. Kilian, Alison (2011) ‘Arab Spring Boosts Dream of Desert Power’, Spiegel Online International, 26 May, http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/desertec-and-democracy-arab-spring-boosts-dream-of-desert-power-a-764877.html (accessed 26 August, 2014).
  48. Knust, Cornelia (2011) ‘Multimilliarden-Solarprojekt Desertec — Kairo antwortet nicht’, Manager Magazin, 2 February, http://www.manager-magazin.de/unternehmen/energie/a-742926-2.html (accessed 31 July, 2014).
  49. Korff, Jens Jürgen (1997) ‘Darf es auch billiger Solarstrom sein?’ Die Tageszeitung (15 July): 6.Google Scholar
  50. Krasner, Stephen D. (1982) ‘Structural Causes and Regime Consequences: Regimes as Intervening Variables’, International Organization 36 (2): 185–205.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Kulke, Uli (2010) ‘Kraftwerke in Afrikas Wüsten’, Welt Kompakt, 26 June, http://www.welt.de/wirtschaft/article8166662/Solarkraft-aus-Afrika-bleibt-Zukunftsmusik.html (accessed 5 August, 2014).
  52. Kurze, Christina (2010) ‘Changing Discourse of Energy Security: A New Impetus for Energy Policy Integration in the European Union?’ Transatlantic Research Papers in European Studies (TraPES), No. 2.Google Scholar
  53. Laclau, Ernesto and Chantal Mouffe (1985) Hegemony and Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics, London: Verso Books.Google Scholar
  54. Laclau, Ernesto (1990) New Reflections on the Revolution of our Time, London and New York: Verso.Google Scholar
  55. La Presse (2010) ‘Création d’un réseau Desertec pour la région Eumena’, La Presse, 29 June, http://www.lapresse.tn/05082014/8220/creation-dun-reseau-desertec-pour-la-region-eumena.html (accessed 5 August, 2014).
  56. Magenheim, Thomas (2009) ‘Aus der Wüste: Zwölf Konzerne starten das Desertec-Konsortium mit großem Anspruch’, Der Tagesspiegel (14 July): 15.Google Scholar
  57. Magenheim, Thomas (2012) ‘Wüstenstrom verbilligt Energiewende’, Frankfurter Rundschau (22 June): 15.Google Scholar
  58. Magenheim, Thomas and A. Menn (2009) ‘400 Milliarden Euro für Solaranlagen in Afrika’, Der Tagesspiegel (17 June): 15.Google Scholar
  59. Maghreb Confidential (2009) ‘Green Energy a Euro 45 Billion Market’, No. 887 (9 July).Google Scholar
  60. McKie, Robin (2007) ‘How Africa’s Desert Sun Can Bring Europe Power’, The Observer (2 December): 18.Google Scholar
  61. Methmann, Chris, Delf Rothe and Benjamin Stephan (2013) Interpretive Approaches to Global Climate Governance: (De)constructing the Greenhouse, London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  62. Methmann, Chris and Delf Rothe (2012) ‘Politics for the day after tomorrow: The logic of apocalypse in global climate politics’, Security Dialogue 43 (4): 323–344.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Mouffe, Chantal (2005) On the Political, London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  64. Nonhoff, Martin, ed. (2007) ‘Politische Diskursanalyse als Hegemonieanalyse’, in Diskurs — Hegemonie — radikale Demokratie: Zum politischen Denken von Ernesto Laclau und Chantal Mouffe, 173–193, Bielefeld: Transkript.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Nonhoff, Martin (2010) ‘Chantal Mouffe und Ernesto Laclau: Konfliktivität und Dynamik des Politischen’, in Ulrich Bröckling and Robert Feustel, eds, Das Politische Denken: Zeitgenössische Positionen, 33–58, Bielefeld: Transcript.Google Scholar
  66. Obertreis, Rolf (2012) ‘Tunesien geht 2016 ans Netz’, Der Tagesspiegel (25 January): 13.Google Scholar
  67. Oettinger, Günther (2010) ‘Energy in the EU from Northern Africa: A Realistic Option?’ speech of Commissioner Oettinger at Desertec Industrial Initiative, Barcelona, 26 October, http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_SPEECH-10-601_en.htm?locale=en (accessed 5 August, 2014).
  68. Pace, Michelle (2006) The Politics of Regional Identity: Meddling with the Mediterranean, London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Pfeiffer, Tom (2009) ‘Plans to Power Europe Using Saharan Sunlight: Miracle or Just a Mirage?’ The Daily Star, 25 August, http://www.dailystar.com.lb/News/Middle-East/2009/Aug-25/81703-plans-to-power-europe-using-saharan-sunlight-miracle-or-just-a-mirage.ashx#axzz39WlvIejr (accessed 31 July, 2014).Google Scholar
  70. Rose, Nikolas and Peter Miller (1992) ‘Political Power beyond the State: Problematics of Government’, British Journal of Sociology 43 (2): 173–205.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Rothe, Delf (2012) ‘Security as a Weapon: How Cataclysm Discourses Frame International Climate Negotiations’, in Jürgen Scheffran, Michael Brzoska, Hans G. Brauch, Michael Link and Janpeter Schilling, eds, Climate Change, Human Security and Violent Conflict, 243–58, Heidelberg: Springer.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Salami, Youcef (2010) ‘Les pays du Maghreb et l’UE en réunion ministérielle à Alger — L’Union magrébine dans l’intégration du marché de l’électricité’, La Tribune, 28 June, http://www.djazairess.com/fr/latribune/36341 (accessed 4 August, 2014).
  73. Schinke, Boris and Jens Klawitter (2010) ‘DESERTEC — Baustein einer neuen Sicherheitsarchitektur innerhalb des MENA-EU-Raums?’ Backgroundpaper to the expert workshop ‘DESERTEC — Baustein einer neuen Sicherheitsarchitektur innerhalb des MENA-EU-Raums?’, Bonn, 6 May.Google Scholar
  74. Scholwin, Sören (2009) ‘Desertec: Wirtschaftliche Dynamik und politische Stabilität durch Solarkraft?’ German Institute of Global and Area Studies (GIGA), GIGA Focus, No. 11.Google Scholar
  75. Scrase, Ivan J. and David G. Okwell (2010) ‘The Role of Discourse and Linguistic Framing Effects in Sustaining High Carbon Energy Policy — An Accessible Introduction’, Energy Policy 38 (5): 2225–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Seager, Ashley (2009) ‘Solar Power from Sahara a Step Closer’, The Guardian (1 November): 27.Google Scholar
  77. Swyngedouw, Erik (2007) ‘Impossible “Sustainability” and the Post-political Condition’, in David Gibbs and Rob Krueger, eds, The Sustainable Development Paradox, 13–40, New York: Guilford Press.Google Scholar
  78. Swyngedouw, Erik (2010) ‘Apocalypse Forever? Post-political Populism and the Spectre of Climate Change’, Theory, Culture & Society 27 (2–3): 213–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Thumann, Michael (2009) ‘Besser als jeder Militärpakt’, Zeit Online, http://www.zeit.de/online/2009/30/desertec-nabucco (accessed 26 August, 2014).
  80. Töpfer, Klaus (2011) ‘Wir müssen Stabilität bieten’, An Interview with Klaus Töpfer, Frankfurter Rundschau, 1 February, http://www.fr-online.de/politik/fr-interview-mit-klaus-toepfer--wir-muessen-stabilitaet-bieten-,1472596,7145490.html (accessed 31 July, 2014).
  81. Trade Arabia (2009a) ‘Mena “Can Earn $90bn from Green Energy Project”’, Trade Arabia News Service, 20 July, http://www.tradearabia.com/news/OGN_164599.html (accessed 26 August, 2014).
  82. Trade Arabia (2009b) ‘Middle East to Become Solar Boom Center in 10 Years’, Trade Arabia News Service, 15 December, http://www.tradearabia.com/news/MISC_171872.html (accessed 31 July, 2014).
  83. TREC Development Group (2003) ‘Trans-Mediterranean Renewable Energy Cooperation “TREC” for Development, Climate Stabilisation and Good Neighbourhood’, http://www.desertec.org/fileadmin/downloads/media/TREC_Amman_2003.pdf (accessed 26 August, 2014).
  84. UNCSD (2012) ‘The DESERTEC Concept — Energy Security, Sustainability and Development’, http://www.uncsd2012.org/index.php?page=view&type=1000&nr=430&menu=126 (accessed 26 August, 2014).
  85. Vorholz, Fritz (2012) ‘Wüstenstrom, eine Fata-Morgana?’ Die Zeit (18/2012), http://www.zeit.de/2012/18/GL-Desertec (accessed 5 August, 2014).
  86. Walker, Rob (1993) Inside/Outside: International Relations as Political Theory, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  87. Werenfels, Isabelle and Kirsten Westphal (2010) ‘Solarstrom aus Nordafrika: Rahmenbedingungen und Perspektiven’, Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik (SWP), SWP-Studien, No. S03/2010.Google Scholar
  88. Werner, Kathrin (2012) ‘Afrikaner lassen Desertec alt aussehen’, Financial Times Deutschland (20 February): 5.Google Scholar
  89. Whittel, Giles and David Charter (2011) ‘West Urged to Seize the Chance to Boost Arab Democracy with a Huge Aid Plan’, The Times Online, 21 February, http://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/news/world/middleeast/article2920379.ece (accessed 5 August, 2014).
  90. Zeller, Tom (2009) ‘Green Inc. — Europe Looks to Africa for Solar Power’, International Herald Tribune (22 June): 20.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Ltd 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  • Delf Rothe
    • 1
  1. 1.Institute for Peace Research and Security Policy, University of HamburgHamburgGermany

Personalised recommendations